'From Dust' review: Can a boring videogame be good?

There are certain videogames that you play when you are very young — say, between the ages of 6 and 9, when your brain is still stitching itself together and your hormones haven’t fully kicked on — that occupy a curiously strong place in your memory. As you get older, the games begin to take on the double resonance of literal memory and recurring dream; they can even begin to seem more real than your actual memories from that time. For me, Eric Chahi’s Out of This World is that game. A semi-forgotten example of a semi-forgotten genre released in the semi-forgotten era when people still owned Amigas, Out of This World (which was rather poetically titled Another World everywhere except America) is an eerily silent cinematic platformer which follows the misadventures of a man who finds himself on an alien world. Even though the game looks a bit primordial now, the actual experience of playing it remains very visceral — there are no directions, no heads-up displays, and no dialogue, just strange unearthly sounds and a seemingly infinite number of ways to die.

I was thinking about Out of This World quite a bit lately, because I’ve been playing From Dust, the XBox Live Arcade offering that marks Chahi’s return to videogames after over a decade spent in the wilderness apparently taking pictures of volcanoes. In past summers, XBLA has produced modern classics like Braid and Limbo. This summer’s other big offering, Bastion, was similar to those earlier games — they’re all modern riffs on retro genres — but From Dust is quite different. In the game, you are a godlike force who can control the classical elements: You can gather up dirt from one area and deposit it elsewhere; you can sprinkle water over a desert landscape to help plants to grow; you can assemble a great big ball of lava and spill it over the water, creating rocks out of nothing. It’s a uniquely meditative game experience. Which is another way of saying that From Dust is kind of boring.

I’m not sure that that’s necessarily a bad thing. More so than any other medium, videogames are hamstrung by the simple fact that people expect them to be “fun” — constantly and without fail. There have always been markets for artsy films and for impenetrable novels; there is an emerging vogue for bleak, glacially-paced TV. And I want to stress: artsiness, impenetrability, and glacial pacing can be good things. But the videogame genre is based on immediacy, on forcing the player to do things, and it can be difficult to thread that needle.

Still, I think there’s something low-level fascinating about the gameplay in From Dust. As you build up villages and attempt to divert the path of lava from a volcano, it begins to feel like Chahi is attempting to create something like the videogame version of The Tree of Life — a movie which attempted to juxtapose a single family’s life against the history of existence. In that sense, the problem with From Dust is that there is no juxtaposition: It’s like the “Creation” sequence in The Tree of Life without the movie around it. But I can’t deny that the game makes for a uniquely meditative experience. I mean this as both a compliment and a complaint: From Dust is exactly as much fun as planting a garden. Grade: B-

Follow Darren on Twitter: @EWDarrenFranich


Comments (9 total) Add your comment
  • pastafarian

    is this a prettier version of Alchemy on my Droid?

  • Olive

    I’m a single woman. I uploaded my photos to MySingleParentMatch.c0m. Hoping find my true love online, feel free all women with or without child to contact me for more.

  • misael

    I just paid $22.85 for an iPad 2-64GB and my girlfriend loves her Panasonic Lumix GF 1 Camera that we got for $38.78 there arriving tomorrow by UPS. I will never pay such expensive retail prices in stores again. Especially when I also sold a 40 inch LED TV to my boss for $625 which only cost me $62.81 to buy. Here is the website we use to get it all from, GrabCent.com

  • Terrence

    Wow, really? I thought this game was pretty great and in all honesty, I’m a little surprised you would call the game boring as it was far from that. Racing against the clock to save a village and its inhabitants from dangers ranging from tsunamis to erupting volcanoes became something of an obsession with me. However, I do appreciate your references to Out of This World, one of the most atmospheric games ever released.

  • tresorparis

    You¡­are¡­amazing! This weblog is so great. I really hope a lot more people read this and get what you are saying, ¡¯cause let me tell you, it¡¯s critical stuff. I never would have thought about it this way unless I would run into your web site. Thanks for sharing it. I hope you¡¯ve excellent achievement.

  • tresorparis

    Great article. I can¡¯t wait to hear more about your research tool. If it is as good as your other products, then you will have another winner. Your article pretty much summed up what I have been seeing too. Great to see some hard data.

  • tresorparis

    Thanks for interesting blog post. You guys are always provide information that it makes it impossible not to want to buy your next product ;I can¡¯t wait to see what you guys come up with based on all your research and data that you gather.

  • coachfactoryoutlet

    Thanks for interesting blog post. You guys are always provide information that it makes it impossible not to want to buy your next product ;I can¡¯t wait to see what you guys come up with based on all your research and data that you gather.

  • dust control minnesota

    Some really wonderful information, Gladiola I found this. “War does not determine who is right – only who is left.” by Bertrand Russell.

Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP