• More
Back to PopWatch Main
Complete Archive

'Swingtown' recap: More cabin fever

Aug 9, 2008, 08:21 AM | by Gary Susman

Categories: Mini TV Watch

Miriamshor_l Since you were probably watching last night's awe-inspiring Olympic opening ceremony instead of Swingtown, you missed what was actually one of the most satisfying episodes so far. Nearly everyone's secrets spilled out, resulting in a lot of awkward silences, bitter confrontations, and cathartic emotional outbursts. All because Bruce's determination to fix his family (as he stated at the end of last week's ep) took the form of a seemingly harmless trip to the cabin, which quickly went to hell.

The weekend proved dramatic even for the folks left back home, the Thompsons and Deckers. Janet (Miriam Shor, pictured) and Roger (who had packed Rick off with the Millers so they could have some private time) went to see a shrink, ostensibly because Janet felt Roger was depressed and going through a midlife crisis after losing his job, but the therapist could see that the tightly-wound Janet was undergoing a crisis of her own. Janet stormed out, dragging Roger with her, but she returned the next day and confessed what was really disturbing her: Tom's attentions (especially that kiss last week) and the sense that, for a moment at least, she had feelings for him, too. Some sage advice from the psychiatrist: Roger won't feel any less manly if you support him by getting a clerical job, and you should confront Tom about how uncomfortable he's making you feel.

Janet went to Casa Decker to do just that, but when Trina appeared, Janet got flustered and ended up inviting the couple to dinner. (And despite the role-playing, costume-wearing games that Tom and Trina have been playing to keep their swinging moratorium spicy, they were so bored that they accepted the invite.) The pricelessly awkward dinner party did yield positive results (and I'm not just talking about the saucy way Tom complimented the nuts on Janet's cheese ball). First, Janet did manage to tell Tom to back off, and he took it like a gentleman. Second, Trina (whose almost as insightful as the Thompson's shrink) told Roger he needed either to tell Susan how he feels about her (and face the consequences) or get over her. Third, the Deckers realized they were in danger of turning into the dull, domestic Thompsons and quickly ended their moratorium after dinner with a couple of old friends, Anthony and Michelle.

Roger and Susan did spend much of the weekend on the phone; she clearly missed him, too. This tied into some great conversations with Laurie, still appalled by what she saw in the living room last week. She told Susan she didn't understand how, if Susan still loved Bruce, she could entertain the idea of sex with someone else, and she didn't buy Susan's it's-complicated-and-one-day-you'll-understand line. For Laurie, it wasn't complicated; she loves Doug, doesn't want anyone else, and couldn't bear to see him with anyone else. She also told Bruce what we observed in this space last week: that he no longer has any moral authority to pass judgment on her. Clueless, arrogant Bruce was to angry to see this, but Susan finally made him realize that if he tried to keep Laurie from seeing Doug, she was only going to act out in dangerous ways. Which she did, by hitchhiking back toward Chicago to see her former teacher and attend a Jackson Browne concert with him. (Did teenage girls ever get excited about mopey Jackson Browne?) Fortunately for Laurie, she was picked up not by an axe murderer but by a wise old lady (hey, it's Ida Greenberg, the cat-loving, fastball-hurling Wisteria Lane resident killed by the tornado on Desperate Housewives!) who couldn't remember if she'd been married three or four times, and whose whose salty aphorism about how men are as disposable as light bulbs (the best line of the evening) helped Laurie realize that maybe not all romances last forever — maybe not her parents' and maybe not even hers and Doug's. Doug finally proved to Bruce that he was a man of honor by showing up at the diner to pick up the stranded Laurie; tempers were cooled via some soothing pie; and Bruce finally let Laurie go.

I'm still puzzled by what's going on with Rick. He picked a fight with B.J. over last week's spin-the-bottle incident. For the third time this series, he got punched out over a girl. Still, after some grappling and wrestling, the boys made up and were soon doing male-bonding stuff again like shooting at cans with a BB gun. I still think Rick is harboring feelings toward B.J. he doesn't want or even know how to acknowledge (and of course, B.J. has no idea), but it could just be that he misses the friendship he and B.J. used to have before B.J. moved away and met Samantha. Alas, despite the boys' idyll in the forest, the days of shooting BB guns and building sofa-cushion forts in the basement are probably over for these two.

Questions: Will Roger and Susan ever admit their feelings to each other? Will Roger, who fished the psychiatrist's phone number out of the trash where Janet threw it, see the shrink on the sly? What's up with Rick? Is trouble looming for Laurie and Doug? Why did the producers pick a Jackson Browne song from 1977 that hadn't been recorded yet ("Running on Empty") for this week's episode title and final montage, instead of, say, 1976's "The Pretender," which is all about the failures of love and the emptiness of life in suburbia? Who among you had tonight's episode in the pool for when the Deckers would start swinging again? And are Anthony and Michelle the first black people we've seen on this show?

Rachael Wed, Sep 24, 2008 at 08:42 AM EST

I love this show, it's so natural, It must stay on, it's way better than most of the other shows not to mention it's the best thing that shows on Friday nights

JJ Wed, Aug 13, 2008 at 11:15 PM EST

Swingtown is the only thing on TV these days that I look forward to every week. I hate the fact that CBS is killing it on Fridays.

Sharon Wed, Aug 13, 2008 at 10:53 PM EST

Swingtown is the only show I enjoy this summer. Seeing 1976 from some of the kids point of view is interesting for me. I was a kid then and can relate to the changes that were happening to the adults of the time. The first divorces, seeing parents, families changing, has affected our culture today. I mean how many people willingly went to a Psychiatrist before the mid '70's. I think that kid scenes are relavent. It shows the transition of the solid family structure of the 50's to the varied structures we have today. I mean how many people remember hearing the phase single parent before the mid '80's

Crystal Wed, Aug 13, 2008 at 12:49 PM EST

This has become one of my favorite shows on television. If anyone at CBS is reading, pleeeeease don't cancel it!!! It's what I look forward to every week!

Marvin C. Wine Tue, Aug 12, 2008 at 08:17 PM EST

Best show on T.V. Its no wonder that God created 2 1/2 women for every man on earth. This should be a wake up call to all women that if you can't keep your man satisfied he will find someone who will. It would be much more fun if the wife could understand that three people can have more fun than two as they do in the basement.

brannon Tue, Aug 12, 2008 at 07:20 PM EST

Best show on television. I will be seriously crushed if its cancelled. Needs more promotion. And I need more swingtown!!!!!!

Bubba Tue, Aug 12, 2008 at 02:00 PM EST

Alpine Valley makes total sense as a Jackson Browne summer tour stop in that part of the world. But Runnin' On Empty wasn't out yet, and he didn't break big until that album. I was 17 then, and chicks my age totally dug him, at least the cool ones.

Delon Tue, Aug 12, 2008 at 04:40 AM EST

This show is my favorite waste of time during this summer. I thoroughly enjoy it. I want the show to stay on and see more seasons and more complex emotional situations unravel between the characters.

Jen in WI Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 10:38 PM EST

To Samsara: Yeah, I know what and where Alpine Valley is. My point was with the way they toured back then--every city, not selected, why insert Milwaukee, when surely Jackson Browne at that time also played in Chicago. (Perhaps, poorly worded.)

Ann Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 10:05 PM EST

If anyone at CBS is paying attention... PLEASE give this show another chance!!!! Remember how meaningful "Thirtysomething" used to be to those of you who were thritysomething in the 80's? Well, this is the same show for those of us who are now thirtysomething, married, have kids and struggling with what it means to have meaningful relationships with our spouses, our children and our friends. The bonus is that for those of us who are thirtysomething now, we were kids in the 70s and can appreciate the kitsch of the show's setting too.

pai Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 06:31 PM EST

I'm not quite as enthused as the rest about this week and the show in general. The only true entertaining ep for me so far was when all the couples were at the cabin. It's been kind of "well this could have been better" since then. Every week, at least one of the character's motivations change WILDLY.

DanOregon Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 04:46 PM EST

This show has to end its run with a six-way, am I wrong?
Not enough Deckers in the episode to suit my tastes.

Tracey Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 02:05 PM EST

Karen wrote - "I thought it was interesting that the shrink's number contained area code 312. Chicago only had one area code until 1990."

I believe it was until 1987 or 89, but regardless, it was 312. So the show was correct.

Sean Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 01:14 PM EST

Great episode. Lana Parillio's Trina is a sage who proves honesty is always the best policy. However, the Mrs Dekker always seems to be missing the life Susan and Janet have. I think they are scared to be intimate sometimes. Janet and Roger were great last night. A marriage that is falling apart because they arent communicating. Susan and Bruce are headed for divorce because they married too young. Its all about relationships - and this show confronts it honestly with the swinger angle thrown in for spice. Best comments of the night: Tom about Janet's cheese ball - Its all in the nuts!

b Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 12:53 PM EST

The most satisfying episode yet! I agree, Janet hit the nail on the head with that advice. Roger just better be careful,with the wives being best friends and all. Janet doesn't take surprises very well. I think Laurie and Doug are going to reach some tough times. Yes, Anthony & Michelle are the first black couple on the show...go Deckers!

Samsara Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 12:42 PM EST

To Jen in WI - re: Alpine Valley
I saw the Rolling Stones at Alpine Valley in the early '90s. It's a popular concert location, central to Chicagoland, Milwaukee and Madison. What I like about this show is their attention to detail. I live in Chicago so I'm sensative to all references regarding the city. By the by - I LOVE Jackson Browne. I would have ran away to see him too!

G.E. Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 12:08 PM EST

Oh, yeah, the charades! Do you think Ricky's impression of The Towering Inferno is the writers' way of telling the viewers that he's "flaming"? It's just a matter of time until Janet comes home to find him in one of her plaid outfits, or maybe that smashing dress she wore to the hospital fundraiser, trying on her makeup.

Brian Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 10:41 AM EST

This will go off the air as the best family drama currently on television. Best actors, even the kids are better actors than anything currently airing or coming back.

I hope network show runners are watching this show very closely because we are going to miss these exquisite actresses in Molly Parker, Lana Parrilla and Miriam Shor when this show gets cancelled. Mark Cherry
only WISHES that ANY of his "Desperate Housewives" were this good.


I love these characters and this cast.

Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 08:27 AM EST

Really? A TV show is unrealistic? Which shows are realistic? Exactly none - it's entertainment. Anyway - I can see Susan and Laurie having these discussions given what Laurie saw. Just because it was 2 weeks for the viewer doesn't mean it was only two weeks elapsed in "tv show time".

Les Mon, Aug 11, 2008 at 07:15 AM EST

I don't know why I watch this show. It seems so unrealistic. Parents are really going to let their daughter spend the night with a guy 7 years older than her? They didn't even attempt to speak to her about staying at her own house. Didn't the mom get pregnant at 16? Also, what's up with the Decker's? They had what 2 weeks of not swinging and that was all they could handle? Swinging was (in theory) to enhance the sexual excitement in a marriage not be the only source. I think the writers are just looking to titillate without explaining anything about what motivates people. I'd be surprised if any of the writers lived during the 70's. Just a hunch.

MEL Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 10:31 PM EST

Let me encourage everyone that is posting here to e-mail CBS and ask them to please renew Swingtown for the fall season, or at least as a mid season replacement. This is a great show, I can hardly wait for it to come on every week! Only missed one episode, and that was because they changed nights on me. We need something other than reality shows and cop shows to watch!

Jen in WI Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 03:58 PM EST

I also thought the Alpine Valley thing was goofy--back then groups played so many cities, that it would stand to reason he'd've played somewhere in Chicago, no? Driving to Milwaukee, well, that just sort of cracked me up.
I thought the two boys were just at odds because of the intrusion of the girl, but latent homosexual feelings is definitely a possibility. And that poor kid if he is gay, with such an uptight mother like Janet--he'll be in for some aggravation there.
Yes there are typos in this review, but big deal. If we had to pay to read, then I'd expect perfect grammar and punctuation. Perhaps Gary Susman was having a crisis and had to hurry to get this review in. Cut him some slack. (Of course, this is my first Swingtown review I've read, if it's a habit to submit poorly proofread entries, well, then the chiding is deserved.

Jen in WI Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 03:45 PM EST

I think the reviewer of this show does have a firm grip, and totally gets it. Laurie's righteous indignation about her father no longer having moral authority is exactly what a smart teen would say and think in that situation. Whether or not he does, is not the point. From her narrow point of view, of absolutes, it makes perfect sense.
Janet's 'mundane and conventional world' is her comfort zone, she likes it there. She is not trapped. The changing social mores is what she has problems with. And agreeing with everyone so far--she is the best character in the group and does well portraying this woman's struggles and uncomfortable situations where she tries so hard to be and do the right thing without compromising her own standards.
I always thought that Tom was just trying to make her feel welcomed into the group and not such an outsider. He did not know about her 30 second fantasy way back in one of the earlier eps--I wanted to her let loose and at least mack on him and hard. Heh.

Michael Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 03:03 PM EST

Good catch on "Running On Empty". I thought it was out of place but was too lazy to look it up. And for LeahD, you've missed several episodes if you think this was the first one in several weeks. I don't think the show has skipped a week since it started. Three episodes to go. This is easily the best new series of the summer, but I really don't think there's any hope of renewal.

Suzi Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 02:35 PM EST

In answer to your question ... YES, INDEED we were drooling over Jackson Browne, are you kidding? I'm STILL drooling over Jackson Browne.

Pamela Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 02:16 PM EST

I thought this episode was terrific! I loved the Susan/Laurie scenes where they were discussing love. I'm partical to both points of view.

Of course, CBS will cancel this show and ruin my joy.

SteveZ Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 09:33 AM EST

I realize this show doesn't have the ratings it deserves but I hope the network has enough sense to keep it around.

Does anyone think they could grow the audience by playing it in repeats as part of the new season? Or should it strictly be a summer show?

Ted Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 08:42 AM EST

Janet is just starting to awaken from being trapped in a conventional mundane world, but telling Roger that she was going up to take a bath and that he should remember to take out the garbage just seemed perfect symbolism for her inability to connect with her hubby's changing needs. I found Trina's advice to Roger an interesting scene. It seemed like she was just telling it like it is and leaving it to him to decide. I think that Trina and Laurie are the true romantics, but Trina is experienced enough to understand that there are consequences to actions and Laurie is too naive to understand that.

Frank Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 07:51 AM EST

What a great epidode. Points for Tom for not hurting Janets feelings on what she mistook as real feelings for her. LOVE JANET, but am really loving Roger and Susan chemistry. Laugh out loud moments throughout the show. Charades and B.J.'S "Towering Inferno"..lol..the storylines were all coming together and the characters have all become so interesting. LOVE THIS SHOW.Please bring it back CBS!!!

LeahD Sun, Aug 10, 2008 at 03:42 AM EST

I love this show, and was horrified to find out that I missed this, the first new one in several weeks. Very glad to see this extensive review! I was about the same age as the "Swingtown" couples in the '70s, and can really relate to all the changes in attitudes and behavior. Viewing it the first episode, was surprised to find it so good in every way. Hope it can continue some way, somewhere.

karolplus Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 11:20 PM EST

A show is great when you're still mulling it over days later. You gotta admit that these plotlines would be interesting even without swinging. I stated earlier in the season that it was just a hook to get us tuned in. Now we can't quit.

EP Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 11:17 PM EST

This was the best episode of the season so far! Janet, who I love!, needs to take it down a level. I love the idea of Susan and Roger together, even though it it so wrong. I think Bruce is a complete idiot. He is such a simple character. Let Susan and Roger have an affair while Bruce and Janet are ridiculously unaware! (Even though I do love Janet!)

Dude Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 05:53 PM EST

bootsycolumbia, I noticed that as well. Left the boys alone playing with BB gun no less. I may be wrong, but I thought Janet ripped up the phone number before throwing it in the trash, but I could be wrong. Anyway, does not really matter. It was another great show. As much as I like all the actors, the dynamic between Tom and Janet is so fun to watch. The actress playing Janet is amazing. I think Tom sees her as a challenge, and she see him as everything she thinks Roger is not. Also, while I liked the discussion between Susan and Laurie at the lake, it was weird for Laurie to see her Mom's longing for another man - and encourage it. Maybe that was the 70s. I was about BJs age in 76, so I was only worried about playing pong. One more thing. Once Susan and Bruce act on their feelings, it will be interesting to see how Janet reacts. Tom may end up getting more than he bargained for.

pop-off Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 05:02 PM EST

i love this how, but laurie is annoying, yeah i know that most teenage girls are, but i wish they would cut back her storylines as well as the other kids, the adults are way more interesting

bootsycolumbia Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 04:05 PM EST

Marcy, you missed another typo: "a wise old lady...whose whose salty aphorism..." Yikes, I know it's the weekend, but really! Find some editors who know how to do their jobs! That aside, I thought Tom was a real gentleman last night; I thought he was really kind to let Janet "break up" with him. It's still obvious to me that the Deckers have the most solid and loving marriage of all the couples. Did anyone else think it was strange that Susan and Bruce drove off to find Laurie and left two young boys alone in the woods? And these two consider themselves responsible parents? Good thing Janet didn't find out!

angela Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 03:11 PM EST

Last night's episode was AWESOME! Everything seems to be coming to a boiling point. This is the first episode I really liked Laurie -- the questions between her and Susan re life's big questions of chices in love really got me. I'm digging the dynamic bewtween Roger and Susan. Really the only one I don't care for anymore is Bruce -- he seems like such a cad.

joules Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 03:04 PM EST

I'm very glad the writers sent a little old lady to pick up Laurie - I was afraid the writers would turn this episode into a cautionary tale about the dangers of hitch-hiking (and of being an assertive, sexually active young woman) by having some creep assault Laurie. The old lady's line about men being like lightbulbs' "Keep screwin' 'em until they work." Priceless! I loved at the end when Laurie says Susan should be happy because life is short. Susan says sometimes life is long, and Laurie says all the more reason to be happy. Lots of good advice from several sources in this ep. I hope Roger goes back to the shrink and figures out what her really wants, both in a partner and in a career, and then goes for it. Ditto for Janet.

joules Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 02:59 PM EST

I think we (including the reviewer) all agree that Tom was just trying to boost Janet's self-esteem and maybe crack her uptight shell a bit, just to see her reaction, not because he wants her. But Janet is upset because *she* misinterprets his flirting. Tom did his best not to crack up because he knows it would hurt her feelings and embarrass her if she knew he wasn't seriously trying to add her to his collection. P.S. Kudos to the set designers for Janet & Roger's living room. My mom had glass grapes just like Janet's. Tom & Trina's donut-shaped phone was another great touch. Love Trina's jewelry, too.

Patrick Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 02:20 PM EST

Ok - better review this week BUT I still don't think the reviewer gets this show. Case in point - this statement "She also told Bruce what we observed in this space last week: that he no longer has any moral authority to pass judgment on her. Clueless, arrogant Bruce was to angry to see this."
The fact is - Bruce does still have moral authority over Laurie - he is still her parent and she is a teenage girl who is dating her teacher!
What two consenting adults do is one thing. Basically, the teacher is breaking the law, at least it is a crime here in Canada. It's known as 'abusing a position of trust' and is punishable by time in jail.

What Bruce/Susan do with other CONSENTING ADULTS is morally ok as long as they are not hurting other people, which they are not. Laurie just wants to use this situation to get permissiveness. I thought Bruce's actions were understandable and justifiable.
Still, I hope that Roger and Susan talk it out but stay with their spouses though.

Lind11 Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 01:54 PM EST

Commenters cid9 and Marcy are 100% correct about the Tom/Janet confrontation in Janet's kitchen. The reviewer is wrong to presume Tom was actually "interested" in Janet. He genuinely wants to help Janet in the self-esteem department and played right along with Janet's speech about stopping their physical 'interaction'. The reviewer did bring up an interesting point about Rick possibly having same-sex feelings for B.J. I personally think it is just a typical teenage reaction when your best buddy cuts back your friendship time to pal around with his new female neighbor. If CBS doesn't renew the show, I hope some other network will be wise enough to pick it up...this is my once-a-week journey through time in the Wayback machine, it's the mid-70s and I am 14 all over again. LOVE IT.

karen Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 01:42 PM EST

I thought it was interesting that the shrink's number contained area code 312. Chicago only had one area code until 1990.

cld9 Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 01:25 PM EST

Yet another crappy review *sigh*.
Tom was doing everything he could to not laugh at Janet. I was laughing through the whole "back off" scene. Poor Janet. She didn't know she was simply being looked out for like a kid sister and developed a little crush on Tom. Too cute.
It really was the best episode so far.

Marcy Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 01:15 PM EST

OK, who is editing these things? "whose almost" vs. "who's almost" and "to angry" vs. "too angry?" Was I the only one who thought that Tom was shocked that Janet took his flirtation as genuine interest? Maybe I read that all wrong but what I tbougbt was most gentlemanly about it was the way he acted as if he was let down to help her maintain the illusion that he actually had feelings for her beyond friendhsip. I too thought this was one of the best eps yet and I'm sad CBS has given up on this show! It was on at 4 AM here today, thank goodness for DVRs.

Mel Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 12:30 PM EST

can't believe Janet confronted Tom like that. You could tell he was confused as to why it was a big deal. Sad because there can't be many episodes left.

shana Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 11:20 AM EST

The scenes from next week made it look like Roger was going to storm into Susan's house and kiss her. Woohoo!

kellie cruz Sat, Aug 9, 2008 at 11:08 AM EST

THIS REMINDS OF ME WHEN MY DAD AND I WENT TO A SWING PARTY. I SWEAR WE DIDNT KNOW. OOOPSY

advertisement

Add Your Comments

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject — or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.



  • 1000 characters remaining
    • When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Copyright ©2008 Entertainment Weekly and Time Inc. All rights reserved.