• More
Back to PopWatch Main
Complete Archive

Coachella 08: Dark Side of the Sunday (Or, wait: Dark Sunday of the Moon?)

Apr 28, 2008, 06:59 AM | by Whitney Pastorek

Categories: Coachella 2008, Music

Justice_l

Well, nuts. Here it is, 1am on Sunday night, and I'm all proud of myself because I've returned from the last day of Coachella-- where the crowds were not quite as pathetic as Friday, but certainly more comfortable than yesterday's soccer-riot-esque conditions-- to write up my blog post so you kids on the east coast can have it nice and early. And what do I discover? That the Whitney of Thursday told her photo editor she'd like a picture of Justice (left) embedded in her Sunday night blog post, because she would obviously be seeing the French DJs as they closed out the fest. But here's the embarrassing part, PopWatchers: The exhausted Whitney of Sunday didn't make it to that show, which means I've now missed Justice something like four times because they insist upon playing after my elderly bedtime. Tonight, they weren't going on until 11-- basically sunrise by the festival clock, even if they had started on time, which I doubt. Besides, at 11, mainstage headliner Roger Waters was still only like four songs into playing the entirety of Dark Side of the Moon, despite the fact that Roger Waters had already played a good two and a half hours of other stuff. Bored, filthy, out of water, and out of patience, I couldn't take it anymore, and totally bailed. So that picture of Justice over there? Useless to me-- and to you, the PopWatchers I so lovingly serve. I'm sorry.

I wish instead that I had a picture of the Shout Out Louds, or Stars, or Gogol Bordello, or, ideally, My Morning Jacket. Instead, all I have to give are the memories of those four bands, each one simply terrific on this final Coaafternoon, compensating for another generally lackluster lineup by providing sets I watched from start to finish. All this-- plus Swervedriver, Does It Offend You, Yeah?, Manchester Orchestra, Metric, Sean Penn, and my discovery of the world's most perfect food item-- after the jump. And I promise to keep it short. This is something I learned while watching Roger Waters.

Bounded through security to the danceably rich rhythms of the Shout Out Louds, rolling up just as the poppy Swedes launched into "Impossible." Frontman Adam Olenius has a voice that's more than a little bit Morrissean, if Morrissey ever employed a cowbell as Olenius does for the catchy bop of "Tonight I Have to Leave It." The group also receives today's Best Guest Star award for bringing out James Fearnley of the Pogues to leap about with his accordion during "Very Loud." Then a quick sampler platter of appetizers (or Jacketeasers, as I think I shall now call them): Manchester Orchestra, a group out of Atlanta that circles the emo county line, and the Field, who-- oh. Right. The Field cancelled, something to do with visas.

So back to the mainstage we went for Broken Social Scene Side Project #1, Stars, where Torquil Campbell and Amy Millan festooned the keyboards with roses which they tossed out to the crowd along with some serious reasons to call B.S.S. Nation the most vital collaborative family working in music today. Not sure what it is about Montreal that breeds such talent, but as Stars cranked their lush, romantic volume up to fill the empty field, I definitely wished more people were around to appreciate it. "Prince said this was the coolest place on earth," said Campbell. "And if he said it, I believe it. Thanks for having us." Then Millan dedicated "Midnight Coward" to the swingers in the tents, yelled, "We'll see you at Metric!" and the two launched into a "Take Me To the Riot" so harmonically golden it's still stuck in my head.

More Jacketeasers: The reunited Swervedriver, whose shoegazey sound Josh best summed up as "Why don't girls like me as much as I like staring at my guitar pedals?", and today's most unexpected surprise, current hype-darlings Does It Offend You, Yeah?. A very nice man in VIP would later refer to them as "Do You Find It Offensive, Right?" but whatever, I totally knew who he meant, and it turns out we both liked those space punks and their furiously hyper video game rock a whole lot, especialy after they dedicated "Let's Make Out" to Elliot Spitzer. Also, further research has informed me that their band name is a quote from the British Office, so now I have to buy their album, I suppose.

Speaking of loud and hyper, Gogol Bordello! So, this was the point where logic unravelled-- maybe in a good way-- and I kind of stopped working and focused on enjoying myself instead, as the day had begun to feel like a wonderfully weird musical desert oasis that only we could see. Josh and I grabbed a beer to better appreciate the Bordellos' gypsy mindset, and we retreated to VIP where, in the press area, a group of journalists were very intently interviewing a man wearing a giant red expressionless mouse head. Out on the picnic tables a woman wearing the lady equivalent of a Borat swimsuit and a Native American headdress was making sure every last one of us saw her ass cleavage. Behind the mainstage, a giant white pig balloon was being spraypainted with graffiti that read, "Don't Be Led to Slaughter," complete with a man in an Uncle Sam hat wielding a pair of bloody cleavers. And in the field, Eugene Hütz was whipping the crowd into a frenzy, everybody jumping up and down to the Eastern European party vibe. I decided that Gogol Bordello are the world's most perfect festival band: They are bouncy, they are encouraging, they do funny things on stage, and you don't have to know their music or understand a single thing they're saying in order to have a blast.

Jacketeaser: Broken Social Scene Side Project #2, Metric, where the lovely Emily Haines and her silver short-suit were plagued by technical difficulties, even though she got the crowd to shout "I LOVE YOU, PRO-ONE" at her cranky synth. Then someone's guitar went nuts and she sighed, "It wouldn't be a Metric show unless we were f---ed." We stayed in earshot to grab some dinner-- might I recommend the Burgerito? It's nothing special, just a cheeseburger and fries wrapped in a soft flour tortilla and the greatest thing I've ever eaten in my life-- then warily meandered over to the last thing keeping us from My Morning Jacket: Oscar winner Sean Penn, who was "playing" his second "set" of the day. Seems Mr. Penn is worried about the direction in which our world is going, and during a short, rather scattered speech, he attempted to enlist Coachella attendees to leave their cars here in Indio and immediately join him on The Dirty Hands Caravan, a six-day "awareness-raising" bus trip to New Orleans complete with free food, free lodging, and campfire songs from Ben Harper. There were about a million and a half things to be snarky about in Sean Penn's short, rather scattered speech, but I don't want to go to hell for mocking someone who's trying to help, even if he can't remember the URL for his own website when he's speaking in front of thousands of people. Needless to say, however, I am not currently on a bus to New Orleans.

How on earth did this get so bloody long already? Um... MY MORNING JACKET WERE AWESOME. Things that were awesome about My Morning Jacket: The new, funked-up material (like "Highly Suspicious"); the new contemplative material (like "Smokin' from Shootin'" and "I'm Amazed"); Jim James' no-longer-shy rock star antics; his space boots; his omnichord; his propensity to wear a scarf on his head and walk around the stage crying like a histronic elderly Russian woman; "Off the Record"; Patrick Hallahan's hair; "Gideon" (so awesome it gave me chills). Show of the Day™ x 1000000000. I have to stop there or I'll write you all to sleep with the sonic crush I have on this band.

Plus, we want to save room for Roger Waters! Um... You know what? I'm outsourcing this one to my estimable colleage, Chris "Handles the Headliner" Willman, because I didn't get it, and I didn't try all that hard, and were it not for the aforementioned giant pig balloon, I might still be sitting, dazed, on a picnic table somewhere. Yes, in what I have recently learned is a long-standing Pink Floyd tradition, that pig went soaring over the heads of the crowd at the end of Waters' first set, while a small plane dispensed a stream of what appeared to be confetti that never hit the ground. (Josh and I are both banking on the fact that it was confetti and not some sort of biological warfare, though I can't stop thinking of that old Onion headline about the Yo La Tengo concert.) Angry political piggy then went floating perilously close to the stage, where extravagant pyrotechnics were lighting the chilly sky on fire; he was eventually released to rise up, up, up into the heavens and flirt with the searchlights until he flew out of sight. I can't help but wonder what that giant pig balloon was made of, and where it's going to come down, and what will happen to it when it does. Meanwhile, it also seems I still can't listen to Dark Side of the Moon all the way through.

Aaaaand it's time for the big finish! PopWatchers, it has been an honor and a privilege to once again have you all in my pocket for this year's Coachella Music and Questionable Behavior Festival. I hope I have in some small way managed to give you a glimpse of what it was like out here, and I hope if I botched it, those of you who attended will let me know. Tune in next weekend for my coverage of Coachella's country cousin, Stagecoach, which has been expanded to three days this year because Goldenvoice is trying to kill me. TTFN!

Mike Thu, May 15, 2008 at 03:11 PM EST

You guys must be sickened to know that the Waters set was by far the most popular set, and the Coachella forum was raving about it as the best set in the history of the festival. But don't take my word for it, see for yourself:

http://www.coachella.com/forum

bryan Tue, May 6, 2008 at 05:50 PM EST

I am going to agree Whitney. Regardless of how influential and monutmental and whatever other words you want to use for Dark Side of the Moon (and in case you weren't there he didn't play dark side until like 9 hours into his set) Roger Waters was boring at Coachella. And that opinion should not call into question one's intelligence. He may be a legend and other bands may not last 35 years,so what?
That's not the point of Coachella. This year more than any other (I've been 4 years) it was about the opportunity for music fans to see bands they might not otherwise get a chance to see live. Case in point, last year's amazing set by Amy Winehouse just before her decent into drug abuse. This year was the only chance for anyone to see Portishead this year. Cafe Tacuba anyone? fantastic! Santogold? Awesome. Duffy? Sublime. Yes Prince was amazing but his appearance was announced 2 months after most of us had already purchased our tickets. As for my vote for the best performance of the festival? Sharon Jones and the Dap Kings. Roger Waters sent me to my tent after taking an hour to play 4 songs. My hope is next year when I get my email announcing the band list for 2009 it will be more of the good solid "unknown" bands and less of the big name novelty acts.

Julia Tue, Apr 29, 2008 at 05:05 PM EST

You missed a great set first thing on Sunday -- Austin TV on the Coachella stage. They're a sweet band from Mexico City, mostly instrumental, and quirky enough for Coachella with their red/black panther masks.

I left just before sundown because I didn't want to die. 2.5 days is my limit it seems. I don't think you should be condemned for not 'getting' the Roger Waters set. There are some things that are better left for private introspective listening and can be really confusing in a festival setting. Maybe that's one of them. I saw Massive Attack at Coachella a couple of years back and I wish I hadn't because it was not the same experience as I had sitting in the dark in my room as a teenager. It was a let down and also why I chose to forego Portishead this past Saturday and go check out Mark Ronson and Flogging Molly. I think I made right call there...for ME.

Kaitlin Tue, Apr 29, 2008 at 03:21 PM EST

I agree with TSM and Brian. Everyone is entitled to their music likes and dislikes, but a good critic knows good music even it it's not his/her thing. The original Pink Floyd and Roger Waters solo are some of the greatest acts of our time-and the real popwatcher is the critic that can't see that.

Scott K Tue, Apr 29, 2008 at 02:03 PM EST

You missed a great show at Justice. Ifg you didn't like the Roger Waters, you should have done what I did: head over to the Sahara, watch Simian Mobile Disco, Chromeo, And Justice. I danced for 3 & 1/2 hours straight and it was incrdible! That was a fantastic way to end the weekend. I am a little sad you missed Mark Ronson, Architecture In Helsinki, I'm From Barcelona, and Islands. All of those guys put on some awesome shows.

Anal0g Mon, Apr 28, 2008 at 05:16 PM EST

OMG, ROFLMAO. FYI, EW: Pink Floyd DWARFS just about every other Coachella act you "write" about (except maybe Prince.) I mean, Swervedriver? Shout Out Louds? Does It Offend You, Yeah??? Like these bands matter, like they'll even be remembered a year from now? Give us a break, sister.

'Dark Side of the Moon' is one of the most beloved albums ever released, and has been for 35 YEARS. Just because you're not smart ebough to appreciate doesn't mean you can convince anyone else otherwise.

Yeah...I'm sure millions of people will still be listening to, uh, "Justice" in the year 2043.

TSM Mon, Apr 28, 2008 at 05:02 PM EST

"I didn't get it...it also seems I still can't listen to 'Dark Side of the Moon' all the way through..."

Honey, how on EARTH did you manage to convince yourself you can write about music? This entire column reads like the blog-drivel of a 14-year-old teenybopper. EW should be ashamed for letting you type this utter nonsense. What a JOKE!

Brian Mon, Apr 28, 2008 at 11:43 AM EST

I only wish you'd admitted to disliking Floyd upfront - your teaser hinted taht he just sucked, but in reality, you don't like Dark Side.

Waters was amazing, as a young Floyd fan. And I wasn't even on drugs.

moo Mon, Apr 28, 2008 at 08:42 AM EST

The justice performance isn't all that special either. They weren't all that great in 2006, they aren't all that great now.

Could just be me. The wierd thing is i happen to like the record label they're on, Ed banger. oH well.

advertisement

Add Your Comments

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject — or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.



  • 1000 characters remaining
    • When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.