Mar 1
2008
04:35 PM ET
Which 'Idol' contestant is the new Haley Scarnato?
- Comments 18
- Add comment
Latest News
- 'Voice' season 4: And the winner is...
- 'So You Think You Can Dance' top 20 is...
- 'Channing All Over Your Tatum': Kimmel clip
- Selma Blair exits 'Anger Management'
- Miss USA 2013: Our recap in pictures
- Armie Hammer: No 'Fifty Shades' for me
- 'Dumb and Dumber' sequel finds new home
- 'Man of Steel' gets religion?








I agree about Luke,But please get rid of Danny.He is about as strange as they come.Should have cut Kady,can’t carry a tune in a bucket. And Please someone tell Randy and Simon to Apologize to Connie Frances for Thinking Where The Boys Are, was a country song by Patsy Cline.
The new Haley probably Kady Malloy. Like Haley looks helped her stick around for another week and both can’t sing that well when they are not impersonating another singer. Kady should of went home this week. Alaina should of been safe for at least another week. Luke should of went home instead of Robbie. Robbie was good enough to make the Top 12. Danny and Luke need to go home next week.
Kady should of went home this week.
Kady should have GONE home…..
Haley Who?
Get rid of “Danielle”….he acts like a diva already, and there’s no reason why. Oh yeah, by the way: Noriega is to “Punk-Rock” as Michael Jackson is to Gangsta Rap.
…and clj, please also apologize to Connie Francis for spelling her last name Frances!
I think Kady Malloy is definitely the new Haley Scarnato.
Kady is the easy choice but I think it may be Kristy Lee Cook. She’s nice to look at, seems to have average singing skills but bless her so far she is BORING! Maybe the editing during the audition rounds made her seem more ‘all that’. Um, where is Haley now by the way?
Kristy “Amazing Grace” Lee Cook… or whoever trots out in the hot pants first! I would’ve said Kady, but the judges can’t decide who they want her to be.
Without hesitation, Kristy. You guys are confusing plain crappy singer with SKANKY crappy singer. Kady is the previous; Kristy is most definitely the latter. Need proof: dial back to when they announced the top 24 at the end when the show all the contestants doing goofy dances.
Without hesitation, Kristy. You guys are confusing plain crappy singer with SKANKY crappy singer. Kady is the previous; Kristy is most definitely the latter. Need proof: dial back to when they announced the top 24 at the end when the show all the contestants doing goofy dances.
It’s a tossup: Kristy or Kady. I would go with Kristy because she’s already had a record contract.
kady
Clearly Kady. You can’t just sing you have to have be an actress. Kady walks on stage like she is half asleep!
What the heck ever happened to Haley Scarnato anyway? Is she under that rock with Carly’s scary husband drinking Guinness??