Things are starting to get a little hairy in Round 2 of our Under-appreciated Entertainer of the Year bracket game. Sure, you may be emotionally invested in your Round 1 choices, but how do you choose between a (fictional) husband and wife? A vampire and a (sometimes) vampire hunter? No one said it was easy, PopWatchers, but alas, it must be done.
Image Credit: Monae: Jiro Schneider; Adam Taylor (2)
Let’s begin with movies, where the parental duo of Patricia Clarkson and Stanley Tucci (Easy A) go head-to-head, making this a very difficult decision for a one Ms. Emma Stone. Both have been nominated — and overlooked — by Academy Award voters in the past, but now they have a chance to win their very own Prize To Be Determined Later here at PopWatch. In music, it’s between two young ladies rocking daring ‘dos, as newbies Janelle Monáe and VV Brown, whose debut albums you should have been listening to, take the center ring.
In a TV matchup that may divide friends, families, and even countries, The Vampire Diaries‘ Paul Wesley battles Supernatural hunk Jared Padalecki for the title of most underrated brooding CW star. Over in the land of reality television, are you partial to Wipeout host John Henson and his “big balls”? Or, in a sea of sequins and sparkles, is Tom Bergeron the true hidden gem of Dancing With the Stars?
Image Credit: Bob Mahoney/The CW; Jack Rowand/The CW; Adam Larkey/ABC; Jeff Samaripa/ABC
It’s time to show them some love, PopWatchers! Get to clicking after the jump. Vote early, vote often, and check out our entire bracket of 64 entertainers worthy of your attention.








Under appreciated is easily Jerry Trainor from iCarly – hilarious
yes!
Completely agree!! He definitely has the funniest moments on that awful show!
Supernatural is the worst show on television. No way that show hasn’t been cancelled yet.
SUPERNATURAL is the best show on tv ever!! Vampire Diaries needs to be cancelled hell that shit should have never been made?
SUPERNATURL is the best show ever!!!! The Vampire Diaries should have been cancelled before it aired! The Winchesters need take them out
Patricia Clarkson against Stanley Tucci? That’s not right, they’re both so great!!
I don’t understand how Stanley Tucci can even be considered “under appreciated”. He is a pretty big star! I thought this little poll was reserved for those who get small roles in TV shows or little known shows/movies.
I agree. That’s why I chose Patricia Clarkson. Stanley Tucci’s awesome, but I don’t think he’s under-appreciated.
i think the point was they are sooo good that they are not necessarily lauded for their solid consistent work. for instance, no one really goes on and on about Stanley in Julie and Julia, yet he was such an integral part of the flick.
Out of all the movies that he has been in that I have heard of; Julie & Julia, Devil wears Prada, Burlesque, Lovely Bones, Shall We Dance, The Terminal, Kit Kittredge, Maid in Manhatten, and America’s Sweetheart’s; he’s always supporting and never the lead. He is underrated and deserves to be the Lead.
@Liz- check out Big Night. Another great one and he has a leading role. It’s one of his classic roles.
@Liz – Tucci is excewllent as the lead in a wonderful movie called ‘Big Night’, with Tony Shaloub, Alison Janney, Campbell Scott, Ian Holm and Marc Anthony. Check it out – you won’t be disappointed.
Go Janelle Monae!!!
Ugh Tom Bergeron is still in this? How is he under-appreciated? He already gets way too much appreciation, especially for someone who isn’t even funny.
So you consider JOHN HENSON to be funny?! His jokes are almost as bad as Leno’s.
No I don’t. For that particular face-off, I chose not to vote.
I also chose not to vote in that one! I have always loathed Tom Bergeron and John Henson makes Wipeout virtually unwatchable!
if it wasn’t for Jill Wagner I couldn’t watch…
Ugh. It’s because soooo many people who go to EW.com are obsessed with DWTS (notice how they write like 3 articles a day on the show!) and no one cares what this poll is actually about, they just like DWTS so they vote for him. Blech. I agree, he should have been voted off the island in the first round…
Asking me to choose between Patricia Clarkson and Stanley Tucci has to be in violation of the UN Charter on Human Rights, somewhere within in the Charter. It’s just not right.
I had to choose Patty.
It’s cruel! Sophie’s Choice all over again…
Under appreciated ~ Jensen Ackles, Jared Padalecki, and Misha Collins
Precisely and add on Mark Sheppard
I love Mark and he shows up on most of the series I watch, he was great in Firefly.
I love Mark so much. All the people on Supernatural are under appreciated. I really hope Jared wins.
Dean from Gilmore Girls vs Stefan from The Vampire Diaries. Sorry don’t watch Supernatural. What kind of sick joke is that, I can’t choose between them.
Tell me about it. Both Jared & Paul are underappreciated. Let’s just declare them the winners and call it a day.
I like this logic. I love them both, it was a hard decision.
For real!
I’m all for that!
I’d say Paul is more underappreciated. At least neither Jensen nor Jared get much notice, Paul is overshadowed by Ian(who is awesome too). Ian is all over the major magazines.
PAUL WESLEY Should Mos Def. Win. He Has Immense Talent. Goes Unnoticed and Unappreciated. LOVE HIM. I Am Also TEAM VV Brown.
Stefan crying like he was on Oprah is episode 2×06 earned Paul my vote
LOL – I agree. His crying was so heartfelt. I could really believe that he was crying.
Deffinately, it was so sad, he made it look so real.
Sam vs. Stefen?
Too hard. Too hard. Too hard. Too hard.
I chose Paul simply because so many of Jared’s fans have been screaming out this year their love of him with the changes to his character on Supernatural. That kind of love says he isn’t that unappreciated.
Totally. Jared isn’t underappreciated to the extent that Paul is, that’s why Paul deserves it more.
Even though Paul and Jared are BOTH underrated for their show, I had to go with Jared since that is the show I watch.
i watch both and it was very difficult.. i ultimately went with jared just cause i’ve loved supernatual longer.. i’m a bigger dean fan than sam though lol
how is Tom Bergeron underappreciated he was nominated for 5 emmys and won 1? I love the guy but he’s not under appreciated
Jared all the way!!!! It’s a touch one, but Sam will always be #1 to me.
I totally meant tough, my bad.
Freudian slip!
Paul all the way! I love Jared, but I think he’s more appreciated than Paul. Paul is an incredible actor, but doesn’t get the recognition he deserves, IMHO.
i really hope jared’s wins this one…
paul is fantastic, but not really underrated, V diaries is getting tons of attention. and jared’s been playing a very complex character for 6 seasons now…paul’s got a long way to go before he has to deal with that kind of story arc.
and by jared’s…i just mean jared. oops.
I completely agree!
I don’t agree. TDV gets attention but a great big chunk of it goes to Ian Sommerhalder.
Totally agree. Paul shouid have more attention from press and fans, and of course writers. He deserves to play the best storylines not because I’m a Stefan fan. It’s because Paul is really amazing actor, who can play everything very, very naturally. He makes us believe him.
What is wrong with them?! Paul vs. Jared? This is so unfair to the fans. I adore both of them, but I’m gonna have to vote for Jared. He’s really pulling off the whole soulless thing. Jared really deserves this.
This vote really tormented me, and I still don’t know if I made the right decision, but I ended up going with Paul. I agree that Sam gets underappreciated, but when I dare to venture into the VD fandom it’s all Damon all the time, while Paul has been quietly kicking a** as Stefan the entire time and not getting nearly as much press.
Me too!! I started to worry when I saw the bracket line up last week. Speaking of Sophies Choices. Two of my fav shows and love both characters. Went with Paul because in the last year I thought his acting seemed more believable. Also Ian Somerhalder has gotten sooo much more attention. While Jard often gets overshadowed by Jenson, Jared seems to hold his own. Comeon there all lots of Sam girls, but who really says they are a Stephan fan when Damon is out there.