It's a bird! It's a plane! It's...'Idol' superhero Syesha Mercado?

luxury watch Wed, Apr 22, 2009 at 08:12 PM EST

It's good! rolex watch?
luxury watch?

bvdlhtc luczkwy Fri, Dec 26, 2008 at 01:36 AM EST

gpknlab jmbkv ptbk ukbvos sqghlomi jpluryn mblikas

zhpdevbqo cfego Thu, Dec 25, 2008 at 05:30 AM EST

flshv spnqy janchd esnzwkyiv wouvftlyp wtmuzdiko tpcfuobrv

Thu, Jun 12, 2008 at 11:41 AM EST

Syesha is awesome and I think one of my top female singers on Idol. Her talent is so pure. I can't believe all of those haters are so mean to her. I hope there will be nobody like Syesha next season that gets mistreated by the judges, the haters, or whoever that ignores good talent. It is sad that she is so underrated, she deserves more love and credit and this is one of the other factors in which Idol is also losing credibility b/c good deserving talent like Syesha is being dismissed unlike other contestants like Brooke who deserved to go way before Michael and even Carly and David Hernandez. The voting system should stop looking @ contestants based on personality; they shud look also @ pure talent which Sy has & I wish people cud see that in her.

Thu, Jun 12, 2008 at 11:40 AM EST

Syesha is awesome and I think one of my top female singers on Idol. Her talent is so pure. I can't believe all of those haters are so mean to her. I hope there will be nobody like Syesha next season that gets mistreated by the judges, the haters, or whoever that ignores good talent. It is sad that she is so underrated, she deserves more love and credit and this is one of the other factors in which Idol is also losing credibility b/c good deserving talent like Syesha is being dismissed unlike other contestants like Brooke who deserved to go way before Michael and even Carly and David Hernandez. The voting system should stop looking @ contestants based on personality; they shud look also @ pure talent which Sy has & I wish people cud see that in her.

Thu, Jun 12, 2008 at 11:37 AM EST

Syesha is awesome and I think one of my top female singers on Idol. Her talent is so pure. I can't believe all of those haters, judges, bitter people out there never give her credit she deseves. Even if she gives a mindblowing memorable performance like "One Rock Roll 2 Many" people will still degrade her. It's a shame that this season everyone has counted her out and said mean things to her. I hope there will be nobody like Syesha next season that gets mistreated by the judges, the haters, or whoever that ignores good talent. It is sad that she is so underrated, she deserves more love and credit and this is one of the other factors in which Idol is also losing credibility b/c good deserving talent like Syesha is being dismissed unlike other contestants like Brooke who deserved to go way before Michael and even Carly and David Hernandez. The voting system should stop looking @ contestants based on personality; they shud look also @ pure talent which Sy has & I wish people liked her

Thu, Jun 12, 2008 at 11:14 AM EST

Syesha will have the last laugh. She is not fake at all. U all shud stp hating on her. When she ends up becoming famous everywhere she goes, most of u jealous people/haters will have the shock of the century. 1 more thing Syesha got more votes than Jason. Get over it. I do not understand how people like his singing. (No offense Jason fans)

Cassandra Fri, May 23, 2008 at 10:35 AM EST

Iam so glad it came down to the two Davids.I think they are both winners, but I am ecspeacally happy that David C. won because he can change the tone of his voice, unlike the other David.I also thought that the other David, David Hernandez was realy smoking hot and got voted off too early.

cj658 Mon, May 12, 2008 at 09:26 PM EST

Et tu Brute?! You honestly believe that Jason didn't care? Here's a link to your website's interview with Jason since you seemed to have missed it: http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20007164_20171835_20198726,00.html

You may want to make yourself familiar with it before you interview Jason yourself.

Oh, if you want to see how badly Jason was thrown under the bus during Paulagate, here it is in Paula's own words: http://www.newnownext.com/2008/05/paula-abdul.html

You never have to question Jason's integrity. He is one of the few involved with the show who actually has any. He expects to be able to connect with a song and make it his own. He found it hard now that there were two songs, because, in his own words, "it takes time to fall in love with a song." Not to mention the lack of time to prepare. I'm sure it was really important to fly them to Vegas last weekend to see "Love".

Listen to Carly talk about Jason: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yYVblrMJc5U

aw Mon, May 12, 2008 at 01:19 PM EST

slezak - you sly one - saw the brief clip at the end where DC & DA magically turns into DC & Saynosha. Are you prophecying - or hoping?

cimagato Mon, May 12, 2008 at 12:13 PM EST

Other than his singing, the thing I liked most about Jason was that he was completely himself. He didn't change for the Idol Machine. He said what he thought, appropriate or not, and he didn't dress it up into a cute, pre-packaged, professional sound bite. Amazingly refreshing. But I have to agree with Slezak, his "immaturity" was showing. He wasn't ready to take on 3 new songs. He's young enough to think you have to "love" the song to sing it well. I love that, but the Idol Machine doesn't. My husband thinks it's because he's too stupid to figure out how to be a professional musician, but I think it's because he's young and in love with music.
I hope David Cook isn't staring into the maw of the Idol Machine and having second thoughts. Last week was very disappointing. I hope he pulls it together and wins this thing.

ML Mon, May 12, 2008 at 11:37 AM EST

CHADDOG- you must not have been watching any of the youtube of Syesha's hometown visit - the seats were EMPTY at her singing of the national anthem. really hilarious! also it was widely reported that she had the LOWEST turnout of all 3 idols who went home last week. all she will have in the long run is a lukewarm broadway career and her baby cry!!!!!

undecided Mon, May 12, 2008 at 11:32 AM EST

I can't believe NOONE has commented on the fact that she was able to turn on and off tears at will. The song choice was a plan and the performance afterwards was brilliant. Do I think Syesha can sing? Yes, Do I think she should still be there? No.

Cassandra Mon, May 12, 2008 at 10:59 AM EST

I don't think Syisha is that good. It will come down to the two Davids in the end.TThats the way it should work out. They are the best singers left.

gailer Mon, May 12, 2008 at 10:57 AM EST

For all the Jason haters:
I think most of us are happy that he is off that rigged show! And because Jason is the only real and genuine one on the show, his reaction was the most real and genuine! Only the posers and star searchers act like they aren't relieved to be away from that fray!
Jason you are the real winner in all of this!

yssys Mon, May 12, 2008 at 10:27 AM EST

I love the Wonder Woman spin on Syesha...just perfect!!!! and the only thing that makes me sad about Jason departures is that we won't get to hear him sing Coldplay's Green Eyes but if he thinks it was his time to go who could disagree with that...here's hoping for the Idolatry interview with JC!!!

Lint_Licker Mon, May 12, 2008 at 10:26 AM EST

I see the Castro-tards are still in full-whine mode. STFU. Give it up y'all. It wasn't even about the forgotten lyrics, it was about the sloppy performances and general "Don't Give a F***" attitude that he displayed. I've never seen a contestant happier to get the boot. And Slezak isn't reporting for CNN, he's reporting for an entertainment magazine so all that whining about "integrity" is lame; this is just an opinion piece. I don't like Syscreecha one bit but I do give her points for tenacity. The "Wonder Woman" clips were hilarious. Keep up the good work.

RisingSun Mon, May 12, 2008 at 10:09 AM EST

Joe, the 12 year old girls vote for David A.. Jason has a huge fan base of people from all ages. That argument is so false and getting really old. If you don't like Jason, fine, I don't think he really cares. He has plenty of fans that do get him and his unique style. Jason is going to be missed. But you know what? Jason is lot cooler than American Idol and the only raw talent that they had.

coco Mon, May 12, 2008 at 09:46 AM EST

you guys outdid yourselves with the wonder woman clips. saesha spinning into WW...priceless.
The end..Saesha vs David Cook....wow that will be a ratings breaker!

mscisluv Mon, May 12, 2008 at 09:44 AM EST

Are there really no postings anywhere on this site about Jeff Archuleta being banned from backstage? Everyone else has this story, why not EW?

joe Mon, May 12, 2008 at 09:25 AM EST

Jason wasn't squashed by the powers that be. He was held on so long by 12 year old girls. He should have been gone weeks ago as he just plain sucks.

DT Mon, May 12, 2008 at 08:16 AM EST

I really don't like Syesha. She's had an attitude the whole show. I can't believe she's the only girl left standing. But I'd still prefer her in the finals with Cook than Archuleta. I don't care for his voice but mostly I think that poor kid doesn't need to win AI he needs to get away from his Dad and be normal for awhile.

Chaddogg Mon, May 12, 2008 at 08:04 AM EST

Wow, Slezak. Looks like one intrepid Castro fan came and continuously posted the same exact thought, in slightly different words. That or some Castro fansite did it. Either way, who's drinking kool-aid now?

Anyways, this was by far your greatest Idolatry ever. And as a Syesha fan since she's from my hometown, let me tell you right now - her Homecoming video will BLOW. YOU. AWAY. She has the largest media market of any of the remaining contestants firmly behind her (the Tampa/St.Pete/Sarasota/Bradenton/Orlando market) and the GORGEOUS shots of her hometown and the HUGE reception she got there are truly impressive.

Wonder Woman's gonna knock out one of the Davids for sure. I'm not sure which one I'd rather see gone - Archuleta (who I can't stand) or Cook (who is really good and maybe the best on the show, but might be better long-term if he's not the "winner")

ben Mon, May 12, 2008 at 06:39 AM EST

wonder woman spinning and turning into syesha is just soooo funny! one of the best idolatrys definitely!

Momo Mon, May 12, 2008 at 01:09 AM EST

Michael Slezak, it is nice to see that you have finally been brainwashed by the geniuses over at AI.
Do you seriously believe that the shrieking actress who likens her experience on AI to the civil rights struggle is the next great American Pop Star? Now, that is funny.
As for Jason Castro "not caring" and "giving up" well, be serious and gather up what little integrity you have left. The reason you were so excited about Jason in the first place was because he was so new and a real raw and undiscovered talent. He was like nothing that had ever been seen on AI before. The fact that he had missed a lyric and that is why you contend he "gave up" and "disappointed his fans" is one of the biggest lies you told this week. David A. blew a Beatles song all to heck and didn't even land in the bottom 3 and Brooke stopped her song to claim a do-over not once, but twice!& Let's not forget the 20+ yr. show biz veteran, Paula, judging a song that hadn't been sung. Oh & 1 more BIG flub-idolatry.

Regencyweiler Mon, May 12, 2008 at 12:34 AM EST

If nothing else Jason Castro is an "Honest" person. He said he was relived but he never said that he wanted to go home prior to his being eliminated. He is a true artist and a very new vocalist. To expect the contestants to learn two songs, a group number and a number for the commerical is a full plate; when you also expect them up bright and early and working into the late evening. He is a very young man who truly loves music. He sang a song that he loves and was not just blasted but insulted. He then had to come back out and sing again. Like he said he is young and inexperienced. He did better than most of us.

As a Jason fan I don't hold this against him. His music is beautiful and so touching. He is a crooner for this generation. I should also point out that many singers forget lyrics of songs they sing everyday. The criticism presented here is so superfical and inaccurate.

I am boycotting AI for the rest of this year. The true raw talent has left the building!

Regencyweiler Mon, May 12, 2008 at 12:34 AM EST

If nothing else Jason Castro is an "Honest" person. He said he was relived but he never said that he wanted to go home prior to his being eliminated. He is a true artist and a very new vocalist. To expect the contestants to learn two songs, a group number and a number for the commerical is a full plate; when you also expect them up bright and early and working into the late evening. He is a very young man who truly loves music. He sang a song that he loves and was not just blasted but insulted. He then had to come back out and sing again. Like he said he is young and inexperienced. He did better than most of us.

As a Jason fan I don't hold this against him. His music is beautiful and so touching. He is a crooner for this generation. I should also point out that many singers forget lyrics of songs they sing everyday. The criticism presented here is so superfical and inaccurate.

I am boycotting AI for the rest of this year. The true raw talent has left the building!

Claire Mon, May 12, 2008 at 12:16 AM EST

A bit hard on Castro, I think. After Carly Smithson got voted off the show that kid couldn't have caught a fair break from these people no matter what he did; he was the scapegoat for her demise and they were pretty much hell-bent on punishing him. I've seen them do this before to other contestants blamed for the demise of the producer's favorites.

Remember, only last week Paula Abdul handed him a most un-Paulaesque (read: scripted) bad review for a song he had not sung. Then, knowing he was going to get blasted by the entire panel, he had to sing it anyway. On national television. With everybody in the entire world watching.

Frankly, I think much more seasoned performers might have found that situation rather hopeless and unbearable. I am very disappointed that Jason fell apart, but he was under unusually cruel circumstances and I think I'm inclined to cut this kid a break. Nobody in the show's history has had to endure what he did.

justine Slater Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:57 PM EST

Did you drink their kool-aid? You were with him all season - don't you get it's "SURVIVOR AMERICAN IDOL" - he just wasn't able to eat the maggots - and Syesha and the Davids were. The guy was brand spankin' new, with TONS of potential THAT YOU SAW which why it's even MORE upsetting to see YOU abandoning him. As soon as the guy gets some sleep and can really work at some songs to write and sing - he will be fufilling all the potential we all see in him. Daydream was at the beginning - yes, you were right - an unbelievable debut - and he was rested and not at the end of a brutal season, AND he still delivered two others that you will probably put in your "best of AI" when you revise that list. YOU of all people throw him under the bus when he can't crank out performances like some robot!???! Give me a break! I expect it from idiots with no taste - but never from you, Michael! Now, in the spirit of not throwing YOU under the bus, I will give you another chance. Don't let me down!

Patti Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:52 PM EST

Michael. I have always found you to be a reporter with integrity, able to see through the line that AI wants everyone to buy. Please say this hasn't changed! I loved Jason's Tuesday performances. I have them both on my CD player and they are quckly becoming my favorites. Everything I have seen of Jason tells me that he is an honest young man and if he says he was giving his all and really wanted to stay, that is all I need to hear. Not to mention the proof of the heartfelt performances he gave. What gives you or anyone else the right to make false accusations. Please don't give in to rumors that AI is planting!

Amanda Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:47 PM EST

Jason was quoted in another magazine as saying he had "the best fans". He said he got "the most packages and the most mail" and he talked specifically about some of the "gifts" (a stuffed animal and ballons). There are photos of him wearing a bracelet a fan sent him, having a pin a fan sent him on his guitar strap and wearing a bead a fan sent him in his hair. Backstage photos show him reading fan mail. He commented on the AI site saying "Reading his mail" was one of his favorite things (he was the only contestant to say something like that!). He also said he has "many loyal fans" and he thought their votes might pull him through Tuesday. Truthfully, I think he probably DID feel an "obligation" to his fans and that's why he kept putting up with all the "stuff" he was having to put up with. He was "frustrated" because he couldn't put on good performances...WHO do you think he wanted to put on good performances for? It was NEVER about winning...so it was ALWAYS about pleasing people!

Angela Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:32 PM EST

Sandy, I'm sorry you feel that way towards Jason. He actually has thanked his fans in some of his interviews and he seems very appreciative of the gifts he has received from his fans (check out some of the exit interviews and Idol Extra). I don't really see where you are getting that he doesn't appreciate them. Also, Jason had no obligation to his fans...he had an obligation to himself! I would have been disappointed to hear him say that he was only in this for the fans. I wanted to see him be passionate and excited about music because thats what he loves. I got that every time I tuned in and it was especially evident last Tuesday. I'm very proud of Jason because he stayed true to himself and his style and thats what made me fall in love in the first place. Jason is an incredible talent that didn't let me down on Tuesday and I think he will be tremendously successful! BTW Slezak the Syesha, superhero thing is hilarious, you always crack me up!!

susan Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:19 PM EST

So Carly Smithson was labled a proffesional and crucified for recording a album when she was 15 years old.Then I read that a previously recorded David Cook album has a current bid of $225 on EBay.The hypocracy and double stanard this year is pathetic!Ok people Jasons going to be fine.He's exatly where he wants to be.So please let go and move on!Seyesha has been counted out every week for the last twelve.Like her or not now she's in the top three.I'm not a fan but I am so sick of all the hype surrounding the robotic duo of "David vs. David" in the finalie I hope she blows them out of the water!!!This is my first year of Idolalitry and I have definitetly been missing out.Consider me a new member of the fan club.GO SEYESHA!!!! PS-just a reminder only two of the last six crowned the winner of American Idol has risen to become actual commercial successes.And now even Kelly Clarkson is struggling.

Sandy Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:17 PM EST

As a fan, I was hurt by Jason's performances last week. I agree that he did not do his best and I felt let down by him. I do wonder why he didn't try harder because he knows he has alot of fans. He also never mentioned that in any of his interviews that he wanted to stay in it for his fans or that he didn't want to disappoint his fans. He has never said "Thank You" to his fans either....ever! Maybe he really doesn't appreciate us. But I also think the people at the show were being very mean to him and that must have been hard. I also think the judges were unfair, especialy about "Traveling Thru" & "Fragile"..those were really good and they weren't very nice about them. I don't think he's lazy, he just seems to need a lot of sleep. He's only 21 and maybe he's kinda immature...that might be why he doesn't handle things very well. Hopefully, he doesn't hate his fans. I want to see him on tour and buy a CD but not if he doesn't want it.

travelin' thru Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:12 PM EST

AI needs to be investigated. Period. Why doesn't 20/20, Dateline, or 60 minutes show up? They'd be heroes. We all know the votes don't count. Quit with your games, already, AI.

Kelly Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:04 PM EST

Simon practically let it slip on Good Day LA last week that Jason would be eliminated this week. He said "He's too cool for school but next week...." then he stopped abruptly, looked flustered and changed the subject making absolutely no sense. This clip was e-mailed to numerous media but of course, no one was brave enough to question it. And look what happened...Jason is gone! Simon must be able to predict the future!
I suspect Jason has been abused behind the scenes for weeks now. The vocal coach was bashing him on Ryan's radio show following Neil Diamond performances so I suspect he didn't get much help from her either. They've been "diminishing" him systematically for weeks now....less face time, bad performance position, judging him before he performs, etc. How could he want to be there? How could be have any fight left? Why wouldn't he be relieved to be away from such a negative environment? He can't say what really happened publicly and he's too polite anyway. Bravo Jason!

toshnoelle Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:00 PM EST

Are you serious? Jason Castro throwing in the towel? How about being squashed by the powers that be! There is NOTHING he could have sung that would have received positive reviews. He went out the way he wanted with the music he wanted to sing!!! I will NEVER believe that he intentionally tried to get voted off! He was HAPPY because he made it a lot further than he thought. His personality doesn't allow him to be "bummed"! He went for the high road and stayed positive! He WANTED to make the top 3 - did you want him to go out crying????

heinzline Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:00 PM EST

Please talk to Jason before you slam him for not trying. You have fallen for all of the "judges" opinions, which we have seen are pre-written. He made a statement about that night, and has been the only contestant to show that he is not DESPERATE for a title. I would rephrase the "not trying" attitude to "not desperate" attitude.

Mariana Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:00 PM EST

Jason Castro has no obligation to me or any of his fans! We like him... no LOVE him because of the way he is, true to himself and he has no obligation to anybody! If I were Jason I would have felt so great to be out of the place where they are beaten him so muh no matter how hard he tried. Jason grow so much, and he will do great ANYTHING he decides to do. He is a beautiful soul and that's why many of us love about him.

heinzline Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:00 PM EST

Please talk to Jason before you slam him for not trying. You have fallen for all of the "judges" opinions, which we have seen are pre-written. He made a statement about that night, and has been the only contestant to show that he is not DESPERATE for a title. I would rephrase the "not trying" attitude to "not desperate" attitude.

Lisa Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:51 PM EST

It's "interesting" to me that in EVERY on-line popularity poll prior to Tuesday Jason was anywhere from #1-#3. Syesha was last in all of them. On the official AI Forums...as of Sunday night Jason has 12,344 MORE Topics posted than Syesha and 198,443 more Posts. Syesha has been in the Bottom 3 MORE than any other contestant who's ever made it this far on AI...Jason was only in the Bottom 3 once prior to Tuesday. I will be honest...I was very disappointed in his performances Tuesday. I hated "ISTS" and was offended that he chose it and "Tambourine Man" was ok but he flubbed the lyrics. STILL, I voted for Jason non-stop on 2 phones plus text messaged in for him for 2 hours straight!!!!! I got many, many busy signals so I find it hard to swallow that many other "loyal" fans were not doing the same thing! I do not believe for one second that Jason "quit" on this competition. A barage of negative comments finally took its toll and that's what we saw Tuesday night! I blame the judges-not JC.

brenda ginnings Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:49 PM EST

Slezak, I couldn't believe the comments concerning Jason Castro's performance in the top 4. Just because he didn't react to his departure the way you saw "appropriate" does not mean he wasn't giving his best to the performance. I totally believe him when he says "inexperience" caught up with him. This might not have been the case if it were season 1 or 2 when the song requirements were different, but in AI 7 Jason was the only singer left with no professional experience or who had been groomed for the stage. Jason is and was the only original and authentic singer actually in the top 8! Also, please don't say "even his fans have to admit that it was time for him to go" HIS FANS love him and voted endlessly for him to stay. AI made that decision for us. Last, please quit saying that Jason was taking the place of singers already voted off that wanted it more than he did - Jason proved he wanted it in the way he went for it in ISTS and in his own words following Wed. night's vote

majorlift Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:45 PM EST

Jason Castro consistently brought fresh, original, beautiful performances to American Idol this year, and he represents what many believe the show is all about.

Mr. Slezak, I've enjoyed your commentary this season, and for that reason, I ask you to look behind the scenes at AI and read between the lines of Jason's interviews to find out what really happened between his IDWC performance and last week. There's a story that needs to be told.

jolynogaha5 Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:42 PM EST

On a lighter note, the Syesha/Wonder Woman thing was great for a laugh, but she is more like a cat with 9 lives...'nuf said.

jolynogaha5 Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:39 PM EST

Michael, I listened to your idolatry edition with great sorrow. Are you entitled to your opinion of how you liked or didn't like Jason's songs? Of course. But to put a judgement call on it and imply that A. He didn't want it, B. He threw in the towel, C. He didn't care...is simply wrong. This idea totally contradicts EVERYTHING Jason has said in his very articulate exit interviews, including the printed one on EW's website. Do you not read? For you to say what you said in this piece basically makes Jason a liar and SORRY, his character shows something WAAAY above such behavior. He has always been honest and humble to a ""fault." His reaction the night he was eliminated showed a young man who was, "As happy as the day I found out I made top 24." (Jason's words) and the same young man who put on a beautiful smile and happy demeanor when each contestant was eliminated, b/c he understood that their lives were not defined by that moment in time. I hope your interview makes this right!

Voice of Reason Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:37 PM EST

Wow....people need to calm down. Just because Slezak didn't love Jason's performances this past week does not mean he has "fallen for" what the producers are trying to sell. I thought we were all still allowed to have our own opinions? And while Jason might not have given up or tried to get voted off, he did say he was "kind of ready to go home" and then appeared elated after he was voted off, so you have to admit that those things will raise some suspicions. Regardless of whether or not he gave up, I think everyone should just take a step back and remember that this is not a matter of life and death. Jason will make a CD and those who want to buy it can, and those who don't can ignore it. If the man himself is happy coming in 4th place, shouldn't we all be happy for him too?

Kelli Jones Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:36 PM EST

Too bad there isn't an accounting firm that handles American Idol's votes. We'd see an entirely different show. Jason Castro is the one truly unique, gifted artist to grace the stage of AI. It's like he's not one dimensional enough for them. He won't fit into their broken mold. Why do people put so much stock in Paula, Simon and Randy's words. It's not like they have any success. Kelly? Carrie? Come on. They've been on seven seasons now.

Kathy Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:28 PM EST

The brilliant Slezak just became a dolt in my opinion if he can't see what happened on this sleeze bag show the past few weeks. I can't believe he fell for that nonsense and is singing the AI machine tune.

bonnylass Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:14 PM EST

Just when I thought Idolatry couldn't get any better...but Wonder Woman twirling into Syeshia just made my day!

Oh and also: holy crap, you Jason supporters are crazy! And i don't think the brilliant Slezak needs you to tell him what his own opinions should be. It's really not the end of the world. Just boycott AI for the rest of the season or whatever, then buy Jason's cd when it comes out. Jeez.

Kit Sun, May 11, 2008 at 09:56 PM EST

Can the Jason Castro bashing please stop! I did not understand the intensity of the abuse that came his way last week. I guess I don't know a lot about music, but I know what I like and I loved I Shot the Sheriff. I will buy a cd that he puts out as I have enjoyed everything he has done. And I am not a teenybopper, I'm over 60.

Jo Sun, May 11, 2008 at 09:27 PM EST

Really Slezak? I'm so disappointed. You were the one reporter that I thought was impervious to the machinations of AI but you caved. You bought what they were selling, and that is that Jason is lazy and just not good enough. I, for one, want him to know that this fan saw that he was trying to do something different and fun, and I am so proud of him for taking such a risk. Worked for me because I loved ISTS. So he flubbed a line in MTM. Big deal, they all have. His elimination reaction was typical Jason trying to make everyone feel better about his exit. He's polite like that. You turned on him so fast. I just didn't expect that from you. I'm sure it hurts him to hear the (far, far) off base things being said about him, but it's okay. You are only making him stronger. And in my eyes you are now just another easily led AI lackey. Have fun with that.

rockwello Sun, May 11, 2008 at 09:27 PM EST

Michael, you are our honorary dreadhead! Surely you understand what they did to Jason! And I'm sure we know only the half of it!
I loved Jason's performances on his final night, but even if he sang Pavoratti, the fix was on by the judges and they would have ripped him to shreds anyway!
I still love Jason, and will support him in his music career in the future!

Stephanie Sun, May 11, 2008 at 09:20 PM EST

Some suggestions for you Michael:
-Listen to Jason's Studio tracks (You can get them on ITunes or on YouTube)
-Listen to Jason's original songs (YouTube..just search Jason Castro)
-Listen to Jason's tv interviews...both when he made the Top 24 and after he was eliminated (You Tube)
-Read articles where people who truly know Jason are interviewed
-Sit down with Jason face-to-face for an interview
Then I'll listen to what you have to say about him, his abilities and his character.

Flower Power Sun, May 11, 2008 at 09:16 PM EST

Jason's performance Tuesday night was enjoyed by his fans. He came alive on ISTS. He performed to the crowd more than he ever had. The only thing he did was miss a lyric on the chorus of MTM. Not the first one to do that this year I am going to point out. I found it a little odd, that when the other 3 contestants did it, is was glossed over with out even a mention, but boy Jason was call to the carpet for it. Looks to me like you Mr.Slezak, bought right into the judges and AI spin machine. There is no way I believe that Syesha had more vote than Jason Castro. This show has been trying to get rid of Jason since ALW week. When they couldn't do it with their comments and bad press, they resorted to taking matters into their own hands. Was this week Jason best performance? No, but it sure wasn't as bad as AI and you made it out to be.

Trish Sun, May 11, 2008 at 09:14 PM EST

Jason Castro should have won American Idol!!! He's a true ameatur and a true star! Proof:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VYd_doxZIYM
http:www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_lCKMFZegU&feature=related
http:www.youtube.com/watch?v=9rDethTI3jM
---AND---check out his ORIGINAL song "Someday" (google it on You Tube).
If you WATCH Jason's post-Idol interviews on tv, he's very articulate, funny and intelligent. WHY was none of that EVER shown on the show??? He was edited in a way that made him look like an airhead. Thta's the image the show wanted for him!!! Jason was a HS Honors Student and on a scholarship at Texas A & M...he also is completely self-taught when it comes to music and learned the ukele in leass than one week!!! LAZY....UNMOTIVATED....NO WAY!!!!

Tina Sun, May 11, 2008 at 09:03 PM EST

JASON CASTRO is the best thing ever to grace the American Idol stage...he's unique, different, raw and REAL!!!! This guy is truly beautiful---inside and out. The producers of American Idol should have worked to nurture and guide him and draw out his God-given talent. Instead, they weren't sure how to "market" him so they tried to destroy him instead. It's "interesting" that Jason is one of the top-sellers on ITunes, he still has more posts in the AI Forum than any of the remaining contestants, he has multiple fan sites on the internet with at least 15,000 members and he has a doll selling on E-bay for nearly $300 and yet American Idol didn't feel he was "marketable". That's almost laughable!!!! Jason WILL be a success. He is NOT LAZY....he's a perfectionist and a true musician who sings from his soul and was "frustrated" when he wasn't given enough time to prepare. he also says he was tired of doing other peoples' songs and waats to get back to doing more of his own original stuff.

gailer Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:58 PM EST

MICHAEL -- you fell for the ruse. There is no way Jason got less votes than Syesha, whether you believe his performance was weakest or not. The AI "machine" found a way to oust him, and that they did. Jason may have opened the window, but AI pushed him out. His loyal fans, including the powerful and numerous Aggies, CERTAINLY did not leave him hanging. We voted in record numbers, and I am disappointed in your bailing on Jason, too. Tsk, tsk. You should know better. Look into the contract the contestants sign. Look for the part about producers being able to determine the final outcome. Look carefully! We will NEVER abandon our uber-talented Jason Castro. He is AND will always be THE true American Idol of Season 7.

Donna Wallerstein Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:48 PM EST

Hey, Michael, what happened to the glimpse you got behind the wizard's curtain? It absolutely wouldn't have mattered if Jason Castro had sung the "Hallelujah Chorus" as performed by the Mormon Tabernacle Choir....he was going to get voted off. He sang a fine rendition of "I Shot the Sheriff" - not my favorite song, but he didn't butcher it. And "Mr. Tambourine Man" was vocally very nice, excepting the lyric bit. He just doesn't fit the pre-determined Idol mold. I say hurray! One more time, they get exactly the finale they deserve with three already-professional singers. The soulful amateur moves on to greater things.

Elaine Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:40 PM EST

I always thought AI was about the best performance. Guess I was wrong bc I thought Jason was perfect. He was true, he was ORIGINAL. he did something that was completely Jason, with no apology. Many did not like his version (Bob Marley) of ISTS but only Jason has ever had the guts to come out and do anything like this. The top three are all really good singers but Jason is sooo much more.

I don't honestly know if AI messes with the votes or not. I do know that it is thier show and they can run it anyway they like. Whether we like it or not DOES NOT matter. AI is no different than any thing else produced in Hollywood or whereever. Believe it at your own risk. That being said I thank AI for introdicing me to Jason. For the first time in years I am excited about someone. I don't care what anyone wlse thinks. If he turns out CDs, I will stand in line for them. IT'S ALL ABOUT THE PANTS, LOVE YA.

rollingstone Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:38 PM EST

Michael, Please, can you tell me one memorable performance Syesha has had all year? I only remember her awesome baby cry. She's a pretty girl, but not original at all. Nothing unique about her voice. I miss Carly. I miss Michael Johns and I will REALLY miss Jason Castro. I agree with whoever said not to give up on Jason. He did try, he stayed true to himself. He showed his grace and manners through it all. He wasn't really cut out for AI. Like he said, he needs to connect emotionally with a song before he sings it and he didn't have the time. I think his frustration with it all was seen as he didn't care. Jason is shy, inexperienced with the showbiz scene and different from the rest. He did give it his all the best he could. Cut him some slack..and try to hear his side when you interview him. You are a great writer and I've liked your reviews this season..come on stay gold.

kimconmom Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:38 PM EST

Mr. Slezak...thank you for being Jason's fan all season. I'm sorry you felt the way you did about his last performances. Those of us who have followed Jason all season KNOW exactly what he was doing...he realized THEY were NOT going to LET him WIN, so he did what he and his fans wanted (many fanbased boards were itching for him to do Marley and Dylan) and he delivered. He was animated, totally stepped out of the box, and TARGETED the AI machine for their blatant running over Jason with their agenda buses!!! I'm proud of him and will support him from here on out. Jason, your true fans applaud you and will follow your career post-AI! The Dreadheads and Castronauts have your back - BIGTIME!!!

Charlene Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:28 PM EST

Oh no, Michael, you didn't! You fell for the Idol machine spin doctorory. Jason didn't throw in the towel. He showed a lot of energy in his ISTS. So, he forgot a line in MTM? None of the others who have done so in this season were accused of quitting because they had a misstep. How unfair of you. I'm sad that you even thought this. Sounds like the brainwashing has taken its toll on you.

Angie Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:28 PM EST

Slezak I usually love you but I was a little confused and disappointed in watching this idolatry. I don't believe that you gave into the AI conspiracy, as others have suggested, but I do feel that you misread Jason last week. What I saw was a young man fully enjoying himself on the stage. I thought he did amazing and I especially loved Mr. Tambourine Man, even with the slip of the lyric. I think you should go back and watch again and maybe you will see that he really was committed and trying. He was the only one I really enjoyed last week and the only one to take a risk (umm Bob Dylan and I Shot the Sheriff)! In many interviews Jason has stressed over and over again that he really wanted to win and he was trying his best. I think what you have to remember is this kid started singing two years ago, is very inexperienced compared to the others, and has never really learned songs, all the way through, until AI. Jason was under a lot of pressure and his inexperience just got to him

SAlaimo Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:27 PM EST

I can't believe that you think Jason wasn't trying to win American Idol. He was the only one last Tuesday that had the guts to go for it. I loved his "I shot the sheriff" you could tell that he was really enjoying himself and the judges kept telling him to go out of his "comfort zone" I really think he did and then all he got was cut down. Also Mr. Tambourine Man was great but for the missed words. We all know that Simon hates Dylan (by an interview Simon had done a while back). He was probably mad at Jason for doing Dylan. Did you listen to his studio version of Tambourine? It was great, I'm a huge Dylan fan and I thought Jason's version was better. Hopefully you will get a chance to talk to Jason this week and retrack your negative comments. I won't be watching AI this week because it will be boring without Jason...same old..same old stuff.. people shouting old ballads

Tina Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:19 PM EST

AC, even if that's true about the casual voter, they are not gonna vote for the entire two hours. Trust me, I was once a casual voter, and I know some casual voters, who would'nt vote as feverishly as we did. As I understand it, Syesha's iTunes have'nt cracked the top twenty. So who are her fans? AI's and alot of the media's mistake, is thinking that Jason's fans are mostly 13-20 year olds. When in fact, we are much older, and smarter than they think.

kchill Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:18 PM EST

You've gone to the dark side. If you'd taken the time to listen/read Jason's interviews - he didn't throw in the towel. He just can't be molded into an AI pop and they wanted him gone. And, by the way, Seyesha with more votes than Jason? You really did swallow the Kool-Aid, didn't you?

Kim Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:14 PM EST

Michael - Have you lost your mind???? Jason did not throw in the towel, he did NOT stop trying. Instead he stayed true to the type of artist he is and he is the most inexperienced of the lot and that caught up with him. I know it is not as exciting a story as he "gave up" but I thought better of you. Instead of trying to bash Jason more (didnt Idol do enough of that??) why dont you look at what this show does to these people behind the scenes. They maniupulate the audiance, they use these kids for their own gain to the point of not caring what happens to their future and dreams... they used Pauala in the whole Paulagate thing... just so some research. But whatever you do, stop trashing Jason. He is a good kid with PURE dreams and I hope he takes his music outside of Los Angeles before they ruin him. Do an indepth on him, see his awesome mission work, his environmental causes, his work against abuse for women and children. He IS the American Idol.

Tina Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:12 PM EST

AC: it's not so much we're upset that he's gone. I, for one, have accepted this, especially watching Jason on his exit song, and his interviews- that really helped me. What upsets me, and I think I speak for alot of his fans, is how badly he was, and continues to be treated, for the sake of this show. It's not right! He's been nothing but respectful and gracious this whole time, and they still won't let up.

twistedgrape Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:07 PM EST

Also, I can not wait to see how you treat Jason when/if you interview him. You all are very quick to trash these contestants behind their backs, but pretend to be real fans/supporters to their faces. You are just as bad as AI.

twistedgrape Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:04 PM EST

I have enjoyed watching Idoaltry until I saw this episode. I am getting sick and tired of hearing about how Jason gave up. I thoroughly enjoyed both of his performances last week. I could tell that he had fun singing I Shot the Sheriff. And when a singer enjoys what they are doing, I enjoy it too. I think that Syesha was completely fake throughout this whole season, from her "Laryngitis" to her tears this past week. I was really upset that she compared her journey on American Idol to the Civil Rights Movement. I can not wait to be rid of her. There is no way I will ever believe that Castro got less votes than her. In fact I have a hard time believing that Brooke or Carly got less than her. This show has become so transparent. It is obvious to me that the producers of AI did everything they could to get rid of Castro because he could not be molded. Well, its up to David puppy dog Archuletta to be their golden boy now. I really expected you to see though the fakeness of AI, Slezak.

stephanie Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:00 PM EST

I am so very disapointed that after all the effort to defend Jason all season you conviently jumped ship to complete the AI sping cycle to keep the man behind the curtain. Jason performances were from the gut and brought a whole different level of emotion than any of the other 3. I believe as this season winds down the truth will come to light as to what was being done behind the scenes to sabatoge Jason this last week. His votes were massive last week and he threatened one of the Davids for sure . Now how would that look if the 2 golden boys were not in the final after the judges and the producers went to extra unethical lengths to tell every talk show or radio show that these 2 were going to be in the finale. The judges and the producers behavior should and shall be exposed to show that no matter what you may think or who you may support YOU ARE GOING to get the ones that they drive down your throat. I cant wait to support Jasons success thank GOD without AI's input whew

AC Sun, May 11, 2008 at 07:41 PM EST

I'm a big fan of Jason Castro and will be buying his cd but I don't see why everyone is so upset that he's gone! He's even happy to be gone! I think he did get the least amount of votes because the results even show that on zaba on dialidol. I don't think Syesha has more fans than him though! I think Jason has a bigger fanbase but the more casual viewer is probably supporting her (but would not end up buying her album) and she prob. got a lot of votes for those who want a female winner.

Tina Sun, May 11, 2008 at 07:30 PM EST

I'm noticing how none of the Jason haters are adressing the fact that Jason was the ONLY one who stepped outside of his box that night. Syesha stayed in her actress box, and IMO did'nt emote the songs -not even her tears moved me. David C stayed in his angst rocker box. His doo da doo's were annoying the heck out of me, in his first song. And his second song was nothing different from what he's been doing week after week (except ALW). And Archie never steps out of his programmed box.Jason was a spark, in an otherwise dark and dreary room.

Kathy Sun, May 11, 2008 at 07:26 PM EST

Michael, I have enjoyed all your commentaries up til now. Since with did you join that sham of the AI execs? I totally enjoyed Jason Castro's songs last week. Yes, he forgot the lyric to a portion of one song under pressure but the way he handled it was pure professionalism. All others have too. At least he didn't make the band start over like Brook. No way in he** do I believe he came in last place either. NO WAY that syesha got more votes than him. I don't know a soul that likes her or votes for her. No one votes or liked Syesha. AI producers just decided to oust Jason and put her in 3rd place. No where did they say he got the least votes. Also, someone that works for the show said he saw the voting results and that Jason came in 2nd and Syesha last. Jason was just too much trouble for AI. He didn't do things their way but he did things his own way. He has HUGE fan base that voted for him in record numbers.
Go listen to his studio version of Tamborine man. Its wonderful!

Dashing4 Sun, May 11, 2008 at 07:16 PM EST

sorry, for posting twice, i didn't think my first went through, so I redid! oops!

Dashing4 Sun, May 11, 2008 at 07:16 PM EST

I just watched it too and was disappointed..but I think Michael was honestly really upset with Jason's performances based on his article he wrote the day after. He has been such a fan and defender of Jason this season and he almost acted hurt in the article. I think he had expected Jason to do really well and he felt like he let his fans down. Based on some friends of mine's opinion they felt the same way.

On Idolatry, I was surprised that he thought Jason "phoned" in his performances. To me, Jason seemed very pumped and put alot into ISTS..and besides dropping the lyric in MTM, he did really well. I totally believe he is telling the truth with the "vote vote" thing. You can tell in his interviews, he is sincere. Although, I understand your frustration, don't give up on Jason!

Dashing4 Sun, May 11, 2008 at 07:11 PM EST

Micheal, I always enjoy your articles and interviews on Idolatry. I understand your disappointment and frustration with your boy,Jason last Tuesday. I was surprised the night went down the way it did myself. But, I disagreed with you that he "phoned" in the performances. To me, he was pumped (alot more so that ND week)and seemed to be having fun with ISTS. I wish he had picked a different song for sure, but he was trying. And besides dropping the lyric on the Dylan song, it sounded really good to me. But him dropping the lyric sealed his fate. It was so obvious that Simon wanted him gone after Round 1, that even if he had sung MTM well, he wouldn't have gotten the credit he deserved. I'll really miss Jason and totally believe him that he said "vote, vote". Its obvious he is not lying in his interviews. Jason is a class act and was misunderstood by so many this season. I support him 100% and can't wait for him to make a record. Don't give up on him!

Sun, May 11, 2008 at 07:05 PM EST

Oh boy, it sounds like Jason Castro fans are becoming the new version of Claymates, where they will defend him without objectivity no matter how horrible he sounds.

kana Sun, May 11, 2008 at 07:01 PM EST

Lame. Boring.

Paisley Sun, May 11, 2008 at 06:57 PM EST

MICHAEL -- you fell for the ruse. There is no way Jason got less votes than Syesha, whether you believe his performance was weakest or not. The AI "machine" found a way to oust him, and that they did. Jason may have opened the window, but AI pushed him out. His loyal fans, including the powerful and numerous Aggies, CERTAINLY did not leave him hanging. We voted in record numbers, and I am disappointed in your bailing on Jason, too. Tsk, tsk. You should know better. Look into the contract the contestants sign. Look for the part about producers being able to determine the final outcome. Look carefully! We will NEVER abandon our uber-talented Jason Castro. He is AND will always be THE true American Idol of Season 7.

JoanneLight Sun, May 11, 2008 at 06:41 PM EST

Michael: Yure buying into the spin. You're not doing your research. Did you listen to Jason's interviews? He's a perfectionist. He practises very hard. Carly said this. It's a fact. Did you take a listen to his studio Mr. Tambourine Man on iTUNES. Fantastic! Vocal coach gave him highest adjudication (9.25) for that night's performances. You're going to be surprised when this bandwagon leaves you in the dust if you aren't a journalist riding with the truth on his side. He said "Vote, vote!" He would have done his three songs to perfection despite his humility. He got lots more votes than Syesha but they kicked him off anyway. Man, aren't you reading the facts outside the AI propaganda. Saddle up on a real horse, not the kiddie merry-go-rund where you're riding the circle of deception. Come on, you're a writer man. Dig!! or bite the dust.

JoanneLight Sun, May 11, 2008 at 06:39 PM EST

Michael: Yure buying into the spin. You're not doing your research. Did you listen to Jason's interviews? He's a perfectionist. He practises very hard. Carly said this. It's a fact. Did you take a listen to his studio Mr. Tambourine Man on iTUNES. Fantastic! Vocal coach gave him highest adjudication (9.25) for that night's performances. You're going to be surprised when this bandwagon leaves you in the dust if you aren't a journalist riding with the truth on his side. He said "Vote, vote!" He would have done his three songs to perfection despite his humility. He got lots more votes than Syesha but they kicked him off anyway. Man, aren't you reading the facts outside the AI propaganda. Saddle up on a real horse, not the kiddie merry-go-rund where you're riding the circle of deception. Come on, you're a writer man. Dig!! or bite the dust. From a fellow writer

JoanneLight Sun, May 11, 2008 at 06:39 PM EST

Michael: Yure buying into the spin. You're not doing your research. Did you listen to Jason's interviews? He's a perfectionist. He practises very hard. Carly said this. It's a fact. Did you take a listen to his studio Mr. Tambourine Man on iTUNES. Fantastic! Vocal coach gave him highest adjudication (9.25) for that night's performances. You're going to be surprised when this bandwagon leaves you in the dust if you aren't a journalist riding with the truth on his side. He said "Vote, vote!" He would have done his three songs to perfection despite his humility. He got lots more votes than Syesha but they kicked him off anyway. Man, aren't you reading the facts outside the AI propaganda. Saddle up on a real horse, not the kiddie merry-go-rund where you're riding the circle of deception. Come on, you're a writer man. Dig!! or bite the dust. From a fellow writer

Houstonian Jen in DC Sun, May 11, 2008 at 06:24 PM EST

Slezak, I'm with you about Jason. I think he stopped trying--I understand why he would feel so dejected, but I would have preferred an "I'm going to sound awesome and have fun despite you B****es!" attitude from him. It felt like a wasted turn. Would have even preferred Brooke to have that opportunity---and I wasn't a big Brooke fan.

In other news, the Syesha = Wonder Woman clips were HILARIOUS! I almost fell out of my bed. It was so funny, I had to watched that part twice. Keep up the good work, kids.

steveforbertfan Sun, May 11, 2008 at 06:20 PM EST

Jason is a stoner!, he deserved to go. Archuleta has had an unfair advantage, his father coaching and helping him pick songs, thank God he was booted out.
Sayesha is HUNGRY! David Cook just ROCKS!

Rita Sun, May 11, 2008 at 04:31 PM EST

Jason was trying all he did was foirget his lyrics. Excuse me? when Archuleta and Brooke forgot theirs no one accused them of giving up.. JAson just got soo underpraised this couple of weeks. Starting with Memories which was great and was bashed by ALW and the judges i have no idea why. Then came Paulagate and she even admitted she didnt hear FOrever in Blue Jeans which was great!! Then I shot the sheriff and Mr. Tambourine Man which were really cool and entertaining. It's not that he stopped trying it was just that no matter what he did he was never going to get praised anymore. This show is rigged!!!

ilana Sun, May 11, 2008 at 04:29 PM EST

Michael Slezak this year of idolatry is been amazing!
The kristi lee robot, the bambi brooke and now this... priceless!

Lisa Sun, May 11, 2008 at 03:50 PM EST

I agree with Tina. I'm so sick and tired of people saying that Jason stopped trying. His performances of I Shot the Sheriff and Mr. Tambourine Man were great even if he did lose some lyrics. It's not the first time a contestant this season forgot the lyrics, and Jason got through it nicely. Also, I will NEVER ever believe that Syesha got more votes than Jason. Sure, she has a nice voice and all, but her fanbase can't even compare with Jason's or either of the Davids.

Jenna Von Oy Sun, May 11, 2008 at 03:21 PM EST

Slezak on the run-over-Jason bus? Are you kidding? He fawned over his performances, even "Memories," all season long and just because he finally gives the guy serious criticism doens't make him part of a vast all-David conspiracy. Get real.

Tina Sun, May 11, 2008 at 03:10 PM EST

Well, I see your on the run over Jason bandwagon now. I'm getting sick and tired of people saying that Jason did'nt try. In my opinion, his performance Tuesday was the ONLY interesting and entertaining one. Jason did'nt give us the same 'ol song and dance- like the rest of the contestants- he really let go, missed lyrics and all. And I don't believe for one minute that he got the least votes. If you knew anything about our fanbase, you would'nt either.

Angela Sun, May 11, 2008 at 03:09 PM EST

Slezak I'm disappointed this week! Jason had kick a** performances this week, aside from a brief lyrical miss which he recovered from and still did a marvelous job on Mr. Tambourine Man! I'm disappointed that you think he wasn't trying especially since he said in all his interviews that he was giving it his all. I think his song choices really reflected who he was and I thought you would have liked I Shot the Sheriff and the fact that it was a big eff you to the man (i.e. AI machine)! I'm really sad that you couldn't look past the fact that he forgot the lyrics, which every other contestant (some several times in fact) has done this season. I have to disagree with you because I am a huge Jason fan and would have loved to see him in the top 3! BTW a David C. v. Syesha finale would make me cringe!! However, the Syesha as wonder woman thing was hilarious! I wish you had given Jason a little respect but I still love ya and think you are hilarious!

StaleCake Sun, May 11, 2008 at 02:23 PM EST

ok... BEST. IDOLATRY. EVER. You know how people write lol? Well this time I actually did LOL -- loud! And when you edited Syesha's spins to the WONDER WOMAN theme, I may have even LMFAO. Well done! Wonder Woman... You're amazing!

Colleen Sun, May 11, 2008 at 01:06 PM EST

David Cook’s Analog Heart CD sells on ebay for $760.00 May 9!!! #220230908969

David Cook’s Album, Analog Heart is currently listed on ebay at $255.00 bid and rising with one more day to go for this auction. WOW!! Kudos to David on your Beautiful Album!!
Gotta See this for yourself:
http://cgi.ebay.com/American-Idol-David-Cook-CD-Analog-Heart-OUT-OF-PRINT_W0QQitemZ140231299054QQihZ004QQcategoryZ307QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem

During David’s Radio Show Interview Friday, the local DJ, Rocket gave DC a message from Mariah Carey. Mariah DEMANDED that David record his version of “Always Be My Baby.” David graciously said, “OK”.
http://www.mix93.com/Article.asp?id=687716&spid=

Syesha and David Cook finale would be high-energy and awesome to watch!
Go Syesha and David Cook!!

mj Sun, May 11, 2008 at 12:37 PM EST

I dream of a David Cook -Syesha finally. If only...

mj Sun, May 11, 2008 at 12:36 PM EST

I dream of a David Cook -Syesha finally. If only...

NineDaves Sun, May 11, 2008 at 11:40 AM EST

syesha as wonder woman = priceless. honestly the best thing i have seen to date. and stephen - i'm all for a en vogue american idol all star group. just put mandisa and vonzell in there too, okay?

Suzanne Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:23 AM EST

thank God you're here EW to help get us all mad about the all-davids finale that we have no control over. If only the public had a way to render an opinion or, perhaps, "vote" for the best contestants? If only ... if only.

ZF Sun, May 11, 2008 at 10:10 AM EST

Through seven seasons, there have been a lot of contestants who embodied the Peter Principle. They rose to their level of incompetence, but seemed totally oblivious to it. Are we supposed to be mad at Jason Castro for recognizing that he's out of his depth now?

BrandonK Sun, May 11, 2008 at 09:29 AM EST

Why in the world did David Cook record "Hungry Like the Wolf" instead of "Baba O'Reilly" for his iTunes song? (It would have been nice if they recorded all of the performance songs...I wanted his second song last week, too.)

Kiersten Sun, May 11, 2008 at 08:58 AM EST

Why is it that others can forget their lyrics, but when Jason does it, it is labeled as , "Not Trying"?
If he had broken down in tears a la Brooke White, would you have percieved it differently?

Once again Jason is being penalized for being a grounded, well adjusted person who realizes this is a singing competition and not a meeting of his fate at the Pearly Gates!

Hopefully when you talk to him in person you will realize that he WAS trying, but AI is not a structure that nurtures artists who prefer to feel and interpret their music instead of just belting it out.