Fall TV Mondays: What to watch? What to DVR?

There are a lot of things that stress me out in life: what to eat for lunch, what to wear to work, what to do after work…you know, decisions in general. But few things fill me with more anxiety than figuring out what to watch on TV during the fall season. From new and returning scripted dramas and comedies to so-bad-it’s-good reality shows, each night poses a fresh dilemma between what to tune into live versus what to save for the DVR (or for that matter, skip all together).

I’m sure I’m not the only one going through this. So, this season PopWatch readers, I say we  save ourselves the agony of indecision by declaring our allegiances early on. Everyday this week, I’m going to list the shows I plan to watch live, and record on my DVR, for this season’s coveted 8 p.m. to 11 p.m. slot. Then it’s your turn to share your picks. Let’s get started with Mondays below! 

8 p.m. – 9 p.m.
LIVE: The Lying Game (ABC Family):While I’ve always been partial to the Upper East Side dramatics of Gossip Girl’s finest, this season I’m jumping ship for freshman series The Lying Game. Both shows have similarities (backstabbing? Check.) but TLG gets the upper-hand as a result of a slew of fresh faces and storylines. (Premiered Aug. 15)
DVR: 2 Broke Girls (CBS): There’s no shortage of stories about how to make it in New York City, but thanks to the irresistible duo of Kat Dennings and Beth Behrs this one gets a solid shot from me. (Premieres Sept. 19)

9 p.m. – 10 p.m.
LIVE: Hart of Dixie (CW): No better way to follow-up the twists and turns of The Lying Game than with some comforting Southern hospitality. Also, who doesn’t love a little Rachel Bilson in their lives? (Premieres Sept. 26)
DVR: Two and a Half Men (CBS): Now that Ashton Kutcher’s moving in, I plan to be a good neighbor and keep tabs on how this series is faring. (Premieres Sept. 19)

10 p.m. – 11 p.m.
LIVE: Castle (ABC): While I’m usually already in bed during this time slot, if I happen to have a restless night I’ll spend it with Beckett and Castle. (Premieres Sept. 19)
DVR: Nothing: I’m tempted to record The Playboy Club, but for the sake of my sanity I’m going to limit myself to five shows or less on Mondays.

Okay, PopWatchers, you’ve heard my picks and now it’s your turn. Share your commitments in the comments!

Comments (46 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3
  • Melissa in CA

    Seems that my Mondays this fall belong to CBS. The only show in their line-up I don’t watch is Two and a Half Men. I’m super excited for John Locke on Hawaii 5-0!!

    • Melissa in CA

      BTW, I don’t watch anything live. Except Monday Night Football if I care who’s playing.

      • pastafarian

        MNF is the only thing worth watching on Mondays, looks like. Ima pass on the rest.

  • Chris

    8-9 Record Terra Nova, Gossip Girl, Watch HIMYM, 2 Broke Girls
    9-10 Record New version 2.5 Men, Hart of Dixie
    10-11 Record Playboy Club

  • Justin

    Why would anyone DVR Two and Half Men, let alone watch it at all?

  • AJ

    8-9 Live: HIMYM and 2 Broke Girls
    8-9 DVR: Terra Nova
    9-8 Live: Hart of Dixie
    10-11 Undecided – maybe DVR Playboy Club or just watch football

  • Jay

    Wow, I have absolutely NO interest in any of the shows this guy is watching. Tonight, its Hawaii 5-0, Hell’s Kitchen and the Charlie Sheen Roast for me.

  • Erin

    Mondays are actually a very simple TV night for me. Tonight I’m going to check out 2 Broke Girls, and then it’s The Big C. I’ll probably also check out The Sing Off (Love Sara Bareilles)

    • David

      Me too, I have to watch for Sara even though I’m busy with Dancing with the Stars and the CBS comedies.

  • Hilaryy

    the 10 o’clock time slot belongs fully to Hawaii 5-0! I’m damn excited to see this gang back together and one Mr Terry O’Quinn joining the fun! And I guess I’ll try Hart of Dixie at 9. I do enjoy Rachel Bilson

  • tigge8r51

    8-9 DVR- Terra Nova
    9-10 DVR- Hart of Dixie
    Wed- watch Mon episodes!

  • ChrisV

    I love Kat Dennings, so even though I usually don’t watch comedies (particularly those with laugh tracks or live audiences), I’m willing to at least give this a try. It will really have to earn its way onto a repeat, weekly viewing though. But I’ll try it tonight.


  • JBM

    What a crap list!!! I cant wait to see how worthless the rest of the week will be

  • pie thrower

    FYI: I saw “Whitney” and “Up All Night” ON DEMAND. The pilots air on Thursday on NBC and they both suuuucckkkk big time. Especially “Up All Night.” Not one funny original gag.

    “Whitney” has potential but it better pick up quick or its out after 5 episodes. I give “Up All Night” 2 episodes (it is that bad!!!!).

    Why do networks continue to turn to Christina Applegate to headline a show??? Her only successful show was “Married With Children” and people weren’t watching it for her.

  • Geor

    8-8:30 LIVE How I Met Your Mother
    9-9:20 LIVE Top Gear
    DVR Two and a Half Men/Weeds

  • Michelle

    On Monday, there is only 1 show that exists: Castle

    • Tess


      • Lisa


  • nodnarb

    I grew up in Georgia and went to college in Alabama, so that Hart of Dixie preview looks like the stupidest thing on TV this fall. It’s Hollywood’s idea of what the south is like.

    • IMHO

      In my opinion there is only one Normal culture in America, and that’s Hollywood’s culture. They just set shows in other states to try to convince viewers that there will be something different in the show. If they want dysfunctional families or “cah-razzzy” characters, they set the show in the midwest. But nothing of the actual culture of individual midwestern states is portrayed. “The Good Wife” is set in Chicago, but the shows has references to “Menlo Park” (N. Calif. ??) and NY stuff, but no

      • IMHO

        Stuff about going to cabin up north or …. And Seattle is usually the hip, cool place to set shows, but “The Killing” had no references to Microsoft or the Cascades or even Mt. Ranier or U-Dub but “The Killing” inexplicably had a mob (which Seattle doesn’t have). So there’s no surprise if they’d get Southern culture wrong. And I’ve just realized this is a random, unsolicited rant & if I’ve offended anyone, I am so sorry.

      • Julian

        Seattle doesn’t have mobs? What was the battle for Seattle? & what city does have “mobs”?

  • Ben

    CBS 8 to 11 PM for me. I especially want to watch Hawaii Five-O to see how they resolve the season ending cliff hanger. It will be difficult, since Wo Fat’s man killed the governor, but, they (Five-0) did take the money!

Page: 1 2 3
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP