PopWatch Blog

More

Back to PopWatch Main
Complete Archive

'Idolatry': Somebody sticks up for David Archuleta!

May 2, 2008, 10:41 AM | by Michael Slezak

I admit it: I'd prefer a Cook-Castro, or even Cook-Mercado finale. (Idol blasphemy?) But Dave Karger dropped by the cubicles to try to talk some sense into me. Does my dapper co-host have a point? Discuss!

Permalink

Comments

Add Your Comments

k Thu, Jun 5, 2008 at 04:55 PM EST

It's fine to say that you prefer Cook to win over Archuleta. But there's no point in arguing about whether he would have been "ready" to win idol. The runner ups usually get signed to a record deal anyway. I personally think Archuleta is a "breath of Fresh Air" in the sense that, despite all the rumours of his dad, or how he has clearly been preparing to be a singer since his youth - I don't get the sense from him at least that he's doing this for fame and attention and that he just a genuine talent and enjoys singing. But I do see how Cook winning will help the Idol Franchise, more than Archuleta winning.
I wish both much success.

Julie A. Tue, May 27, 2008 at 09:59 AM EST

I love David Archuleta! I just can't resist his good looks or his awesome singing voice. I hope he is very successful in his future in whatever he decides to do. LOVE YOU DAVID ARCHULETA!!

ToldYa Thu, May 22, 2008 at 09:16 PM EST

So, how do your words taste? So your little man DID NOT win the title. Don't worry, Idol is opening a Disney Theme Park, he can be Goofy for real.

AI_fan_from the Start Tue, May 13, 2008 at 04:51 PM EST

Ok. PLEASE do not take this the wrong way. I think David A is VERY talented. I JUST dont think he is mature or ready ( mentally ) at his age to handle winning. Now that being said i feel jordin was much more ready for this then david is now. she might not be as good as david but she is being able to survive in the industry. and these people that say DAVID A IS A AMAZING I HATE YOU HATERS LIKE IT OR NOT HE IS GONNA WIN.... come on no one is saying he isnt talented... and you all are being immature your showing how this might not be the best time for him. and for the people who say its his parents fault... you dont know the family... his mom has nothing to do with this JEFF is. anyway i think it needs to be a COOK-MERCADO finale.

&@#oNe sTeP aT a TiME%$

AI_fan_from the Start Tue, May 13, 2008 at 04:51 PM EST

&@#oNe sTeP aT a TiME%$

Kat2 Mon, May 12, 2008 at 03:45 PM EST

Personally, I can't stand David Archuleta. He sings boring ballads, and he doesn't sing any other style. All of his songs sound the same, and the tweens have ruined the show for me this year. I don't think he is top 40 material, but maybe tune Disney material or the Mickey Mouse Club.

MichelleLOVESDavidArchuleta Fri, May 9, 2008 at 01:06 AM EST

I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA
I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA
I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA
I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA
I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA
I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA

nita Thu, May 8, 2008 at 08:58 PM EST

Yep I agree. David id a nice kid but ovrrated and in the final outcome, the ones voted off will do better. What the show offered the others was to watch Archuleta be promoted with a half good voice. I hope the judges are using reverse psycology. And for the little teens, well Archuleta is good until the next one comes since teens are fickle and that is good.

Mary Thu, May 8, 2008 at 11:15 AM EST

Archie is far from humble. On Youtube, he approaches Kelly Clarkson and other idol hopefuls singing 'I'm Telling You". I honestly think he is not going to have logevity in the industry and will tire of his father. I think week after week, his songs sound the same. I think it was so unfair to bring a bunch of teens on stage to hug him giving no thought of other contestants. Some of the best are voted off and they are fortunate to be off the show. I hope David Cook is voted off and given a better contract. He has longevity as a songwriter and performer. Syesha deserves better than Idol votes are given and Jason Castro will be given a bettr chance off the show.

MichelleLOVESDAVIDARCHULETA! Thu, May 8, 2008 at 03:18 AM EST

I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA AND HE'S GOING TO WIN LIKE IT OR NOT HAHAH!
HATERS SUCK! AND THEY KNOW IT!
DAVID ARCHULETA : THE NEXTS BIG THING!!!!

I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA

*BTW, when i read the HATER'S post, i was like what
LOSERS. THEIR LIFES MUST REALLY SUCK BECAUSE THEIR JEALOUS OF A 17 YR OLD SO SAD!*

BACK TO MY POST...

I LOVE DAVID ARCHULETA

HIS VOICE ROX UR SOXS!

Vicky Tue, May 6, 2008 at 11:53 AM EST

I prefer David Archuleta vs. Seyesha finale! David Archuleta totally deserves to be in the finale! Good luck to David Archuleta! I love his pure, emotional voice and his wonderful personality. Anyone here that wishes to have a child or a brother like David Archuleta? I do! I love him as if he were my younger brother. About Seyesha, she is better than Jason. At least, she has tried hard in the past weeks. I was impressed with Jason performance "Hellaluja" at first, but now I just have faith in David Archuleta! David Cook is also very good, but too much pimping! Hmmm...

sarah Mon, May 5, 2008 at 08:06 PM EST

Okay, first of all, i understand and respect that not everybody thinks in the same way, so you may like Archie or not, i think he is a wonderful person, i don't think he is too young for being there, he is really humble, he is shy, yes, but it makes his personality even better for me! and well at least he's got nerve to stand on that stage and sing every week, i love his performances, i can feel how he connects with the music, and that's what it takes, love and passion for what you are doing, in this case, singing. I don't get why people says Cook is original, what does he do every week? sing a rock song! i recognize he is a really good performer, but he is the same week after week after week, rock, rock and rock. Mmm...yes, i'm a 13 years old girl and i'm proud of it and being a David Archuleta supporter as well.

Blues Mon, May 5, 2008 at 03:31 PM EST

Kat, you don't have to be a referee but I do appreciate it.
It is what it is. I cannot ignore what is in front of me, so I react. It could have been much worse because that's an old-fashioned expression *winks*

I wish you all the best in your life. It was good to know you, although it was brief - again, thank you!

BluesBrother out

Kat Mon, May 5, 2008 at 02:59 PM EST

BLUES AND DINO: I feel like a referee at a wrestling match, but here goes. Dino - Blues very graciously acknowleged on Sat. @ 9:05 P.M. that he (Blues, I don't know if you're a "he" or a "she," so please forgive if I'm wrong here) had gone too far in previous posts, and even aknowledged that David Archuleta is a "bright light in a cynical world." After that, I couldn't help but reach out in frienship, and since then we have had very congenial exchanges. He's defending his favorite contestant, and we are defending ours. Let's all do it in a way that wouldn't make us ashamed to look at our favorites in the eye. Blues - I think that the "take a walk off a long pier" comment is a step backwards for you. I bet that you already regret saying it, and I'm not going to let it spoil our cyber-frienship. Everyone, take a deep breath and think before you post. Our Davids deserve it!

78closegate Mon, May 5, 2008 at 02:36 PM EST

To dadaqueen: Thanks so much for that link. It has really given me much to think about. This is not the impression of DC I have gotten from all else I have read and seen. Maybe this is just how 23 year old guys talk. I still think he is a sweet guy with a lot of talent, but I don't like him as much. Thanks again.

Amy Mon, May 5, 2008 at 12:45 PM EST

d k - Archuleta is a normal 17 year old; he hasn't any tics. Go watch his AI top 24 interviews on youtube--normal 17 yo kid. Pressure has gotten to the Top 4 and you can see it in their performances and comments during the show.

And my friend, you are way off base on the pedo comments. Make those only if you can defend by revealing who you are--otherwise just a cheap shot.

d k Mon, May 5, 2008 at 12:17 PM EST

I am a fan of D cook, but I am hoping that David A wins, it would be a pity for Cook to be tied into a contract with AI, he's better off on his own ie; Daughtry. That said, I simply don't see the appeal of David A. He creeps me out, and some the comments of his adult fans smack of pedo. I do feel simpathy for David A, because most of this is his parents's fault; it's sad to see a 17 year old with such a degree of social ineptitude and so many bizzare nervous tics. Ido needs to raise the age to 18.

sarah Mon, May 5, 2008 at 12:16 PM EST

Finally, I see someone who find a nice word for DA on EW. Anyway, I think I'm tired to read on EW site just hoe MS does not like David A. We know, Michael. You don't need to repet over and over and over that you don't like him. You will not change his fans opinion. We want just to stop remember us how you don't like him, every week.
And like every opinion, yours it's subjective, but you lost your credibility because you can not stop reiterating the same thing, no matter how DA perform. Also, you investigate his performance like he is a the pro of this show. Remember, he is the ypungest and at his age many of his competitors doe not start to sing.

Robin Mon, May 5, 2008 at 09:00 AM EST

It's me again Sleazak! I just had to stop by today to see if the love was still happening around here. I am thrilled to see that so many David A supporters showed up! Note to all you single ladies out there: I still have first dibs on Dave Karger! Step away from your computers!! I love a man who tells the truth! C'mon Sleazak, admit it, even you're coming around!! Archuleta is the American Idol because he epitomized what the contest is all about....superior vocal skills, amazing fortitude and composure for such a young man, not to mention what appears to be a good, kind heart. Raise your hand if you really see something wrong with this. I thought so. I'm out..

Blues Mon, May 5, 2008 at 06:37 AM EST

Dino: All I have to say to you is this.
*crickets chirping*
I assume you have never said anything less than complimentary you self-righteous pompous person you!
Talk a walk off a long pier and keep going, will ya?
I admitted the error of my ways ~ would you be so willing to do the same in my situation? If I could make one person smile from my 'confession' it would have been worth it. You continue to bring up the past. Feel better now?

dino Mon, May 5, 2008 at 02:34 AM EST

"We are all God's children in the end." hahaha... What? Are you a priest now? You forgot what you wrote yesterday?(Sat, May 3, 2008 at 08:11 AM EST)
Stop pretending! You know who you really are!

Xena Sun, May 4, 2008 at 11:38 PM EST

Blues - I cannot speak for dadaqueen, but I'm no part of any so-called organized attempt to undermine David Cook. I was simply reacting to an interview that he voluntarily gave, and one which is readily available for public viewing on the internet. This article is not a rumor, nor is it a fabrication. It is what it is. People can judge for themselves.

Blues Sun, May 4, 2008 at 11:19 PM EST

It was a planned attempt by some A fans to undermine DC just prior to the voting Tuesday night. Plain and simple. I'm sure Mr. A himself would not approve of his fans posting this article. I think he'd be mortified as it seems him and DC are pals. Shame on them!

Lux Sun, May 4, 2008 at 11:18 PM EST

Just some thoughts.
First of all, I completely agree with soundscene. Just because you don't like the type of music a certain contestant sings doesn't mean they aren't worthy of praise. David A has touched so many people, including me, with his music. For people who say it's boring, perhaps they simply aren't trying to even listen to the tone or emotions of the song?
And how are people "so over" David's humbleness? Are they saying they prefer the contestants to be cocky and to argue all the time? Because I'm convinced it isn't an act. From everything I've heard, David was exactly the same way before Idol and at school.
And really, didn't the rumors about David's dad start with tmz anyway? They can't find anything scandoulous about the contestant so they bash on the dad. (Rumors debunked by David's vocal coach by the way). It seemed that ever since that rumor, people have suddenly seemed to "realize" how robotic David is. Wouldn't any 17 year old be nervous in front of cameras?

Xena Sun, May 4, 2008 at 11:14 PM EST

You can call the article "tame" if you want, but the last comment I tried to post gave me an error message and said that it would have to be reviewed for spam first. The only explanation I can come up with is the fact that I quoted David Cook. I guess that his language was deemed worthy of review. We'll see if the editors allow it to be posted.

Blues Sun, May 4, 2008 at 09:13 PM EST

Where I come from, that was tame. You'll have to do better than that. Just because someone is 'wordly' doesn't mean they are bad people. We are all God's children in the end.

dadaqueen Sun, May 4, 2008 at 07:12 PM EST

Apparently Mr. Cook is TCO by TPTB at this moment. But do you believe he is as classy as he looks like on TV? Here is an interview with him back to 2006. It will tell you everything. And look how many bands has he been on.

http://musicequalslife.com/Site/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=26&Itemid=1

inna Sun, May 4, 2008 at 05:14 PM EST

I like both Davids. But so far I only downloaded 1 song from AI itunes and it was by Archuleta so I guess he is my favorite. :)

Blues Sun, May 4, 2008 at 05:12 PM EST

Kat - David will certainly have longevity over DC due to the fact that DC already has 10 years on him! :) Some rock guys go the distance. Rod Stewart for example; however, he had to reinvent himself. The Stones, are still going strong and still together. I wonder what Path they all will take. Let's hope for our sakes that they both give us many years of listening pleasure. I do know that in the beginning DA was better. I believe the pressures of 'keep your eyes open', etc., are wearing on him. But I do believe that next week the playing field is fresh and anyone of them can be outstanding. Hoping he knows one of the songs because that really helps!
Good luck to both of them :)

Amethyst Sun, May 4, 2008 at 05:09 PM EST

How can cook compete with Archie? Archie has a gorgeous face, gorgeous personality and more importantly he has a gorgeous voice that connects to the audience everything about him screams American Idol!

davidcharty1 Sun, May 4, 2008 at 03:18 PM EST

Love sex

Kat Sun, May 4, 2008 at 02:28 PM EST

Blues, I agree that the Final Four will all enjoy success. I honestly believe that -- if he wants it --David Archuleta's career will have the most longevity. Why? Because in my opinion his voice is the most distinctive, and because his singing style lends itself so well to music that has not only stood the test of time (r&b/soul/blues), but has also enjoyed contemporary takes on it. Your man, David Cook, may have a faster ride to the top since his style is really "hot" at the moment, but he'll have to quickly reinvent himself if he wants a lasting career in the industry. Here's wishing for the best of success for all the contestants!

Archuleta fans Sun, May 4, 2008 at 12:42 PM EST

Are a bunch of angry, frustrated losers.

Highland Sun, May 4, 2008 at 11:34 AM EST

I'd be shocked if even one of them sang one of my picks, but your lips to god's ears, Blues! I want to hear these kids sing some good songs, for crying out loud. Jason will surely choose something great, and I think D. Cook will as well. I wish I were as confident in Syesha and D. Archuleta, but they rarely get it right. Say, did anyone ever see this? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sV4KfFRbhlI Doesn't it seem like someone stole the kid's mojo before he came to Idol? I mean, where's the confidence he had back then? Maybe I'll try a little telepathy and lead him to the good tunes. David, go to your computer...give these a listen...you are drawn to Sixty Minute Man...you love Higher and Higher, and you're realizing you're the only one on the show who has the chops to sing it...you're starting to feel a familiar feeling...it's, it's...you know, don't you!? It's Soul, man! You forgot you had it! Ah, that's better. Now go blow some Sam Cooke.

sunrise Sun, May 4, 2008 at 11:16 AM EST

Can Dave Karger come back for next video? Forget about it, give me link to Dave Karger's own column.

If EW wants to judge the contestants, at least make an unbiased judegment and evaluate everyone's performance rather than their appearance, age, and mannerism. Or in David Archuleta's case, why not pick a fight with someone your own size, rather than bullying a 17 year old boy week after week?

EW has been in David Cook's corner for most of the season. That's ok if you have one candidate you support. But at least be fair to all the others, especially the main threat to your own candidate.

Blues Sun, May 4, 2008 at 10:50 AM EST

Extending my hand in cyber-friendship right back at ya, Kat!
I think with all the possible songs listed by Highlander for all the idols, it's going to be a 'Heck of a Night' of songs and since this list is so incredible ALL of them have a shot at the title (I think that's what scares me)! Regardless, ALL the Idols, Even Mr. A :), have already paved the way for their success, am I right? *winks*

Highland Sun, May 4, 2008 at 08:46 AM EST

I mean, come ON. Good stuff, right? These are the winners, kids. I know what I'm doing.

Highland for David Archuleta Sun, May 4, 2008 at 08:44 AM EST

"A Change Is Gonna Come"-Sam Cooke; "Teenager In Love"-Dion; "Sixty Minute Man"-The Dominoes; "Crying in the Chapel"-The Orioles; "Earth Angel"-The Penguins; "Runaway"-Del Shannon; "(Your Love Keeps Lifting Me) Higher and Higher"-Jackie Wilson

Highland for David Cook Sun, May 4, 2008 at 08:32 AM EST

"House of the Rising Sun"-The Animals; "More Than a Feeling"-Boston; "Biko"-Peter Gabriel; "Dixie Chicken"-Little Feat; "Nights in White Satin"-The Moody Blues; "Lawdy Miss Clawdy"-Lloyd Price (Elvis '68 Special version); "Rosalita (Come Out Tonight)"-Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band; "Dear Mr. Fantasy"-Traffic

Highland for Syesha Mercado Sun, May 4, 2008 at 08:28 AM EST

"The Weight"-The Band (Aretha's arrangement-don't be scared); "He's a Rebel"-The Crystals; "You've Really Got a Hold on Me"-The Miracles; "Shake"-Otis Redding; "River Deep, Mountain High"-Tina Turner

Highland for Jason Castro Sun, May 4, 2008 at 08:26 AM EST

"Suite: Judy Blue Eyes"-CSNY; "Tangled Up In Blue"-Bob Dylan; "Sin City"-Flying Burrito Brothers; "Peggy Sue"-Buddy Holly; "Tracks of My Tears"-Smokey Robinson and the Miracles; "Madame George"-Van Morrison; "Little Red Corvette"-Prince; "Be My Baby"-The Ronettes; "Sounds of Silence"-Simon & Garfukel

Highland Sun, May 4, 2008 at 08:21 AM EST

REMAINING IDOLS: Choose from the following lists for Tuesday. No need to thank me. BEHOLD (the next four posts).

slezaksucksDC Sun, May 4, 2008 at 01:18 AM EST

hmmm...notice how karger's comments are making ew a safe place for Archies again? I see that our boy has reclaimed his rightful place on the powerlist too. Good job ArchAngels!!!!

daftw!! Sun, May 4, 2008 at 01:14 AM EST

slezak, can you let us know ahead of time when karger will be back? I've been purposely ignoring this site for obvious reasons. But I will come back just for even one nice comment about Archie on here.

Kat Sun, May 4, 2008 at 01:09 AM EST

Thank you Blues. I'm extending my hand in cyber-friendship. Although you may not connect with David Archuleta (at least not yet!), isn't it amazing how he has been able to "connect" us?! Peace to you too brother/sister.

sarah's mom Sun, May 4, 2008 at 12:59 AM EST

Karger, please take over Slezak's job!! You would be much more enjoyable to read...and look at. David A. for the win!!!

sabrina Sun, May 4, 2008 at 12:08 AM EST

Warning: Do not piss off David Archuleta fans.

Remember that video of a bunch of girls beating up one girl? Yeah... girls are vicious these days. HAHA

I thought I'd just give you a heads off.

BTW, I'm a David Cook AND Archuleta fan.

Sally Sat, May 3, 2008 at 10:52 PM EST

I had a cat named dino oncst. I think that person was apologizing. Stop continuing the hate please.

teddy Sat, May 3, 2008 at 10:03 PM EST

I think Slezak is kidding us and he really likes David Archuleta - a lot! I haven't been reading his articles because I have found them unfairly critical. However, he let down his poker face for a second and was trying to hide a smile and I am happy to see that he is exaggerating his feelings.
I'm not sure why anyone would say they "don't get" David Archuleta. He is a passionate, talented performer who will undoubtedly and unbelievably, improve as he matures. His connection with songs and the audience, is on a level that I have not often seen on American Idol. Although some of the contestants might not be my favorite, I am honest enough to say I get their appeal.

dino Sat, May 3, 2008 at 09:52 PM EST

Blues is a bully! Shameless! Picking on a 17 yrs old. He is singing to 30 million people every week. So what were you doing when you were 17?

Blues Sat, May 3, 2008 at 09:05 PM EST

Dear Kat:
What you posted is very true, except for the fact that I was never a bully. I detest bullies. And you'll be happy to know that I guess I just realized that bullying doesn't have to involves fists as words can hurt, too. I initially wanted to make myself feel better because of the frustration I have been feeling about some of his fans. After the first two posts, I felt elated! After awhile, it wasn't fun anymore, and when I found your comment it hit home.
Thank you for opening my eyes. I still do not connect with him, but he is a bright light in a cynical world (did I just say all that?) YES, I DID! Peace!

LeaNNe Sat, May 3, 2008 at 09:01 PM EST

way back i used to like archuleta. now, i somehow i think that he doesn't have enough personality to become the next american idol! or if he does ... he's not showing it. with carly and brooke out of the competition, david cook is the one to be.

Xena Sat, May 3, 2008 at 08:25 PM EST

vader1013: Your incredulity sums up my previous post perfectly. Thank you.

vader1013 Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:57 PM EST

xena- are you for real?

vader1013 Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:55 PM EST

oh, does this double as an article now? set up a video camera and call it a day, huh? lame-o.

naomi Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:35 PM EST

I always vote for Castro & Archuleta. From now on, I'll only vote for Archuleta! Nice job, Blues!

Blue Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:33 PM EST

Thank you Dave K....You are right on track. Archuleta is amazing. He will have a great career win or loose although I do hope he wins.

dino Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:26 PM EST

Cook is going home soon!

Kat Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:22 PM EST

Hey "Blues." Check out my post on Saturday @ 1.38 a.m. You're in my prayers buddy.

Amy Jeremiah Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:20 PM EST

Blues - think you mean Arch-u-Envy

Blues Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:20 PM EST

Let's see if I'm right:
Syesha will be voted off next (if Sleazak is correct in his prediction). Then ArchieBoy because after all he's like an Elliott. Then comes Jason and Cook in the finale and then it will be a close one for the win! Honestly, I don't care if it's Cook or Jason or Syesha for that matter. As long as Archie doesn't win, I'll be happy! I know, I'm evil!

Blues Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:19 PM EST

Blues Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:14 PM EST

I don't have ODD - no no no!
I have David Cook-itis!

Amy Jeremiah Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:07 PM EST

10 Reasons Michel Slezak hates David Archuleta
10. He is 17 years old
9. He behaves like a normal 17 year old
8. He is cheerful and smiles
7. He is humble
6. He is kind
5. He is shy
4. He tried out for and got on American Idol
3. He works hard every week and then gets on stage, sings and knows he will be critique by the judges and media (especially the bottom feeders)
2. Simon, Randy and Paula have given him consistent positive feedback
1. He is extraordinarily talented

Slezak & Lemming-like followers Blues, Craig – you have O.D.D. – Obsessive David Disorder – it is ok to admit it

Xena Sat, May 3, 2008 at 07:00 PM EST

Darkness hates the light. The entertainment industry is a very dark and empty place indeed. A young man named David Archuleta steps into this darkness and shines a light on the negativity, hypocrisy, and total lack of decency that describes today's cultural wasteland. Of course he's going to be attacked and mocked for it. Those clinging to their jaded world view cannot understand someone so decent, so pure of heart. They believe that such a person does not, cannot exist. That, my friends, is a mirror into their own souls. Why are tv ratings down, movie attendance in decline, and cd sales slipping? Because for the most part the entertainment industry does not "get" what the American public wants. The highest grossing films are family friendly G rated films, and yet Hollywood produces so few. They are too sophisticated for that. They need something edgier, scruffier, something more in keeping with their cynical outlook. Sort of explains their love for David Cook, doesn't it?

Xena Sat, May 3, 2008 at 06:57 PM EST

Sue Sat, May 3, 2008 at 06:44 PM EST

I predict David Cook goes home this week. David Archuleta is the VOICE to beat. At least he does not scream his songs AT US. YUK already. So what is wrong with a TEEN IDOL at 17 with a great VOICE. I grew up in a rock and roll era where TEEN IDOL's were COOL and FUN and needless to say the younger actors and singers are the new multimillionaires. Go Figure!!!!

Maria Sat, May 3, 2008 at 06:40 PM EST

I just read that Simon predicts that the finale will be David Cook vs. David Archuleta, and that David Cook is going to win because he has the better voice and Archuleta will not because the majority of the votes come from teens and grandmas. SAY WHAT???? Why because he prefers LOUD ROCKERS? Geez Judges, don't be so sure. Daughtry was predicted to win also and he went home in 4th place and his voice was a lot better than Cook. I find that very offensive since I am not a GRANDMA but a woman in my 30's Whoe votes for David Archuleta every week many times. Archuleta is going to win. We need more American Idol role models with mature voice than LOUD Rockers. Don't we have enough of these guys already? GEEEEEEEEEEEZ. I would love to see a grand finale of Archuleta and Castro and Archuleta for the WIN!

Blues Sat, May 3, 2008 at 06:39 PM EST

He's got the tween vote, the mothers' votes whose sons have been a disappointment to them and the grandma vote. I love this Sleazak person! You Rock! You tell it like it is! Hallelujah! Sure, David is pure and innocent NOW. Wait until a BAD GIRL gets a hold of him (if they even want him that is) and that will be his undoing. Better off going home now and being safe. Wait a minute, he'll have all the 13 year olds screaming for him and he'll be like aw shucks. And you don't think Daddy knows this? He can't hold his hand forever. He'll go the route of Miley Cyrus if he doesn't go home now.

courtney Sat, May 3, 2008 at 06:30 PM EST

i've been saying ever since his audition that he would win! i love him so much! he is so hot an he's my future husband! i love u soooooooo much david!!

Taylor Sat, May 3, 2008 at 05:45 PM EST

I think that David is adorable and my feature husband, even though im only 12. Ever since I started to watch American Idol, the persin I have voted for has won. This year David A. is going to win, so just face it, David Archuleta is the next American Idol of season 7! I LOVE YOU David Archuleta!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Craig Sat, May 3, 2008 at 04:18 PM EST

You are right on, Slezak. Archuletta has nothing inside. He may have a good voice, but he is a completely uninteresting singer to me.

Blues Sat, May 3, 2008 at 04:17 PM EST

Once in a lifetime? You people are delusional!!
I've seen the same or better at high school plays! Come on now.

daisawesome Sat, May 3, 2008 at 03:06 PM EST

David Archuleta is a talent that comes once in lifetime. It is a great loss to Michael Slezak that he does not "get" David A. My deepest, sincerest condolences to you Michael.

Allie G Sat, May 3, 2008 at 02:31 PM EST

I really think that you should give David Archuleta a break. He is a fantastic singer and is probably the most naturally talented contestant ever to step foot on Idol's stage. He is only 17 and is very genuine and modest. His humility is genuine. He has a paralyzed vocal chord so I think everyone should keep that in mind and just give him kudos for being as talented as he is.

natasha davies Sat, May 3, 2008 at 02:14 PM EST

i think you all should give david archuleta a break, he is 17 doing a thing he loves, he deserves 2 win as much as everyone else, go david lol x

Betty Sat, May 3, 2008 at 01:39 PM EST

The most vocally talented, Carly & Michael, have already been eliminated.
David A. is just too young & has a lot of vocal maturity to work on. He should retry in a couple of years. David C. is the only one on there now to even be considered as an American idol contestant.
This has really been a big disappointing year for Idol.

slezak hater Sat, May 3, 2008 at 01:24 PM EST

i have 2 admit that slezak has issues wid david archuleta's popularity..............but david doesnt have 2 worry abut anything as we r always rite behind him!!!

love archuleta Sat, May 3, 2008 at 01:20 PM EST

i have just one thing 4 slezak................U SUCK!!@!

Blues Sat, May 3, 2008 at 01:07 PM EST

Mandy, your response only proves that he shouldn't be the American Idol because even you're saying he's not at his best yet. He's predictable. You know when he's going to inflect, when he's gonna do a run, what high note he's gonna go to, etc. Nothing surprising, same delivery every time. He looks like he's done one too many high school plays. He has a good voice, but not the voice of a star.

Ari Sat, May 3, 2008 at 12:50 PM EST

Archie is a kid, no doubt. My daughter is 17, and also a singer. I find it funny when she sings love songs, since I know she hasn't really experienced certain truth of life as of yet.

When they are that young, they are unbelievable.

David Cook sings with a passion of life, love, and loss. He also knows how to tear up the stage and have fun. Believable, and my idol whether he wins or not.

emmylou Sat, May 3, 2008 at 10:58 AM EST

Just a note....David A. is so young, why does everyone think he has to be the AI this year? He needs to grow up and not look like he is always "ready to burst out in tears". I'm not sure about his father, but that doesn't matter, he is to young and immature. Granted, he does have a good voice, but David C. rocks!!

FindtheCure Sat, May 3, 2008 at 10:53 AM EST

Got to say "I get DA." I'm 38 & look forward to watching this kid get up and do his best every week. Don't think I could do it at 17.

I think what you see is what you get. Don't think its an act he's suprised he's safe. He's likely a typical insecure teenager who believes one negative comment over any positive. If he's seen ANY press, there's nothing positive, personally attacks him, and asks for America to send him home. What 17 year-old wouldn't believe that?

I am going to enjoy every performance of DA & will be sad when he's gone. He makes me smile. Maybe because he reminds me of a time when I was 17 and believed the world was good and that doing your best was in its own right a virtue.

BUT if the Archuleta fans are smart they will NOT let him win. Get him to the final, then vote for Cook. DA has enough publicity. Winning AI would be premature for him. He needs to live a little & come back in a few years. I enjoy this kid enough to worry what will happen to him if he wins.

Alvin Sat, May 3, 2008 at 10:30 AM EST

What is with the "hate-on" on David Archuleta? Some people are actually saying that they "hate" him. To those people; do you know him, have you considered how immature and petty you sound?

How do you hate someone who does their best every week and then are voted to stay on by the viewer’s choice? If you can't handle the format and the rules of the competition without welling up with hate, then I suggest a pastime other than watching American Idol. And, especially, don't bother watching the Olympics this summer, because you'll just hate constantly, and this cannot be good for your mental health.

It is true that David Archuleta lacks experience, but he more than makes up for it in depth of soul in his voice and considering his age and inexperience he is doing an amazing job.

Come on people lighten up, David A. is a kid who is doing his best. I admire him.

Randi Sat, May 3, 2008 at 09:53 AM EST

I've followed EW's Idol commentary with growing dismay.It's unfortunate at the lack of respect David Archuleta is continually shown in your coverage. He is not a kitten, a Teletubbie, or a teddy bear--he is a young man. The "cute" factor you constantly shove in our faces in lieu of a serious performance evaluation shows you don't get David's voters. Granted he has the tween screamers, but I think you'd be surprised at the number of serious music lovers out there who appreciate this young man's pure sound and emotional connection to his song. It was refreshing to see they have SOMEONE on staff who is neither cynical or prejudiced. I'm not sure which of the remaining contestants "deserves" to be the next Idol, but there is no doubt in my mind as to which one deserves an apology for his shameful treatment by Michael Slezak.

looly Sat, May 3, 2008 at 09:47 AM EST

I loooooove "Idolatry." Thank you, Slezak. I think Archuleta has a talent that is rare and an aura of hope about him. When they were not on a theme week early on, his song choices were more indicative of what he is really about. I like him because of this quality of innocence and light about him and the clearness of his voice. I like David Cook maybe better because of his interpretations of songs I've heard a million times, but never quite like he does them. Isn't that what an artist does? Don't they take things we know and allow us to see them in a different light? David Cook has a way of pulling you into his performance in a purposeful, visceral way that leaves you catching your breath and wondering what just happened. This might not have happened when he was 17, but now, with a little more of life opening up places in his soul, he can sing with the tortured passion which speaks to me.

Owen Sat, May 3, 2008 at 08:38 AM EST

David Archuleta is a "good nice" person? How do you know? How does HE know? He's 17 year old. And a backwards 17 year old at that. He is barely a person yet, and what is there, I'm guessing, of his personality has been stunted by an extremely over-reaching stage father (just read this week's EW magazine and there' smore proof). Yes, the child has an amazing voice, there is no doubting that. But at 17 I was also a "Christian" and "plyable" but I grew up and out of that. I wasn't a whole person yet. Very few are at 17, and its painfully obvious that little David Archuleta isn't.

Mandy Sat, May 3, 2008 at 08:36 AM EST

Blues, you need to keep your facts straight. First David, his Dad's friend, and DA dad all interviewed all those attacks are false. The media just needed something to ride DA about since there is NOTHING at all wrong with him. No one likes for someone 2 have a good rep in hollywood. 2nd david is not even at his peak and he will get better with time. No one can even imagine what he'll be like at 25. He deserves a chance.

Blues Sat, May 3, 2008 at 08:11 AM EST

This goofy child (would do good with Goofy in Disney) has no business becoming the next American Idol. He does not deserve that honor because he's a child in every way. He looks like he's 14 and acts like it, too. God only knows he appeals to lots of people. I guess middle america - not the two coasts, that's for sure. I cannot stand the sight of him if you want to know the truth because he's a puppet and his father is the puppet master. It seems like he's mortified most of the time. It will be a happy day when he gets voted off! He's a giggly, goofy NON-star. What were these judges thinking to put him through? Must have had good acoustics in the room. To me and many others, he sounds nasally all the time, and doing all those runs is the only thing he can do to change up a song. Throw him back, he's not big enough.

Christoph Sat, May 3, 2008 at 05:40 AM EST

For me, a doctoral student in Philosophy at the K.U Leuven - Belgium, David Archuleta's singing is incredibly and uniquely touching. I have watched few intenrational TV talent show. But never before have I found myself got hooked as the way I feel Archuleta's voice. I feel grateful to America for such a gift. I downloaded all his itunes. Amazingly enough, the more I listen to them, the more I like them. I feel them deeper and deeper everytime - non-exhaustibly!!!. To me, that's the point of 'owning' a CD.

dino Sat, May 3, 2008 at 05:37 AM EST

Slezak loves to make fun of David, but himself looks like a Teletubby!

lala Sat, May 3, 2008 at 05:20 AM EST

The guy in blue shirt and sweater is hot!
The guy in pink shirt with glasses is so gay!

CMS Sat, May 3, 2008 at 05:15 AM EST

Love the passion here! I am over 50 and will buy every album D.A. makes! When I close my eyes and listen, I have heard Cook's voice in many other groups through the years. DA is a nice fresh sound which will only improve with age and experience!!!
Hey Rascal...LOVE YOUR DA SITE!!
CMS

www.notingdavid.org

rascal Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:47 PM EST

Carolyn Sat, May 3, 2008 at 02:44 AM EST

My 2 cents - I am 3x David's age, I never voted for an Idol before but I vote for him, I am going to wear out Youtube listening to him, and I will buy his CD.

Kat Sat, May 3, 2008 at 02:09 AM EST

What the Mentors on Idol have said about David Archuleta: 1) Dolly Parton said that he conveyed the emotion in "Smoky Mountain Memories" that she had felt while writing it, and that she believed he could become a "great, great singer." 2) Mariah Carey said that she was proud of where David was as a person, and that he sang "When You Believe" beautifully. 3) Andrew Lloyd Webber said that David has a musical soul, and gave him a complimentary "bravo" for his risk in taking on a song originally written for a female vocalist and for arranging it in a contemporary fashion. 4) Neil Diamond said that David is a prodigy and that with a little guidance he should be able to perform very well. Finally, on Access Hollywood, David Foster, who has often been in Cook's corner, complimented David A's performance on Andrew Lloyd Webber night, saying that he had finally displayed the necessary musical maturity. Compliments attesting not only to David's muscial abilties but also to his character.

sandy parks Sat, May 3, 2008 at 01:57 AM EST

What does Slezak have against David A? He wants to be all that David A is and he is not. May be he was a bubblegum chewing teen at 17 failing his Math classes. Who hired him at EW in the first place? If you need any viewership or subscribers GET RID OF HIM.

Underestimated Sat, May 3, 2008 at 01:46 AM EST

I keep seeing notes by bashers that think it's just tweens voting over and over out there for David Archuleta. Hold that thought and we'll see what happens! It's girls 9-99 voting for David Archuleta!! He's also got the vote of every Father out there who has a daughter and wants him for a son in law!!!

Kat Sat, May 3, 2008 at 01:38 AM EST

Even as a child I disliked and/or felt pity for people who put others down. Even then I knew it displayed a lack of self esteem on their part. That is why I often was baffled by the popularity of certain kids who bullied or made fun of others. Those who make disparaging remarks about David Archuleta fall into this category. It is they who are lacking in life experience since they have obviously never grown up, except chronologically. Honest differences of opinion are one thing. Ad hominem attacks simply reveal weakness, insecurity, and a lack of substance to support one's statements. These people need our prayers. I know that David Archuleta has already forgiven them.

Leanne Sat, May 3, 2008 at 01:19 AM EST

Whoever thinks the rocker's gonna win over the soulful singer -- remember what happened between Bo Bice and Carrie Underwood. Everyone thought the rocker was gonna win, but, hello, look what happened!

AngelOnEarth Sat, May 3, 2008 at 01:14 AM EST

David Archuleta is blessed beyond measure with talent and with the sweet spirit and voice that magically touches your soul. Humble, genuine and kind, he is what the world needs right now and he will change lives. And BTW, don't believe what you hear about his Dad. When someone doesn't have dirt, you have to create dirt. His Dad is completely kind, supporting and loving not only to David but to all his kids. David is a product of his environment and the love he has received shows through in his sweet smile and the sparkle in his eyes. David A. is my Idol 2008 no matter what! I'll buy every album or song he puts out!!!

Dying Angel Sat, May 3, 2008 at 12:50 AM EST

I hated my friend because I think she's a bad singer. Finally I realized that she's really good and I got her. I was too shy to admit it. I created another issues about personalities, families and others to make her still bad for me. It's not about her voice anymore.

It's the story when I was a kid. I was 10 years old when I did that stupid things.

Got the point? If you don't get David Archuleta just say that you don't like his voice because it's all about singing contest. I'm sick of people who acting like kids.

I love Archie's voice. That's all!

KE Sat, May 3, 2008 at 12:01 AM EST

I love David Archuleta's beautiful, soaring, passionate voice! I've bought all his songs from iTunes and have used them and a lot of older stuff that I found to make a CD. I listen to it constantly; I can't get through it without getting teary, though. He touches me like no one else I've heard sing.

I think he is a rare, raw talent who will get nothing but better. I predict that he will become one of the biggest stars and top sellers in the music industry and will have a LONG and very successful career.

I love everything about him--the incredible voice, the sweet, down-to-earth person that he is, the way cute face.

I agree with a previous poster--a lot of people these days are uncomfortable with really good, nice people. Maybe what David is doesn't jive with their lifestyle or whatever. Who knows? Who cares? Personally, I find him completely charming, totally refreshing.

I don't buy CDs and the last concert I went to was Edgar Winter in the late 1970s. But, I'm telling you now, I will buy every CD David Archuleta ever puts out. I'm going to the Idol concert ONLY because I will get to hear David A. in person. By the way, it's 300 miles one way to the concert--but it is a small price to pay to hear an angel sing.

deexann Fri, May 2, 2008 at 11:47 PM EST

ooops sorry...
"sucks for those who CAN'T appreciate real music"
this is what i meant...
sorryyy

deexann Fri, May 2, 2008 at 11:44 PM EST

dont be so upset if a 17 year old kid would kick all the adults out of the competition..
:D

deexann Fri, May 2, 2008 at 11:39 PM EST

what in the world is your problem for those david a haters? Like there's you can do if there's bunches of 12 year old girls will vote for David! They voted because they find david A so GOOD, so CUTE, so GOOD LOOKING, so TALENTED, so HUMBLE and everything-that-so-excellent about david! I love all the Idols, especialy the Davids.. It's a show which requires 100% of voting from the fans, so if david A has the numerous voters... YOUR NEGATIVE COMMENTS WILL NEVER CHANGE A BIT OF OUR LOVE for DAVID!

SUcks for those who can appreciate real music!
GO DAVID ARCHULETA!
GO FOR the win!

Shaylynn Fri, May 2, 2008 at 11:23 PM EST

Gosh, it is nice to see something positive said about David Archuleta for once. I think it is well deserved and overdue. I just didn't and I still don't understand where all the Hate was coming from with you Sleazak. I mean really, I would ask myself, what did David ever do to you? I can understand you not "getting" David, not everyone is going to, but you just couldn't even acknowledge that the guy is talented until today. All I know is that this young man sings from the heart and it touches my soul and I know there are tons of people out there who feel the same way. I guess you have to open to his music without bias. I don't know if he is going to win AI because David Cook is what is hot right now. I can see Cook winning and selling lots of records because you can turn on the radio and hear bands that sound just like him. That is not a bad thing though, his type of music is just really popular. David A has aways to come, but he will be great in a couple of years.

SweetCAROLINE Fri, May 2, 2008 at 10:46 PM EST

David's voice has brought me to tears on a few occasions. That is a FIRST for me. Anyone that can't hear the purity in his voice needs to see a doctor. I've watched A.I. every single season and never voted once until David walked out on the stage. He is bringing people out of the woodwork. Amazing talent, amazing kid. I can't wait to see what he does when the A.I. pressure is off. He's going to be a superstar. (He already is). If you're older than 17, don't have a singing voice, and you've ever cursed, then to you I say this: Go pick on someone your own size! David is just a kid and deserves some respect.

Brooke!!! Fri, May 2, 2008 at 10:40 PM EST

Why can't people just be happy for David? Why does there HAVE to be something wrong with him? He's 17. Leave the poor kid alone. He's got more class in his pinky finger that most of his bashers have in their whole body. What is this world coming to when we bash a 17 year old kid that's going after his dreams & doing a damn good job, I might add. His voice is what is carrying him through. Whether or not you like his personality is based soley on your own insecure reasons. Probably because you feel ashamed that a 17 year old boy from Utah has more humanity already in his short life than you'll accumulate in a lifetime. If you have nothing nice to say, why not say nothing at all? Would you want someone bashing YOUR child because he's gifted? I think NOT!

Ann Fri, May 2, 2008 at 10:16 PM EST

Mmmmm, David Archuleta is so loved and hated. I think this will only means one thing: He is going to win. If you look at the president elections, the candidates with such kind of inspirational qualities are those who win at the end.

Braden Fri, May 2, 2008 at 10:01 PM EST

Thank you for allowing someone with some influence to be able to defend David A. I'm tired of all the "teeny boppers vote for him" crap. My wife and I are 30, and my Dad is 60 and we all love David. His clear voice and perfect pitch make him an extremely enjoyable contestant... much better than David Cook's mumbliness.

And yes, he really is that nice. You can tell.

Christine Fri, May 2, 2008 at 09:56 PM EST

David Archuleta is VERY rare talent--he will be successful because he definitely stands out from all the rock and rap heard on the radio. He is refreshing and is definitely what music today needs--a teenager singer who can SING and sings from the HEART. He has an amazing appeal and huge potential. I believe these themes that the contestants are dealing with prevent them from showing who they really are. David Cook can make anything into a rock song, but the others who have good voices? They haven't grown up with these songs, which makes it difficult to master in one week. Just think if Jason Castro could sing some jack johnson or ben harper or if David Archuleta could sing some stevie wonder or john mayer--I bet we would be amazed. Thank god for these diverse theme this week for the contestants--I believe they can all find something that suits them well. And I wish the themes in the top 24 didn't restrict them from showing us the kinds of music they're capable of singing.

frame_it Fri, May 2, 2008 at 09:43 PM EST

Unbelieveable! I stopped going to this site weeks ago and stopped buying EW because I couldn't understand the hatred of David A. I like other singers in the competition, but David is the standout for me. I love Karger!

I am emotionally moved every time DA sings. What most impresses me is that with each performance he in some way adds something new and pushes himself. I believe he focuses on competing with himself and not the other contestants. He will have a long and great career and I can see him EVOLVING.

I liked DC previously, but then it came out his "brave" performances were not, in fact, original. He still sounds good to me and seems like a truly nice guy, but its interesting that no one ever comments on how he sounds the same every week. I know I am going to see him hold the guitar and make it look like he is playing the more difficult parts (not his fault, I'm sure) and song will sound the same. I think that unlike Archie HE HAS PEAKED. Nothing new to look forward to.

Dorrie Fri, May 2, 2008 at 09:41 PM EST

David A. has a beautiful clear voice that is unique. When he sings, you instantly recognize who it is. David C. is just like many other singers who yell and scream. And Jason puts me to sleep. How he is still here amazes me. Are people so fad crazy? This is definately a personality contest and not a talent contest.

Owen Fri, May 2, 2008 at 09:00 PM EST

Oh, and I'm willing to forgive the Archuleta nonsense...I love him in SPITE of that...

dany Fri, May 2, 2008 at 09:00 PM EST

david archuleta for the win!!

Owen Fri, May 2, 2008 at 08:59 PM EST

Can I marry Dave Karger? Please? In Massachusettes, in Canada...a civil union in the UK...Please. I...I love him....

artslvr Fri, May 2, 2008 at 08:33 PM EST

I am middle aged, and David Archuleta's voice and stage presence both move me because they are powerful, heartfelt, and sincere. David A's singing makes me remember an insightful quote from another AI finalist, Jon Peter Lewis of season 3, who blogs for EW online: "Love the music in yourself, not yourself in the music." Unfortunately, far too many rockers seem to focus on themselves when they sing, so I will be very interested to see if David A. will continue to effectively channel the core of his songs for rock week. I believe he will.

On a different note, maturity has many facets, not just age. David A. is mature beyond his years in empathy for other people and in resisting pressure to simply go along with a crowd. This maturity shows in his singing because he conveys genuine emotion and humanity.

Becky Fri, May 2, 2008 at 07:42 PM EST

Dave Karger - Thank you for bringing some reason back to 'Idolatry.' Even as a regular EW reader, I've been so turned off by the blatant hatred of David Archuleta and silly references to Teletubbies, Disney, etc. For quite awhile now, I've felt this blog had veered far from being an honest critique to a personal vendetta against an extremely talented kid whose only real sin is not being as cynical as Michael Slezak.

Marie Fri, May 2, 2008 at 07:41 PM EST

10 most ridiculous reasons given for why David Archuleta shouldn't win Idol:

1. He licks his lips.

2. His father is controlling.

3. He's too young.

4. He sounds too old.

5. The judges like him.

6. Teenage girls like him.

7. Teenage girls vote for him.

8. He's too nice.

9. He's pretending to be nice.

10. He won Star Search at age 12.

Why David A. should win?

He is a gifted singer who is humble, genuinely likes to perform for people and whose singing touches many people from all demographics.

MurMaz Fri, May 2, 2008 at 07:12 PM EST

Michael, I have to say I've been loving D'Archie less each week. It occurred to me last week that my dream final two would be Cook/Mercado. No way Jason deserves to be in the finals.

Samara Fri, May 2, 2008 at 07:09 PM EST

One minute, Slezak's saying David A.'s not good enough, the next minute, he's saying his performances are consistently good! Make up your mind.

David Archuleta for the win ;)

DavidAFan Fri, May 2, 2008 at 07:02 PM EST

Sorry, I meant Imperio, not Crucio. My bad.

DavidAFan Fri, May 2, 2008 at 07:02 PM EST

To Xenophilius,

You used the wrong curses. David A would not want his fans hurting other people, even his haters.

The right curse would be Crucio: Vote for David. That way, no one would get hurt and we would just be helping the haters do the right thing!

Peace!

Go DavidA Fri, May 2, 2008 at 06:52 PM EST

Archuleta is the most talented on the show, I tell you once but I'm telling it once again..We Love you David A
hahaha number 1 baby!

josh Fri, May 2, 2008 at 06:35 PM EST

Wow, Dave Karger, You are just right on. Everything you said. Do you have your own column? I think you are the most objective and fair (not biased) critic. I think Jason and Brooke should have gone before Michael and Carly. Although I am a fan of Brooke, hers and Jason's singing is limited.
Here is my observation.

Karger Slezak
Good Evil
Nice Sarcastic
Good-looking Ugly
Genuine Arrogant
Davie A David C

Xenophilius Fri, May 2, 2008 at 06:05 PM EST

*Aims at all David Archuleta haters*
*CRUCIO*

a day later...

AVADA KEDAVRA!

yssys Fri, May 2, 2008 at 06:03 PM EST

The flying teletubbie was so funny...another great episode of Idolatry, Thanks Slezak!!

Corey Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:57 PM EST

Can we all agree to disagree? As a David A fan, I am not going to profess as a FACT that his voice is moving, his performances are genuine, and his personality is endearing. It’s simply MY opinion. At the same time, I appreciate Cook’s artistry and vocal abilities. That’s why I feel that both of them have deserved the *pimping* that they have received. These two have ‘earned’ the praise because of their strong performances and broad appeal. I don’t think there’s a need to bash someone (esp. the contestant himself) because their musical preferences are different from yours.

stefan Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:56 PM EST

"Archie" is just lucky they don't allow 13-14 year old kids to compete, because he would have been long gone by now, along with every other contestant over 16.

CMU Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:56 PM EST

David A has a great voice, but I really think he should have waited a few more years to do this. He lacks the maturity and experience (and perhaps the time to break away from his horrible stage dad) to really handle this competition well. I loved him at the beginning, but at this point I think David C should win it. He has blown me away several times this season, but only "Imagine" has done that for me with David A. I think it's a travesty that Carly and Michael aren't part of the top four. I doubt that anyone will break up the David-David final, especially with David A's rabid, blind fanbase that would vote for him even if he vomited on stage. I love Jason Castro, but of course he's not "the" Idol. Syesha is very good, but also not "the" Idol. So a David-David final it is.

P.S. Dave Karger is sexy. :)

Francesca Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:44 PM EST

David Archuleta is the most talented contestant on AI, people bashing him are very tasteless. David puts his heart, passion into his songs he can relay it to the audience. And he is only 17 now that is what I call a gifted person. David is the next american idol whether you like it or not.

d k Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:31 PM EST

re Hank & people who find 'good' boring. Jason C is a devout christian who donates a lot of time to building homes for the underprivileged, I don't find him boring at all. David A, on the other hand I find to be creepy, not boring. He reminds me of Igor in Frankenstein. I can just see him rubbing his hands together, licking his lips, and saying "yesss master" to his Dad. ( yes, I know that was mean, and he's just a kid, which is why they need to have an over 18 rule)

smiling4you Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:30 PM EST

Some of these comments are insane! I have to comment on a comment made here by someone who didn't leave a name. They said, "David Archuleta is a good singer, but that's it. I never feel like he really connects with a song." ARE YOU KIDDING ME? That's all he does is connect with a song. The proof is in his fanbase. We all feel that connection. If you don't it's not Davids fault., It's yours. You just like a different kind of genre and that's okay, but you have no right telling the rest of us what we do or do not feel. David is the reason I am watching this year and the reason I am voting for 2 hours every tuesday for the first time since Idol started. He may be young and he may not have the stage presence that some of the others do, but he is learning from this experience and he has one thing that the others don't and that is an amazing vocal talent bar none!!!! I will buy every album he will ever make and enjoy them forever.

Marie Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:19 PM EST

It's interesting how all us David A. supporters have come flocking back to EW since the rarely seen (on EW) positive commentary about DA. Seems to suggest Slezak's aversion to him drove his supporters away..giving a very one-sided view of his chances of winning this...which he should!!

houstonrufus Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:18 PM EST

Dave Karger has always been my favorite writer and commentator from EW. And now I have one more reason. FINALLY, someone not so concerned with being cool and witty. FINALLY. Someone who can give praise where it's due rather than trying to so hard to be the "hip" blogger re: AI. Dave, I've always marveled at your oscar predictions. You are fantastic. I canceled my subscription BECAUSE of Sleazak. Yup. I did. But Karger may win me back. Maybe. Maybe I said.

ang Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:07 PM EST

I think we are at the stage on AI that all he singers are really good.
David A. has an excellent voice but he does not have the maturity level to handle the pressure of winning AI, I'm actually worried that he will have trouble handling the pressure of his success now. Although my personal favorite is Jason and I will vote for him until the bitter end, I have a feeling David C. will end up winning the whole thing. Reguardless of who wins they all have a good shot at a successful future if they play their cards right.

Jim Lacey Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:04 PM EST

David A's "Coming to America" thrilled me. So did his "Imagine." So did at least 2 of his other performances.

I admit it, he can make me cry and I can't explain the reason, but I think it goes something like this, that his voice is the inside proof of what we see about him outside -- and just can't believe is possibly real or true. And then he proves it is.

Archuleta has almost no stage presence, I agree, while Cook has excellent stage presence. Even Jason Castro has more stage presence than Archuleta, but I think that's what it really comes down to: Stage presence versus vocal greatness. And in the end, for me at least, the stage presence of all the others combined can't equal the single vocal greatness of Archuleta.

What would I prefer? To drive down the highway listening to someone I couldn't see (Archuleta) or to be at home in front of the tube and see someone (Cook) I couldn't hear?

It's not even a contest.

Jim Lacey

SweetDavid Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:01 PM EST

Glad Sleazy Slezak stood and listened for a change. It is because of this idiot I don't come here. I only came today to listen to this because we could not believe someone stood up to the idiot Slezak. I can't stand to look at that face. He knows nothing about anything. I love David A. and he is the most talented contestant on there.

SweetDavid Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:01 PM EST

Sam Fri, May 2, 2008 at 05:00 PM EST

Nice to see some support for DA on EW.

Mandy Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:58 PM EST

Idol would kill theirself if either David went home b4 the finale. For one no would watch the finale if either one is not there cause syesha or castro can not up stage either one of them. With that DC is musically talented and has smart ideals but I simply hate his singing. I find nothing new and refreshing about him. DA stole me at the beginning I've been around musicians all my life and have never heard anyone with a voice like his. You may hate him or whatever but when he gets on that stage the Heavens open up even if he would sing Mary Had A Little Lamb. He's not even at his peak and can't imagine what he'll be at 25.

Mandy Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:58 PM EST

Jim Lacey Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:53 PM EST

David A's "Coming to America" thrilled me. So did his "Imagine." So did at least 2 of his other performances.

What would I prefer? To drive down the highway listening to someone I couldn't see (Archuleta) or to be at home in front of the tube and see someone (Cook) I couldn't hear?

It's not even a contest.

Jim Lacey

rascal Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:47 PM EST

StaticCling - The only possible way I can think of for you to be airing dirty laundry from over at Rickey's in such detail is that you are the unfortunate Jeffrey Christian himself. And if you are going to call me and my site out on a public board, at least have the courage to give out the address so that people can judge for themselves: www.notingdavid.org

And just so there are no misunderstandings: It was I who called Jeffrey Christian out for making base, puerile remarks about David Archuleta, not for his profane and adolescent remarks about me. Far from wasting my time on some random comment poster, Mr. Christian sets himself up as a reviewer with professional credentials. That has attendant responsibilities for which Mr. Christian evidently holds a contemptuous disregard.

wtf Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:39 PM EST

Great vid, as per usual. Slezak - Jason's patience has been wearing down for awhile, has even been telling the media this (like the EW article where he SAID he was ready to leave, not for the first time). IMO, that's why Paula had that written speech prepared - TPTB know he doesn't really want to be there. And why let the AI machine keep grinding him down (like it did w/ Brooke)? He's got a platform and a fan base - he'll be okay. Really. IMO, AI has worn DA down, too - he's not the DA of Imagine or Crazy. I hope he can get that back, cause I'd like a DC/DA final. Cause AI has no power over DC - he just gets better and better and better... :-)

shawshank Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:26 PM EST

I am surprised that you stole some of your comedy, but downright offended that you stole it from Jimmy Kimmell. Really? How totally shameful! Last week, I was watching Lost online, and one of the ads was for Kimmell and featured "This Week in Unneccesary Censorship" which had Syesha hand blurred out implying she flipped off the camera. And now you guys do the exact same joke. I expect more from Idolatry. While I am annoyingly criticizing, I second the comment that I like the puppies and kittens better than the Telletubbies, and I also don't think your South Park clips have near as much charm as your robot movie clips. Run Lola Run though-that was classic. Keep up the good work, just don't steal from lame comedians.

Timv Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:22 PM EST

I am a fan of David A so I "get" him but if you dont get him no matter what you write you can never convince me to switch to your side in fact you are doing the opposite. David A my AI although I am an over 20 Aussie.

OverratedDA Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:16 PM EST

LOL so I think someone acts and looks immature, and that makes ME immature for my observations? Riiiiight. But the people who call the Idolatry writers (or those who agree) stupid, blind, and dumb, or change Slezak's name to Sleazak or some derivative... they aren't immature at all. It's interesting to see people get so enragged over others' opinions.
As for the objectivity of my name: I've had months to form an opinion so it's not exactly a snap judgment. Archuleta will benefit from some age behind him to get the true emotion behind his lyrics. No one's saying he can't "technically" sing- just that there isn't the life experience backing it, leaving many of us feeling empty.
And those of you who are so upset that you want to cancel your subs, I'm not quite sure what you are doing GETTING a magazine that is for critique in the entertainment industry. We're not all going to like the same thing. Variety is the spice and all that....

HR Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:11 PM EST

In my opinion, David Cook is the most overrated contestant in the entire history of AI. He is mediocre at best, his voice sounds strained, and he continually struggles with both the low and high registers. There's nothing really original about him, he is a thirteen-in-a-dozen emo rocker.

Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:08 PM EST

Finally, the voice of reason instead of Sleazy! They r ALL good contestants. And I 100% agree with Karger! Karger FTW! ha ha

ANTM Freak Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:03 PM EST

David vs. David would certainly be a lot more dramatic in terms of the result. I just feel if it's Castro vs one of the Davids it's pretty much a gimme that Castro will come in second. On the other hand David vs. David is what 19E wants so I rather not see them get their dream finale. I'm surprised somebody finally stuck up for little Gaspuleta around EW, Slezak was letting the hatred burn white hot. One more thing: can you retire the Carly flashbacks? All it does is remind me how much I disliked her and her singing.

PorkPieHat Fri, May 2, 2008 at 04:00 PM EST

No, I'm not jealous of D'Archie, as many of his fans are claiming on here. I don't think many people who don't get him are jealous either. We just don't feel any sort of emotional connection to the kid, and he truly acts like a little kid. I think he has a terrific voice, but that's it. I need a more emotional connection than I'm feeling from him. I feel the same about Syesha--great voice, emotional disconnect.

Chad Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:58 PM EST

He is easily the most overrated contestant in American Idol history. Although, Taylor Hicks could give him a run for his money in the overrated catagory.
One of the reasons that American Idol's ratings are going down, is the fact that David Archuleta is the foregone guarenteed winner. The problem with the viewing public,
is that he is not the best. He is the manufactured winner. It's not a believable competition. Just a buch of 10-12 year old girls who text, text, text. His voice cracks constantly,
and he is PITCHY throughout his songs. He did sing Imagine beautifully, but one song does not an American Idol make. EVERY one of his songs are the same --> BORING!!
He has absolutly no stage presence, and if I have to hear one more "it had a really good message" song, I am going to go crazy. The judges never criticize his voice for being pitchy,
and they judge him with kid gloves. The critique everyone of the other contestants, but not Archuleta. He is an above average Amusement Park singer.

shelby Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:52 PM EST

Im glad someone is sticking uo for David Archuleta. He's one of the most talented people ever to be on this show, and I hate how people are constantly trying to bring him down. I'm hoping for a David vs. David finale; they are my favorites.

ShowSomeDALove Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:51 PM EST

Thanks for showing DA some love. I just may renew my subcsription that I already cancelled because of all the DA hate from Sleazbag. EW, the Sleaze is losing you BIG $$$$, you may want to replace him.

bpj Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:47 PM EST

I share your fantasy michael. a castro/cook finale would be my wish. i don't know how much longer i can take DA and his dad. sweet kid, killer pipes, but cheesy-cheesy. jason to me is the really refreshing figure in this whole thing. a real come from nowhere, untrained, genuinely authentic guy who has made it. i hope he doesn't give up.

Andee Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:46 PM EST

I don't get the overwhelming praise for Cook. There's nothing genuine about his "rocker" image. He's just a kid who one day decided to become a "rocker" because it's kinda cool. Then he went to a cool store and bought cool clothes and hair products that fit the part.

Also, he hasn't really evolved as an artist. His cd "Analog Heart" sounds exactly like his performances on AI.

Isabel Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:46 PM EST

I WONDER HOW MUCH THIS CROOKS!( OOPS) I MEAN DAVID COOKS( FANATICS) GET PAY FOR SAYING SUCH NASTY COMMENTS???????THEY ARE TRYING TO BUY THE MEDIA!!!JUST BECAUSE THEY WANT Cook TO WIN!- D.A.IS THE BEST!!!!

BabyBommerForDA Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:43 PM EST

I have never voted on A1 although I have been watching since season 6. I have bought Kellies, Carries and Daughtries CDs. David A has captured my attention, stole my heart and earned my votes. I love all different kinds of music and appreciate a good voice when I hear one. David's voice is beautiful, unique and captivating, he personalizes each song his way. I like his versions better than the original singers, I will buy his CDs and attend his concerts. Heck I'm even planning on spending 65 to go to the A! concerts just to see David A. It's nice to see something postive about him here for a change.

john Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:41 PM EST

David Cook really needs to win so that he can have a recording contract with 19 entertainment co.
Win or lose doesn't matter to David Archuleta. Music executives are lining up to talk to him after Idol. If he doesn't win, he can avoid the high cost of commission by 19 Entertainment co. If he wins, he can still handle the commission because he will have other recording contracts with other companies. Do not ignore Disney population. Miley Cyrus is a young millionaire empire. Plus, David's fans are not just Disney audiences. Their parents and grand parents, and some 20's and 30's, and international fans. His name is spreading to the world.

Suzanne Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:36 PM EST

Good Idolatry. (Love Karger for more than his Arch supports.) I preferred the puppies and kittens imagery to the teletubbies. Why don't you have demeaning images for Cook, Jason and Syesha? Wouldn't that be even MORE FUNNY?!

Katie M. Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:28 PM EST

I'm with Slezak on this one. I'd rather see a Cook/Castro or Cook/Mercado final. Archuleta has a nice voice but there doesn't seem to be any "there" there. He is nowhere near the performer that Cook is. Cook deserves the win and if he doesn't get it I'm really going wonder what the heck is up with this show. Even more than I wonder what the heck is in Paula's Coke cup.

Brooke Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:28 PM EST

Get a grip people. Anyone that doesn't see David Archuleta's talent is BLIND, and DUMB. Only someone that is feeling threatened by him would insult such an incredible singer. He sings circles around everyone, and that is a FACT. He is the first contestant in all 7 seasons that I have EVER bothered to pick up the phone and vote for, let alone vote the entire 2 hours. That has to say something. He is a gift, really.

Squinthia Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:27 PM EST

I am SO happy you guys at EW finallyyyy decided to give some love to Archie! For the past few years I've been a dedicated Idolatry watcher/Slezak fan in general, but this year it has not been watchable. If you're going to cover Idol, please at least TRY and find good points/bad points in everyone...I do not want to listen/read to even more Cook pimpage than I already get on a weekly basis on Idol.

meleah Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:25 PM EST

I love Dave Karger! Get him on here more! He was SPOT ON

Rita Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:19 PM EST

I completely agree with Slezak! Archuleta sings ok but he's not AI winner Material.... If there is a Jason vs. David Cook finale... I'll die of joy!!!! That would be so awesome like i live in NY but i would go to La to see the finale if it's between those two.. Great Idolatry and agree 100% about how tuesday's gaffe should've been approaached with an apology from paula to Jason and her admittance that she biased her opinion on his rehearsal.

jared Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:17 PM EST

The versatility of David Cook? David Cook sounds exactly the same every week. He gives every single song the "Billie Jean" treatment.

joji771 Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:14 PM EST

Ah... getting personal now are we with the fans? so instead of insulting david A, we now attack the fans? =(

i think i'm a pretty normal person who just happens to be a fan. so let's not call each other names and labels. =) i guess i better stop responding now and let this boring topic rest... otherwise, i may be accused of being a fanatic.

Archie i love you Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:13 PM EST

Some people are just jealous of David A, so sorry for them, but David is the best singer for me, and he deserves to win..David A rocks...!!

Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:08 PM EST

David Archuleta is a good singer, but that's it. I never feel like he really connects with a song, and, although many people disagree, I find his song choices to all be very similar. He doesn't have the versatility, of, say, David Cook. Archie doesn't really have an identity, and I think it's just because he's too young and not emotional mature enough to handle such attention. There's no doubt he'll have a great career, and maybe someday he'll mature to the point where I actually enjoy his singing. But as for right now, he does not deserve to win this thing.

mady Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:06 PM EST

i luv david archuleta!! he's great and ill support him 100%!!

Fri, May 2, 2008 at 03:03 PM EST

That discussion was 8 minutes longer that it needed to be. BOOORRRIIING! Who the heck are these guys?

StaticCling Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:59 PM EST

Yep, there be some crazy DA fans. Theres one guy who used to go on rickeys site named rascall who got into it with another guy named jeff just because he didn't like DA's perfromance. jeff likes DA but that didn't stop rascall from insulting him over and again so jeff hit back and rascall got so p'd that he left ricky's site. What jeff said was true. rascal was kind of a stalker, his comments for DA were nasty at times like talking about his tight jeans. Ew! DA is 17 and rascal was an older guy. jeff called him out on it. JUICY! now rascall has a fan tribute site to DA. CREEPY!
DA is a good singer but his fans love him so desperatly that they are becoming worse than the claymates. Watch out if you say anything against a DA song!
DA is not a great singer but i do enjoy him. these fanatics make it seem like hes the second coming though. He's a good singer with problems. Too gasping, too much theater, too breathy, hes a cute gay kid who has a lot to learn yet so give him time.

pinkf Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:55 PM EST

wow i wasnt gonna post anything else but a post practically made me, i need to ask: would you take anyone who chose the name "OverratedDA"s thoughts on this? I really don't think so. Doesnt sound too objective

abraham Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:54 PM EST

I think some people are annoyed by David Archuleta mainly because of his age and young looks. They can't simply accept that this little kid is competing against adults in American Idol as a frontrunner. It's a grown-up competition, right?

To me, he is the best representative of American Idol, and what's all about; Finding a talent who can grow to be the great singer in American music industry. Without talent, he couldn't have come this far.

He has a voice that made Dolly Parton cry. He has ability to write his own music. His instruments(piano & guitar) just add up to his resume as nice accessories. His ability to connect people is so rare at his age. He may not have enough life experience but that's why he is very careful in choosing lyrics that he can connect to. His potential is sky high. All I see is money, money, and money. BTW, I am in 40's not a teen.

AI should allow these kids to sing more contemporary songs they like. Bring right mentors for the rating.

joji771 Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:49 PM EST

hmmm... let's see...

prodigy [próddiji]
(plural prodigies)
n
1. somebody with exceptional talent: somebody who shows an exceptional natural talent for something from an early age
2. something marvellous: something very impressive or amazing

oh right... i think David fits the criteria. :) seems like from the age of 10 he's been showing his gift and winning too.

Yes, people might feel he is overrated, but i respect that not everyone will like him. There are artists that i also don't like, but it doesn't mean they are not connecting to the fans that prefer their music. so its a preference. If you don't feel his soul, that is okay. It does not make it less of a reality that there a lot of DA fans who totally feel him when he sings.

Manda Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:46 PM EST

People that make negative comments about DavidA's 12 year old maturity needs to look at theirs. Because your comments make you sound the same way!

Mandy Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:40 PM EST

Dave Karger - thank you for finally trying to talk some sense into Slezak. David A. is extremely talented and is an amazing singer. And Mr. Slezak - you enjoy hearing David A. sing, so try not to bash on him so much. The way you write about him is like he is a Sanjaya or John Stevens. He is not even close - those people sucked and he is amazing. So please try to be a little more objective from now on.

jwipe Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:34 PM EST

Well just because you don't "feel" it, doesn't mean it isn't there. I actually feel really sorry for the people who don't feel him. I would hope that just once in everyone's lifetime they could experience what he makes us feel (we who do "feel" him), because it's the most incredible thing I've ever experienced. And that is why he's so popular, not because of his "aw shucks" personality (though that is the icing).

Archuletasoldier Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:33 PM EST

hahahaa yeah last tuesday I voted like crazy for the legendary 17 years old David Archuleta....
Go David Archuleta...hahahaa!!

sheila Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:32 PM EST

david a. is an incredibly talented singer...you really don't even pay attention to that fact...you just go immediately for the oh he's so young and too cute..well he's way more than that..he is an amazing singer and I will buy anything he records...

OverratedDA Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:27 PM EST

ugh apparently the Archie fan base all came here at once. Yeah, he's got a decent voice. I don't FEEL it though. I don't feel his soul. Must be nice to never be called out on forgetting your lyrics or hitting a bad note, like the other singers. And how is a 17 year old a prodigy singer anyway? 13 maybe (Which he looks btw...).
And I have my doubts as to how he'd fit in on the radio... I don't see him selling as many records as some of the other contestants. His fan appeal seems to be centered on his "aw shucks" attitude-- yeah, I had one of those at his age, but then the world wasn't offered up on a platter. Now I'm a more cautious, optimistic realist. Or perhaps it's based on the fact that he is sexually non-threatening and therefore safe for kids to listen to. Shrug, I just. don't. see it. So flame away but the way I see it, Slezak's dead on.

BrianM Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:25 PM EST

Thank you, Dave Karger, for putting into words why I like David A. I'm not against any of the top 4, and I admire Syesha's growth. To Slezak, have enjoyed your work for some time, but your critiques of David A. seem personal rather than performance-related, and I have not understood that.

Susan Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:24 PM EST

David Archuleta is such a star! I have voted for him for day 1. I am not a teenybopper either! He has continued to bring it every single week. Go David for the win!

haha Archie the winner of my heart! Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:20 PM EST

Archuleta is the best singer out there. He is humble, handsome, he can sing, he is original, he is likeable, very down to earth, he doesn't like to be the center of attention..He should win and I hope he wins..
God Bless You David A!

Archuleta fans Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:15 PM EST

You people are surprisingly nasty. Seriously. How do you think Archulta himself would feel having such nastiness spoken on his behalf.

Suzanne Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:11 PM EST

People feel very strongly about David Archuleta. Tons of people think he's an inspiring angel. Tons more really dislike him. I look forward to seeing him sing every week because he's a good singer and adorable. It's always a good performance, and maybe he'll be awesome again before the end. Thanks, Slezak, for doing this episode and acknowledging the huge crowd that royally feels differently from you.

slezakduzintnojack Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:08 PM EST

Slezak...apparently you have met Jack!
Whew! I thought I would never see the day..you said you like listening to David A. sing?? Is the sky falling?? I try to stay away from EW cuz you and I don't see eye to eye BUT today is great! David A. is MY American Idol because first and foremost, he's got an amazing amount of raw talent and secondly, how many of us adults could handle himself/herself with the mature composure that he has demonstrated over the past few months? God, I love that kid!

pinkf Fri, May 2, 2008 at 02:04 PM EST

Why would i want something that's already readily available all around like a generic voiced rocker when I can have something original. The real deal here is Archie. Distinctive voice, different sound... I can listen to Nickelback or Daughtry or David Cook and they all sound the same. But EW is not exactly Rolling Stone so not much to worry about biased opinions.

Adam Fri, May 2, 2008 at 01:57 PM EST

Believe it or not, I am a guy in my 20's and I do get Archuleta. It's rather simple..he's amazing. Nuff said. Dave Karger for President!

pinkf Fri, May 2, 2008 at 01:55 PM EST

I want to kiss you rascal. Well put. I really cannot stand the bias and hypocracy of Sleazyak

donnyc Fri, May 2, 2008 at 01:55 PM EST

words words words everybody has an opinion full of wrods.

like it or not, it's archuleta all the way.

Kara Fri, May 2, 2008 at 01:54 PM EST

I have been tired of hearing the negative comments regarding David A. He is truly talented and his potential should be obvious to anyone watching. He is not perfect or radio ready now, but eventually he will be and he will be amazing. David Cook reminds me of any other lead singer of a bar band that gets lucky and has his one hit on the radio. He will be forgotten eventually even if he wins. Jason Castro is just fodder for teeny boppers and will not stick around. Syesha may do well on Broadway but will never win AI.

Robert Fri, May 2, 2008 at 01:54 PM EST

I too, had become an EW.com avoider. Word is now spreading that intelligent life does pop in every once in a while on Idoltry. Thanks for bringing me back Dave.
DAVID ARCHULETA FOR THE WIN.

joji771 Fri, May 2, 2008 at 01:54 PM EST

Soundscene: i definitely agree with you. to be honest, i love both davids. my mother and sister love david C, my father and i happen to love david A. both of them deserve this chance and thi