Aug 18 2006 10:41 PM ET

Justin vs. Taylor: The inevitable apology

Categories: American Idol

16330__jt_l_1Is it time to tell the Soul Patrol to stand down? Justin Timberlake is (Sexy)back-tracking on his earlier trash-talking about Taylor Hicks. Actually, it’s sort of a non-apology apology, with JT’s publicist telling the Associated Press that the singer’s remarks ”were taken completely out of context.” Hmm, I didn’t realize there was a context in which ”He can’t carry a tune in a bucket” doesn’t come off as an insult.

Maybe the ”out of context” part referred to Timberlake’s remarks about the difficulties of sudden fame: ”If he has any skeletons whatsoever; if, God forbid, he’s gay, and all these people in Mississippi who voted for him are like, ‘Oh, my God, I voted for a queer!’ It’s just too much pressure.” I’ll buy that he wasn’t actually trying to imply that Taylor is gay or has other skeletons; he just said it in a clumsy way that should have riled not only Hicks but the entire state of Mississippi.

To his credit, Hicks himself has kept admirably silent about the whole affair. Still, someone must have pressured Timberlake into damage-control mode. Is the lesson here that you shouldn’t risk the wrath of the Soul Patrol, or that people who live in crass houses shouldn’t throw stones?

Pick a side, people: Team Soul Patrol or Team SexyBack?

Comments (1-30) of 82 Add your comment

Page: 1 2 3
  • brittney

    team sexy back!!!

  • ger

    Team ‘Get the f#@% away from me, both of you’.

  • Just Me

    Please, Spare me!
    Justin thought that his comments would be well received, but they started a roaring fire. Sure he is sorry. I will believe his pathetic apology when pigs fly.

  • Dana

    definetely team soul patrol. Justin’s whinning is just masking the pain of already being a has been.

  • Orlando

    Who cares! I kinda liked SexyBack, but Justin’s remarks have made me rethink buying future songs. I don’t even watch ‘American Idol’ anymore, but his comments where just plain wrong. So Justin, come foward and apologize!

  • newbie

    I still vote for a Dance-Off!

  • Rebecca B.

    Team Whichever One Doesn’t Do Another Effing Ford Commercial.

  • Zink

    Team SexyBack, i hate taylor hicks with an angry passion! i agree with everything JT said, Taylor hicks makes me want to puke whenever he sings

  • Mel

    TEAM SOUL PATROL
    …without question

  • The Hoff 2D Max

    I smell a 2007 Grammy hookup, a la Eminem and Elton John a few years back!
    But seriously, while Hacks…er, Hicks…certainly DOESN’T have any talent/staying power (they’ve already pretty much phased him out of those Ford ads…and as bad as he sounded in them,it DOES explain Ford’s sales plummet lately), to have a one-trick pony like Timerlake actually SAY it reeks of a “pot-calling-the-kettle-
    black” type of moment.

  • Jessica

    The main issue here is that Justin Timberlake is HOMEPHOBIC! I’m banning his music!

  • sam

    Justin didn’t mean it when he ripped off Janet Jackson’s top, either. Guess that was taken out of context. Not only is this guy apparently homophobic, he is also totally unable to take the heat for the stupid things that he says and does. If we have to rely on this loser to bring sexy back, we are in big trouble.

  • jon

    I just realized that I don’t care about this anymore. My Timberfake hate is a constant and I don’t really care for the Soul Patrol guy. He’s like a young Michael McDonald and I like Michael McDonald. Can I be on Team Sweet Freedom?
    [Shine sweet freedom, shine your light on me. You are the magic. You're riiiight where I wannna be!]

  • Angela

    I like Justin’s music, but the only reason he is apologizing is to hold on to his public. Taylor Hicks is definitely the classier, more honorable man.

  • Kris

    Justin needs to close his mouth. Can we say damage control? Every article I read he is trying SO hard for this “cool”image. It ain’t working, it’s just making him look dumb. And bringing the sexy back? Oh Please, don’t make me laugh!
    I can’t stand Taylor.
    So Team Sexy-back or Team Soul Patrol? How bout neither.

  • Joy

    What would make Justin be so random as to slam Taylor Hicks anyway?? He either:
    1.) knows that using Taylor Hicks’ name will get him noticed (score one for Taylor then being the bigger star and JT the name dropper)
    2.) Cameron has a crush on Taylor and JT is jealous.
    3.) Lance has a crush on Taylor and JT is jealous!!!!

  • Chels

    team SexyBack!! i never liked this taylor character…and i agree with what JT said…

  • T&A

    I took Justin’s initial insults to be the opening big in a quest to be the agressive top in a relationship with Taylor Hicks. Since Taylor didn’t respond due to a total lack of interest in Justin’s come-on….a new offense was clearly required. Hence, Justin’s publicist mentioned that the all the quotes were “taken out of context”, which translates to, “OK Taylor, Its me Justin….I’ll totally be your bottom any hour of any day or night that you want me to bend over.”

  • T&A

    I took Justin’s initial insults to be the opening big in a quest to be the agressive top in a relationship with Taylor Hicks. Since Taylor didn’t respond due to a total lack of interest in Justin’s come-on….a new offense was clearly required. Hence, Justin’s publicist mentioned that the all the quotes were “taken out of context”, which translates to, “OK Taylor, Its me Justin….I’ll totally be your bottom any hour of any day or night that you want me to bend over.”

  • Liandre

    The Hoff 2D Max said:”while Hacks…er, Hicks…certainly DOESN’T have any talent/staying power (they’ve already pretty much phased him out of those Ford ads…and as bad as he sounded in them,it DOES explain Ford’s sales plummet lately),”
    Here, I’ve been blaming Kelly Clarkson’s silly Bold Moves/Go campaign for Ford’s downfall. I hope they didn’t pay her too much because they wasted their money. Twelve year olds don’t buy cars.

  • Kevin

    1st he slams Kanye now Taylor Hicks? That is soo random. Isn’t this the same stunt campaign Christina Aguilera used when she started insulting everyone from Beyonce to Mariah Carey thinking that people would think her comments where clever?

  • Josh

    Justin is trying way too hard to fit in. Didn’t he start out in the Mickey Mouse Club? He wants cred bad and it shows. Knocking other artists is desperation in my book. Be real, put the CD out there, if it’s good, it will sell on it’s own merit. How much money is wasted on all this PR for these people? Taylor is annoying. Again, when his CD comes out, it will sink or swim. Music is subjective, I won’t be buying either.

  • Saush

    I would like to remind JT that I’m very certain there were plenty of people throwing out the “can’t carry a tune in a bucket” rhetoric his way during his N’Sync days. As Josh indicated, I don’t know why these celebs feel the snobbish need to be taken WAY TOO SERIOUSLY by trashing on those doing exactly the same thing that he’s doing. Although I’m not a huge Taylor fan, he’s got what JT lost several years ago.. and that’s heart and love for what he does. It’s now all about the sex for Justin and countless of other artists. I don’t need that rubbed in my face, thank you!

  • Roy Stephens

    Very poor taste, Justin!! Is Justin gay himself, I was watching Punked with Ashton Kutcher (one of the August 18 shows that aired) the other day, Ashton made a comment about loving Justin Timberlake, are they a team?

  • Everlyse

    Parents DO buy cars for their sixteen year-olds, however. Team Soul Patrol.

  • Mia

    Although I would have to agree that I do have a hard time finding any worthy talent within Taylor Hicks …the comments were just uneccessary and rude. Since when does starting out on the Mickey Mouse club trump starting out on American Idol? Watch you mouth Justin, you aren’t that untouchable.

  • Nori

    Team Sexyback!

  • mv

    to the people who keep insisting his comments were homophobic- um, no. i think you missed his point. he was trying to insinuate that if taylor was gay that his southern-conservative backing from Mississippi would be outraged! THAT’S the stupid point he was trying to make. he’s not homophobic but basically he is judgemental in trying to say everyone in MS is narrow minded and bigoted and that is why Gary Susman makes the comment above that this comment should’ve riled not only Hicks but all of MS.
    So can people quit it with the homophobic rants?
    I’m on team taylor only because i like them both but just found JT’s diss unnecessary.

  • Nancy Walker

    Justin is a bonafide jerk! This is not about his fear of homosexuals. This is about his idiotic comments. The former Mickey boy has alot of nerve critizing someone for entering a talent show when he is the king of talent show auditions.

  • lance

    Justin’s an idiot… and a COKEHEAD. He was probably high when he said it.

Page: 1 2 3

Add your comment

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Advertisement
Powered by WordPress.com VIP