Dawnie Walton and I discuss Jason Castro’s heartthrob potential, Carly ”Irish girl” Smithson’s "forgettable" factor, and whether David Cook’s "Eleanor Rigby" was really all that. Ch-ch-check it out, then weigh in with your own thoughts in the comments section below.
Mar 18 2008 04:34 PM ET
Who's got momentum heading into tonight's 'Idol'?
- 'Dancing With the Stars' champs are...
- CBS takes 2012-13 ratings crown from Fox
- 'Voice' dedicates song to tornado victims
- Justin Bieber booed: Will he listen?
- Bon Jovi to Bieber: Don't be late!
- 'Criminal Minds' season finale peek
- 'Buffy': 10th anniversary of series finale
- Microsoft debuts next-gen Xbox One