What's the all-time best Madonna video?

155529__madonna_lI’ll say this much for Logo: In the fledgling cable network’s ongoing quest to snatch the title of Big Gay on Campus from HGTV and Bravo, its enlistment of megahag Madonna (pictured) is a pretty savvy move. I mean, what better way to stop viewers from flipping to Divine Design with Candice Olson than by interspersing 30 of Madge’s videos amid its regularly scheduled programs from now till June 24, right?

On closer inspection, though, there’s a snag in Logo’s carefully woven strategic tapestry: Its online poll to determine the Ultimate Madonna Video somehow omits the new H&M spokesmodel‘s crowning clip, ”Bad Girl,’‘ a vastly underappreciated single off the 1992 Erotica album. The video casts Madge as Louise Oriole, a troubled executive whose lust for booze and men leads her straight into the path of a serial strangler, and Christopher Walken as the guardian angel who desperately tries to rescue her. That’s my pick, anyhow, but feel free to tell me if my taste is jank (not that you need any encouragement).

So let’s hear it: what’s your favorite Madonna video? And don’t take the easy road, folks — limit yourself to just one.

addCredit(“Madonna: Kevin Mazur/London Features”)

Comments (100 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 7
  • Ed

    OH MY GOD! Michael, this is probably the best topice EVER!
    I would have to SCREAM Deeper and Deeper (Erotica). Madge captures the very essence of what it’s like for a gay man to enter into a club. Especially since she chose a 20’s inspired flapper image along with a pink feathery boa around her neck. She truely is – a gay man trapped in a womans body.

  • mike

    Only one? Then I won’t pick Express Yourself or Vogue.
    Only One has to be Material Girl. Madonna’s poking fun at her own image while giving a huge nod to Marilyn Monroe.

  • Kat

    I vote for ‘Express Yourself’ – it had that hold Ayn Randesque quality to it, that incredible green dress, and Madonna crawling along the floor like a cat. Saucer of milk, me-OW! I really think that scene and the crotch-grabbing scene marked my sexual awakening. Should I be embarrassed by that?

  • Ellipsian

    My favorite Madonna video ever is also one of my favorite three videos ever: “Bedtime Story”. The incredible imagery, matched with a track co-written by none other than Bjork, give the viewer a visual and aural trip that I, for one, can’t (and don’t want to) forget.

  • Eleanor Rigby

    My favourite Madonna video changes all the time, but at the moment it’s definetly “Open your Heart”. i watched it the other day and it’s awesome. Madonna as a high-class stripper? it’s just to appropriate to stand. the choreography was great, and i love the song too.

  • J.Me

    “Like A Prayer” hands down. Nothing in Madonna’s vast and brilliant video vault will ever touch on the sheer genius and provacative themes in that video. The song is rock, pop, gospel, and dance all in one five minute song.

  • Maeve

    Oh yeah…Like a Prayer. Awesome song, controversial video. Fantastic.

  • Matthew

    “Bedtime Story,” hands down. No other video of hers matches the visual inventiveness of that one, and the song is fantastic, in spite of it inexplicably being her first single ever not to crack the top 40.

  • Sugarcito

    DonĀ“t forget Human Nature. That video rocks!

  • jon

    Please don’t beat me down but I loved the vid for “Don’t Tell Me.” I thought it was simple, evocative and some of the best Madge choreography ever and ages before the “Brokeback” cowboy love…

  • mrcr

    I agree, Bad Girl has got to be my favourite. I always found it mesmerizing.

  • Laurie

    I thought I was the only one on the planet that had a special place in their hearts for Bad Girl. It was at the height of video story telling with bands like Guns and Roses and Pearl Jam. I love it!! I also love Lucky Star because I was about six and synthesizer and cheesy dancing were the ultimate in coolness. My sister and I choregraphed our own version of the dance. Madge rules!!

  • Adrian

    Just choosing one from so many brilliant clips is very difficult, but I guess I would go with “Frozen” for its beauty, its effects, its stark approach and its timing in my life. “Secret” and “Ray Of Light” would be very close second and third.

  • djm

    Damn you Michael!! How on earth are we supposed to only pick one??? As if it’s even possible. I guess “Vogue” and “Express Yourself” are the easy choices, and I do love her more artistic videos like “Bedtime Story” and “Frozen”. Then there are her statement videos like “Human Nature”, “Papa Don’t Preach” and “Like a Prayer”. Some are just plain fun like “Don’t Tell Me”, “Music”, “Fever”, “Material Girl” and “Cherish”. And we can’t forget the slower tempo gems like “Rain” or “Take a Bow”.
    Hmmm, I think I will pick “Boderline” because that is the first Madonna video I ever saw and I fell in love with her instantly.

  • Delon

    Gee, this is a toughie! The two obvious choices aside- Bad Girl and Bedtime Stories- i have to include Erotica, Frozen, Papa Don’t Preach, Cherish and a sentimental favorite La Isla Bonita. If i’m forced to pick one i will go with PAPA DON’T PREACH. That’s the one that i remember shot by shot after all these years.
    It’s sad, it’s romantic and it was nostalgic even at the time it came out. Watching it now the nostalgia of it seems almost unbearably heartbreaking.

Page: 1 2 3 7
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP