The '06 diamond ad: Gorgeous or gag-inducing?


If you’ve turned on your television at any point in the past two months, then you’ve most likely been subjected to this holiday season’s diamond commercial.

I hate it.

Okay, I take it back. I love it. It makes me cry every time. It’s 90 percent the song: Cat Power’s cover of Cat Stevens’ "How Can I Tell You" (watch a Stevens performance here). Cat Power’s version is so whispery and tender that it feels like a hug and a love letter all at once. And it’s 10 percent the dude — is he not just the cutest thing ever? Closing the window to keep the cold out, fetching the necklace that he’s hidden in the grandfather clock, putting the jewels on his lady, and then pretending to be asleep when she wakes up in squinty shock. I’m practically welling up just thinking about it.

Anyway, riddle me this, PopWatchers: Do I have a pitifully low crying threshold, or are there others out there who’ve teared up over the 2006 diamond ad? Tell me I’m not alone!

Comments (43 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3
  • Lori

    Blech! I love this song by Cat Stevens and this commercial completely wrecks it by the way that it is sung.

  • kriselda jarnsaxa

    Sorry, Helin, but I have to go with the pitifully low crying threshold. The song drives me nuts every time I hear it – the whisperiness of it just seems like overkill on the sentimentality, and I guess I just don’t find the guy to be all that cute.
    Ah well, to each their own, eh?

  • NineDaves

    i hadn’t seen that before. sniff sniff….

  • Christopher

    It doesn’t make me cry, but it does make me smile. I thought the commercial got the point of the gift without suggesting that Ms. Perfect only swaps fluids with Mr. Perfect when a diamond enters the equation. It’s tender without being shmaltzy, IMHO.
    And I’m glad to finally know who covered the song– I love the way she sings, “…when I can’t… think-of right-words… to say…”

  • Stacey

    Every time I see that commercial, all I can think is that if someone put something on my neck like that in the middle of the night, I’d probably think there was a spider crawling on me, start screaming and throw the necklace across the room before I even realized what was going on. I’m such a romantic…

  • Dorothy

    This commercial got me every time I saw it. I would buy that song. I love it. I am huge senitmental and this is one of the top 10.

  • Pracca

    I had the same thought as Stacey. Whenever I see this ad, I keep thinking, wow, I would have knocked that off of me. That would not work on me.

  • Lora

    I have a pitifully low crying threshold, but this didn’t get me.

  • Sven

    Terrible ad, and I would be embarassed to admit it was my creation (were I the ad agency that created it).

  • lilly

    Why the heck was the window open?? Huh I don’t get it, Its winter for crying out loud! This commerical is dumb.

  • fredric

    I kind of like the commercial. I like the way at the end, he’s faking sleep and then all of a sudden you see a hint of the smile just before it ends.

  • Ed

    The only thing that moved in my was my pants; when I saw the husband fake sleeping, it made ME want to thank him for the diamonds.

  • amanda

    love it. and thanks for the song title and artist. i had been meaning to find that info!

  • Kathy

    This commercial only made me hit the MUTE button ASAP! Hated it!

  • Mozz

    Oh, the other day, I was just relaxing after a long day, and I tried tried to watch television, but this commercial followed me to every fracking channel, I even tried watching MONK (which I never watch) but to no avail, there it was… I was forced to watch porn instead. Anyone who cries to this commercial does not only have a low crying threshold, but they definetely are in need of getting themselves a life.

Page: 1 2 3
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by VIP