Let's have a 'Twilight' debate: Team Edward or Team Jacob?

Eclipse_lI realize this debate has been going on for awhile, but I just finished reading Eclipse, the third book in Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight series yesterday, so I’m just now entering the fray. (Oh! If you haven’t caught our sneak preview of Meyer’s upcoming Breaking Dawn, by all means click here!)

Are you Team Edward or Team Jacob? After the jump, it’s on. Spoiler-phobes, beware.

So, the obvious answer is Team Edward. At least to my colleague Alynda Wheat, who says, "Team Jacob is comprised of bitter whiners whohate love, and would probably have wanted Juliet to end up with Paris,and Mr. Darcy to take up with his sickly cousin." While I’m on Team Edward, if only because he has better merch, I can still fathom why some people could gravitate to Jacob. Yes, Edward is handsome and intelligent, understanding and patient, mysterious yet open, and dangerous yet fiercely protective. (He also sparkles in the sunlight, drives a Volvo, and can read people’s minds, which would be highly entertaining.) But even though he doesn’t really want Bella to become a vampire to be with him, you know she’ll have to. Sooner or later. And she’ll be giving up so much. (I wonder if you have to hunt mountain lion if you’re a Cullen, or if Carlisle would help broker a deal with the local butcher to get some blood for me her…)

I may find it impossible to think of Jacob as anything other than a little brother, but Bella no longer has that problem. She’s seen the kind of life she could have with him, and she’d be happy. There’s something nice about the fact that they’d choose their relationship: It wasn’t predestined by an imprint or the scent of her blood. (Maybe Bella’s right to worry about whether Edward would be as drawnto her after the change: How will the vampire venom affect her bouquet?)

Choose your side. (And try to play nicely.)

Comments (8750 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 548
  • Neither

    How about neither and Bella finds a healthy relationship. I mean, Edward stalks her and messes with her truck so she can’t go anywhere. And Jacob kisses her against her will (she even slaps him). I just don’t think either of them are healthy relationships. There are lots of great online discussions about this. But I guess most romantic classics are all about unhealthy relationships (hello Romeo and Juliet).

    • BellaHater

      Honestly, Edward AND Jacob should stop obsessing over a doormat like Bella and find awesome independent girls. Or we should just stop worrying about fictional characters and get a life :S

      But seriously, I wouldn’t want my young girls (if I had children) reading a book that features such a weak female lead. She’s a loser, get over it!!!

      • DITTO

        I like stronf independant females who can be reasonable. A loser like Bella comes off as weak and selfish, frankly i don’t like Kristen Stewart period.

      • amy wilkins

        You’re a loser! Get over that!

      • Jordan Dick

        you dont even know what your talking aboout! can you even read? are you ignorant are you imbred!

      • Kelly Clent

        So True!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:)

      • Brittney

        I totally agree Edward needs to stop being so protective and Jacob everyone knows Bella is soo not his type.

      • i h8 kristen

        i hate kristen stewart she’s a horribl actreesss and cant even make 2 word w/o stuuttering. And why would the most ah-mazing man on earth (jacob) want a hoeish weak chic like bella? it doesnt make sense!

      • MN_Jen

        I hate that I’m 28 years old and have an opinion in this (Team Jacob!) but I REALLY agree that Edward and Jacob could do better than doormat Bella. There are so many great heroines in literature – I find it depressing that so many young girls are loving books with such a bland and weak-willed female. If I ever have daughters I will try to push them towards books with characters like Jo March, Elizabeth Bennett, Anne Shirley, and even Hermione Granger and Sookie Stackhouse.

      • Muffy

        Bella is a killjoy.

        Why are men obsessed with her???

      • Bottom fishing

        bella, is horrible. both dudes can do WAY BETTER!

      • meetsingledoctors

        I love Bella

      • Gabe

        Sookie from True blood would kick Bella’s ass!

      • Jasmine

        alright remember its a debate between edward and jacob over bella…not robert pattinson and taylor lautner over kristen stewart

        so based on the book: i am soo team edward. i always have been and always will. this is coming from a person who read the books a good three years before the movie came out and before it became disgustingly popular. even i can’t stand it anymore and i was obsessed when no one else heard of the books.

      • Nehnah

        No need for nastiness…Bella is a nice character…If you REALLY read the books, you will realise that she is a very strong person, someone who knows what she wants and is not afraid to stand up for it…isn’t THAT something you would teach your kids anyway??!!
        Either which way, I am, always have been and always wll be TEAM EDWARD!!!!

      • Team Jake

        MN_Jen

        I am also 28 and I also feel slightly retarded engaging in this but oh well. Team Jacob!!

        I couldn’t agree more with most of the comments about Bella being weak. I as I finished reading Twilight I just kept thinking her parents need to have a serious talk about what is healthy in a relationship. Then as I read New Moon and saw how depressed she was I was kind of aggravated by it. It’s one thing to be hurt it’s another to be delusional and psychotic because you have been “dumped.” I mean Charlie just let her carry on for too long.

        Nehnah being strong and knowing what you want are not analogous.

      • Selena Hearn

        Why would you say that? The twilight series is the best series of books ever. You are such a twilight hater!! I bet you have not even read the books or seen the movie.

      • Tori

        I personaly dont like the movies but rather the books and i mean i read the books long befor the movie came out and i just hate what they did to it i mean come on it’s really no Extreamly rovolting and i hate it oh yeah by the way im 11 years old never had a phone or my own room had to share every thing for the last four years and watch four children on a regular basis so all of you who dont think a kid can be just as just as mature as grown up you affend me and i am sad for your chilren (i also have fifteen awards for math science and athletics i am also in the gifted department and i dont apreatiate it when grown ups dont keep it real with their children)

      • EdwardandBellaLover

        I read every single one of those books and ladies, you all seriously need to get a life! Just conquer the fact that Edward and Bella rock! In Breaking Dawn Bella becomes pregnant and almost DIES because of it. Edward wanted her to abort but she refused too. Bella is strong, smart, and stubborn; but she is a very good role model. I believe that all woman have the right to be opinionated, but really and truly face the fact that all you Twilight Haters are just jealous of the characters in the movies AND books

      • team edward

        First of all its dormant not doormat, unless of course you intend to walk all over Bella, and secondly why are you even on this website if you hate Twilight so much?

      • natalie

        if you hate bella and twilight why would you even be on this site. if you dont care seriuosly get a life if you have nothing better to do and stop critisizing people’s intrests

      • nicole

        exeuse me ! i love twilight and bella is awesome just shut up caz i love edward cullen he is hot and i wish i was bella . what r u saying your better looking than her and u can get better guys grandma ummm…i gusse not . sooo… shut your old mouth haha lol im not joking

      • ashley

        i love jacob and i agree with everyone i just dont like kristen stewart she just isnt tht pretty and jacob shouldnt waist his time on her and who ever likes edward has some freakin issues have you seen him without his makeup UGLY

      • khloe

        excuse me! edward’s the best!!!! I love twilight! shut ur old mouth! Stephanie Meyer is an awesome writer and it came out great!

    • new

      yeah hes so amazing…. thats why he becomes a pedophile at the end….

      • julianna

        i know and i am on his team

      • woo

        my brother said u can get herpies by sucking blood. he like team jacob IM WITH TEAM EDWORD.

      • Team Edward

        I am team Edward because he, in my opinion, is the better BF, he also loves Bella more than Jacob does. Jacob imprints on Renesme so it’s a good thing that Edward wins, everything turns out right when Edward is with Bella

      • Danielle

        Who Jacob? Ha, thats so true!

      • Bex

        Totally TEAM EDWARD!!! Jacob is a pushy, obnoxious dog! Right, listen up y’all- heres all the bad stuff hes done. First, he is irresponsible and lets bela risk her life on a motorbike in new moon. He tries to steal her away from Edward and is really nasty to Edward even though Edward has never really been nasty to Jacob. Then he kisses bella against her will, breaks her hand, and then threatens to commit suicide so she will kiss him again. Then he crashes her wedding and wrecks it and keeps turning up to see her after shes married. Ugh. He disgusts me. Then he imprints on renesmee, cute, adorable renesmee, and makes bella, edward and the cullens really unhappy. He also says that he would rather see her dead than a vampire in eclipse. I HATE JACOB BLACK TEAM EDWARD UNTIL I DIE!!!!!

    • dave

      How old is Edward and how old is Bella? Dude Edward is beyond a pediphile. That’s super creepy.

      • lilly

        that may be but edward is 17 . its just he has been 17 for a long time. hes a vampire so he cant age. in the 4th book bella and edward have a daughter renesmee and jacob imprints on ( falls in love with ) her whil shes still in bellas womb. that would make him a pedifile too. and yes i know jacob cant age till the vamps go away or he decides to quit being a wolf and renesmee will stop ageing when shes about 17. in that sense both guys are pedifiles.

        personly i dont really have a side. im anything im team bella. i believe shell choose the one whose best for her.

      • jess

        “pedophile” honey… it is a book…. a movie… get over it, made for entertainment… if you are following the true love story (which is what u r supposed to do) you will realize she is supposed to end up with edward. he is the soul mate for her not jacob.

      • georgia

        how is hot, sweet immortal eddy a peedophile! bella’s the pedo! hes like 17 and she’s like, 19 so shutup okay! and anyway, this is a movie! if ur so obsessed with pedophiles u must be so sad! anyway, i’m sooo on team JACOB! HE IS A SEX GOD FROM HELL! i like it!

    • Doesn’t Matter

      If you have read the books, you would realize that this point is entirely moot. Everyone gets who they want in the end.

      • Wendy

        I haven’t read the books… Does Bella ever get turned into a vampire or no?

    • Summer

      Hello!!!! Edward is a VAMPIRE. HE’S SUPPOSE TO STALK PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!! Their just fictional characters, can’t anyone get a life!!!!
      TEAM EDWARD by the way.

      • Winter is a pain

        I agree. These are made up characters. If you did not read the book then why comment. If you did and did not like it then too bad so sad. Go read True Blood. Maybe you would like that type of story….or maybe not.

      • Maria

        Exactly like Summer said, it’s fictional, but defo Team EDWARD 100%

      • samira

        i agee i loooove edward, jacobs cute but i love vampires not wolfs

      • julianna

        no And i like vampiers but no he is week i dont care for him TEAM JACOB

      • silly sally

        I am totally with you i am 21 and my mom is in her 40tys and we are both Team Edward P.S does any of you think the edward and robert pattinson are hot and sexy!!!!!!!!!!!

      • georgia

        TEAM JACOB! SEX GOD ALERT! FEELING HOT HOT HOT! BURN BABY BURN! WOMENIZER! LOVING LOVE! HOTBOY TORSO! GET THE BIG POSTER FROM ASDA!

      • Bex

        I want bella to end up with jacob so i can hav edward. And its not sad to like a series of books, if you dont like them y r u even o this site?

    • Boz

      Heathcliff and Cathy. Holy unhealthy. I always wondered why that pair was considered a great love story.

    • annie peach

      um. there are no “healthy relationships” everyman goes a little stalkerish and over protective and pushy from time to time. just like we women can get selfish and moody and confused about what we want. relationships are messed up and hard.

      • Be

        I’M TEAM BELLA SO THE TWILIGHT BOOKS ARE AMAZING SO Who ever hates that can suck it. Renesmee and jacob and bella and edward now and fOREVER. Team BELLA ROCKS FOREVER!

    • jen

      omg! it’s a BOOK! it’s meant for ENTERTAINMENT! Get a grip…sir preach-a-lot

      • samira

        thank god thats what i`m saying people are taking this to far

    • Agreement

      @Neither: I totally support your arguement! Someone make a fanfiction where Bella has a healthy relationship. It doesn’t have to be normal or boring. It should just be healthy, like Renton and Eureka in Eureka 7.

      I don’t care about Twilight, but hte flamewars are fun so I throw fuel on the fire.

    • edwardlover

      what did bella ever do to you? you are a jacob fan arnt ya. you just hate her beacuse she did not fall for jacob right? if so then i am right. do not be a fraide to tell me the trouth i was just was wondring why YOU HATE BELLA SO MUCH!!!! :(

      • TheSceptic

        I think most people hate Bella hate more her lack of personality than anything else. I, for one, don’t hate her because she didn’t choose Jacob (though again it would be the healthier option), but more because she is whiny, moaning all the time, has no personality, and needs a man through which to define herself. She is always dependent on someone, her way to deal with break-up is ridiculous (throw yourself of a cliff to hear the voice of a guy who broke your heart and ran off – yay for feminism), she makes stupid decisions, abandons her family and friends for Stalker-Lover-Guy, etc.
        This isn’t an angry post, by the way. Just answering your question (you asked for truth).

      • julianna

        i dont hate bella i am on team jacob but i like bella

    • julianna

      i do not agre with you you are a hatre

    • julia

      well every one who thinks twilight is dumb you are dumb and if any of you think you like edward better than me you are wrong!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • madison

      i think edward should get her he found her first and plus he had to work for her why sould jacob be albe to come in and take her o ya so people reading that last part is thinking no remeber they new each other when they were kids a nother reson to be team edward jacob had hes chace if he love her so much why didnt he take the first chace he got now hes all mad because she not following you aroud loving you o ya and edward saved bellas life jacob didnt do jake crap love madison p.s TEAM EDWARD LOVE……MADISON7

    • tierra

      Exactly..LOL

    • Eva

      I half way agree. hy not just stop Edward VS. Jacob!!!!!!!!! WILL U PEOPLE GET A LIFE AND LET BELLA CHOOSEE WHO SHE LOVES?!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • keylimepie

      r u crazzy

    • Nicole

      How about Edward. Its obvious Jacob, is after his daughter. Edward is kind and polite, not pushy and rude like a certain dog.

  • Jackie

    Love Edward, but I will agree that at first I thought it was creeeeeepy how he stalked her/likes the scent of her blood (?!?!?!?!) but also factor in the fact that none of the vampire powers work on Bella (except Alice and Jasper)…she’s gotta be special or something, so….TEAM EDWARD.
    (Jacob can be kinda annoying too, he’s rather cocky, isn’t he?)

    • amy wilkins

      I know, right! Jake is sooooo annoying. The fact that Edward is attracted to the scent of her blood makes it all the more interesting! And he does NOT stalk her! I just finished New Moon for like, the 10th time, and he NEVER stalked her! The factor about the gifts is odd as well.

      • Sara

        Ok lets get it straight lady! Edward is ugly, he stalks her, and he is abusive!

      • lindsay

        I think that its just a stupid book and you should really see how they look in the movie…besides JACOB is way HOTTTTTER

      • lindsay

        If you think Jake is annoying look at your self!! If you think that Edward is hot, you must have been dropped on your head when you were born. (Look at his abs OMG!!!!!!!!!)

      • Aryl(I LUV Robert Pattinson!)

        TEAM EDWARD TOTALLY!!!!!Robert is SUCH a HOTTIE!Bella fell in love with EDWARD, not Jacob. She said she doesnt feel the same way for Jacob.+, as mentioned B-4, Edward is HOT, Jacob is NOT!

      • jess

        wow r u serious right now? stupid books? books are what the movies are all about! if u have read the books u dont even need to see any of the movies!! the characters in the books can (and will) look entirely different than in the movies. books are made to be like movies in your mind. don’t ever say stupid books unless you have read them first. i am a 23 yr old i have never read the books but fell in love with the movies, i am excited to read the books because i know for a fact they will be much better than the movies. that is just how books are. so i am waiting so that i can enjoy the movies first and then fall in love with the books. by the way from the first and second movies, i am TEAM EDWARD!! first, even with the movies (twilight and new moon) you can tell bella and edward are soul mates, jacob is a best friend… do you really want to sleep with your best friend??! come on people get the movies and the actors out of your head, focus on the story. i for 1 will be reading all of them

      • Eva

        I completley agree!!! And sara, u just jellous of bella!!!!! :p

    • Sara aka i h8 kristen

      the cockyness is the hawt part..well ther is the muscelezz (wow i need 2 lern 2 speell)lol

    • MZ_CULLEN

      Man i love edward….team edward rocks. jacob sucks get over it.and u guyz need toget over bella when you think of it both edward and jacob have dragged her into two different worlds she has no choice….she is nothing but a teenager in a world that she didnt know existed….i personally like bella even thought she can be weak at times……so guyz stop bagging on bella and get a freakin life!

      • samira

        right edwards hotter i have a edward team shirt (wow im so stupid)

      • teameward

        i totally agree with u

      • julianna

        MEMY STOPED

      • julianna

        you are stoped and i hate you

    • Andrea

      Team Edward! How strangely ironic is it that I picked up the books from my 8th grade students, and now am a more avid fan than even they!!! :-)

      • Isabelle (aka bells or izzy)

        how can you say that jacob is so much better,sexier,and funnier than edward(ewww)

    • Alicia

      I totally agree, why would anyone like Jacob? Seriously!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • zoey

      I love you edward collins you rock my world you are the cuties guy in the world cutier then zac efron my name is zoey richards I am a 11 years old and if I was your age I would be dating you.

      • Eva

        YOU R SO RIGHTT ZOEY!!!!!!! I’m 10 and willing to kill u 1,000,000 times for Edward Cullens!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • georgia

      WOT THE THANG R U TALKING BOUT!U A SORE LOZERS AND JACOB IS SEXY! BYE BYE EDDY OBSESSERS!

    • i

      yes jake is hot but hes annoying! and edward isnt hot at all but he loves bella and he will always be there for her so team edward all the way!!

  • Samantha

    TEAM MIKE NEWTON

    • shaelyn

      team mike really?

      • diamante

        TEAM JACOB HE’S SO HOT AAAAAHHHHHH OMG:)

    • Ryann

      YAY TEAM MIKE!
      But actually, Team Jacob.

    • Allie

      Lol. i guess minor characters need fans to.

      • Jackiee

        AHAHHAHAHAHHAAHAH woow .

      • any

        my mom says team Carlisle

    • amy wilkins

      Team Mike Newton doesn’t exist! For all I care, he is a newt!

      • Team Edward

        I THINK MIKE NEWTON HAS SOMETHING ALIKE WITH JACOB BACAUSE HE BUGS BELLLA (SOMETIMES)

    • COCO

      EDWARD IS HOT AND PALE COLD SKIN AGANIST DEEP DARK BLOOD IS THE BEST IN THE WORLD HOT IS ALL I MUST SAY BUT BELLA IS SICK EVEN MY GRANDMA CALLED HER UGLY!!!

      • teameward

        i agree 100%

      • twilight fan

        ya stupid bella prety and ya ugly

    • jose

      no offense but are you crazy my cousin says that he is so ugly that can even scare a bear. but im in TEAM EDWARD!!!!!!!!

      • Samantha S.

        Of course Edward can scare a bear, he’s a Vampire. lol. but i’m tottaly for Team Jacob (cuz i like them hott)

    • Aryl(I LUV Robert Pattinson!)

      That isn’t even a real team!+, why would u like Mike Newton?He’s going out w/ Jessica!

    • i am a vampire

      Team Grover Underwood :) Yay Grover! who has read the Percy Jackson series? if so who likes Grover? I do! :)

      Team Grover ;)

      • Cassie

        Team Grover? Honestly, Grover? He isn’t even brave or strong. He has hooves! TEAM EDWARD!!

      • i am a vampire

        Yeah, that’s right. Grover Underwood is awesome. And I’m also on TEAM JACOB. >:-(

  • Zoot

    Team Edward – but my 13-year-old son is on Team Jacob. In his school – it tends to fall along gender lines. Girls like Edward, Boys prefer Jacob b/c he’s more “manly” I guess?

    • Crystal

      i am for team edward but my mom likes Jacob (yuck)

      • portia

        team edward.duhhhhhh. L LUV THEM SEXY AN, SLOW….

      • sammi

        dward rocks! jacob is an idiot!

      • bella

        hi its me bella from twilight and i love edward.

      • titiana

        i go for team jacob becaause he has a six pack and edward does not have a six pack so team jacob

    • Dana

      Team Edward all the way!!!!!!!!! NOT

    • COCO

      HELLO ZOOT WANTS UP WITH YOUR BOY TALKING ABOUT BOYS AND ALL THE BOYS AT HIS SCHOOL? DON’T THEY LIKE GIRLS

      • COCO

        SORRY

        BUT SOMEONE PLEASE DELETE IT FOR ME PLEASEEEEEEE SO SORRY ZOOT DID NOT TRY TO OFEND YOU PLEASE FORGIVE MEEEEEEEE

      • samira

        hahahahahahahahahahaha…..right is he gay hahahahahahahahah

    • jose

      I think most girls are starting to like Jacob because of new moon because he looks more muscular. but im TEAM EDWARD!

    • i am a vampire

      Zoot,if ur son likes Jacob, tell him that a girl that goes by “i am a vampire” said he is smart. Jacob is the best.

      • Eva

        If you say ur a vampire, y r u on team Jacob ?!?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Jennifer

    TEAM BACON.

    • jessie smith

      go team bacon!!!!!

      • Cassie

        Yeah! Bacon!!! I love bacon. Bacon is good. Ever had a bacon grease sandwich? Totally unhealthy, but super delisious! Just take the leftover grease from bacon and somear it on some bread along with some actual bacon. Yummy!!!

    • amy wilkins

      Really? Team Bacon? How idiotic are you?

      • Sara

        ARE U SAYING YOU DONT LIKE BACON?!!!!!!! THATS FREAKIN CRAAAZY! WAT KINDA SICK TWISTED MONSTER R U! THATS SICK AND PATHETIC YOU FREAK!

      • mike

        I HATE BACON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

        IT CAN SUCK MY ASS!!!

    • Aryl(I LUV Robert Pattinson!)

      Team bacon?!?!What the heck!Team Jacob people have brain issues, like, cute finding issues!Want a hottie?Go for Edward!

      • Darwin

        Are vampires still mammals? They don’t produce milk anymore. If that’s the case I think Bella should have chosen the more mammal of the two.

      • teameward

        that is so true

  • Michelle

    Um, didn’t “Team Jacob” already LOSE? Why are we even talking about this? Jacob is a loser, a manipulative jerk. Bella CHOSE Edward. HELLO.
    Move on!

    • Kemy

      Shutup gosh jacob doesnt you do sorry but u do hahah

    • Crystal

      yeah but my mom and my aunt like Jacob

    • Dana

      So it is fun!

    • Taylor

      sooo true! bella already chose edward and after she becomes a vampire she has NO NEED WHAT SO EVER for Jacob anymore! they are JUST friends! the only reason jacob is even around is renessme!

      • jordan blankinship

        sooooo true!i think edwards gonna win after he turns bella into a VAMPIRE so i go 4 TEAM VAMPIRE

    • shalana

      JACOB IS AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! EDWARD SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

      • Sara

        TOTALLY TRUE! YOU ROOOOCCCKKK!!!!!!

      • i am a vampire

        OMG u r SOOOO right!!!!!!!!!!! Jacob is the best! ;)

      • teameward

        i totally disagree jacog is not as hot and sexy as eward

      • Isabelle (aka bells or izzy)

        jacob is so tottaly awsome i agrree

      • mariah

        I THOUGHT THIS WAS OVER?
        ”TEAM EDWARD” ALREADY WON!
        SORRY FOR THE ”TEAM JACOB” FANS BUT THIS IS DONEE!!!!! MOVE ON!
        BY THE WAY:”TEAM EDWARD” 100%

    • jose

      I go with you JACOB IS A LOOSER!!! and im always TEAM EDWARD. GO TEAM EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • booblle

      u suck buddy he is still cool

    • candy acosta

      I TOTALLY AGREE WITH WHAT U HAVE TO SAY!! ITS SOO TRUE!!

  • Krystal

    TEAM MIKE NEWTON

    • Donia

      TEAM JACOB/TAYLOR LATNER IS HOTTTT!!!!

    • Super Jacob fan

      Lol. Mike is cool, but I’m all for Jacob. :)

  • Gillian

    TEAM JACOB. Edward got too controlling and manipulative in Eclipse and I began to hate him.

    • Crystal

      you suck

      • any

        ditto

      • shalana

        shut up

    • Dana

      Team Jacob rocks!!!!!!!!!

      • jose

        Not true Team Jacob SUCKS TEAM EDWARD ROCKS!!

      • cheer127

        TEAM JACOB!!!!!!
        He is hottttt!!!!!!
        FOR ALL U EDWARD LOVERS YOU GUYS SUCK BECUZ I LOOKED IT UP AD IT SAYS 80% JACOB AND 20% EDWARD
        BUT IF IT WAS FOR WATS HAPPENING I WOULD BE ON TEAM JACWARD!!!

      • i am a vampire

        Team Jacob FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!

      • teameward

        i am a vampire that tile does not go with ur team its to be i am a werewolf if ur team jacob

    • Aryl

      Edward already won!Sush about Jacob!Don’t EVER say ANYONE is cuter thanEdward that is IMPOSSIBLE!Go Team Edward!Even though Edward already won, debating the teams is so much fun!

      • portia

        aryl are you my twin sis????!!!!

    • MizA

      I agree! At first I was all about Eddie, but he got so sullen, manipulative, and boring! Plus I hated the fact that he ran off like he did in New Moon. Yuck. Team Jacob!! Super hot boy–and you gotta love all that stuff about the warmth ;)

      • Super Jacob fan

        That’s really true! Edward was boring and lame. At least Jacob has some kind of personality.

      • twilight girl

        team jacob he rulz and he is hot and he is funny

  • Michelle

    Zoot – since when did guys who assault women suddenly the more “manly” ones?? What kind screwed up world are you living in? You better put the belt to your son if that’s his definition of a real man. Hurry before you get the call to bail him out of prison. Run!

    • cody

      how did he assault a woman? i never read anything about that happening..

    • Dana

      It is just a book GET OVER it and move on in your pathetic little life already

      • anna

        if u dont like talking about this kind of stuff get of the website but dont post stupid things like that

  • Vhari

    TEAM PHIL COLLINS bb.

    • shaelyn

      TEAM ALICE

      • i am a vampire

        Yep, team Alice ;)

    • Lelwa

      WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOTTTTTTTTTTTTT TEAM PHIL COLLINS!!!!!!!!!

  • Jackie

    Firmly on Team Edward! He loves Bella enough that he’d go to any lengths to protect her and keep her safe, even at the risk of causing himself(and her) pain. Plus, he wants her happiness more than anything else. He would have been willing to step aside if that was what she really wanted. Jacob kissed her without her permission (major no-no!) and he was totally manipulative with her. I also feel like he wants what will make HIM happy more than what will make HER happy.

    • Kaela

      So, basically, because Jacob is like Bella, they aren’t fit matches? Seriously, though. Bella is manipulative, selfish, and shallow. Yes, Jake kissed her, but she was leading him on and using him for comfort. She was using him for her own happiness and completely ignoring his desires and emotions. Sure, she felt “guilty” but she also never changed her behavior.

      This all pretty much comes down to the fact that I can’t stand Bella Swan as a heroin. She’s weak, ridiculous, and petty. Ick.

    • Dana

      YOU’RE ONLY ON TEAM EDWARD B/C Y THINK HE IS BETTER FOR BELLA THAT MAKES YOU NOT TEAM EDWARD BUT TEAM BELLA!!!!!HAHA

      • Rach

        @ Dana: When you say you’re for “team Edward/Jacob” that means that that character is the one you think should end up with Bella. I’m team Edward because I know he’s better for Bella, but I personally prefer Jacob for myself.

    • julie

      I am 100% team EDWARD! He does everything for Bella and she isluckey to haave him.Ido not hate Jacob I just think Edward is a better match and Jacob could inprint (which he did NOT on Bella) and hurt her if she did….Edward is the right choice

    • team edward

      Bravo!!!!!! I agree 100% long distance high-five!!!!!!!!!

  • Michelle

    TEAM EDWARD. I’ll even root for Team Bacon and Team Phil Collins before I’d want Team Jacob. I can’t even believe that Team Jacob people exist. You’re all like a cancer, killing this fandom. What is wrong with all of you? He assaulted her. Wtf. You lost anyway. Ha!

    • Dana

      NO WE DID NOT IF I RECALL JACOB HAS A HAPPY EVER AFTER TOOOO!!!!! THAT WAS WHAT MOST OF US WANTED!!1

      • Kujiesar

        I can’t believe you. The only reason people are on team Jacob is because they think he’s hot. Otherwise, everyone would be for Edward.

        TEAM EDWARD

      • melani

        i also cant believe you. the reason that people is on TEAM EDWARD it’s because he’s the leading man and who cares whats good for bella were only comparing edward and jacob….and it’s just a movie(TOTALLY TEAM JACOB)!!!!

    • Team Edward

      I know team jacob is a type of weird cancer that is really hard to destroy but TEAM EDWARD is the super heroe here and everywhere like it or not !!!

    • Hi

      errm he didnt assult her in theory and plus she assulted him TEAM JACOB all the way

  • Amanda

    TEAM EDWARD! The concept of Team Jacob is such a joke. Bella choose Edward. She can’t LIVE without him. She isn’t even sexually attracted to Jacob. Her entire range of emotions for his pathetic mouth raping ass stems from the immense guilt she feels because he’s a selfish manipulator. I think wanting Bella with Jacob is setting feminism back 50 years, not wanting her with a mature man that respects both her mind, body, and soul. Jacob is just a boy with a crush that is getting all butt hurt because he can’t just do what his own destiny is and imprint already and leave everyone the hell alone. The books would be much better if he’d just get the hell over it.

    • cassidy

      he actualy dose imprint on nessie bella and edwards kid and TEAM JACOB all the way

    • Dana

      TEAM JACOB IS COOL!!!! TO BAD FOR PEOPLE LIKE YOU TEAM BELLA (B/C YOU THINK EDWARD IS BETTER B/C YOU THINK HE IS BETTER FOR BELLA

      • Kujiesar

        Edward is better for bella and at least edward didn’t forcivly kiss her!

      • Amand

        Team Jacob is basically all the under 18 year olds that have a crush on Taylor Lautner. Most people that read the books before the movie came out can appreciate the characters in the story, not the actors in a movie. Edward is Bella’s true love, her destiny. The whole saga is about fighting for true love, which Jacob was not.

    • anna

      its not fair to say its setting feminism back when edward always has to be there for bella. she cant even stand up for herself!

    • Team Edward

      NO THE BOOKS WOULD BE BETTER IF JACOB WOULDNT EXIST

      • Nora

        Technically, if Jacob didn’t exist, there would be no main problem for the main character to face, therefore making an even MORE plot less, pointless series.

      • teameward

        i would love that

    • Karina Farris

      I disagree completely. I have been on Team Jacob since first reading Twilight. Jacob DOES NOT just have a “crush” on Bella. He loves ger for who she is, and will even wait for her after she is a vampire. It takes a lot of strength to sit in a home full of vampires and not rampage through the place killing every blood-sucker in sight, just to get Bella to be with him. Also, he doesn’t lie to hre to protect her— he tells her the truth so she knows what she is being protected from. And finally, he loves Bella for her idiotic, reckless, trouble-bringing self. And thats all there is to it. TEAM JACOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! =]

    • Erin

      I happen to be on team Laugh at people who are obsessed with Edward or Jacob. Just because Bella chose Edward, doesn’t make him better. Kristen Stewart is a blonde in disguise. No offense to any blondes, I’m blonde too. =D

    • portia

      amanda!!!! its portia in your class

    • jessie

      amanda is so right team Edward of course most Jacob fans only care for his body (notice i said most)which is not right. also remember here that its about edward bella and jacob not the actors ppl. bella loves edward more and its about her emotions for him we r seeing him through her eyes which makes me like him more the thought that jacob is better because of his looks is very sickening which makes u not a very good fan :( while some think edward is abusive he just cares sooo much for her like u guys wouldnt get a little like that if ur gf was around ur enemy alot and then kisses him!!! im surprised edward hasnt hit him yet i would have!!!!!!>:( so stop bitching

  • Stephie

    TEAM HOBO

    • amy wilkins

      really? team hobo?

      • Lelwa

        Yes Amy really.

        Hobos RULE Vamp-wolves DROOL!

        Bwahahah!!!!

    • any

      what in the world?!

  • Audrey

    TEAM BACON LIPS

    • s.

      TEAM HARRY POTTER!

      • Nora

        Personally, I’m team Neville, but I LOVE what you mean!!!!!
        I swear we’re two of the few sane people on this page :).

      • i am a vampire

        no, team Ron!!!
        Ron weasly :)

      • arin

        Weasley is our king c:

      • Super Jacob fan

        I agree with i am a vampire. I <3 Ron. But Neville's cool too.

    • nike0013

      BACON LIIIIIIPPPSSSSS!!!!!!!

Page: 1 2 3 548
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP