• More
Back to PopWatch Main
Complete Archive

'Secret Life of the American Teenager:' Out with grandma, in with the baby

Aug 20, 2008, 10:52 AM | by Lisa Raphael

Categories: 'The Secret Life of the American Teenager', Mini TV Watch, Television

Americanteenager_l When Secret Life first began, we all thought that Amy losing her baby by way of abortion or adoption would mean no more show. And say what you want to about the summer hit -- annoying characters: check! laughable writing and acting: check! pushy conservative Christian vibe: check! -- but they've (at least) succeeded in developing the characters on the show to the degree that we barely need a teenage mom to keep us tuning in. Am I right, people?

And anyways, Amy's not going anywhere. The kooky new gal on the Secret Life block is "Mimzy," Mrs. Juergens' brightly decorated, scarf-and-bauble-adorned mother. She storms onto the show with a nonjudgmental attitude about her pending great-grandmotherdom and starts planning Amy's future -- including her wedding to Ben and where the baby will sleep. Although an odd way to introduce her Alzheimer's, Mimzy proves to be incapable of taking care of Amy after she suggests they keep the baby in the utensil drawer in the kitchen. So the "little complication" Amy kept mentioning in all of the promos for the show was no miscarriage, just her aborted plans to escape to Grandma's house for the rest of her pregnancy. 

While Ben's finding out that the next step in obsession is hallucination, Amy's BFFs Lauren and Madison are back in the show's periphery once more. Ricky wants contact with Amy -- and not the kind that got her preggers in the first place, we hope at least -- so he approaches Madison for her number. Thinking that Ricky is also hitting on her, Madison and Lauren begin a silly catfight over who he'd rather do. (Answer: either/or ladies, this guy's just horny and probably not too selective.)

Ben's friends Alice and Henry are also front and center -- dating, obsessing over masturbation, and fighting. Their lover's quarrel begins when Alice reveals that she too pleasures herself. Henry equates this to her cheating on him -- because she will sleep with herself and not him, obviously. His quest to figure out who she "left-clicks the mouse to" is adorable, but her final answer left this Gender Studies major guffawing on her couch. There's no way Alice, our leading feminist lady of snark, would ever fantasize about her first sexual experience with Henry being on their honeymoon in Paris wearing a wedding dress. She'd be all about domestic partnership -- duh!

Adrian is on a quest to find her estranged father and fix all those nasty daddy issues. Another iffy storyline is between her and hunky counselor Marc Molina -- is she really trying to seduce him, or just get what she wants? I guess the writers and producers of the show don't think we'll get that she's "sexy and spicy" unless they have her sashaying up to every male character that she speaks to. I think Adrian is a smart cookie with good intentions, and her heart really belongs to Ricky. Anyone else sympathizing with her?

There is, thankfully, no camera time for the Bowman parents this episode, and their only mention is actually a refreshing one. Grace reveals that her wishes for Amy to have the baby are not entirely selfish. She thinks that adoption is a great plan -- because it's her choice, right? -- and introduces Ricky to the idea by revealing that her brother was actually adopted. On the Juergens front, Mr. is sleeping at his furniture warehouse and Mrs. is trying to unsuccessfully hide her failing marriage. Hopefully it's only a matter of time before Mr. Juergens skips town. And who knows? Maybe Molly Ringwald will find her acting chops in playing a single mom! 

If you guys missed the show last night, save some room in your TiVo and watch full episodes online with ABC Family viewing parties. Here, you can invite friends and other fans of the show to watch and gossip with you while you watch the show. This is especially perfect if your roommates cringe whenever you turn the show on (thankfully, mine are into it now). How have your households responded to your Secret Life obsessions? Is this a show that you guys are watching with your families or are you sitting around giggling and rolling your eyes with fellow high-school grads?

eden Sat, Sep 13, 2008 at 03:24 PM EST

the show to me although being thought of as cheesy is a good way to keep teens watching tlking about many subjects not just being a teen mother but being a christian in a world we live in today being sexually abused as a child relationships through out the highschool experience this show is most definatley a good teenage drama thats keeps most veiwers hooked and thats what makes it,it doesnt just talk about a young mother but many other stages and places teen all around america are in right now!.

rosie-posie Thu, Aug 28, 2008 at 08:36 AM EST

I love this show. I dont know what all you ppl are on. It really is addicting and i havent missed one yet. It shows teens the type of drama you really set yourself up when having unprotected sex. I believe you can learn a lot from this show. Yeah, i think its kind of crazy that ben wants to get marry with a girl who he just started dating but thats just puppy love and i think he really needs to open his eyes to reality not just depend on his rich father. Amy seems really innocent but sex just dosent happen....You make it happen. Your 15 im pretty sure ppl know what are the consequences of that. My 7th grade sister knows what sex is. Now a days children begin to find out about sex at a really young age and i think that you need to have some responsibilty once you start commiting into doing soo.....Thats just my opinion.

cortney Wed, Aug 27, 2008 at 04:22 PM EST

hey amy justt wanted to say i feel srry for you but. richy is still cute

Anon Fri, Aug 22, 2008 at 05:31 PM EST

I really wanna get into this show but the teens acting is soooooo horribly stiff and bad.

kristi Fri, Aug 22, 2008 at 05:19 PM EST

I just want to take Ashley and hug her and have a good cry with her. I love her! I love this show, even though the writing is terrible and the acting is wooden...it's addictive. I think it's like the show that people sit around and have parties while watching it. I recall things like that for The O.C. or Dawson's Creek.(two shows I have never watched, for some reason?)
I think that Ben needs to get laid!

nourisha Fri, Aug 22, 2008 at 02:13 AM EST

i totally love this show. i don't get why people dump on it. i'm a forward-thinking woman but i'm also married to my principles. i love that alice represents me!!!! it's so rare. and i love the christian aspect of the show. real people live like that so why not show it on tv? this show give a range of the spectrum and i love them for it. totally addicted and i don't miss it!!!

Thu, Aug 21, 2008 at 07:49 PM EST

So, what happens after she has/doesn't have the baby..
end of show? haha.

Joann Thu, Aug 21, 2008 at 10:22 AM EST

I hate to admit this that I, too, am hooked on this cheesy, pseudo high school drama. But, you have to admit it is kind of compelling to watch -- I don't ever remember seeing "kids" talk so bluntly about masturbation and without the "eww" factor. The two friends fighting over who Ricky would or would not "do" and then trying to get him to notice them - that is as old as I am! Sometimes it's nice to know that some things don't charge, they just get younger. And I love Ashley - taking care of her mom, grandmom & sister - I love watching that kid work!

Britt Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 11:59 PM EST

I agree that although this show is inacurate in manys ways of depicting the life of a modern teenager, it is still engaging. As a real life american teenager I dont't think that are lives our secrets, it's just hard to discover why we do the things we do. For example, why were Amy's friends fighting over a guy they know is a jerk? is Adrien really trying to seduce the counsler? do Ben&Amy really want marrige this early? Though the acting sucks (and i can't stand the 7th heaven vibe) I think th reason I still tune into this show every week is because I want to see what makes other people decide what actions they are going to take, even if these choices are a little insane (Ben & Amy).

anonymous Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 10:40 PM EST

Personally, I find this show to be the worst on television right now. The characters on the show are stereotypes and the actors can't even act. I am a teenager and I can't seem to find any character to be relatable or likeable. Also, the way that the parents are portrayed in the show seems a bit off. Furthermore, the storylines are absolutely ridiculous and preachy. I felt that I was watching a show telling me what to do and what not to do. In my opinion, I don't think that this show can curb teenagers having sex as it does not take a realistic approach. I mean come on the show shouldn't leave teenage girls believing that there is some teenage guy who will be willing to propose to them after 6 weeks of dating. Also, find it annoying that Amy and Ben find marriage to be there only solution. What kind of message is that to the younger female audience? What happened to female empowerment? But for some strange reason I keep watching.

Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 10:17 PM EST

Three things:
1: I was so confused about the baby sleeping in the utensil drawer. I thought that Amy's parents were so poor that they had to keep their children in dresser drawers or something. Didn't see the Alzheimer's coming. WEird!
2. Kinda weird having kids talk about masturbation on ABC Fam.
3. When Ashley said that she would take care of her mom, sister, grandmother I actually teared up. Very touching moment.
This show is cheesy and the acting is horrible but I still like it!

Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 10:02 PM EST

this show is awful but too addicting to turn off , tons of my friends watch it with me and pick out what appear to be 7th heaven cast offs (people, music, sets), cringe at the acting and the portrayal of teen issues in the most god awful of ways

Crystal Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 09:29 PM EST

This show is quite unrealistic and lackluster when it comes to the acting and dialogue, but it is addictive.

The writers of the show aren't all that great... what kind of girl, no matter how attractive, tries to seduce the counselor? And what 15-year-old guy jumps on the possibility of marriage so quickly? It's all too far-fetched for me... but then again, it's got me hooked.

Has anyone noticed that the kids never go to class? They just chat in the hallways all the time... and the dress code must be very lax...

Anyways, this show does give an insight on teenage pregnancy though. And the corny dialogues are quite amusing to listen to after a long day.

The End Is Near Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 03:09 PM EST

The fact that any of you watch this show is proof of the further decline of our culture. Go outside and work out you pathetic group of fatties.

tina Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 02:45 PM EST

One last thing -- for all the overdone, hysterical Christianity (my high school friends were PKs, and even they didn't behave like this) and the all-or-nothing approach to sex, religion, and family life, I have to say that Hampton and Co. shocked the hell out of me (in a good way) with the inclusion of (and attitude toward) the gay store help. Kudos for surprising me, and for a positive reflection of a usually trashed and targeted subset.

tina Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 02:38 PM EST

The writers have obviously never (among other things) tried to get a birth certificate in California. You walk into the County Recorder's office, fill out a form, and pay $12. End of story. They don't even ask for your ID -- even if you're asking for a certified copy. (This is why the notion of a national ID is a joke.)

A real security guard would have called the cops.

A real counselor would have suspended them.

This show is a joke. An amusing one, but a joke.

Again, so much wasted potential.

tina Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 02:36 PM EST

Molly Ringwald used to be able to act. What happened? Now she just stares and glares a lot, and thinks that suffices.

Why couldn't dad have come home from 'North Carolina,' and still not have mentioned separation? You know, pretended everything was fine?

How can a lady who wants to put a baby in a drawer and marry off her 15-year-old granddaughter figure out they're separated?

Who really, and so blatantly, undermines their daughter with the sentiment that 'you're an idiot, and your husband will agree with me'?

Silv Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 02:12 PM EST

Katy, I agree with Kristin below, this show's as conservative as they come! How conservative is your dad?

Silv Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 02:11 PM EST

School starts early around here, so until last week I watched this show with both my college-age daughter and HS-sophomore son. Gotta say it's a real gigglefest between the 3 of us, but because the writers truly make us cringe. Is anyone else embarrassed for these actors? The premise is good, they just need to spend time in a high school or shadowing some kids, for goodness' sake.

kristin Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 02:07 PM EST

Katy- what liberal overtones???

Katy Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 01:13 PM EST

I'm seventeen and I enjoy talking about this show with my best friends (an eighteen-year-old boy and a sixteen year old girl), as well as watching it with my parents ( Although my dad tends to complain about its "liberal overtones".)

Caroline Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 11:47 AM EST

My mom is an elementary school counselor, and she really does talk to kids about personal issues. So do the counselors at my high school. That's pretty much their job. But some schools also have peer listening programs where students act as counselors for other students. So the shows portrayal of school counselors isn't inaccurate.

Eli Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 11:32 AM EST

Obviously, the writers of this show have never know anyone with Alzheimer's (one does not become delusional, but increasingly forgetful), nor school counselors (who don't have enough time to deal with academic matters less time to chat) and especially the writers must never have me a teenager.

Tate Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 11:28 AM EST

"It gives kids the side of teenage pregnacny the side that isnt so great."


Outside of having sex with teenagers (which I haven't been able to do in about twenty years, by the way), IS there a great side of teenage pregnancy?

Emily Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 10:52 AM EST

I know this show is pretty terrible, but I can't stop watching! My husband rolls his eyes whenever it is on...I don't know, I don't remember high school being this way, but it has been a while...anyway, in real life, my parents would have taken out a restraining order on Ben by now.

missy Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 10:51 AM EST

I love this show. It gives kids the side of teenage pregnacny the side that isnt so great. Plus I love the people in the show. As for the story line with amys dad thats the only part I dont like. Afterall Why would anyone cheat on Molly? She's still beautiful even after all these years.

Em Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 10:16 AM EST

Ben's obsession with Amy is starting to really creep me out.

julie Wed, Aug 20, 2008 at 10:06 AM EST

My 15 yr old daughter and her friends make this show a must watch every week. In the beginning, they too thought that if Amy lost the baby the show would be over, but now they do not want her to keep the baby and kind of want the baby storyline to be over and move on to other storylines.
Its interesting to hear their opinion of the characters. My daughter says she is not going to have children, she is just going to adopt chinese orphans,so we shall see. We live in a city, so this is giving them a taste of what its like to live in a town where everybody knows everybody elses business. AND... they think that maybe Amys dad is Adrians dad, too.

advertisement

Add Your Comments

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject — or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.



  • 1000 characters remaining
    • When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Copyright ©2008 Entertainment Weekly and Time Inc. All rights reserved.