Who's the most overrated 'American Idol' contestant?

Ronnie Sun, Jun 21, 2009 at 10:47 AM EST

I have to agree that David Archuleta was overrated. He flubbed a number of songs and in some instances, the camera quickly focused on something else so as to downplay his mistakes. He's a nice kid and has talent but he would have been eliminated earlier on for forgetting the lyrics but people gave him a pass too many times.

April Sat, Feb 28, 2009 at 08:35 PM EST

I think Brooke White was THE BEST & will have or be the most successful! I LOVE her voice!!!! I voted religiously for her! I'm sorry I missed her thee other night because I swore I'd NEVER watch American Idol AGAIN! I LOVE Brooke White!!!! xoxoxo

jan Tue, Aug 26, 2008 at 11:16 AM EST

To be over rated he sure has some good ratings!

virginia banker Sat, Jul 12, 2008 at 12:31 PM EST

David Archuleda will sell more records
then any idol in season 7. What and see.

mari Fri, Jul 11, 2008 at 01:32 PM EST

David Archuleta is the most overrated this season. i just dont know why the judges kept on giving good comments to him.. his singing voice sounds like its coming out from his nose.. it is so nasal.. i believe that Jason castro is the underrated one.. i think he is the one who'll be the most successful of all the AI contestants.. he is unique and he has a very nice personality.. eventhough he didnt win the title, i know and i believe that he'll achieve his dreams....

Olga Mon, Jun 9, 2008 at 05:33 PM EST

I believe Jason Castro was under rated and he isn't aware the power he holds with his unique, 'real' and drawing personality and look. He can sing; he just needs to quit listening to the jealous and bias, critics and go for it; show what he can do and determine to keep a level head if he's rushed into fame all of a sudden and not allow himself to follow 'the sheep to the slaugther', and fall into the "no common sense spiral" which causes much loss and sadness.

Pamela Sun, Jun 8, 2008 at 07:46 PM EST

Oh, I forgot to mention Jason Castro. Yes, he is so unique and cool. His performance on the finale was fantastic.

Actually, this was definitely the best season for talent. I hope all of them become successful. Syesha was unbelievably good, too. As a matter of fact, I think she could have been the idol for this season.

Good luck to all of the top ten!!

Pamela Sun, Jun 8, 2008 at 07:37 PM EST

I agree with most of what you have said about this season. David Archuleta in my book is going to be very famous (as long as he performs like he did in the finale--his last three songs....."crazy vocals" like Randy had said!! If he sticks with passionate ballads and the like, he'll make it big time.

I also think David Cook was awesome and he is the whole package. Love him. He, too, will be very famous if he chooses good songs.

American Idol is my very favorite show of all time.....can't wait for January 2009!!

Kacey Sat, Jun 7, 2008 at 09:53 PM EST

Most overated? David Cook. Hands down. He was pimped all season long and I've seen better rockers on the show in past seasons. Cook just didn't do it for me and he certainly wasn't as original an artist as the judges made him out to be. Most overated. Definitely.

that "old" fan Sat, Jun 7, 2008 at 02:38 PM EST

You know if we are looking for who is headed for stardom, I think Jason Castro is the one! I have never voted nor downloaded a song...until Jason...I have all his songs and listen to them nearly every day and I actually voted this year...for Jason.
As for overrated, I don't really know who to vote for on this one, I thought the top 10 were (are) very entertaining and I would watch them every week if I could. Everyone is looking for different things and they give a nice variety.
I also loved that sweet little Asia'h Epperson. I hope she polishes up her voice just a little bit more and does something really great. I would buy her album, too.

Olga Sat, Jun 7, 2008 at 07:29 AM EST

I just say it like I see it. Jason Castro has the most potential to become the next Movie hero.
If someone would look beyond the critical uncalled for opinions. "He's got it" You want to see him over and over, and do well, too; if only someone was wise enough to care.
I spotted Goldie H. and golden hair x-wrestler who now hosts Gladiator, and Arnold S.
I don't care if you don't believe it. Ask any of my family members.
I always say, 'why don't they try him out in a movie?'

JCfan4ever Sat, May 31, 2008 at 07:53 PM EST

I've been watching Ai for the past 4 years and Jason Castro is the only contestant I have ever voted for. He ha s such a magical voice. I have downloaded every song that was available on iTunes. Thank you Jason. As for the others.

The two David's really got to be boring. The judges loved them every week I would never buy theie Cd and I can't wait for Jaosn to put out his own music.

leah123 Thu, May 29, 2008 at 03:55 PM EST

For me this was probably my favorite season of idol. I really enjoyed 4 contestants and I will be buying all of their Cd's. I am excited idol fans voted for indie artists Jason and Brooke. I can't wait to listen to Michael John's cd when I'm at work. As for David Cook...he was not my fav but I can't wait to hear how original his cd will be.

Thankfully Archie did not win. If he did...I may have ditch idol all together.

misc2 Tue, May 27, 2008 at 07:06 PM EST

Check out Jason's studio versions of "I Don't Want To Cry", "Fragile", and "Travelin' Through". Much better than his live performances.

Ben Sat, May 24, 2008 at 03:44 AM EST

The AOL poll is driven by fans. Just go to the AI website and you can see how much campaigning went here to change the outcome of this poll in favor to the favorites. In fact, if I remember right, David Cook was the most overrated last Sunday. But I believe AOL closed the poll 2 or 3 days earlier.

Sal Fri, May 23, 2008 at 10:14 AM EST

Jason was overrated more by the fans than the judges. "Hallelujah" and "Somewhere over the Rainbow" were pretty good, and that's about it. "I didn't know [Memory] was sung by a cat"- oh for God's sake, Jason. It was a travesty that Carly was voted off and Jason stayed.
But I agree with the person who said there wasn't as much talent this year. There was early on, with Carly (IMHO) and Michael Johns but other than that, no one really blew me away.

Laura Fri, May 23, 2008 at 02:27 AM EST

Jason is the most UNDERrated!!! How could he possibly be overrated when the judges crapped on him all season? Especially Randy...he could barely handle giving Jason's "Hallelujah" any praise. The show knew Jason was a threat to their faves, so they threw him under the bus every chance they got. When others forgot their words, they were treated with kid gloves & the flubs were pushed aside as if it was no biggie, but when JC did it one time, they almost executed him for it.

Gaby Thu, May 22, 2008 at 08:13 PM EST

Michael Johns is a REALLY REALLY good singer. And he's an incredible artist. I don't get the guy that wrote this, because being 29 doesn't harm you at all when you really do have star potential. He's got a beautiful, outstanding voice and he's going to have huge sucess with his bluesy soul/rock album. Just wait for it, he's already achieving it.

Just1 Thu, May 22, 2008 at 06:28 PM EST

Thank you, Michael Slezak! If anything, Jason Castro was the most UNDERrated. His voice is so identifiable, and it stirs an emotional response that the other contestants could never manage, with all their technical abilities. Jason just didn't fit the Hollywood style of Idol. He will be very successful if he does not try to compromise his unique talent.
Most overated? Syesha. She has more of a back-up voice, nice but not distinctive!

Kal Thu, May 22, 2008 at 05:06 PM EST

I actually think Brooke White was kind of overrated. Sometimes she did really good songs but other times they just weren't very good, but people let her get by. I really didn't like when she stopped the song and started over and the judges forgave her because it was "her." I don't think other contestants could have gotten away with it.

On the other hand, I don't think Jason Castro was overrated at all. I think he was just tired out; at the beginning of the season, he was one of the few contestants that continuously got praise, it was only as the competition wore on that he started faltering. His style is very unique and he has the talent, just not the training that everyone else had.

JM Thu, May 22, 2008 at 12:34 PM EST

JASON WAS THE MOST OVERRATED SINGER AND HE KNEW IT! I CHEERED WHEN HE GOT THE BOOT.

karen Thu, May 22, 2008 at 08:21 AM EST

I really dont get whats so great about Micheal Johns and Carly. They went out at 8th and 6th place for a reason. They werent that good.

Danielle Thu, May 22, 2008 at 05:30 AM EST

Slezak - you're my hero. As a 39-year-old Castro fan. I salute you :)

Jo Thu, May 22, 2008 at 12:25 AM EST

I agree with the choice of Jason and Brooke for original sounding voices. They are distinct. Everyone else had a common sound.. I would buy CD's by Jason and Brooke, everyone else.. probably not

Chris' Daddy Wed, May 21, 2008 at 11:34 PM EST

"Michael could do very well, but he his 29 and still has not found his niche. You can become successful only with loyal devoted fans, not trying to please everybody." He has found his niche--blues/rock soul. But the judges just wanted him in the white soul/pop box, he resisted and he got kicked off the show in the process--how is that crowd-pleasing? Of course, fans make an artist successful--sure, but that doesn't make him/her good. (You must be a Miley Cyrus fan then?) He won't outsell the rest of the Idols but if he puts out that good rock-soul record that he promised his modest number of fans, he'll have a more credible career, IMO, than any of your favorite chart-toppers.

Dee Wed, May 21, 2008 at 11:10 PM EST

Jason & Brooke are true artists, and will be very successful. They may not sell in huge numbers, but will be respected artists, with possibly a Grammy or two in the future. Hope so! Congrats to David C. I won't be buying his music, or David A's, only anxious to buy Jason's & possibly Brooke's, depending on the music.

Ref. Chris Daddy Wed, May 21, 2008 at 09:51 PM EST

Michael could do very well, but he his 29 and still has not found his niche. You can become successful only with loyal devoted fans, not trying to please everybody. Fans of Celine Dion are not the fans of Barry Manilow!!!. WHO IS MICHAEL as a singer?

Mika Wed, May 21, 2008 at 09:07 PM EST

Archie was so overrated. Any middle-school boy can sound just like him. It showed that he knows nothing about music theory when he had to actually sing a song he'd never sung before. All this kid did was regurgitate songs he has already learned and performed and been overly coached on by his parents.

Chris's Daddy Wed, May 21, 2008 at 07:55 PM EST

Chris, even your idol Jason named one of Michael's performances as his favorite. Cook also said Johns was his favorite Idol. During Hollywood week, you could spot at least 3 (including Cook and Carly) of the Top 24 in the audience clapping for his Queen performance. (Which doesn't happen much in the early stages, when contestants don't know each other well, versus the gracious applause they give to each other on later shows after they make the cut). Johns still can't sing? Even your boy Castro and fan favorite Cook are wowed by Michael Johns.

rp Wed, May 21, 2008 at 06:54 PM EST

David Archuleta did not change the lyrics to Imagine. He just sang the 3rd verse that is his favorite. He did this in an earlier performance. He's an amazing young man and should win the competition. He sings from his heart. We don't need another Daughtry like singer. Arch is not overrated, he's the best. People are just jealous!

niss Wed, May 21, 2008 at 05:18 PM EST

Singing is not always about the slowness or upbeat of the song..it's about the message/feeling behind the song..i feel that David Archuletta should win..he is a solid genuine kid..he shows that through his eyes and heart....a great performer that he reminds me of would be sarah mclachlan..a very gifted woman through song and voice..Go Archuletta :O)

Peter DM Wed, May 21, 2008 at 05:14 PM EST

Was I the only one disturbed by the fact that David A took Lennon's "Imagine" & by eliminating half the lyrics effectively robbed it of all of its meaning (criticising organised religion, nationalism & militarism) & just turned it into a bland "feel-good" ballad.

"Imagine there's no heaven, its easy if you try.
No hell below us, above us only sky.
Imagine all the people, living for today"

"Imagine there's no countries, it isn't hard to do.
Nothing to kill or die for, & no religion too.
Imagine all the people living life in peace."

not a returner 2009 Wed, May 21, 2008 at 05:06 PM EST

It would great if the judges read some of this ....

allicat Wed, May 21, 2008 at 05:05 PM EST

Archie was so overrated. I'm wondering if the show worked some kind of deal at the beginning of the season to make sure he breezed through. What kind of album would he even make? He's got the teeny-boppers loving him - and maybe the producers feel like that audience is where the big bucks come from. I think Jason Castro is going to be a huge success. He has a very distinctive, beautiful sound.

probie123 Wed, May 21, 2008 at 05:04 PM EST

One more thing EW - why would you waste your time and energy on this review when the most awesome thing on TV last night was NCIS. Where is that review?

probie123 Wed, May 21, 2008 at 05:02 PM EST

I think that the judges and contestants should all have to kiss the toes of the striking writers. they definitely allowed this show one more year because if David A. wins, I guarantee you that the attendance will be 1/2 of what it is now next year. Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson are the ONLY two successful winners. Among the "also rans" we have Daughtery, Jennifer Hudson (Oscar winner), Kelly Pickler (At the Country awards the other night) just to name a few. David Cook will be so much luckier if they give it to the little kid who will be lucky to sell 100,000 records. Seriously, do you know anyone that is going to rush out to download one of his "Tony Bennett" CD's. He won Star Search and it didn't get him anywhere - a year from now, they'll have to explain away why they went ga-ga for him. The show has become a running joke.

Tomas Servomoteur Wed, May 21, 2008 at 04:14 PM EST

Overrated in the extreme? Archuleta, every day of the week and twice on Sundays. If I wanted to see The Best Kid In The Show Choir perform there's any number of high schools in my area for that. Watching on my teevee, OTOH, and seeing Randy Jackson rather creepily, "To Catch a Predator"-worthily slobber all over him? Not so much.

natform Wed, May 21, 2008 at 03:13 PM EST

Jason Castro is by far the most UNDERRATED contestant. He got so much grief from certain judges and certain fans from time to time and just took it with class. The funny thing is ... Jason has done better now that he is off AI then when he was on it. He interviews well, he is articulate and kind to people never saying anything negative. He had every right to be angry with the producers and with Paulgaff and he just took it in stride. His voice is purely recognizable, his falsetto is great and he will only get better considering he is new, raw talent that has not been polished on stage like the 2 Davids. Overrated is not something that you think of when you think Jason Castro. Anyone who is even thinking about signing him on or producing music for Jason better jump on it quick because the the guy is going to be selling lots of albums.

izza Wed, May 21, 2008 at 02:45 PM EST

David Cook desreves to winnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn Simon pls pls pls pls

izza Wed, May 21, 2008 at 02:43 PM EST

David Cook had a good voice than archuleta but the kid picks the best song so far that it makes it different,But if cook only had a good adviser and can advice what good song is best for him he is miles miles miles away from archuleta

Wed, May 21, 2008 at 02:00 PM EST

I meant to say that DA is only two years younger than Carrie Underwood was when she won American Idol.

Wed, May 21, 2008 at 01:59 PM EST

For people that say DA isn't mature enough because of his age, he is only two years younger than Carrie Underwood. Furthermore, DC is extremely original, but let's not kid ourselves. He turns every song into a rock ballad. While it does show his creativity, it doesn't show his versatililty because he changes the song to fit his genre. The point is, DA and DC are two very different, gifted singers that will find success no matter what happens tonight. So to the people who believe that their favorite is the only talented one, GROW UP!!!

Ina Wed, May 21, 2008 at 01:45 PM EST

David Cook is the BOMB. I have enjoyed every single one of his performances and He will definitely have success after AI. Meanwhile, DA is a nice kid with alot of talent, but I don't get that he is mature enough to handle the title.

Katherine Wed, May 21, 2008 at 01:43 PM EST

I hope Dialidol is correct in saying DC won the night. David Cook showed a lot more versatility as an artist when he picked THREE DIFFERENT STYLES of songs to sing on the show. While I'm not exactly in love with "Dream Big", it's certainly a refreshing change from all of our other cheesy s-l-o-w-@-$-$ ballads that the winners have sung the past 6 seasons. Predictably, David Archuleta sang three s-l-o-w-@-$-$ songs last night. I don't think even Disney channel will pick him up now cuz he hasn't got a bubbly bone in his personality!!!

BWithers Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:55 PM EST

DA can sing ballads as well as anyone. Problem is: that’s all he can do. Don't dare give him something upbeat... DC is versatile enough to sing anything well, and he has stage presence unlike Archie Boy. Country, rock, ballads, you name it and Cook can sing it. It's a shame the judges were so overwhelmingly pro Archie last night - seems like they were trying to ensure DA a win. AND if that be the case, what is the purpose of voting?

Also, Simon kills me with this “you need to be daring and do something different”, which Cook has tried to do all season. He didn’t repeat a single performance unlike someone else who hasn’t shown much if any creativity. Most of the songs that DA did were quite boring and really stuck to the original versions. I think most anyone can add a woo woo or two to a song like Archie. That’s not being creative at all and certainly not daring.

BWithers Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:55 PM EST

DA can sing ballads as well as anyone. Problem is: that’s all he can do. Don't dare give him something upbeat... DC is versatile enough to sing anything well, and he has stage presence unlike Archie Boy. Country, rock, ballads, you name it and Cook can sing it. It's a shame the judges were so overwhelmingly pro Archie last night - seems like they were trying to ensure DA a win. AND if that be the case, what is the purpose of voting?

Also, Simon kills me with this “you need to be daring and do something different”, which Cook has tried to do all season. He didn’t repeat a single performance unlike someone else who hasn’t shown much if any creativity. Most of the songs that DA did were quite boring and really stuck to the original versions. I think most anyone can add a woo woo or two to a song like Archie. That’s not being creative at all and certainly not daring.

BWithers Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:55 PM EST

DA can sing ballads as well as anyone. Problem is: that’s all he can do. Don't dare give him something upbeat... DC is versatile enough to sing anything well, and he has stage presence unlike Archie Boy. Country, rock, ballads, you name it and Cook can sing it. It's a shame the judges were so overwhelmingly pro Archie last night - seems like they were trying to ensure DA a win. AND if that be the case, what is the purpose of voting?

Also, Simon kills me with this “you need to be daring and do something different”, which Cook has tried to do all season. He didn’t repeat a single performance unlike someone else who hasn’t shown much if any creativity. Most of the songs that DA did were quite boring and really stuck to the original versions. I think most anyone can add a woo woo or two to a song like Archie. That’s not being creative at all and certainly not daring.

Denny Czupryna Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:36 PM EST

Everyone should post their age,that would give readers a clue about replys.Remember winner is under contract with American Idol for a period of time. Second place can do their own thing and make more money. If they are good enough. David C.???

vivi Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:06 PM EST

I hope Cook wins but even if he doesn't winner the title he is The Winner. Howeer, this will be my last Idol I'm over the whole thing . The rigging and the fact the Judges were so biased this year and quite obviously only wanted one Winner (God only knows why) this year that I just don't feel the same about it anymore.

geewindu Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:01 PM EST

Most overrated is definitely Archuleta. Not just last night but most this season. They did overrate Cook sometimes too, but they also overated Carly, Michael and Syesha. Michael should've made it farther than he did but the judges overrated him lots. Syesha shouldn't have made it to the top 12. She took Asia'h's or Alaina's spot. Jason was never overrated I don't think. It should've been a Brooke/David Cook finale and Amanda Overmyer in 3rd or 4th. Archuleta has a good voice but that's it, no personality, no originality, no stage presence. Something bot Cook and Brooke have plus they have good voices. Those two should've definitely made the finale. I'm kinda glad Brooke didn't as now she'll get to make an album her way instead of the producers way. Her per-idol cd was re-released after she was eliminated from Idol and made it to the top 12 on the itunes pop-charts. It's doing well considering it gets absolutely no promotion. You can buy it at www.brookewhite.com

GHall! Wed, May 21, 2008 at 11:53 AM EST

Let's be honest the only reason I would buy a David A CD would be if I needed a sleep aid. He's still as awkward as ever and the "aw shucks" thing has really worn thin. Granted I'm not a tweenbot who will vote just because "he's sooooooooo cute." I have to say in terms of stage presence, Cook has it all. I like the fact he didn't fall back on one of his past successes. He really seems to want to push himself. Maybe he's not in it to win but why play games when you're that talented. Was it just me or did the whole evening seem a little David A heavy. It was almost like the decision was made already (and maybe it was)and we were just letting Cook-man along for the ride. I had to turn it off after Simon's final comment. Randy had the most exasperated look when Cook was in the audience. I don't know if they were really down on Mr. Cook or if they figured what's the point. Either way I'm still rooting for Dave C. It's about time Idol rocked a little. GO COOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

joyce Wed, May 21, 2008 at 11:14 AM EST

The judges and idol have already decided...it's their face haired archie boy. It's very obvious when they push the power of suggestion that he (archie) "took the entire show tonight". Simon talks out of both sides of his mouth. The night before the idol showdown he was on Leno's show and said Cook should win and he'd like to see him win but on Tuesday Simon did everything but hand the keys to the city to archie ol' boy, putting down Cook at every corner. Archie ought to go back to the town choir in Utah. David Cooks the better singer in all senses and is sincere. Archie's a phoney and his act didn't get me. He arrogant and playing the game...dull and all songs sound the same.

Bell Wed, May 21, 2008 at 11:11 AM EST

Blah Blah Blah, most everyone fell for the hype this year, best season ever bull crap. The only thing that was better is it brought in more of a singer songwriter style of musician. Please if I have to hear about range on a damm song again I think I'll go around wearing ear plugs the rest of my life. Some of us want a unique style not cookie cutter bubble gum range seekers. Jason, God bless you weren't one of them! When you start making CDs yours will be the ones that everyone I know will buy.

Diane (to Jean) Wed, May 21, 2008 at 10:22 AM EST

Yes, everyone makes mistakes. The problem is the judges overlook or praise Archie when he makes mistakes while other contestants were taken to task (i.e., Brook, Jason). The judges have been blatantly obvious in their desire to have Archie win. Now, is this fair?

Mel Wed, May 21, 2008 at 10:16 AM EST

Brooke FTW!!! well, i know AI is almost over now, but Brooke will always be the winner in my heart.

Mark Hastings NYC Wed, May 21, 2008 at 09:52 AM EST

It looks like it comes down to personal likes.
I voted for Carrie Underwood, not because I liked her, but because I did not like the song choice and singing style of Bo Bice.
To me David C. seems to be just another Bo Bice, which is a shame because he seemed to have talent.

Mark Hastings NYC Wed, May 21, 2008 at 09:42 AM EST

From the top 24 my family was in agreement that the end would be:
1 David A.
2 David C.
3 Carly
4 Brooke
We were extremely surprized when Jason(overrated) made it into the top 8, but it was a good thing because after that he had three good songs that nobody would have heard otherwise. We were just as surprized when Carly fell apart and went out early(underrated)

Veronica Wed, May 21, 2008 at 09:23 AM EST

Michael Johns PWNS them all. The End.

Stock D Wed, May 21, 2008 at 09:13 AM EST

Cook out sang Archie every week and last night he look like he didn't. Was this fixxed Archie can sing but I would by cooks record

Stock D Wed, May 21, 2008 at 09:13 AM EST

Cook out sang Archie every week and last night he look like he didn't. Was this fixxed Archie can sing but I would by cooks record

Cindy Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:56 AM EST

Hey - Save the Children.How are you going to save children when you are trying to hurt one like David A ? Dont be a phoney.Im sure a lot of readers would like to know.

Denver J. Killpack Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:48 AM EST

I agree with the guy who sent me this article. The winner is defiently going to be David Archaleta, because he out shot David Cook last night. I agree that David Archaleta should be everyone's biggest fan.

Denver J. Killpack Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:48 AM EST

I agree with the guy who sent me this article. The winner is defiently going to be David Archaleta, because he out shot David Cook last night. I agree that David Archaleta should be everyone's biggest fan.

sharon s. bowers Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:48 AM EST

David A. is the most overrated performer. He sings pretty, but alot of people sing pretty. There is more to it than that. David Cook is the next American Idol! I love you Paula!!!!

Jean Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:46 AM EST

Stop using the excuse not to like little David because he forgot the lyrics.There isnt a singer out there that dont once and awhile because they are human.Do you think your perfect?Im telling you your not.

john Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:40 AM EST

Anyone who says David A cant sing and Carly is envious because they are outstanding and you cant stand it.They will be laughing all the way to the bank while some of you have an empty bank book.Eat your hearts out.

maniac Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:35 AM EST

Unfortunately, David A has been overrated all season. Granted, he's a good singer, but he isn't "great" nor is he a very engaging performer. And even when he forgot the lyrics to the song he was singing (and that was several times for those of us who listened) he was praised. Heck, why did they even bother to air the show last night; it was clear who the judges were pushing on the audience. AI is turning into a lame show...why bother to watch when we already know the outcome weeks before it happens?

Marie Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:34 AM EST

Little David is the best male singer and Carly the best girl singer period.Yes Jason is overrated and David Cook is a screamer and little David a swooner.

chris Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:14 AM EST

Michael Johns can not sing. He can, however, impersonate well. It's hard to say he's the most overrated simply because he didn't make it as far in the competiton as many thought. However, I do believe he was full of fluff, so in my mind, it was not at all surprsing that he got eliniated when he did. Baed on all these blogs, I'd say Castro has one of the biggest fan bases of all contestants. Since he was constantly thrown under the bus throughout the season, I'd say he is the most underrated. Personally, I can't wait for his CD to come out.

ML Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:13 AM EST

THREE WORDS:

PHONE BOOK, DAWG

now you tell me who the most overrated contestant was this season. because it was NOT jason castro.

! Wed, May 21, 2008 at 08:09 AM EST

I would like to challenge USA and/or AOL to do a true survey! One where people are allowed only 1 vote. I think the results would be far different as many fans used a mouse recorder to continually vote for them! Oh well, it's just a survey and only time will really tell. I do however think that it's irresponsible to print the results of such a bogas survey!

Claire Wed, May 21, 2008 at 07:53 AM EST

One of the things I am seeing in all the comments here is that very few people seem to understand what the term "overrated" is. In order to be "overrated" you must be consistently praised highly for mediocre work. I do not see how anybody who watched the last three weeks of Jason's tenure on American Idol can call him overrated. Even if you thought he was bad, he was certainly not being overpraised.

Furthermore, it does appear that people are using this poll to state why their idol is better than another - they are not addressing the actual questions in the poll.

This is why I said that the result come from fanwar spamming, and cannot be respected as genuine news. The only news we have here is that messageboard fanwars make people behave in ways that are destructive and childish.

I do not know if any of them will have Daughtry-like success. I think the power of the franchise to create stars is decreasing.

Alleila89 Wed, May 21, 2008 at 07:35 AM EST

Michael Johns absolutely deserves to be at the top of the post-idol success chart. Unlike several others who still have a ways to go before they can command a stage, MJ is the real deal, complete package, with a versatile voice that spans genres and way exceeds the generic tones we've come to accept as radio-friendly these days. I'm definitely buying anything he releases and look forward to his future success!

Lisa Wed, May 21, 2008 at 06:41 AM EST

Jason, you're an inspiration to us all! You're going to soar tonight! Can't wait to see you!!!!

Janine Di Petrillo Wed, May 21, 2008 at 06:35 AM EST

How can you say Archuleta is overrated???? Look where he's at!!!! They talked about him every week because he brought it EVERY week. Why would people talk about ones who don't measure up for the occasion!!! Ever think that he really deserve all the praise he gets??? Man, he's on the edge of 17 for GOD'S sake, and having an idol as young, pure & always having a positive message for people, NO ONE can be a better role model for our kids...Our Country, today, with as much trouble as it is in and the messages are clear for everyone to see!!!Young old, troops, sick, he brings hope and humility to the world. It's very REFRESHING, not to have the same sounding people out there!!! AND, it's straight from his heart!!! Don't be so callus!!!

duh Wed, May 21, 2008 at 06:26 AM EST

Sounds like most of you are choosing style over substance. Yeah, Jason is a cutey and I don't care how 'successful' Kelli Pickler is, fact is, this is first and foremost about singing. These two can't stack up against these 2 Davids or any of the other idols before them. Fact. Face it.

Gladys Wed, May 21, 2008 at 05:00 AM EST

How could Jason be overrated if the judges never gave him the praises that he deserves. So who is over rating him? The fans? Aaaaarrrggghhh! To the people who hates Jason, please think before you post something here. OVERRATED means giving credit that they are not worthy of! Jason is UNDERRATED if you ask me!!!

Gladys Wed, May 21, 2008 at 04:59 AM EST

How could Jason be overrated if the judges never gave him the praises that he deserves. So who is over rating him? The fans? Aaaaarrrggghhh! To the people who hates Jason, please think before you post something here. OVERRATED means giving credit that they are not worthy of! Jason is UNDERRATED if you ask me!!!

Gladys Wed, May 21, 2008 at 04:58 AM EST

How could Jason be overrated if the judges never gave him the praises that he deserves. So who is over rating him? The fan? Aaaaarrrggghhh! To the people who hates Jason, please think before you post something here. OVERRATED means giving credit that they are not worthy of! Jason is UNDERRATED if you ask me!!!

Sara Nichols Wed, May 21, 2008 at 03:51 AM EST

Jason was most overrated. Archuleta is extremely talented, and obviously very well coached, but he can't match Cook. UNFORTUNATELY in this game of American Idol, if Simon says Archuleta won the day, that means he will be named the winner.
My guess, though, is that David Cook
will be the one to be the biggest star.

Sara Nichols Wed, May 21, 2008 at 03:41 AM EST

Jason was the most over-rated. I agree that Archuleta has talent - he clearly has had extensive coaching. But I wouldn't want to hear his voice on a regular basis. David Cook is spectacular. I've wanted him to win since day one. UNFORTUNATELY

edge Wed, May 21, 2008 at 01:57 AM EST

Jason Castro is a refreshing sight on TV with decent signing talent. However, his limited vocal range does not give him the opportunity to interpret more challenging songs. And for that, I agree that Jason is kinda overrated by reaching the final four.

Leslie Wed, May 21, 2008 at 01:16 AM EST

Do we need to look up the definition for overrated? Mr. Webster defines it as "rated or valued too high." Was Jason Castro highly rated in this show by any of the judges? He was given credit for only four songs that I can remember. I sincerely thought he was underrated because he was the only true amateur in the contest that made it past the Top 9. Considering most of the other contestants already had CDs or had been on a show similar to AI, I'd say he held his own pretty darn well AND kept the "reality" of the show in check. He didn't take it too seriously, and I don't think anyone should. Bravo!! I think David A. has a beautiful voice, but telling ANYONE that they could sing the phonebook and it be great screams overrated to me. I think Jason and David C. will have longevity if they choose to stay in the music industry. I'd already be a bit jaded if I were either of them, though. It's hard to truly stay focused on the music when so much is about the business. Sad.

tom Wed, May 21, 2008 at 01:15 AM EST

most likely to succeed - brooke white. she's got it all: a fine voice (singing is not all about belting high notes), accomplished musician, songwriting ability (e.g., her debut album out now), artistry, personality, stage presence, acting ability, humor, looks, and humility. only thing a bit lacking is confidence in herself, as she doesn't even realize how talented she is. just believing in herself will allow her prodigious, natural gifts to shine. overrated? carly - too scary/screechy, jason - too one-note, michael - too uninteresting, syesha - too fake. cook is good but gets too much credit for being original, he does the same basic thing to every song. archuleta is mr chessy ballad but he sells it and he's only 17.

Wissphoto Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:49 AM EST

Got to defend Cook to people who still say he is unoriginal and steals covers. Since Billie Jean (which was great)- he has totally revamped and made classics out of: Little Sparrow, Always be my baby, All I really need is you, The first time I saw your face. What has David A. revamped. Nothing. Nothing but slow to slightly less-slow ballads. Jason is also over-rated. Barely can sing most of the time and hides behind his weak guitar playing. He has some coffee house talent, but he needs to develop it and do his fans justic by having a harder work ethic and remembering his lyrics. I liked Carly a lot, and thought the judges threw her under the bus many a time. She never could please them. She has vocals that were in tune, but voters some how let weaker singers like Brooke and Jason through the cracks.

Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:26 AM EST

most overrated? a David, take your pick.

likely to succeed? Brooke, Jason, Carly (hopefully!), maybe KLC(Kelli Pickler did well) and David Cook (I think he's slightly overrated, but I can't deny he is popular/radio ready)

Lane Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:21 AM EST

Syesha - a screecy, off-key nightmare.

Eric Wed, May 21, 2008 at 12:00 AM EST

I can't believe so many people think Jason was underrated. Don't people have any sense? Have people forgotten what a good singer sounds like. To have gotten that far in the competition and still have forgotten the lyrics on his last night was a disgrace. He'll be a distant memory before the milk in my fridge expires! He's not only the most overrated of season 7, but probably the most overrated EVER!

LetsGetCookin' Tue, May 20, 2008 at 11:52 PM EST

A few thoughts,
Did anybody notice that "don't let the sun go down on me" has been performed by second place male idols, not once, not twice, but three times before? Justin, Clay, and Bo Bice all sang it! Maybe its just a coincidence, or maybe its a prediction of things to come for Archuleta. However, He did have the better overall night.

I love David Cook, but he has to understand that viewers love the idea of a rocker singing a slow, reworked pop song, or showtunes, or roberta flack, something out of his element and surprising. When he is a rocker singing rock songs, he is less well recieved. But i think his overall consistancy will carry him through, and if it doesn't, maybe he won't have to release that godawful songwriter's thing as his first official single, and be branded as the American Idol all his life.

Mig Tue, May 20, 2008 at 11:44 PM EST

i think david should win. American idol is not about being the best from the start.. it is about a progression into being the best. Look at David Cook's audition.. not much has changed. Although he is very talented, he is a bit too professional and it takes away from the meaning of the show. david archuleta is NOT being overpraised.. he deserve all that he gets. The judges are experienced in thier ART, so i think that they know what to say.. cuz simon and randy have been in the business for a long time. and i am sure they know what they are talking about :D

Michael Tue, May 20, 2008 at 11:30 PM EST

David A might have been a bit overpraised by the judges at times, especially on nights when he flubbed his lyrics, but something needed to be done to counter the unreasonable and somewhat cruel attacks on him by viewers. Yes, he seems one-note in his choices(ballads) and yes, that oh-gosh-golly-gee grated on my nerves. BUT...he has an incredible voice and is young and can be molded into a superstar. All that talent at that age deserves the praise.

Jason Castro was ABSOLUTELY the most overpraised of the contestants. Yes, hallelujah was lovely for a little while, but Jason does not have a good falsetto and the final note of that song undid, for me, all the good that was done in 99% of the rest of the song. APPALLING falsetto. The dodobird act got tiring and the absolute and CONSCIOUS/DELIBERATE cave-in towards the end of the show was selfish. Carly and Michael would have given anything for a longer stay but it was instead wasted on that freakshow.

To KG Tue, May 20, 2008 at 11:27 PM EST

Some of us are Kittens!!!!!!

ref: Bella Tue, May 20, 2008 at 11:27 PM EST

That's the problem with Michael, good at everthing = very good at nothing!
Jason is very good for the fans that like what he does, that's the only difference between failure and success.

bella Tue, May 20, 2008 at 11:22 PM EST

Most over-rated: Cook and Castro!
Cook because the judges duped the audience into believing he was "original" when in reality he was clever at using other artists versions of songs and getting all the credit for it, the last 4 weeks showed his limitations when he wasn't able to use covers of covers, at best he is average in voice and performance. Castro should never have made the final 4, the entire season he basically song the same song over and over, no versatility and no range, a one trick pony.
Most likely to succeed: Michael Johns
I have to agree, showed the most versatility of all the contestants, he can sing any style, rock, blues, soul and ballads, appeals to men and women, and has that x factor, interesting that he is the celebs favorite as well, I think they recognize one of their own. Tonights final showed just how mediocre Cook is, he was given the best song of the night, U2's SHFWILF, and should have knocked it out of the park, but was only average, says it all!

KG Tue, May 20, 2008 at 11:10 PM EST

Oh, and I never said Castro wouldn't be popular or his music won't sell. (His fanbase, obviously, would guarantee otherwise.) I just don't think he has a distinct sound--good or bad. You said so yourself, there's Jack Johnson, Carey Brothers et al. (Folk artists who while popular, aren't the best in that genre, either, IMO.) It's really all a matter of preference. [bloodied, extricates himself from a pack of clawing cougars]

KG Tue, May 20, 2008 at 11:02 PM EST

"Michael Johns wore an ascot (?!)I will never forgive that!That alone speaks volumes!" And THIS speaks volumes of music taste, does it? But if it must be raised, most of the contestants simply conceded to the whims of the AI stylist (as Johns did). Others, like Cook who likes stuffing his jeans' backpocket with an annoying scarf wtf, dress as they do deliberately. But even if his mom made him do that, I still won't be buying his alt rock lite. Or feel safe among his fans, for that matter. Respectfully.

To KG Tue, May 20, 2008 at 11:02 PM EST

Michael Slezak has it right. He understands music. Jason has a pure voice that is so refreshing. It's that Jack Johnson, Cary Brothers sound that seems to transport one to another place. You either get him or you don't. Go to itunes & listen to Jason's studio version of some of his songs (before midnight wed.) then get back to this forum & tell us what you think. I'm predicting musically this type of genre is going to be what's HOT!

summergirl896 Tue, May 20, 2008 at 10:43 PM EST

Michael Johns wore an ascot (?!)
I will never forgive that!
That alone speaks volumes!

slivermoon22 Tue, May 20, 2008 at 10:38 PM EST

I am still in shock that David A is still standing. He's a good singer. NOT a great singer. I see right through it. It's a Fox Political thing, and has to do with David A being mormon, to counteract FLDS and help Romney at the time he needs it most....THE NEW OSMOND.

HOW PREDICTABLE.

David Cook will go on to be a huge star. Let me know when his first CD hits.

Judes Tue, May 20, 2008 at 10:38 PM EST

To all those who are bringing out the old arguments abouts Michael Johns voice being Karaoke & wannabe - you are just regurgitating what Simon was saying. Please think for yourselves! If you had listened to any earlier albums of his you would never say his voice is no good, they are brilliant!
To those that think he is too old at 29 - think again. In Australian Idol - the 1st seasons runner up was 28- Shannon Noll. Now 5 years later he is the most succesful, highest selling Idol Australia has had. He's very similar to MJ - Rock & ballads . Shannon has also had to overcome the knockers but he's had the last laugh!!
I also think David Archuletta is the most overated. Nice voice but very boring!