• More
Back to PopWatch Main
Complete Archive

'Greatest American Dog' recap: Salvador Doggy

Aug 14, 2008, 11:56 AM | by Mandi Bierly

Categories: 'Greatest American Dog', Animals, Mini TV Watch, Reality TV, Television

Americandog_l As if having to watch Greatest American Dog instead of the Olympics wasn't painful enough, last night's episode featured the pups painting. Why do dogs need to paint, and why do judges need to critique their work? Even I, who lost her s--- (in a good way) when she read that straight-to-DVD Anacondas 3: The Offspring stars David Hasselhoff, couldn't find the joy in this. Here's what happened:

- With Brandy gone, Travis was finally free to make googly eyes at Laura, though Laura appeared to be putting the moves on Travis' Boxer, Presley.

- Dog Bone Challenge: The week's theme was intelligence, and the dogs had to find their way around a three-wall structure to a plate of food. Though Beth Joy was confident that mutt Bella Starlet would win — Bella Starlet once took an IQ test and she was smarter than Beth Joy — Bill's Brittany, Star, did it in the fastest time, 8.34 seconds. Bill repaid Teresa for her kindness last week by offering her the Suite and the leg-up in the Best in Show Challenge — painting a picture that best represents the bond you have with your dog, with only the dog being allowed to actually apply the paint. Before we move onto that, can we just discuss how whipped Laurie's Maltese, Andrew, is? He wouldn't leave her side for chicken and bacon. Is he the most well-trained dog or far too codependent?

- Painting was difficult for everyone, but really, it tested the human's intelligence more than the dog's. My early favorites, Laura and Pomeranian Preston (pictured), struggled not because he's a tiny dog, but because Laura had him nudge over an entire bottle of paint that flooded underneath her stencil. To deflect attention from her failure, Laura threw Beth Joy under the bus for putting sponges on Bella Starlet's paws — which made her yelp a couple of times. Bella Starlet is a rescue dog, who has issues with her front paws being touched, period. Travis later came to Beth Joy's defense, assuring the judges that she was protective of Bella Starlet and had simply been helping her through her phobia. (Think Laura gave Travis her number after that?) Laurie and Andrew and JD and English Pointer Border Collie Galaxy rounded out the bottom three because Laurie was unimaginative and JD didn't realize that he put the letter stencils on Galaxy's jacket backwards. (Honestly, I can't blame him for trying to pretend that he'd wanted her to roll out FUN as NUF as part of his play theme. In front of judges, you're supposed to pretend mistakes were intentional. Sometimes, at least.) In the end, Laura and Preston got the boot, while Teresa and Border Collie Leroy, who had a "dog art instructor," took Best in Show. (Who bought Teresa's explanation that the moon represented Leroy's ability to send her over it when he barked? PLEASE.)

So, what was your favorite moment from this episode: Galaxy kissing JD during the elimination ceremony (nice to see her do something spontaneous), Travis admitting to the judges that he's a commitment-phobe (Presley is the first being he hasn't run from), or the preview for next week (puppies!)? And whose side are you on in the case of "Pawcasso": Laura's or Beth Joy's?

boxerlover Wed, Sep 10, 2008 at 08:43 PM EST

The right dog won. Pressley was very impressive for a 16 month old Boxer. Anyone who owns Boxers know at that age they are very hyper and don't have a long attention span.

DogNation Fri, Aug 29, 2008 at 02:51 AM EST

No humane owner would never betray their dog's trust for a lark... CBS should be ashamed! Everyone in Hollywood knows the moron producers lied to Laura, saying the vet approved bacon for the bone challenge, when Preston was already sick from salmonella poisoning and no vet in his right mind would feed a giant greasy bacon slice to a 7lb pomeranian. Preston had food poisoning, and Laura refused to ask him to paint. But leave it to Emmy award winning producer RJ Cutler to fool the public into thinking Laura is a lazy artistically-challenged tattle-tale ... when everyone knows they kicked off Laura because they were scared she would shut down production. Laura fought day and night for Preston and the dogs, threatening to violate her contract and go public with the truth. I am appalled that CBS would let Actual Reality get away with this. I'm sure Laura is very happy to be done with it. And now it looks like JD has grounds for a law suit too! The post-GAD tell all will be interesting...

DogNation Fri, Aug 29, 2008 at 02:31 AM EST

Last night's elephant test was proof enough that sensationialism is the only factor for reality shows, whether it's CBS or another network promoting them. I can't believe that the dog owners put up with that baloney. People and dogs were at risk; this was not entertaining for me. It was awful.
The maltese sitting firm ---that might show lack of intelligence rather than "courage". How stupid can people be ? The smart dogs got the H....L out of there. Watching Bill and Star endure that stupidity and then being sent home was very upsetting.
The others all must have had plenty to say off camera, but we'll never hear it, right ? Just when I thought it could not get any worse, it truly has. And now I can't imagine what horrible tasks are left. I cannot believe that they called Kirsten the "dog art instructor" in to examine Galaxy. Since when is she authorized to say the dog is okay. Where's the vet, who allegedly was on set 24/7?

Tillman's #1 Fan Tue, Aug 19, 2008 at 12:18 AM EST

Tillman is the GREATEST AMERICAN DOG -- the show is so dull without that handsome and lovable bulldog!!!

Westie Sat, Aug 16, 2008 at 12:40 AM EST

Mandi, for your information, according to their bio Andrew is a nationally certified therapy dog and therapy dogs are TRAINED never to leave their owners side. What would it look like for a therapy dog to be in the hospital and run off to go eat off a patient's tray? So, yep, not even for chicken and bacon. So for you to call a well trained dog "whipped" because he won't run off to go get food off the ground, then you are calling every service and police dog whipped as well. They are dogs, not humans and therefore cannot be "whipped." Dogs are trained to do things and not do things. If anything Andrew might be too well trained and too well mannered to be on this idiotic show.

Allie Fri, Aug 15, 2008 at 02:56 PM EST

Teresa is the nicest person alive. I would die if i met her>

newshound23 Fri, Aug 15, 2008 at 01:56 PM EST

Go Star!!! Beth Joy is a neurotic mess, and I'd be surprised if she hasn't given Bella Starlet ulcers by now. Would you want to live with her if you were that dog? Her yelps were her way of saying, "Get me the heck away from this insane woman."

Didn't like Laura, but LOVED her outfit on judgment day. Dress was adorable.

Julie Jones Fri, Aug 15, 2008 at 09:52 AM EST

I was a little confused with the judges' inconsistency. On the one hand they crucified JD for having the letters backwards on parts of it (and making it look TOTALLY) like a dog had done it) but then praised one of the others (sorry can't remember) because "after all no one is perfect!"

Dana Fri, Aug 15, 2008 at 09:26 AM EST

How can you not fall in love with Bill and Star, love them :) I have been watching for Tilman and them

leslie Fri, Aug 15, 2008 at 06:34 AM EST

This challenge was stupid. When they brought out the dog painting "expert" I about fell off my chair. Has anyone ever painted with their dog before, except by accident? Although trying to play along and critique art my favorite was JD's painting best. In trying to rationalize her trouble with this challenge Laura made the mistake of pointing out Bella Starlet's cries.
As for me, Bill and Star are the team to watch!

Bonnie Fri, Aug 15, 2008 at 05:13 AM EST

Is there an episode where Beth Joy *doesn't* cry? I hate her using the fact that her dog was a rescue to justify the pup having issues having her paws touched. "Rescue" doesn't automatically mean a dog has issues, or was abused.

okiegirl Fri, Aug 15, 2008 at 01:55 AM EST

Go, Presley! You are one beautiful okie dog. Woof! And, Star, you are a cup of sunshine. I don't know who I want to pat on the top of the head more: Travis, Bill, Presley, or Star!

Val Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 08:33 PM EST

Correct me if I am wrong, but didnt beth joy kind of do the same thing in front of the judges when they got after her for putting clothes on her dog? She brought Laurie and Andrew into it becuz andrew had top knots or something on his head. What goes around comes around

Einstein Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 03:00 PM EST

You call it whipped, most call it trained. Firstly, NO ONE should ever encourage their dog to run off and eat random food sitting on the ground. That's a good way to get your dog killed.

Magdalen Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 02:50 PM EST

Maybe it's because Victoria Stilwell is a judge (she does a lovely dominatrix-cum-dog trainer on "It's Me or the Dog"), or maybe it's because they aren't rewarding J.D.'s arrogant assumption that he and Galaxy will win, but I still love this show. Can't wait for the gloves to come off next week between Wendy & Victoria. I hope Allen has Kevlar on under his shirt...

kristhediva Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 02:47 PM EST

I've met Beth Joy way before she was on this show and in her defense, she would never, EVER do anything to hurt Bella Starlet. True she can be a little nutty, but she is totally and completely in love with her dog. She very careful about what Bella is sensitive to and it was just crappy of Laura to call her out like that.

Jason Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 02:36 PM EST

Travis defended BethJoy b/c Laura was getting to close and he doesnt want anyone to know he likes Larry's, not Laura's.

Paw-lease! Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 02:29 PM EST

This show has so much potential, but CBS is totally wasting it on ridiculous tests. What does painting have to do with the intelligence of a dog? This was the stupidest contest yet, and they've had several bad ones. The dogs are so much fun to watch, and my 5-year-old loves this show, so I'll keep watching. But paw-lease CBS... fix the show next year!!! How about judging them on something that actually has to do with the D-O-G and not the creativity of the owner.

Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 01:55 PM EST

Whose idea was this show. I like dogs, but come on! And they actually dedicated a tv watch to it and I clicked on it!

danielle Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 01:49 PM EST

I think watching Laura backstage gave Travis the perfect excuse to run for the hills (next to Presley's footprints under the beaming sun of course). Talk about cutthroat and totally unnecessary. The look on her face when Travis defended Beth Joy was priceless. Of course maybe Travis was just bothered by her wearing what looked like waders with a sundress.

I'm glad to see Travis wasn't fooled by her obvious fawning over Presley. Presley's an adorable boxer, but you can't convince me that a woman who paints a different colored mohawk on her dog every day would sincerely love a sloppy boxer mush.

azjudyann Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 01:42 PM EST

Kelly, I totally agree with what you said. When Tillman left the show, I left the audience. I only keep up with it now by reading the recaps. I can't stand half of the dog owners left on this show and think the judges need to be severely reminded that they aren't judging the Westminster. This show isn't that important.

Jennifer Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 01:08 PM EST

I think she probably could have done a decent painting without forcing her dog to use her paws, but the show does seem to pressure the owners to do things that aren't in the dogs' best interest. Teresa should have been kicked off for her "snarl" band a couple of weeks back.
I like Travis/Presley (more of them should have stood up for Beth Joy), and Bill/Star, but I think JD thinks pretty highly of himself - I hope he realizes what a great dog he has.

These dogs are being forced to do some pretty stupid things - and it looks like they'll be purposely stressed again next week. And all for the owners' egos.

Kelly Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 12:57 PM EST

Is this show still on? It had so much potential when it started, and now has proven to be a flop. This show was over for me when they booted Tillman!

tickles Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 12:22 PM EST

I don't think laura went home because of the painting...she went home because of what she tried to do to Beth Joy. any idiot can see that beth Joy is besotted with Bella Starlet.
I liked Laura's little dog...he was adorable. I also really like Andrew. But I thought that Laurie's picture looked too "perfect"...no mistakes? I thought that was a little sketchy.
Travis is a gentleman...very impressed. But I still miss Tillman!

TsuKata Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 11:54 AM EST

I honestly think Laura would have done better if she would have explained to the judges that she had an elaborate plan with stencils that ended up failing because she didn't anticipate how much the paint would spread on the canvas, so things that were supposed to be shapes turned out as blobs, and since they were only given one canvas (which I'm assuming was the case given that no one seemed to start over when they had an early mistake), she couldn't go back and correct it, so she had to work with it as best as she could.

I don't know if taping sponges to a dog's paws is "helping the dog work out" their abuse issues. It seems like its own kind of abuse to me, but this show has made very clear that it's totally fine with making the dogs do really darn near abusive stuff so long as it's part of a challenge...but heaven forbid an owner do something that was allowed in a challenge but isn't specifically part of the new challenge.

I love this show, but the judging is really suspect IMO.

Melanie Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 11:50 AM EST

I'm not a Beth Joy fan by any means, but let's face it, Laura ran into trouble because she didn't start the painting until 3 hours before they were to be complete (not the night before like everyone else). Throwing Beth Joy under the bus was really weak. And good for Travis for sticking up for her!

As for JD, I still think the guy is a tool! I think Galaxy was kissing him because she thought she was in trouble (her attempt to appease the alpha male) and then he clearly acted irritated by it.

Kartent Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 11:30 AM EST

I'm personally looking forward to the smackdown between the two ladies judges next week! Travis is a knight in shining armour *sigh* How many men would go against a girl he has a budding 'thing' for to defend a hapless girl that he has no personal interest in? Honestly, that boy is a true gentleman.

majigail Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 11:21 AM EST

I could really do without Beth Joy, but Laura was a little sketchy. I was shocked to see Travis defend Beth Joy. I'm still willing to let him and Presley follow me home anyday though.

Chris Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 11:19 AM EST

And I preferred JD's painting over Teresa's. Was their critique of JDs a put-on or what?

Chris Thu, Aug 14, 2008 at 11:14 AM EST

Having rescued an abused dog myself, I understand the issues they can have and helping them work through them. Not every dog has the good fortune to be treated well their whole lives. Laura took advantage of that to save herself. I was glad to see her go.

advertisement

Add Your Comments

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject — or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.



  • 1000 characters remaining
    • When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Copyright ©2008 Entertainment Weekly and Time Inc. All rights reserved.