'American Idol' behind the scenes: 'Idol' coaches talk the Top 4 -- EXCLUSIVE


Image Credit: Michael Becker/Fox; Kevin Winter/Getty Images (2)

How did James, Haley, Scotty, and Lauren choose their songs this week? What was it like working with Lady Gaga? Did the unfamiliar songbook of Leiber and Stoller stymie the contestants? In our ongoing series, American Idol vocal coach and arranger Debra Byrd and associate music director and arranger Michael Orland answered these questions and more while discussing last night’s Top 4 performance show with EW. For a decade, Byrd and Orland have been on the front lines with the contestants, from Hollywood Week to the grand finale in May. The two work with the contestants on their respective songs, helping them shine on the Idol stage and in front of a national TV audience. Check out their insights below: 

JAMES DURBIN — “Don’t Stop Believin'” (Journey)
MICHAEL ORLAND: I know that the producers always take into account who has gone first before, who’s gone last before. They’re really fair about that. And they also try to do it so it’s a good show. I think it’s just how it worked out [with James opening and closing the show]. I’m kind of bummed that the Lady Gaga and Leiber & Stoller songs weren’t first. I think they wanted to save Lady Gaga for whatever reason, but I think the songs that meant something to [the contestants] were on a whole a lot better performances. But hey, what do I know?

“Don’t Stop Believin’” happens to be one of my favorite all time songs, even when it got overused and abused on Glee. James wanted to stick to the true original arrangement, he didn’t want to do anything really different to it, I think out of respect, because he just loves that song and Journey so much. As soon as he found out a week or two before that that he had to find a song that has meaning to it, there was no choosing between two songs for him. That was it, that was his song.

HALEY REINHART — “Earth Song” (Michael Jackson)
DEBRA BYRD: She wanted the choir, because it’s a big song and she thought three back up singers would not give her the feel that she would like — the subject matter is weighty, she knew that she needed extra voices. I have to laugh [about Randy Jackson and Jennifer Lopez’s criticisms]. I sing a song about what inspires [me], and you say that song isn’t right for [me]. That’s just a bit odd. But hey, that’s the whole thing about this TV show — it’s all subjective. The interpretation I take from that is the judges see her in a specific light and they didn’t see her in that light. That’s what I got out of it.

It’s tough, especially when there are four [contestants], and you sing your face off, and you’re the one that’s told, “Ehh, everybody was great except you.” Her skin is getting tougher, and I have to say we have a lot of talks about this. It’s a learning process for her as it would be for anyone who’s going through that kind of thing. It’s not like she folds and crumbles. It becomes a fighter’s mentality and I applaud for her it. Because you either do that or you die. Those are your choices. And she has no plans of dying on the vine.

SCOTTY McCREERY — “Where Were You (When  the World Stopped Turning)” (Alan Jackson)
MO: Scotty wanted to do that song weeks before [during the Top 7 songs from the 21st century week], and the publishers had not cleared it. I think that they called up again to say, “You know, Scotty wants to do this.” The music publishers get to know the contestants and they become fans. He just loves that song. I think he did [have a second choice], but I don’t remember what it was. When we were in the studio on Friday, working with Rodney [Jerkins], he and I were in the booth trying to figure out some stuff. That whole idea of him changing the melody on the second chorus, those all came from him. He really was so proud of himself for coming up with that.

LAUREN ALAINA — “Anyway” (Martina McBride)
MO: Two weeks ago when those storms hit where she lived, she was absolutely devastated. She was freaked out that people lost their power, she was freaked out that the storm hit her town, so when she was thinking about doing “Anyway,” she was like, “You know what? I have to do this.” The lyrics all pertain to her. When we initially got her first edit back from the studio and they cut the third verse — it was just the first verse and then the chorus and like the little instrumental thing and then the last chorus again — she called me up and she was not happy. She was like, “I really want to do that whole last verse about, ‘Even if they forget you sang the song, sing it anyway.'” I called the producer, and I was like, “Even if it’s a little longer, she’s gotta get that in, that’s really important to her lyrically.”

She sang that song a half [an octave] step higher than Martina McBride. She really pushed herself [vocally]. When she hit it at band rehearsal the day before, it made her really tear up. I literally was up on stage holding her hand, making her just pace back and forth and not think about the notes, just think about what you’re singing. She hit it and at the end of it she broke down because it was just moving for everybody. I was really proud of her.

HALEY REINHART — “I (Who Have Nothing)”
DB: She wanted to sing it, period. It wasn’t hard for her [to choose a song]. She said, “That song,” immediately. She said, “I know Jordin [Sparks] sang it, and I know she did a great job.” And I said, “And that’s all you have to do. You’re totally different seasons, your voices are different, and it’s the Leiber & Stoller catalogue and that’s one of their wonderful songs so somebody’s going to sing that song.”

In past seasons, when a mentor comes through, there’s so much information that’s given to the contestants, they don’t remember a lot of it. So I like to reinforce what the mentor says, because a lot of times the mentor reinforces what I say. I reminded Haley that Lady Gaga said, “I’d like you to sing this song as if you’re psycho.” It made perfect sense. That means it doesn’t become lyrical and romantic, which is where Haley leans. When she first came to American Idol, she was leaning toward the romantic side of her phrasing, the romantic side of her song choices. And for Lady Gaga to give her that advice was pure gold. Golden. So that means we worked on her phrasing, as opposed to being very romantic. [Sings fluidly] “I, who have noooothiiing.” [Sings haltingly] “I [pause] who have [pause] nothing.” Something that simple. Spaces in it as opposed to making it so romantic. Haunting. It’s that love that’s lost.

SCOTTY McCREERY — “Young Blood”
MO: I don’t think Leiber & Stoller songs were easy for anybody. Because you either sing an Elvis song, or an obscure one of their [other] songs. Or you sing “On Broadway,” which nobody really wanted. I love their songs, but the contestants, because of their lack of knowledge of them, really struggled on it. It was just us sitting in the room with Scotty playing through a bunch of songs. When he heard the recording where the guy goes [getting progressively deeper] “Looka there, looka there, looka there” — just from those few spoken lines, he was like, “Oh yeah this is the one for me.” He did want to maybe do an Elvis song, but he had just come off of doing an Elvis song. That’s enough.

MO: When we went into the session with Lady Gaga, we had just been working on going through [multiple Elvis] songs. For her it was like, “Do I do ‘Heartbreak Hotel’ or one of those famous Elvis songs, or do I do something like ‘Trouble’?”  So we did show her online that on season 4, Carrie Underwood did that song. So for her to hear somebody more current doing it and actually a girl doing it, she related to it a little more. She was still stuck on saying the word “evil,” so she had her session with Lady Gaga who said, “Y’know you’re playing a character, you’re singing a song, you gotta have that attitude.” I thought she pulled it off. I just think she doesn’t want anyone to think she’s evil and she kept thinking about that all day, all week, that’s all she was thinking about. But I think she did a great job.

JAMES DURBIN — “Love Potion No. 9″
MO: For Leiber & Stoller, he definitely had a harder time picking. He didn’t know which road to go. He didn’t even really know “Love Potion No. 9.” I had come up with some different arrangements for him before we went and had our session with Lady Gaga, and then Lady Gaga kind of changed it up. She was like, “You really gotta do that rock thing,” and she was making me bang the crap out of the piano.

I got a kick out of watching her with the contestants, I think more than the contestants did. I think [James] was a little uncomfortable, however, I loved that she zeroed in on so many things.  She nailed him [on], Hey, you need to move from your hips there. She just got up and helped him; it probably was uncomfortable at the time, but I bet something good will come out of that.

Read more:
Haley Reinhart on the ‘American Idol’ judges’ criticisms: ‘I’m not going to crack’
‘American Idol’: Randy tears into Haley, and Rupert Murdoch is there to see it, on the scene of Top 4 performance night
Annie Barrett’s ‘American Idol’ recap
‘American Idol’: 30 best performances ever!

Comments (57 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2
  • see that

    Yes!! Thank you Debra for saying you applaud Haley for sticking up for herself!!

    • RCB

      I really hope Haley survives tonight’s elimination. The judges were really unfair towards her. Haley chose a song that inspires her, and the judges said she should have sung a different one???

      • Jeremy

        I don’t think the judges were necessarily unfair to Haley, but they were unfairly positive toward Scotty and James. I’m aactually hoping for a shocker tonite where one of the guys goes home. I’d probably say James, because he hasn’t had the best performances the last 2 weeks.

      • Jaded

        I think that’s totally it, Jeremy! They aren’t super harsh on Haley if you look at criticisms from past seasons, but the fact that they don’t critique the other 3 contestants AT ALL makes the comments towards Haley really harsh. The judges SUCK! But I do like Steven Tyler in the moments that he’s really sweet towards someone–like comforting Haley last night. I would LOVE it if James or Scotty went home!

      • yesrgyer

        hello my dears,I envy my best friend very much,you know he is a young CEO, rich and handsome, just has announced his wedding with a beautiful woman .but Im sitll single. now I am seeking a good woman who can give me true love , so i got a username happylove008 on—-Wêálthy`Connêct.C ó M—– .it is the first and best cl`ub for we’althy singles meet real love or poor people meet a we’althy love…maybe you wanna check it out or tell your friends !
        —-loved last nights episode- thought they all did great! james has been my fav since day 1 but i can see any of the top 4 winning!

      • amie

        Haley time is up.

  • Tupelo

    Scotty should have performed “Captain Jack Sparrow.” I might have voted for him if he did.

  • Joe

    Why is Debra the only one talking about Haley, and Michael is the only one talking about all the other contestants?

    • J

      I was wondering about that too…

    • Kevin C.

      Possibly this week each of the contestants worked mainly with one coach?

    • sourbite

      This is my theory. The contestants have a choice to pick their vocal coach. Debra is known as a difficult one. Laura and Scotty definitely did not want to be under her coaching because with their vocal ablity, they could not meet her standards. The same thing for James. He can hit incredibly high notes, but technically he is a mess. Haley picked Debra because she could handle high degree of technicality.

  • debi

    loved last nights episode- thought they all did great! james has been my fav since day 1 but i can see any of the top 4 winning!

  • linti

    omg u all r really great singers i am writing from (tnt) trinidad and tobago haley-i luv ur voice u hav ur own voice and never try to change it u r a great singer lauren-last nites performance was great and i must say u hav a really gr8 taste in style more than me lol scotty-wow dude ur voice is awsome and u sound just lik an old singer i kno jim reaves i luv hearin u sing u make my day and james-i luv ALL ur song choices u r a rocker man and i really lik u cause u stick wit ur type of music and let me tell u i only listen to rock and it sounds gr8 wen u sing it kepp up all the gd wrk guys im sry one of u have to go tonite gd luck i love u james halley scotty an lauren

  • RCB

    Go Haley! Long live the underdog!!! Death to the Dawg!

    • amie

      Haley is not the underdog. Haley will be going home tonight, deal with it.

      • peb

        Looks like you have to deal with it instead!

      • sourbite

        in your face!

  • ratas assas

    who gives a rats ass about this.

  • Millie Bea

    Haley was shrieking that first song- what she was doing had no relationship to the song, Michael Jackson or how a trained singer uses their voice. It was a train wreck and to say otherwise is disingenuous.

    • DW

      To say what you are saying is disingenuous. The pattern in all these posts is it comes down to the style you prefer. The judges should be providing fair and honest feedback to all the contestants. To isolate one when none of the performances were perfect is unproductive an demoralizing. Haley stuck up for herself; nothing wrong with that.

    • Bree

      Have you actually heard MJ version. He screams the song also. It is the way the song is sung.

      • sourbite

        I agree. MJ could have been proud of Haley because she understands his song and the message in it.

    • Cole

      Please listen to Michael Jackson sing it on YouTube – it’s the same phrasing at the end…and the same “screaming”. Shouting at the world to listen (before it’s too late).

  • jj

    Choose the “underdog” and you get the dog. A career that goes nowhere.
    C’mon people, the other 3 are so much better.

    • Steve

      Then why have so many pro singers been backing Haley and saying she has the bet vocals?

  • liv craner

    Who cares about stupid Halley. We all know she can’t sing and should have been booted out even before pia.I would like Halley to leave tonight. As for my favorite Scotty. Lady GaGa was very cruel to him and she was sick to. I hope he stays. Halley deserved the mean comments.

    • DW

      No one deserves mean comments.

    • amie

      Pis should never have gone before Haley the screamer.

  • Catca

    Actually, the song that stuck with me was Haley’s performance in MJ’s the earth song. My personal fave of the night. Least favorite was Jame’s Journey song. He hit several wrong notes, but as usual, the judges said nothing (except Steven Tyler, when he has nothing good to say he deflects it like last night- “Hey Randy, how’d you like having a Journey song sung” – that’s criticism from Steven Tyler, you could see it on his face).

  • Elizabeth

    Here is the answer to ‘ratas assas,’ apparently you do. If not, why bother to make a comment. Even if Scotty goes off Idol, he has it made. I predict he will be a bigger star than Brad Paisley, and many of the country singers. He’s only 16, and has the maturity of a much older person. I love Scotty, and wish him the best of luck. My second choice is Haley. Her first song may have been a train wreck, but she came blazing back with the best performance of the night. Good luck tonight to Scotty and Haley.

  • Melanie S

    The “half [an octave] step” edit is wrong–Lauren sang it half a step higher, not half an octave. (If you listen to the versions side by side, Lauren’s “do it anyway” phrase ends on the same note as Martina’s starts with, and the drop in that phrase is half a step.)

    • Rebecca

      I was just about to say the same thing. A “step” is not at octave. A half an octave would be 4 notes, while a “half step” is half a note. Big difference.

      • morgan

        The Gaga song sounded like “Anyone Else but You” from the movie, Juno to me. Not a country music fan really, but I loved Scotty first performance and then his second…I really, really don’t like “fun Scotty”. It irritates me the way he looks when he is holding the microphone sideways and making that Howdy Doodie face. I know this is supposed to be about singing, but am I the only one that bothers? I wish Jacob was still in. The Victor/Victoria performance he lost on was unfortunate. Just because you can sing soprano doesn’t mean you should through a whole verse. His sweet spot is an octave lower.

  • tuppy

    I have to echo Melanie S — WAY too much bracket editing in these pieces: We get what they’re saying! We get that it’s a transcription of spoken cadences! And, yes, the over-edits are especially problematic when they actually make the coach’s statement LESS clear.

  • Patty Harris

    Love Scotty & Lauran singing together. A blend of two perfect voices. Hope they win.

Page: 1 2
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP