• More
Back to PopWatch Main
Complete Archive

Comic-Con: Did Fox nix a 'Star Trek' preview at the 'Fringe' panel?

Jul 26, 2008, 11:24 PM | by Lynette Rice

Categories: Comic-Con 2008

Jj_l The Fringe panel at Comic-Con Saturday ended up being far more noteworthy for what it didn't have rather than for what it did offer: a half-full ballroom of lookee-loos and no footage from Star Trek.

For days, there had been lots of buzz that executive producers J.J. Abrams (pictured), Roberto Orci, and Alex Kurtzman were going to use the panel to debut a few minutes from Trek (which was directed by Abrams and written by Orci and Kurtzman, and is set for release next May). Zachary Quinto, who plays a young Spock in the new movie was even in attendance. But almost 40 minutes into the session, it seemed certain that Abrams had no intention of unveiling the much-anticipated footage, despite comments from insiders around him who said he actually had three minutes from Trek ready to debut. (When asked on the panel about the progress of Trek, Abrams said that most of the special effects work hadn't been completed, which is why he couldn't show anything at Comic-Con).

So what happened? One key source says Fox, the network that will air Fringe, may have nixed Abrams' plan at the very last minute (a Fox spokesman could not be reached late Saturday). Then again, Abrams may have also given the stunt a second thought out of respect for the movie's studio, Paramount, which had no presence at Comic-Con this year.

Curiously, the turnout for Fringe -- arguably the most talked-about, if not the most expensive, show debuting this fall -- was not very substantial, given who's behind the series. The massive room that once served as the home for Lost and Heroes panels (they've now moved up to the hall that holds 6,500 people) was nowhere near capacity, and there was no long line of people waiting to go in before the session started. Too bad, because Abrams had an important promise for potential viewers: This show won't be as dense as Alias or Lost. "I got sick of hearing people say they got confused when watching those shows," he explained. "We will do the show in a way that if you miss an episode and come back a week later, you won't feel confused." Abrams didn't rule out the possibility that Fringe, like his movie Cloverfield, will pay some sort of homage to Lost someday. Though he's kind of done it already: Actor Lance Reddick, who recurs as Matthew Abaddon on Lost, plays an FBI man in Fringe.

Speaking of Cloverfield, Abrams said he's already huddled with the movie's creative team and they've got an idea for a sequel, though nothing's been set in stone.

sallyjupitershair Mon, Aug 4, 2008 at 02:32 AM EST

not only was quinto there, but so were chris pine, john cho and simon pegg aka MOST OF THE CAST.
and there was no "out of respect" to fox or paramount here. this was clearly all JJ himself, being, I hate to say it, but an idiot. all he had to do was show the cast together on stage and that damn scene he showed harry knowles of all people and the fans would have gone nuts. paramount had a lot of potential for an amazing panel this year with transformers and g.i. joe coming up - but a paramount panel with no star trek? couldn't be done.
thanks a lot, JJ.
you better make up for this at wondercon!

Rob Grizzly Tue, Jul 29, 2008 at 07:59 AM EST

It's a shame they didn't have anything to show, but if the FX aren't ready, then they aren't ready. The last thing Abrams or Paramount needs is hundreds of fanboys walking out of Comic-Con thinking Star Trek looked like complete ****

wg Mon, Jul 28, 2008 at 05:38 PM EST

"Paramount, which had no presence at Comic-Con this year."

Did you tell that to the people running the big Paramount booth in the middle of the dealers room? They were handing out Star Trek posters and other promo stuff for Tropic Thunder and Transformers 2 and the line to get their swag t-shirts was regularly over an hour wait.

I'd pretty much call that having a presence at Comic-Con. ;)

to Belly Button Mon, Jul 28, 2008 at 09:52 AM EST

Couldn't agree more. My fear is that in JJ's attempts to dumb down his new show for the masses, it will be, in fact, dumbed down. Seriously, what's so hard about following a show from week to week? Or being confused once in awhile? That's half the fun.

Belly Button Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 11:56 PM EST

"I got sick of hearing people say they got confused when watching those shows."

I get sick of hearing how America is filled with idiots and the extent to which they are catered.

ST Fan Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 08:27 PM EST

Paramount really blew a huge opportunity to talk about the Star Trek movie to their prime audience. I'm sure Comic-Con would have loved them to do a program even if they didn't have footage to show. Clearly they had the director there (Abrams) and some of the cast (Quinto) since they showed up to promote other projects. I guess Paramount just doesn't care about the fans.

Doc Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 07:44 PM EST

went to this panel and it was pretty low energy. JJ Abrams seemed sharp and Josh Jackson actually did too, but the moderator was terrible. His first question to Jackson was a Pacey joke that tanked; then he bombed again with some Australia jokes to the two cast members from Australia, culminating in a Lord of the Rings reference that led to confusion on the faces of the people on stage and murmers of "New Zealand, idiot" throughout the audience.... You just didn't sense enthusiasm from the show's makers, Abrams came across as over-extended, and among the three cast members present, only Jackson had any charisma. The two writers also went on a tangent about how they were waiting to write Transformers 2 until they had a "necessary" plot, which came across as completely inauthentic. By the end, I thought, 'Wow, I am sitting here just listening to advertising.' As I was leaving, I got the keychain-leaf that another poster mentions, but I threw it away.

Daniel Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 01:37 AM EST

On the way out of this panel, I was handed a leaf (a sign fromt he show) and a black light. the light revealed a clue on the leaf that me and many others on a chain of directions across the convention center and downtown, involving ginger ale, barrels of apples, skywriting, and cows in the middle of downtown san diego. It ended with a screening of the pilot episode on top of a parking garage. at night.

Nathiest Sun, Jul 27, 2008 at 12:15 AM EST

people are stupid I would totally had been there.

advertisement

Add Your Comments

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject — or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.



  • 1000 characters remaining
    • When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Copyright ©2008 Entertainment Weekly and Time Inc. All rights reserved.