More Tech

Jun 14 2010 07:25 PM ET

Kinect: Microsoft's answer to the Wii

xbox_360_slimAfter a year of speculation and a blockbuster presentation last night, Microsoft officially revealed (most) of the important details surrounding its motion-control camera — once dubbed Project Natal, now called Kinect — to assembled gaming press and industry today in Los Angeles. The camera system will debut in North America on Nov. 4 with 15 launch titles and will be compatible with all current Xbox 360 consoles. Curiously, Microsoft did not announce a price for the Kinect, although gaming blog Kotaku is reporting that GameStop is charging $149 for Kinect pre-orders. As a kicker, Microsoft also announced that a smaller, slimmer version of the Xbox 360 (in a shiny black case, with a 250 GB hard drive and wifi internet capability built in) will be shipping to stores today for the same $299 price as the old Xbox 360.

But back to Kinect. Is it worth all the hype? Depends on what kind of gamer you are.

If you’re already impatient that I haven’t yet mentioned the big game title announcements and first looks at Microsoft’s presentation today — I’m talking about Halo ReachGears of War 3, Call of Duty: Black Ops, Metal Gear Solid: Rising, Fable III, etc. – then you are likely going to be sorely disappointed by the Kinect. There wasn’t hard-core, shoot-’em-up, dense and sprawling and graphically intensive game among the Kinect demos we saw today, although Microsoft did announce an exclusive Star Wars Kinect game that will debut next year. Even though the short swing-your-lightsaber-and-use-the-force demo looked a bit rudimentary, both my colleague Jeff Jensen and I wanted to play the game immediately. Mostly, though, the feature Kinect games were essentially Xbox 360 versions of Nintendo Wii titles. And that is entirely the point.

The Microsoft presentation was, in fact, split right in two, with the first part devoted to the “blockbuster” hardcore gaming titles, all Xbox 360 exclusive in one way or another, all designed to reassure the regular gaming press and loyal Xbox 360 gamers that, yes, we will take care of you, we promise, stop message-board flaming us about Kinect please please please. Of those titles I listed above, the most promising by far was Metal Gear Solid: Rising, a sword-slicer that appears to literally allow you to carve up anything — cars, buildings, humans, watermelons — every which way you’d like. The trailer for the game earned the biggest, most spontaneous cheers from the assembled audience. (For more info on the entire presentation, you can check out the live-tweets I did of the event on my Twitter feed: @adambvary.)

But then the presentation shifted away from the hardcore gamers, and to that elusive “casual” gaming audience that Nintendo’s tapped so successfully. This is where Kinect comes in, and where it really started to shine. Wanna watch a movie via Xbox Live? Wave to your Kinect camera, select the movie title with your hand, and suddenly you’re watching Alice in Wonderland. Need to pause? Say “Xbox, pause.” Move your hand to move back in a scene. Say “Xbox, stop” to go back to the main menu. Say “Xbox, play music,” and there’s Justin Bieber, singing his moppet head off. It worked so well, and so seamlessly, I honestly began to wonder if Microsoft was making good on its evil genius grand plan for the Xbox 360 to become the elusive “everything” box for all your home electronic needs.

As for the Kinect games, like I said, most were essentially polishes on games the Wii’s made popular over the last four years: Bowling, ping pong, racing a car by holding an imaginary steering wheel, etc. etc. That said, four games did leap out at me as actually making good on Kinect’s promise to deliver something truly new to the world of gaming:

1. Kinectimals: A virtual-pet game that felt more intuitively interactive than anything else I’d ever seen — pet your baby Bengal tiger, tell it to sit and roll over, hide from it and make it look for you through your TV, and jump rope with it… although I could’ve just been won over by the ridiculously adorable girl who was demonstrating the game.

2. Kinect Adventures: Like the Wii Sports games, this is just a collection of adventure sport centered mini-games, but these require you use your entire body to collect tokens and jump over obstacles.

3. Your Shape: Fitness Evolved: A fitness game that blows Wii Fit out of the water thanks to Kinect’s precision mapping of your entire body. The in-game avatar also gives players the first full picture of how Kinect’s three separate cameras see you, and I gotta say, it was more precise and dimensional than I was expecting. It really does look like a proto version of the Holodeck.

4. Dance Central: Think Dance Dance Revolution meets So You Think You Can Dance, and you’ll get an idea of this dancing game, which is destined to become a major party favorite. The initial release will feature 600 moves and 90 routines, and includes a “break it down” mode that teaches booty-shaking novices how to get their groove on.

My colleague John Young will be along shortly to share his experience actually playing many of these games at last night’s Kinect multimedia extravaganza. Meanwhile, you tell me Popwatchers — does the Kinect sound like a must buy for the holiday season? Or are you more keen on snapping up the newest Halo and Call of Duty game when they hit stores?

And be sure to check back at EW.com tomorrow for updates on Nintendo and Sony’s big E3 presentations. I’ll (hopefully) be reporting from both of them live via Twitter: @adambvary.

Comments (27 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2
  • Nerwen Aldarion

    Kinect looks really cool but I’m a hardcore gamer and until they adapt the truly awesome X-Box games like Gears of WAr, Mass Effect, and Halo, there really isn’t a point to getting the Kinect when I already have a Wii

    • David

      If your a hardcore gamer wouldn’t you get it… Just means your an avid gamer, not truly hardcore.
      Not really your fault though since I know what you mean with the term. I just think the term is inaccurate, I especially hate when PS3, Xbox, or even nintendo fanboys call themselves hardcore gamers and yet own one console, or only play a certain type of game. If you really are hardcore, wouldn’t you invest a much greater amount of your disposable income in gaming, thus possessing all the consoles, accessory hardware, and games you can…
      Oh and props to Microsoft for not blatantly copying Nintendo (PS3 move anyone) and actually trying to innovate, even if only a little.

  • therealeverton

    If it works I’ll be buying one for sure.

    • Nathan

      Knowing Microsoft, that’s a mighty big ‘if’.

  • Chris G.

    Kinect looked good, but continuing this generation trend of moving away from the hard-core gamers to all this casual audience business is going to be rough for them. As I said, it looks good, but it’s a market Sony and especially Nintendo have already taken on with their own systems. I don’t see them gaining all that much ground, even with Kinect.

    • DF

      Don’t think of it as moving away from hard-core gamers are much as getting more people into video games and developing future hardcore gamers.

  • rvb

    Perfect I am a hardcore gamer with a family rare probably…lol . My kids will have an xbox of there own now they are go’n to love Kinect and I will be able to interact w/ them on even more fronts .. can’t wait see what else Kinect will do, im sure they didn’t share everything yet..

  • mary q contrary

    I had to call my 7 and 8-year-olds in the room to see this. They’re completely stoked, I think my son might have even drooled a bit. He’s POSITIVE Halo Reach will be compatible. I hope they don’t disappoint him.

    • Charlotte

      Sorry it’s not at all.

    • mary q contrary

      Yeah, I kinda picked that up after going in search of some more info. He’s gonna be heartbroken, but he’ll still want both the Kinect AND Halo Reach. Better start saving my pennies.

  • dee123

    I think Microsoft’s problem will be a lot of people already have a Wii why buy something just like it?

  • Heather

    I’m not a gamer at all, but this definitely has my attention piqued. I’m anxious to hear about the price before I get too excited though.

  • Rob Grizzly

    I wasn’t impressed.

  • Nathan

    And the really good news is that Microsoft claims there’s only a 45% chance it will red ring on you this time.

    • Joe

      Yawn,
      I get so tired of that … like the people who still think BSOD is a problem on Windows. I think all the consoles have a lot to offer and they all work just fine.

  • Skip182

    Why does EW report this exists, but not bother reporting the horrible reaction by industry experts? There are so many problems with it, not least of which it offers nothing new that has not been available on the Wii and other formats for years.

    • Joe

      what are the problems? Only thing I heard was months ago it was a little laggy but has been fixed. If you are talking about having to wear the orange jumpsuites like on Jimmy Fallon that is false.

      • Skip182

        No, that’d actually be an improvement. What I’m talking about is that offers nothing that hasn’t been around for years. The coverage on the expo by G4 has been particularly harsh on the product. The basic problem with the product is that it ignores hardcore gamers and attempts to market towards the casual gaming crowd of the Wii. The 360 is not a casual gamer system. The PS3s version of this hardware will also be a letdown.

    • Many

      You’re insane. This thing will work perfectly….it is the xbox we’re talking about. I’m told that Microsoft personally made sure there are zero errors in their new “Bounce the Red Ring of Death” Kinect game.

  • Joe

    I am kind of baffled that people thought this would have hard core games right off the bat. I am not sure those games would be any fun without a controller to be honest. However, if those games do come I would not expect them at launch or a few months later. It takes a long time to develop those kind of games. I suspect some companies might have started workiing on a few last year but if anybody is starting now it will take a while. The value in Kinect is its potential and the amount of game studios that are loyal to XBox

    • Skip182

      Seeing as how the next gen of systems won’t be available for at least another 3-5 years, there is a rush for the in-between gimmick. Newsflash: this is not it. If there is a push in anything (at least for hardcore gamers) it will be in the 3D category. While 3D might be crap for movies, it could do wonders for games (especially FPS).

  • Auriana

    The Xbox is just getting built in wifi now? I always assumed it must have it (I have nearly every video game system both console and handheld except for the Xbox). I mean…my ancient clunky DS and my PSP both have built in wifi. What took them so long? Back on topic, the Kinect doesn’t really make me suddenly want to go out and get a 360. I have a Wii and honestly, the only time we actually use the motion sensor are on the Sports and Sports Resort games and then usually only with friends over. I usually can’t be bothered.

  • Stephanie T.

    Does Xbox still have issues with “the red ring of death”? That has been one of it’s weaknesses since day one. Still Xbox has a lot of shooter games so with the Kinect you do not have to use a wand or a remote to shoot. You can just use your hands. Market wise, Kinect is going to big with males.

  • Nicolas Caruso

    popwatch.ew.com’s done it once again! Great writing.

  • Natalia Hatch

    popwatch.ew.com’s done it again. Incredible post.

Page: 1 2
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP