After 20 episodes, the 39th season of Saturday Night Live draws to a close this weekend, with a very special homecoming for Andy Samberg, who returns as guest host for the first time. Expectations are understandably high for Samberg, who was an SNL all-star for seven seasons before taking his talents to Golden Globe-winning Brooklyn Nine-Nine. Fans of Samberg and his Lonely Island comedy group are likely counting on a new digital short, like its SNL viral hits “D-ck in a Box” and “Jack Sparrow,” and there’s always a solid chance — it being the season finale — that some other famous faces make a cameo.
Those possible developments will only enhance Samberg’s already solid chances for winning this year’s Mr. Saturday Night contest. After all, hosting the finale is a built-in advantage since voters will have his episode fresh in their minds when they have to chose between him and the four surviving finalists from this week’s vote (Josh Hutcherson, Jimmy Fallon, Anna Kendrick, Andrew Garfield, Charlize Theron). Then again, appearing last didn’t exactly help Ben Affleck last year. He finished last in the final vote, far behind his Runner Runner co-star and fellow SNL Five-Timer Justin Timberlake.
There will be one additional name on the final Mr. Saturday Night ballot on Monday, and once again, it’s up to you to grant a second chance to one of the season’s best hosts. Every year, some of our favorites get cut unfairly, tragic victims of the tyranny of the masses. (Hint, hint… Tina Effin’ Fey!) Last year, Seth MacFarlane was rescued by the voters, and he ultimately placed fourth in the final tally. Might Kerry Washington, Louis C.K., or two-time runner-up Melissa McCarthy shock the vote if they get a mulligan? Now is your time to be heard, to right a wrong. Vote below for the best SNL host who didn’t make the cut — but should’ve.
This shouldn’t be a popularity contest, and you’ve proven during the course of three seasons to appreciate that. We all revere the history of Saturday Night Live, so give new life to the host that did the show the most proud.
The host with the most votes will be on the final ballot, with Samberg and four other finalists, on Monday morning.