• More
Back to PopWatch Home
EW Home

Live-blogging the Oscar telecast

Mar 5, 2006, 07:37 PM | by Josh Wolk

Categories: Oscars 2006

115216__oscar_l_2Josh Wolk offered his insights live from L.A. on the Oscar telecast:

4:30 p.m. It’s on to ABC, where Billy Bush talks to Reese Witherspoon and Ryan Phillippe, who seems to be doing a Christopher Walken impression. But as long as nobody asks him what he’s wearing, he could be doing Daffy Duck for all I care.

4:44 p.m. Oh, Chris Connelly. You asked Felicity Huffman who made her dress. If she starts talking like Christopher Walken, I won’t tolerate it this time.

4:46 p.m. The Desperate Housewives send taped encouragement, but they do it separately, Teri Hatcher and Nicollette Sherdian first, and then Eva Longoria and Marcia Cross. Felicity starts crying when she sees it, not because of the sentiment, but because she knows that this segregated thank-you will mean her possible Oscar win will be drowned out by deafening gossip about which of her four costars aren’t speaking.

4:47 p.m. Jake Gyllenhaal says he’s a little tired about questions about kissing a guy. His interviewer then rolls her eyes sympathetically… and then asks about his show-biz family, a question he’s been answering long before he made Brokeback Mountain.

4:49 p.m. Cynthia Garrett says that this year’s nominees proves that "America is ready to think." Considering she’s now on ABC, home of Wife Swap, her bosses better hope that’s not the case.

4:56 p.m. Billy talks to Sid Ganis, president of the Academy, who, when asked for his prediction, says it’s going to be "a great show." Is he really the best spokesman for a razzle-dazzle industry?

4:59 p.m. Some final fashion chatter from the ABC bunch; they are breathless over the outfits, as am I… technically -- in that I am letting out a series of deep, aggrieved sighs.

5:01 p.m. Graphic montage mixing great movie characters of the ages, and their computer generation makes it look like "Sims: Movie Nerds."

5:05 p.m. Very funny opening, with old hosts saying can’t do it; plus, Mel Gibson rediscovers his sense of humor, albeit in Mayan.

5:06 p.m. Bonus: Stewart makes it through the whole thing without doing his collar-tugging, "Oooh!" thing.

5:10 p.m. Tonight’s "night of glamour" better than last year’s "night of 1,000 sweatpants." Cut to stone-faced Charlize Theron, who will not have fashion mocked.

5:12 p.m. Charlize Theron has bow on her dress that is the size of a gift-wrapped Jonathan Lipnicki.

5:16 p.m. Stewart introduces Western clips to prove that Westerns have always been gay, and all the footage is pretty suggestive -- caressing guns and whatnot. But the effect is subtle, especially compared to a bit on Conan last week where they interspersed footage of John Wayne and Clint Eastwood that made them look like they were having grunting sex.

5:20 p.m. George Clooney wins for Best Suporting Actor, and, as usual, he is self-depreactaing, charming, and impossible to dislike. Then he hails the Academy as a group he’s proud to be a part of, since they’re ahead of its time in progressiveness. And just like that, Ann Coulter stops swooning.

5:30 p.m. Ben Stiller gives best visual effects to King Kong with a very funny bit with him thinking he’s invisible in a green screen suit. And all I can think of is: Very funny, but as soon as he hands off the Oscar, he’s just a guy wearing a green unitard slinking off the stage.

5:32 p.m.
Orchestral version of "I Walk the Line" played for Reese Witherspoon’s entrance is what Johnny Cash would be hearing if he went to hell.

5:35 p.m. Wallace & Gromit wins for animated feature film, and co-directors accept wearing silly bow ties. This what you think is a good idea when you spend a lot of time alone in a room huffing clay.

5:38 p.m. Dolly Parton sings song from Transamerica, wearing different wig than the one she walked the red carpet in. If she wins, she’ll accept wearing dreadlocks.

5:43 p.m. Nice zinger at the Baldwin brothers! It doesn’t matter how infrequently Stephen Baldwin works, he’ll always be working in the punchline industry.

5:46 p.m. When Martin McDonagh wins for best live action short, the camera cuts to some woman in bleachers crying. Who is she? Who is Martin McDonagh? What is his movie about? Was Steven Baldwin in it?

5:49 p.m. Uh-oh. Animated characters are presenting. For the audience, this must be like watching a precocious 6-year-old do a tap dance at a family party. Not funny or entertaining, but everyone has to be polite.

5:51 p.m. Jennifer Aniston always looks like she’s slightly flinching, as if she's expecting someone to yell: "So what about Brad and Angelina?" from the audience.

5:52 p.m. Memoirs of a Geisha wins for Best Costume Design. Now it can be advertised as an "Oscar-winning movie," and still no one will see it.

5:52 p.m.
And why do costume designers always show up in ugly dresses? Are they daring people to criticize it? "You think this is ugly? Really? Because my Oscar says it’s gorgeous."

5:58 p.m.
Russell Crowe introduces montage of biopics. Notice they don’t let him present, because that Oscar statue makes a hell of a weapon.

6:01 p.m. Chronicles of Narnia wins for best makeup. Star Wars can’t even win in categories that don’t involve crappy writing and directing.

6:03 p.m. Rachel McAdams’ hair is the exact same color as her dress and as the Oscars behind her, and none of it is a color found in nature. Now that is a technical achievement.

6:07 p.m. Rachel Weisz wins for Best Supporting Actress, and the announcer cites her work in The Mummy and The Mummy Returns. And even in her most shining moment, a little bit dies inside of her.

6:12 p.m. Morgan Freeman, rocking an ascot! Did the monocle break on his walk out to the stage?

6:17 p.m. Lauren Bacall has had chemistry with many costars. The TelePrompTer is not one of them.

6:19 p.m.
The film-noir montage reminds us all of many great movies. What it does not remind us of, however, is any reason why they’re doing a film-noir montage.

6:20 p.m. Pimps are "an agent with a better hat." Oh, how everyone laughs -- and then still hands over their 10 percent. Who’s the joke on now?

6:23 p.m. Loved the Best Actress campaign-ad bit. Jon Stewart is doing a great job at using Daily Show political humor without being overtly political. And anything that pre-empts Bill O’Reilly from complaining is okay with me.

6:25 p.m. March of the Penguins wins best documentary, and the producers come onstage with stuffed penguins. Thank goodness a Holocaust documentary didn’t win this year, because nobody wants to see a 4-foot-tall stuffed Hitler.

6:27 p.m. For the performance of the nominated song from Crash, extras walk behind singer Bird York in front of burning cars. Better that than shouting racial epithets.

6:34 p.m. Wow, Sandra Bullock’s makeup job is not all that different from Will Ferrell’s.

6:36 p.m. Memoirs of a Geisha wins again, for art direction! Now there are two reasons you think you should see it -- but you still won’t.

6:39 p.m. People must have been warned about droning speeches, because no one’s been thanking agents, lawyer, and publicists, and the audience is the better for it. I’d thank the producers for making this rule, but that would ruin the point.

6:41 p.m. Now we’re getting a montage of political films. But why? I guess the reason for these greatest-hits collections is that tonight is Hollywood’s one night to remind everyone what good, talented, thoughtful people they are, and have been for years. And then on every other night they go back to making things like The Hills Have Eyes and Ultraviolet. Meanwhile, Samuel L. Jackson, the presenter of this montage, is working on... Snakes on a Plane. Where’s that montage?

6:43 p.m. Keira Knightley has been seated next to Jack Nicholson. (I'm just saying...)

6:47 p.m. Yitzhak Perlman solos through Best Score nominees. Will he be coming back out for "It’s Hard Out Here for a Pimp"?

6:52 p.m. Brokeback Mountain wins for Best Score. Which means that all those online parodies that use the song are now Oscar winners, too. Congratulations, Brokeback to the Future!

6:54 p.m. Wow, I think I just saw Jake Gyllenhaal’s heart stop in the middle of his awful patter.

7:00 p.m. This whole evening is anti-DVD propaganda. Ironically, they are proving this by showing old movies that are only available on DVD.

7:04 p.m. Jon Stewart started the evening making jokes about Hollywood, but all with respect. But now, in hour 2, he seems to be losing his patience. Like with that joke about the montages. By the end of the evening, he’ll be calling Steven Spielberg a hack.

7:06 p.m. Meryl Streep seems to have antennae sticking out of the back of her dress. Who is controlling Meryl Streep?

7:12 p.m. The montage introducing Robert Altman’s honorary Oscar is a testament to how vital his work has continued to be -- unlike last year, when Sidney Lumet’s reel began with Dog Day Afternoon and Serpico, and ended with Gloria, Guilty as Sin, and his new movie with Vin Diesel in a bad wig.

7:20 p.m. M. Night Shyamalan’s American Express ad airs, and it is a very successful ad for M. Night Shyamalan.

7:23 p.m. During "It’s Hard out Here for a Pimp," the singers are surrounded by dancing whores and pimps. Randy Newman nearly went this way for the Toy Story song, but cooler heads prevailed.

7:24 p.m. The singer has substituted "witches" for "bitches." As if that'll help. There was a group of people who protested the Harry Potter books because they didn’t like their kids learning about the occult. It just goes to show that you can never childproof the world enough.

7:26 p.m. Holy frappe! "It’s Hard Out Here for a Pimp" won! That is ducking unbelievable! I just about twit my pants.

7:27 p.m. When Jon Stewart made the joke that "it just got a little bit easier out here for a pimp," show director Louis Horvitz cut to Jamie Foxx. Didn’t we just see a montage praising Hollywood for being progressive?

7:29 p.m. Jennifer Garner is nearly topless. Jennifer Garner is also clearly breastfeeding her new baby. These observations are not related, but I’m just keeping you all up to date on Jennifer Garner.

7:30 p.m. There’s something ironic in the fact that the winning King Kong sound editor could barely get a word out.

7:34 p.m. Applause-o-Meter time: Who’s this year’s favorite dead celebrity?

7:35 p.m. Pat Morita takes an early lead… but here comes Vincent Schiavelli! Who didn’t love Fast Times at Ridgemont High? Oh, Sandra Dee! They should have shown John Fiedler on The Bob Newhart Show; he would have gotten more applause. Schiavellis’s still ahead. Chris Penn! Applause, but they were showing a thinner Chris Penn. A heavier Chris Penn might have been more recognizable.

7:36 p.m. Brock Peters making a good showing… and Shelley Winters takes the lead! But wait, down goes Winters for Anne Bancroft! Good show by Eddie Albert, but he’s no Bancroft. And not even Richard Pryor can beat Anne Bancroft! It’s Anne Bancroft!

7:37 p.m. But the biggest tragedy? Where was Don Knotts?

7:42 p.m. Tsotsi wins for Best Foreign Film! And the producer is sitting in the last row! So begins his long trek to the stage. But he makes the most of his 38 seconds, demanding that the camera show his actors. I’m sure in the control room they were saying, "Actors? That movie has actors? If it ain’t out of Hollywood, I just assume it’s a film strip."

7:44 p.m. Crash wins for Best Editing, and the winner accidentally walks away from the microphone. But it’s okay, they can just edit that out. (Ba dum-bum.)

7:51 p.m. Philip Seymour Hoffman wins Best Actor, but he does not bark like a dog as he told David Letterman he would have to if he ever won an Oscar, as part of a bet he made with childhood friends. Instead, he pays a touching tribute to his mother. Tribute, schmibute -- he's a friggin' welcher!

7:55 p.m. John Travolta appears to be wearing his favorite hair helmet.

7:57 p.m. Memoirs of a Geisha wins for best cinemotraphy. Wow, this really must have been the most gorgeous dull movie ever -- like a rambling history professor wearing a really pretty hat.

8:05 p.m. When Reese Witherspoon thanks her parents, the cameras start to zoom in on her husband, Ryan Philippe, assuming she’s going to thank him… but she doesn’t. She does finally give him lip service, but not as passionately as she did her parents. Mabye if he’d jumped out of his chair like he did at the Golden Globes, he’d have earned some bigger props.

8:12 p.m. The writers of Brokeback Mountain script wins again, and Diana Ossana looks like she’s been summoned to jury duty. Larry McMurtry, on the other hand, looks lke he’s just been summoned from a deep sleep. I can’t wait to see the fashion gurus take him to task for not getting dressed up, and I can’t wait for him not to give them the satisfaction of caring.

8:14 p.m. Torch up the cars again! Crash wins for best original screenplay.

8:19 p.m. Haggis’ cowriter, Bobby Moresco, steps up to the mike just as the music starts, and it’s sad to watch him still try to talk as the orchestra drowns him out… and then continue as even the spotlight dims. Someone oughta make a movie about how some people will keep trying to talk to an audience that can’t hear them… just to try to connect.

8:21 p.m. Ang Lee wins, and makes a "quit you" joke. Shouldn’t he have been the first guy to get sick of that joke?

8:23 p.m. Jack Nicholson: making the Academy Awards all about him since 1985.

8:27 p.m. Wow! Just as I was bemoaning the lack of surprises in this ceremony, Crash wins. Not that everyone wasn’t talking about this being a dark horse, but still, it looked like nothing would stop the Brokeback train. It’s exciting, but mostly because it wasn’t obvious. Now if Jon Stewart would come out at the end and tell everyone that he wouldn’t do this again if they asked him, that would end the evening on a doubly surprising note.

8:28 p.m. Uh-oh -- Paul Haggis’ producing partner Cathy Schulman is thanking financiers. We were so close to an evening without moneymen being thanked. I guess in the end, Oscar night wasn’t so surprising after all.

1 2 3 4 5 Next »

SEAN Wed, Feb 11, 2009 at 07:58 AM EST

Josh Wolk'S WIFE DIED OF AIDS .

NOBODY CARES FOR HIM ., OR HIS MISTRESS .

G Wed, Feb 11, 2009 at 07:57 AM EST

YOU STINK

acpgs pgut Tue, Nov 18, 2008 at 09:44 PM EST

zihan hiswfcoq vrsxdlzwo fshlvnqu kqpjzuls tnjlehc infrcxq

acpgs pgut Tue, Nov 18, 2008 at 09:44 PM EST

zihan hiswfcoq vrsxdlzwo fshlvnqu kqpjzuls tnjlehc infrcxq

jhpdxc shjwzl Mon, Nov 17, 2008 at 01:08 AM EST

qjfocbwe mkqa afrz rndfhx qyemfgoc uqrgzyb nrlhweg http://www.ximeb.qkcvzsh.com

qbuxoiy zbqnre Mon, Nov 17, 2008 at 01:08 AM EST

movtb pwsfbrxma vsdrhclq csyui dphaw nfwvyhre jsqctvf

Holly Tue, Mar 7, 2006 at 09:27 AM EST

My thoughts after reading the comments:
1) It's funny how many LOTR dorks there are on this site...
2) Forrest Gump is one of the best movies ever, and
3) Reese is a doll, I love her.

Kim Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 09:32 PM EST

Thus spake Corran:

"To me, personally, Crash is the more important film."

But...the Oscars don't give out awards for for "most important" film. They do for BEST film.

In terms of "importance" -- BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN makes statements about love, self-denial, caving in to societal pressure, and the tragedy that can come of people not being true to themselves.

CRASH was a fine film, don't get me wrong, but its central message can be summed up with the phrase "everyone's a little bit racist." Which...well, is nothing I didn't already know. I saw both films; CRASH didn't tell me anything I didn't already know. BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN did.

But, as I said, it's not about "importance," it's about best -- in terms of art as well.

Personally, I thought the Academy was going to give the nod to MUNICH, anyway. I didn't think CRASH was up to it, and I had a hunch they were going to shy away from BBM. I've also found that the Academy never gives it to my own personal favorite anyway (last year it was SIDEWAYS that was my favorite; and I knew it didn't have a chance in hell).

ca Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 06:19 PM EST

Anytime, James, anytime. And for the record, I also think Felicity deserved to win. Oh, and I think you should know that I'm typing this as I ride around on my tractor, in my overalls, with both of my teeth. :)

Katnip Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 06:17 PM EST

LOL, Roxie. Not just joyful bed-hopping but joyful bed-hopping in slo-mo. Accompanied by weird, echo-y "Ho-Ho-Ho" laughing. And Gandalf giggling non-stop at the foot of the bed.

Still, I'm a big fan of the whole trilogy.

map Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 06:00 PM EST

I agree with a few other posters. Crash will ultimately become a sidenote in history much like Chicago and A Beautiful Mind have; good movies that beat better movies for Best Picture.

roxie Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 05:11 PM EST

Eloquently said, Katnip. I agree, ROTK, did go on too long, esp that final farewell scene with all of the joyful bed-hopping. But the sheer grandeur of those films needed to be acknowledged by the Oscars and they did blow it a couple years earlier. I'm scaring myself with my own geekiness here so I'll simply sign off ... :-)

James Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 04:17 PM EST

LOL. I was not stereotyping Tennessee in my post. I was merely saying that she is originally from Tennessee which makes her a southern girl; and since southern culture is the root of country music, this makes it easier for her to play a country music singer. She even enthusiastically said it "fullfilled her life-long dream to be a country western singer" no matter how much she might not have actually meant it she is still lightyears closer to June Carter than Huffman is to a transexual. I made no mention of intellectual superiority over Tennessee, but you seem to have done so and now I am beginning to question it. Thanks ca!

Stephanie Travitsky Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 04:08 PM EST

America,

Your response is EXACTLY why Crash won so get a life. I thought Hard out there for a Pimp was an awful son, and In the Deep was depressing. Best song should have gone to The Corpse bride for The Corpse Bride.

ca Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 03:55 PM EST

An insightful comment from James about Reese W's home state. Because everyone knows stereotyping indicates superior intellect. If only we could all be from LA & New York, like intellectual giant and arbiter of good taste Paris Hilton. Maybe one day...

HP in Buffalo Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 03:51 PM EST

John Stewart, usually witty and self-assured, was out of synch. Not funny. The opening was a cute touch, but the Oscars need to get brevity - now!

djm Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 03:44 PM EST

I am a gay man living in LA and while Brokback wasn't my favorite film of the year I think it was WAY better than Crash. Crash has about as much to do with living in LA as Paris Hilton has to brain surgery - in other words, nothing. It was preachy and unrealistic (although the performances were great). The ONLY thing about Crash that stayed with me for days was how annoying it was. Teh Oscar telecast was kind of boring - no real surprises (including Crash winning Best Picture - you could see that coming 5 miles away) and it just kind of plugged along. I really HATED the music playing behind the speeches, I liked Jon Stewart as host, and thought Uma looked absolutely amazing. Also, while I liked Hustle & Flow, I can't believe for even half a second that the song was the best from all of the movies of the past year. Eminem's "Lose Yourself" - sure, but "Hard Out There For a Pimp"? Not even. I would have given it to Dolly.

Paul U. Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 03:41 PM EST

gosh...calm down, i can't believe someone has used the n-word on popwatch...what year is this again? we obviously still need films like Crash...sad.

Mike Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 03:12 PM EST

I love movies. I love the Oscars - no matter how long and I loved both Crash and BBM. I was a little disappointed that BBM didn't win Best Picture but Crash was a deserving winner. Both will go downa s classics and I think this year was good for movies! Lighten up everyone!

Victoria Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:57 PM EST

hmm, so they show a montage of the great epic movies. and the only part from ANY of the Lord of the Rings movies was the statue head from the Fellowship of the Ring. RIGHT. way to go Academy, snubbing quite possibly one of the greatest achievements in cinema history

(although they did use the LotR score and showed Star Wars, which is up there w/ LotR as well, although it is more significant in pop culture than cinema culture)

oh, and Peter Jackson was one of the biggest snubs of the night. to be able to actually make a grown redneck sitting behind me scream and squirm during the insect scene in King Kong deserves an Oscar in itself, not to mention he truly outdid himself, proving the Lord of the Rings films were not flukes. along with Steven Spielberg, he deserves to be recognized as one of the greatest filmakers.

JT Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:56 PM EST

As Tom Hanks walked onstage to present Best Pic., he looked pissed and mouthed "d-----bag" followed by "f---ing p----" as they cut to another camera. We watched it over & over on Tivo and I'm surprised more people aren't talking about it. Jon didn't set him up with anything to piss him off....Maybe someone backstage? Weird.

James Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:53 PM EST

I just have to say that Reese Witherspoon is the most maudlin, self-serving fool in Hollywood. That speech was sickeningly self-important. It is so obvious when she switches into "PR ME" mode. Least impressive performance, I thought. Felicity Huffman? Wasn't her role harder to pull off? She's clearly not a transexual. And Reese? She's clearly from Tennessee.

Jen Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:50 PM EST

My theory for who Crash beat brokeback:

Think about the 200 personal friends who likely voted for Don Cheadle, another 200 for Sandra Bullock, plus friends of Terence, Matt, Ludicris, Ryan, Tandie and rest of the huge Crash cast plus the LA-BASED crew plus the rolodex of Paul Haggis's. Add that all up. Then imagine the 80 plus personal friends give or take of Ang Lee's and Heath and Michelle's in hollywood, plus their canadian crew.

I can imagine more academy members voting for a movie set in LA, hired LA film crew and featuring many of the actors they have known for years, over a movie shot in canada featuring a couple promising yet young actors who have already been bathed in more spotlights than any other hollywood veteran could only envy.

Katnip Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:16 PM EST

Oops mean "oops". Oy, my keypad buttons suck.

Katnip Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:14 PM EST

Oop, meant "fearsome".

Katnip Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:13 PM EST

Hey Roxie,

Not smoking catnip. I am a huge fan of the Lord of the Rings, but I think the first one is what deserved that Best Picture Oscar. Return of the King was great, but needed SERIOUS editing. Like the fairly disjointed multiple ending (I know he was trying to be faithful to the book - but still it was a bit much).

Mystic River was lyrical, seamless, tense and had some of the best acting performances that year. The ending was amazing, with Sean Penn and his family bathed in light, taking their fearesome place high above the block parade, while Marcia Gay Harden was running in the shadows, sealed behind the backs of her neighbors, trying to catch the attention of her dejected son, whose father she had betrayed. Amazing. Go watch it again.

roxie Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:50 PM EST


Katnip, are you smoking catnip?! Mystic River over Return of the King?! I'll take happy hobbits over grouchy Sean Penn any day.

Miles Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:49 PM EST

Love will be "the strongest" when it is denied "

So "BBM will be become strongest when it got denied also.."
It won every awards beat Crash all the way [accept for SAG awards]
but BBM end up just like its own story ....." Got denied because of it's forbidden love"


" So now.....it's Crying quitely ,...painfully .....unspoken....alone... in the closet...."
My friend who didn't get this movie ,will never will.....
but for whoever ...touced by this movie ,will understand it........

WHOEVER WROTE THIS IS LARGELY IN NEED OF A LIFE!

pgt Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:46 PM EST

NO MORE MUSIC UNDERNEATH THE SPEECHES. Sorry for the upper-case, but that is how distracting it was to performers & audience alike. It is what sapped the emotion out of the speeches, and so the show. The emotion is also found in the quiet pauses in a specch, which this year was filled with music. An Oscar acception speech isn't a movie that needs a soundtrack; need to keep it real, people! Think maybe some winners, after years of watching the Oscars, are used to hearing the music meaning "it's time to get off", and so affected their speech. Hope they don't do that next year

Katnip Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:34 PM EST

Evidence of the Academy's taste:

1. Million Dollar Baby over Sideways

2. Return of the King over Mystic River

3. A Beautiful Mind over Fellowship of the Ring (best of the trilogy)

4. Chicago over the Pianist

5. Forrest Gump over BOTH Pulp Fiction and the Shawshank Redemption. (being one of 10 people who originally saw Shawshank in the theater, I nearly threw my Coke at my TV when they announced Gump. Thanks to DVDs Academy(!), people have come to their senses).

6. And the most outrageous: Gwyneth Paltrow beat Cate Blanchett's Elizabeth.

Mark My Words: The New World should have been nominated and won Best Picture.

Laura Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:29 PM EST

Loved John Stewart last night. I'm glad Crash won (only movie out of the nominated films that I saw) though I'm disappointed Keira Knightly did not get Best Actress. I knew it was unlikely to happen but, there's always hope. I also would have preffered a win for Geisha or Pride and Prejudice for Original Score.

CIP Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:23 PM EST

I'm a gay guy that didn't love BBM. As someone posted earlier they made a short story into an overly long movie. It was well made but far from perfect. "Crash", imperfect as it is, will stay in my mind as one of the few movies that really moved me and made me think.

Jessica Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:16 PM EST

Did anyone catch what Tom Hanks mouthed to Jon Stewart as he came on? He seemed angry and it drove my friends and I nuts for the rest of the night trying to figure it out!

Rahul Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:16 PM EST

Forget all this talk about 'Brokeback' being snubbed because of its subject matter. All this b.s. and hype will be forgotten in a week or two. What matters is film as an art. Go watch 'Crash' again and admire the skill it takes to put together a film with multiple story lines and great ensemble acting. Politicizing is not what movies are ultimately about. The Academy recognized that. If you want to complain about good films not being rewarded, go bother Harvey Weinstein for robbing 'Saving Private Ryan'.

tanet Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:16 PM EST

" Love will be "the strongest" when it is denied "

So "BBM will be become strongest when it got denied also.."
It won every awards beat Crash all the way [accept for SAG awards]
but BBM end up just like its own story ....." Got denied because of it's forbidden love"


" So now.....it's Crying quitely ,...painfully .....unspoken....alone... in the closet...."
My friend who didn't get this movie ,will never will.....
but for whoever ...touced by this movie ,will understand it........

BoxOfficeGoddess Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:08 PM EST

To me, the Best Picture Oscar should go to a film that is well crafted and leaves a mark on our collective film experience, a film that holds up 50 years from now. True, sometimes it's not the best film of the year (example: "Forrest Gump" beating "Pulp Fiction"--"Pulp Fiction" was a better movie, but "Forrest Gump" left an imprint on our collective movie conscious.)

Last night, I felt the only film in the Best Picture race that had that quality was "BBM." Everything about that film--the cinematography (should have won), the acting, the costumes, the setting--it all came together. Can anyone quote a line from "Crash" the way, "I wish I knew how to quit you" has become part of our lexicon? Is any image from "Crash" seared into your mind the way those mountains, sky, sheep and tent are from "BBM"? Yes, "Crash" was about racism, an important issue--but so was "Do the Right Thing" and "Gentleman's Agreement" and both films are far superior to the histronics and staged racial tensions in "Crash." Twenty years from now, this will be another one of those "What the heck were they thinking?" moments.

Robert Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:03 PM EST

First off....I thought the show was good fun! I enjoyed every moment...Although I have to admit I thought it would lack the "surprise" element, up until the end. Crash?? For Best Picture? The Academy had indeed chickened out! In the beginning of the show after accepting his statuette for Best Supporting Actor, George Clooner pointed out that he was proud to be a part of Hollywood and added to the The Academy's history because they never were afraid to break new ground and many times awarded films who pushed the envelope and tackled issues like AIDs and racism... So then why couldn't the Academy honor "Brokeback Mountain"?? A film which has portrayed love in a form never portrayed so beautifully on film before. "Brokeback" was provacative, fantastically written, acted and emotionally connected with millions... Although "Crash" was a good film, it was lacking the ability to start a movement... It could have been "Brokeback" breaking ground, it could have been the beginning of an influential era. I guess as a country, we've got a long way to go... It's just funny, how the Best Original Song can promote "Pimps", yet "Gay" is still somewhat taboo... Funny...

Matt Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:58 PM EST

If Brokeback Mountain hadn't been the most overrated movie in history and actually been good, maybe it would have won. This has nothing to do with homophobia. Capote should have won from the 5 nominated movies, but I know of 20+ movies I liked better than Capote last year. Just because a movie's serious, it doesn't make it superior.

E R Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:39 PM EST

There's no other way to read what happened last night than to admit that Hollywood is rife with closet homophobia. "Crash" didn't win on its own merits: it won beacuse it was a safe, "liberbal" choice for people who were not comfortable with "Brokeback." If "Brokeback" had been about AIDS, or in some way communicated a safer message than its simple, urgent plea that we understand that love between two men is the same as any kind of love, and MUST be respected as such, people would've voted for it. Hollywood's really proved its irrelevance to the vanguard of American culture once and for all.

Scott Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:04 PM EST

I think BBM's bigger snub was not for Best Picture (Crash was just as great a movie and it was a tight race), but, for Health Leger for Best Actor. I knew Health Leger wouldn't win since Phillip Seymore Hoffman has a larger body of work to award, but, Heath, to me, gave the performance of the year and showed a talent I had never really seen before.

Jon Stewart, as host, got better as the night moved on, maybe as the theatre loosened up. Perhaps because so many of the category winners were such a lock, it seemed like the audience was really bored and uptight. Maybe alcohol really does need to become part of the Oscars (a la the Golden Globes). Charlize seemed particularly put out to be there.

And I think it was incredibly rude that the musicians kept cutting people off during the speeches. Especially those awarded to more than one person in a category. I understand some people ramble on, but one guy from Crash had the lights turned out on him before he could even speak. If they need to save time, cut out those useless montages the Academy used to shamelessly beg people to go back to the movies.

Delilah Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 11:53 AM EST

Thought this was a good Oscar telecast. Loved John Stewart. Even liked the montages.

Wish Heath Ledger would have won, but respect Philip.

Hate Reese. She is so contrived. I think the best acting she does is when she is accepting an award. The look on her husband's face prooves it - even he doesn't believe she's as sweet and innocent as she plays.

Thought the dancers during the songs were hysterical! What would the Oscars be without some tackiness?

Someone tell Jennifer Aniston to comb her hair. She's dressing up - she can wear it styled for once.

r_quale Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 11:44 AM EST

Fact: Brokeback Mountain is the best film of the year. Crash is not.

Fact: Crash producers set up an unprecedented (and expensive) Oscar campaign for the film including sending out DVD's to Academy members and even their family and friends.

Fact: Producers of Brokeback Mountain did NOT campaign anywhere NEAR as heavily as producers of Crash.

Fact: A group of conservative movie stars (i.e. Tony Curtis and his cronies) and other conservative industry folks were holding actual meetings and making phone calls to try and get people NOT to vote for Brokeback Mountain.

Fact: Brokeback Mountain lost the award because Hollywood is a living, breathing corporate machine whose sole purpose is making money and pleasing and appeasing an audience that is, let's face it, not ready to examine issues dealing with homoosexuality.

Fact: America has become Jesusland. The American movie industry reflects the attitudes and social concience of this nation, which has become more conservative, more Republican, and of course, more ignorant.

Solution: Pay not one whit of attention to any award shows like the Oscars in the future.

Gil Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 11:31 AM EST

I know that Cate Blanchett is working on a play in New York, but shouldn't she have been there to present George Clooney with his Best Supporting Actor Oscar? And why no mention of Don Knotts or Jack Wild in the memorial tribute? I realize that they each died in the last week, but couldn't they have been edited into the tribute at the last minute?

jim Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 11:28 AM EST

The clever jokes need to end. The cute parodies need to go away. The Brokeback Mountain backlash needs to stop now. The universal praise for this beautiful and important film was watered down when all the jokes started. Maybe it was straight people's way of dealing with an "uncomfortable" situation or homphobia coming through. Either way, it needs to stop. I am going to see Brokeback tonight and Letterman, Leno and Kimmel can start the Crash backlash. I'll bet that won't last long.

Brendisch Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 11:26 AM EST

This award wasn't some kind of showdown between racism and homophobia--which is the "more important" form of bigotry. It was a decision between MOVIES--which was better crafted, better acted, told a more engaging story, had more compelling characters, etc.

On that level BBM wins hands down. It has nothing to do with the relative merit of whatever political issue people are reading into the films.

brandonk Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 11:18 AM EST

I'm surprised that Jon Stewart is getting mixed reviews. I thought he was hilarious, and definitely funnier than Chris Rock. Someone mentioned Conan O'Brien's name as host, which would be good, but Stewart should definitely be back. Maybe they can switch off.

Theo Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 11:15 AM EST

I must be very honest; I'm glad that CRASH beat BROKEBACK.

The one common thread about many of the comments made among these threads is the fact that CRASH is about much more than racism in Los Angeles. It is a very interesting study of character, one factor that many of the critics and many of the people who have trashed-talked the film seem to ignore. These characters are not flat; if anything, this movie speaks of the nature of prejudice, which is a prevailing problem in this country. Just because you claim that you are tolerant does not mean that you are; just because society "looks down upon" overtly racist remarks doesn't erase the deep-seated fears and prejudices that exist within people; and just because people are openly prejudiced doesn't mean that they are incapable of showing compassion and are void of finding redemption.

If anything, BBM was the obvious movie. Yes, homophobia is a big problem; but the characters are extremely flat; the movie is well-written, but I still went away from the film feeling that the story on the screen failed to have the emotional impact of the richly wonderful and nuanced short story by Proulx. Its praise by critics was its key to success, primarily the fact that faux-homophobic people can convince themselves they possess a shred of tolerance by going out to see this film.

Oscar needs a little controversy. The fact that CRASH received such a visceral response from the people of this post just proves how relevant and important this movie really is, and why we need more films like it.

TorontoTom Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 11:08 AM EST

When a film wins EVERY award around (Producers Guild, Directors Guild, Writers guild, British Academy Awards, Golden Globe, Independent Spirit Award and N.Y. & L.A. Critics) you cannot deny it the Oscar. It beat out Crash at each of the above (actually, Crash wasn't even nominated for some of them)
This is simply a case of backlash. Don't tell the Academy have to like "the gay movie" - they live in George W.'s America and are obviously proud of it!!!

dma69 Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 10:50 AM EST

I thought Jon Stewart did a great job. The problem was that the audience didn't get his humor. Apparently not everyone in Hollywood watches "The Daily Show". The fake campaigns were a riot.

Yeah, what's with the music playing during the acceptance speeches? That was very distracting.

Enough with the montages!! There were too many of them.

Nothing against Bird York, but I simply found the Crash song boring. Even a burning car in the background couldn't keep me interested.

Jan Erik Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 10:40 AM EST

I think 'Crash' is a movie that is mainly of interest to people from the U.S. Here in Europe 'Crash' is mainly seen as a quite good but not very subtle attack on racism, while all the other nominees for best picture have been praised more, be it 'Capote' for the great acting, 'Brokeback mountain' for being a well made, well acted classically told love-story, 'Good Night and Good Luck' for being well made and not being afraid of being political and 'Münich' for being a tight, relatively evenhanded thriller about a difficulkt subject. Not having seen any of the movies (I live in the north of Norway), but having followed the reviews of writers that I generally agree with, and watched clips from the movies, I kinda think 'Brokeback' is a little bit over-rated due to the gay-thing, but that the four films that didn't win generally were of higher quality than the one who did. I kind of saw the 'Crash' win coming as the show went on, especially when it won editing and 'Brokeback' didn't win cinematography. The awards in general seemed to be given out to the right people, but I think that if 'Münich' had won it would have been a more deserving surprise winner, 'Crash' will probably be forgotten quite quickly, and 'Münich' could need the attention box-office-wise.

Howard Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 10:28 AM EST

Three comments:

As montages go, the film noir one was decent, but including "Grease" in the epics montage and "Something's Gotta Give" in the issues set is stretching things more than a little bit. You want to cut time? Relevance when selecting film clips - then Jon Stewart won't have to claim they ran out.

Shoulda left the dancers out of the musical numbers for Crash and Hustle & Flow - in the former, they were distracting from a haunting performance by Kathleen York (who knew, from her appearances on the West Wing that she had that kinda talent?), and the latter would have been ten times better if you put them in front instead of behind the dance troupe.

As far as BBM vs. Crash - Aside from McMurtry's urban vs. rural theory (which isn't that far-fetched), the reason for it might be that there are some people who -- wait for it -- DIDN'T LIKE BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN!! I didn't see it, but the two women I was watching the end of the broadcast with were both extremely underwhelmed and thought that aside from "looking great", it wasn't that great a movie. They both cheered like crazy when Crash won.

Danielle Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 10:18 AM EST

We had this conversation last night and YES!!!!! YES!!!! YES!!!! Jack opened the envelope. there were Tivo's involved, so we know he did.

khansolo Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 10:17 AM EST

Actually, the presenters usually read off the teleprompter when announcing the nominees. They only open the envelopes AFTER they do the recap.

tb Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 10:10 AM EST

I saw Crash and Brokeback. Quite honestly, I thought the only thing Brokeback would win would be cinematography. No, I'm not homophobic; I just didn't think it was anything special. If it had been two gay actors playing those roles instead of straight actors being "risky", no one would have given the movie a moment's though.

On the other hand, Crash was the best movie I saw this year - hands down. I don't think the Academy wussed out; I think they just chose the better film.

Miles Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 10:06 AM EST

wow, conspiracy theory about the envelope. The envelope was clearly opened, many presenters open the envelope while they're recapping the nominees... Get over it. CRASH WON.

khansolo Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 09:56 AM EST

Did anyone else notice how Jack Nicholson never opened the envelope? Maybe he thought it would be funny to blurt out "Crash" as the winner. And I also thought it was weird how they cut to a shot of Jack appearing to shake his hands "no" to the orchestra. I hope someone can back me up on this because it's killing me that no one is talking about it. I fear this has been another year of Marisa Tomei.

jason Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 09:43 AM EST

I have to be honest and say that I have not seen Crash. I was rooting for BBM because I thought that if it won, it would be a real statement about the country's shift toward tolerance and understanding of homosexuality. The problem I have with those posting about the relevance or importance of racism vs. that of homophobia is that in our country today, expressing racist sentiment is generally looked down upon, whereas expressing homophobic views is still widely accepted. Can you imagine the outcry if states in our country tried, today, to ban interracial marriage? This was seen as an abomination by many not more than 20 years ago. And yet, we don't have the hindsight or foresight to realize that the same type of prejudices are still in existance today. There is just a different target. I am more disapointed at the state of our society than I am about any awards show.

jason Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 09:36 AM EST

where to begin? all actor races were predictable. everyone that was predicted to win, won. snooze. so "crash" won best picture. get over it. if you think brokeback was better, then it was better, you don't need an academy to tell you what's good. jon stewart, maybe a 6.5 out of 10. there were ups and downs, i was waiting for political humor, but i knew we wouldn't get much, which i actually praise jon for, i guess. WHAT WAS WITH THE MUSIC PLAYING DURING ENTIRE ACCEPTANCE SPEECHES?!?!?! it was distracting and annoying. don't ever do that again! i chuckled when three six mafia won, how cool was that? not a bad song either, i thought i was at the grammy's (the "crash" song deserved it though). predictable award shows are so boring, no excitement. by the way, within the last 2 weeks everybody was saying "crash" would pull an upset, so no real surprises. i give the whole affair a 4 out of 10. snooze

LHH Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 09:33 AM EST

Was "Crash" the best picture of the year? No, probably not, and it shows exactly why there should be an award for Best Ensemble, because that's the only thing in which "Crash" excelled above all the others - no matter how contrived the plot or overwritten the dialogue, the cast was never anything short of superb, and they are the only reason that this picture got any viewing and any subsequent awards. "Brokeback" deserved the big award because it had an overall excellence, rather than one big strong point covering for a whole lot of weaknesses. Plus, I also have a feeling that Ang Lee went home and cried, so that also makes me kind of bummed.

Miles Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 08:52 AM EST

As a gay latino. I think I won more than once last night. I loved both Crash and Brokeback Mountain. I was more impressed with Crash as a story and as a film achievement. Let's face it, the only twist to the Doomed Romance of Brokeback Mountain was that the cowboys were male and hot for each other. I thought the movie itself could lose 20 minutes. It was too long and cumbersome for such a small story. And Crash was a small story that felt epic. At the end I called it, CRASH was the BEST MOVIE of 2005, I thought that when I first saw it and I still think it today.

Tina Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 08:48 AM EST

Corran, go to sleep already!
I can't believe you've been posting in defense of Crash all night long...and through the morning. Something's wrong here, babe!

Nancy Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 07:44 AM EST

I can't believe how ridiculous some people are being about this issue. Someone asked when did the Oscars become so political. When have they not been political? Anyone remember a few years ago when Shakespeare In Love beat out Saving Private Ryan for Best Picture? Miramax was lambasted for all the campaigning they did that year. I'm sure there are plenty of other examples. I wasn''t surprised that Oscar went the way it id. Besides, Crash is not a bad picture. It was well written, had some great performances by its ensemble castand talked about an issue that most Americans think they've dealt with but haven't (look at the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina).So BBM didn't win Best Picture. I thought it was supposed to be an honour just to be nominated. It did win Best Director for Ang Lee and I think that's fantastic. Plus, if you really want to talk about gettting robbed, look at Ralph Fiennes, who gave an incredible performance in The Constant Gardener. And he wasn't even nominateed!

Sean Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 07:27 AM EST

Seriously, could it be that BROKEBACK lost the big prize because it's ponderous and boring? The movie has been wildly overpraised. A bellwether for changing attitudes in Hollywood? Are you kidding? The fickle press (sorry, EW) is to blame for this one. My timing may be off because I live in Katrina-land, but wasn't it just a few short months ago that CRASH was anointed as the salvation of American film? Now it has spoiled BROKEBACK's coming out party. Or conversely, BROKEBACK, thought to be the jewel in Hollywood's gay crown, suffered from the Academy's inability to accept the truth about homosexuals in our culture. Come on! They gave the Best Actor award to a man playing a homosexual. It's ludicrous to watch the desperate attempts to ascribe some sort of political clout to nothing more than a glammed-up version of the awards show that my local theatre community throws on a yearly basis.

Katy Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 04:03 AM EST

Academy demonstrates irrelevance and homophobia.

With the best picture win for Crash, the Academy has demonstrated its irrelevance to American culture. This country has been crying out for the message conveyed by Brokeback Mountain or Good Night and Good Luck. They chickened out with Crash-a movie that was relevant maybe 20 years ago, and will be forgotten by next year. They missed a special opportunity with a best picture win for Brokeback Mountain. But I suppose that we should not expect anything less from the Academy-who waited how long before you recognized actors like Hally Berry and Denzel Washington? Hypocrites-they should stop claiming to be culturally relevant, when clearly all you are is self congratulatory.

Mike Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 03:38 AM EST

Maybe it's better that Brokeback didn't win. It is the singular movie of the year and the best, but it joins the list of nonwinners in a year that saw an actor from Facts of Life, the star of the Mummy and, although I love her, an actress notable for being blonde took home Oscar. Brokeback is in a class way ahead of the rest of the night. Sometimes you don't need a trophy to know you're the best.

Corran Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 03:32 AM EST

Hmm....too be honest, maybe Brokebacks likability and box office hurt it. Academy voters may have seen it as potentially becoming too mainstream, as it really targeted smaller independent films. Then again, Crash is still the better film. No offense, but those fake moustaches on Jake Gylenhaal's face are pretty awful...

Conner Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 03:30 AM EST

Dang. I really wish it had been Brokeback. I loved that movie. I'm not bitter...I haven't seen Crash so I won't say anything on how good it is. However, I am upset that Brokeback didn't win. Bah. Oh well...as long as it won fair and square there's nothing I can do.

Corran Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:38 AM EST

Ok, here's my picks in order of deserving of the oscar (remember I am pro Crash unlike most of you "BROKEBACK WAS ROBBED" PACK)

1. Crash
2. Munich
3. A History of Violence
4. Brokeback Mountain/Walk the Line
5. King Kong

ShaneXtopher Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:34 AM EST

Some points;

1) For those of you who say CRASH was spread by word-of-mouth alone, and THAT'S why it's so successful... the fact is, this film had one of the costliest Oscar campaigns in history.

2) If ANY film succeeded on word of mouth more than any other this year, it was BBM. The film has been in theatres for three months and is still making money. It has made $80million and has never placed any higher than number 4 on the weekend charts.

3) I honestly feel Crash won't be remembered down the road. This year will be remembered as the year Brokeback got robbed, much like 1985 was the year The Color Purple got robbed.

4) The academy had a real opportunity this year to make up for past mistakes, and prove it is not "out of touch". If anything, this year the academy lost what little credibility it had left. And not just for the BBM shaft, but for being boring, predictable and SAFE in every single category, with the exception of Song.

dom Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:13 AM EST

CNN ... head line

Crash...... is ...." Upset" best picture winner......

Upset indeed.......

Mark Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:07 AM EST

Snow, people are upset because Crash is a lousy movie. BBM didn't deserve to win, either, in my opinion, because it's overrated. Capote and Good Night, and Good Luck are so far and away the better movies out of those five it's not even funny and anyone with any real taste in movies will tell you that. BBM and Crash got the publicity they did because the media wanted them to. If we're talking stricktly moviemaking and story telling neither Crash nor BBM deserved to win.

Corran Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:07 AM EST

I really think most Americans are actually afraid of the content in this film, which is why it creates such division amongst everyone. Lets just look at this on a movie perspective: Editing was fantastic, it had the best script of any movie of the year, the cast had the all around best acting of the year, the cinematography of Los Angeles was fantastic, the Altmanesque interwoven storylines were ingenius and riveting, it had excellent drama, suspense, and tragedy, which are all elements of a great story, and while Brokeback Mountain had love, this had more complicated issues involved, and that is ultimately what attracted voters. You sore losers can be upset because your "mainstream" film BBM didnt win, but I am thankin God right now that a movie that deserved to win after being released in early May that has had so much contraversy, truth, and soul, deserved the top prize of the oscars. Crash, you deserve all the awards, dont listen to the sore losers who are against contraversial movies like Crash.

Barry Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:03 AM EST

Lets face it, Brekoback was i fishing trip and 20 minutes too long....Crach was tighter and deserved the BEst Picture

Mark Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 02:02 AM EST

I'm not shocked, but I'm not happy. Crash is not a very good movie.

Jim Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:58 AM EST

WORST...OSCARS...EVER.F'ING EMBARRASSING TO WATCH AND A COMPLETE BORE. I HATE HOLLYWOOD.

Jane Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:55 AM EST

Any movie nominee winning the best picture is better than Crash...boy, what an insult to the public's intelligence and sensibility!

Corran Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:53 AM EST

I am apalled at how sore of losers everyone is being. Of course Crash got mixed reviews, THAT PROVES THAT CONTRAVERSY OVER RACISM! If critics are so riled up to be uncomfortable to have mixed reviews over a contraversial movies, then that shows Crash as a rare gem. One of you just stated BBM wasnt about homosexuality, just love, so then why are you complaining? Crash was about racism, politics, and social problems we are facing in this world. And Crash did not get spread by marketing, it got spread through word of mouth by how shocking it was. Crash has been the little engine that could and it was the one, not Brokeback Mountain, that shook everyone's inner psyche. Brokeback Mountain was not as contraversial as people saw it as. When it was released, its box office draw and critical priase drew it as mainstream, whereas Crash was so anti-Hollywood, and completely original (original screenplay anyone?) that is completely polarized audiences when they saw it. To me, personally, Crash is the more important film. BBM was mainstream as everyone seemed to love it.

Nicole Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:45 AM EST

One more thing for all of the BBM fans out there - Oprah is going to be vomitous tomorrow. She's doing an "exclusive" post-Oscar show from the Kodak and she's been seriously championing Crash for best picture. I usually look forward to her post-AA show, but I won't be able to handle her smug satisfaction tomorrow. Too bad she will fail to acknowledge that Lion's Gate paid cold, hard cash for that trophy.

Nicole Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:42 AM EST

And just for the record, I thought Jon Stewart was absolutely fantastic - great job!!!!! We were all laughing throughout the show (until the movie that shall not be named stole the top prize that is).

Lesley Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:42 AM EST

Not to disagree with anyone, but I don't think that "Crash" winning had anything to do with racism vs. homophobia. I think it had everything to with a really aggressive marketing campaign. It's "Shakespeare in Love" winning over "Saving Private Ryan." Mediocre movie wins over classic because the studio shelled out tons of money to academy voters. It cheapens the award. Oh, well.

Sue Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:40 AM EST

Academy played the safe card and awarded the movie about racism. Ang Lee's work is not only about homosexuality, it is about the power of love and how the deniability and suppression can destroy people. Passion, desire, longing, guilt are all are very powerful emotions conveyed by this little movie.

Nicole Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:38 AM EST

Brokeback Mountain was robbed - I am actually upset at this loss. I tried to prepare myself given the huge amount of publicity the "Crash" bandwagon has been getting lately, but I didn't actually believe it could win. BBM has become a part of the international psyche - it is a phenomenon of a movie. It has consistently received outstanding reviews. It has won almost every other award for best picture. Crash received mixed reviews, was largely ignored by the public (until Lion's Gate began spending serious bucks on their campaign that is) and is about as subtle as an anvil landing on your head. How is it possible that it beat BBM? I'm stunned and incredibly disappointed. What a load of rubbish.

Robin Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:18 AM EST

Brokeback Mountain was robbed.

End of story.

snow Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 01:06 AM EST

Alright, I correct, it is still NOT ok for the Academy the validity of love between people of the same gender, regardless of how masterfully the film was done. All those other awards, but not best movie? It still is very contradictory.

Corran Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:56 AM EST

People are getting mad at my previous comments, but you are ALL proving my point. Many are saying Crash is a movie not dealing with racism but saying deragatory remarks, many are saying it robbed Brokeback Mountain, and many are saying that Brokeback Mountain is far more contraversial than racism. If that is so, why is everyone getting so upset? The thing about racism nowadays is it still happens day in and day night, it is just kept under subtle wraps and pretended like nothing is going on, when that just is not the case. At least the issue of homosexuality is out and about and people are making an issue of it, but Crash was the more important film because it finally is making an identification that racism still exists and its an inherent part of society and that if we dont stop to think (remember the first message of the movie) we are doomed to forget how are actions and thoughts are adding to this racist evil. So in that sense, I think my opinions hold strong.

Jasmine Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:55 AM EST

Frankly, I'm happy that the awards were split. I liked Brokeback, but it's certainly not my favorite movie of the year, closer to 3 or 4. Crash is my #2, and I'm so happy that it stopped the Brokeback juggernaut. Did Brokeback deserve to win something? Yes, and it did win! It won three major awards people! Is it so hard to accept that people may not think it deserves to take every award under the sun?

Brandon Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:50 AM EST

Of the 5 best picture nominations Crash was the least deserving. The topic it attempted to tackle is a big one and it was very wrong in the way it handled it. The characters were cut-outs, near stereotypes. The Ryan Phillippe character was way beyond the realm of believability. And yet it won. I am so sick of films getting awards because they dealt with an "important" topic. The award is for BEST PICTURE not MOST NOBLE CAUSE and Crash was rife with problems. What a disappointment. I read an earlier post that said that racism is a more important topic than homosexuality. This is completetly missing the point since we are supposed to be discussing achievements in film, but I have to take issue with that statement. Or perhaps I should feel honored that someone would tell me which issue should concern me more. When did these awards become so political? And movies in general? It would be nice to sit through two hours at the multiplex without having someone's agenda shoved down my throat. And with Crash's victory I feel like I've been had again.

Jack Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:44 AM EST

"Crash" winning the best picture is adding insult to injury. Everybody knows Brokeback Mountain deserved to win, but to be upstaged by a sentimentally manipulative melodrama about racism (which by the way, has been many times tastefully done before) is adding salt to the wound. I'd have felt better if a far elegant and progressive movie won, such as Munich or Good Night & Good Luck.

Adriel Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:42 AM EST

CRASH is literally one of the worst films ever to win Best Picture, rivaled only by OLIVER!, CHARIOTS OF FIRE, AN AMERICAN IN PAIRS and OUT OF AFRICA. BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN is a film that broke barriers, cinematically and culturally, and the fact that the Academy passed it over for a B-level, Sesame Street-deep "treatise" on racism is stupefying. 10 years from now, people will be thinking "WTF were they on that year?". Oy.

Fatima Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:38 AM EST

Once again to discredit that theory, Phillip Seymour Hoffman won for playing "Capote"

snow Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:30 AM EST

I still think that the Academy members took the "no queers" Hollywood's homophobic tradition. I guess the Brits (and the independents) still have better taste than us, uh?

jon Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:29 AM EST

Last time I'll chime in I promise... I just think its funny how on Jimmy Kimmel Live they are going to have two unsuspecting men act out the sex scene from 'Brokeback' for a car... At least 'Brokeback' is engaging people to think (even if they are just jokes) about homosexuality... I don't see people joking or talking or examining racism because of 'Crash.' Why? Because it's not very good. Although I liked Terrence Howard, Sandra Bullock and Thandie Newton.

Let's get over the 'BBM' snub and celebrate all the other academys and critics who are secure enough to honor the best film of the year.

Observer Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:28 AM EST

George Clooney needs to get over himself. His remark that Hollywood is the only place where serious issues are taken up is adolescent and boorish.

V.M.L. Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:21 AM EST

Four words: BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN WAS ROBBED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Nancy Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:21 AM EST

Man , I was gonna check out and hit the sack, but Corran, you stopped me cold. Racism is more controversial than homophobia? What a stupid thing to say! I know we all are entitled to our opinions here, but really. How do you quantify one against the other? If someone doesn't get a job, it's not so bad, but if they get beat up in the streets, well, that's serious? And you think only gays, or people of colour experience these things? Gee, my husband is black, and one of my closest friends is gay. I bet if they got together and talked about their experiences, they'd find out they have a lot in common. Bottom line: they're movies. BBM is going to last a long time. It's going to become a classic Hollywood love story. Crash was really good and I enjoyed it a lot, but it's the exact kind of movie liberal Hollywood loves to reward to show how aware they are of the world around them.

dom Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:18 AM EST

em..... come to think of it ...... AT least ....let Munich won , still be much better ...than Crash ...

it's just a lower standard of Oscar this time.....

How come all the critics and other academys give it all to BBM and Oscar just

choose somthing totally different than other ......

Dimitri Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:09 AM EST

Hollywood isn't homophobic, but racism hits closer to home and is something that more people can easily relate to (as opposed to homosexuality).

Matt Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:09 AM EST

Well, this was fun for the last two hours but it's starting to get less fun.

Good night to all.

Dimitri Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:09 AM EST

Hollywood isn't homophobic, but racism hits closer to home and is something that more people can easily relate to (as opposed to homosexuality).

Matt Mon, Mar 6, 2006 at 12:09 AM EST

Well, this was fun for the last two hours but it's starting to get less fun.

Good night to all.


advertisement

Add Your Comments

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject — or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.



  • 1000 characters remaining
    • When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.
Latest Comments
Top Categories

All Categories

Blog Roll
Top Authors
Recent Posts
PopWatch Archive
July 2009
S M T W T F S
      1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31  

Complete Archive