Aug 29 2011 12:10 PM ET

'50 Documentaries To See Before You Die': Do you agree?

Filed under: Movies and tagged: , ,
hoop-dreams

For the last four weeks, Current TV has been running down its list of 50 documentaries every person must see in his/her lifetime. Tomorrow night, the series unveils its No. 1 documentary: Hoop Dreams. Steve James’ moving portrayal of inner city athletes is a safe choice to top the list of docs, though its only Oscar nomination at the time was for editing. Still, there are some glaring omissions that made room for host Morgan Spurlock’s Supersize Me (#5) and network honcho Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth (#8), not to mention more dubious inclusions like last year’s Catfish. See what we think was left off the list and share your own opinions after the jump.

Perhaps Current TV takes it moniker a bit too literally, as there are no docs on the roster earlier than 1988. That leaves no room for 1922′s groundbreaking Nanook of the North, Alain Resnais’s brilliant Night and Fog from 1955, Leni Riefenstahl’s controversial Triumph of the Will (1935), or Dziga Vertov’s 1933 proto-study in cinematography, Man with a Movie Camera.

The narrow date range of the documentaries selected also fails to pay credit to the people who shaped the form. Emile de Antonio (Point of Order, In the Year of the Pig) is missing entirely. And the Maysles’ brothers’, whose “Direct Cinema” style heavily influenced Brother’s Keeper (#34), are nowhere to be found. Where is Grey Gardens? Salesman? Gimme Shelter? That rock doc is one of a slew of music-related documentaries that were buried under the blush-inducing bravado of Madonna in Truth or Dare (#49). Where are 1970′s Woodstock, Martin Scorsese’s The Last Waltz, Dylan doc Don’t Look Back, Talking Heads film Stop Making Sense, and Buena Vista Social Club?

Naturally, modern documentarians Werner Herzog and Michael Moore figure prominently, but of the other fine auteurs of our time are conspicuously missing. Where is Ken Burns? Or Spike Lee, who took on Civil Rights in Oscar-nominated 4 Little Girls and Hurricane Katrina’s aftermath in If God Is Willing and Da Creek Don’t Rise. Where is Michael Apted, who began his Up series about British schoolchildren in 1965 and is taking it into its sixth decade of cinematic anthropology next year?

March of the Penguins makes the list (#38), but its Morgan Freeman-less — and visually superior — counterpart Winged Migration didn’t make the cut. Nor does The Cove. Other omissions include 1984′s The Times of Harvey Milk, 2004′s Born into Brothels, and last year’s exploration of soldiers’ lives in Afghanistan, Restrepo.

So, PopWatchers, which docs do you think got dissed? Which ones made the list that you don’t think are up to snuff? Do you think Hoop Dreams deserves its place at the top of the list? Are Spurlock and Gore’s high rankings legit?

Comments (104 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 5
  • Laurie

    I think this list was based solely on what they could get the rights to air. I have seen about half of the ones you said were missing and I agree all are great.

  • Chris

    A list without Grey Gardens is not a list, but a scam.

    • Ryan

      Did not even think about that one. I completely agree.

    • Dyana

      Agreed. And Exit Through the Gift Shop is too hipsterriffic for me. I’d like to see Cats of Mirikitani on there.

    • Mia

      CurrentTV does specify that their list of documentaries is chosen from the last 20-25 years. Grey Gardens (though brilliant, and one of my all-time favorites) debuted in 1975, so it fell outside of the target date range.

    • Pattie

      Chris, I totally agree! I loved watching the series and kept waiting for them to mention Grey Gardens. I was SHOCKED it didn’t make the cut! I didn’t even think about it being out of the date range…..

  • whydoesewhavetospoileverything?

    This doesn’t air until tomorrow so why are you telling us #1 today?!?!? This is an article that should have been put up on Wednesday AFTER we have seen the entire list, not today. Really stupid EW. I have been thoroughly enjoying the first 4 installments and you have now ruined the last hour for me.

    • Ki

      It’s been out for a while. ( or at least on demand)

      • whydoesewhavetospoileverything?

        On Demand where? The author even admits it airs tomorrow. Really stupid judgment – were they desperate for stories for a Monday?

      • Dennis

        I believe the complaint wasn’t about spoiling the docs availability, but spoiling which doc was #1. If that’s the case, I have to agree.

  • Todd

    I kept waiting for The Times of Harvey Milk to show up and kept thinking it was just really high on the list, so it’s disappointing to see it was left off. The doc I keep telling everyone about is Dear Zachary, which is a absolutely amazing piece of work. So sad and touching.

    • Emilee

      “Dear Zachary” is the most heart-breaking film I’ve ever seen.

      • Sara

        So true. I was doing a big ugly cry toward the end of that one, and it hung over me for days after watching it. Powerful stuff.

  • seemkay

    No doc’s before 1988=a list put together by children.

    • child

      Using an apostrophe to make a word plural = Not as brilliant as you think you are.

      • seemkay

        Point taken, although I was using the apostrophe to indicate that the word was shortened (like ne’er do well).

        I still stand by the point, however.

  • Ryan

    Where’s Grey Gardens and Harlan County, U.S.A? I’m skeptical of any “Best Documentary” list without either of those two in the top five. Get real.

  • Ethan

    Poorly thought out list – I can definitely agree with some of the choices, but the writer points out much of the ignorance of the creators of this list…assuming that all good docs happened within the past 20 years. Harlan County USA? Completely agree about the shocking omission of some of the documentarians and films.

  • Ryan

    Oh, and how about The Times of Harvey Milk?

    • Bobby’s Robot

      agreed. and Common Threads

      • Pattie

        Common Threads ripped my soul out….a brilliant piece of work!

  • Really?

    Any list that includes “Catfish” as a documentary is automatically invalid. I suppose the Blaire Witch Project also got snubbed?

  • D

    I still remember Nanook of the North well, and I haven’t seen it in 10 years. How do you not include that on a doc list? Seriously… just no logic.

    • Rock Golf

      Cause it wasn’t really a documentary, since many of the most famous scenes were staged.

  • char

    catfish? really?

  • Kevin

    A very disappointing list. Night and Fog should definitely be on the list.

  • Liza

    I agree that certain movies were added just because they are “current” and popular but are they really the best? I personally can’t believe they would put Super Size Me above One day in September or Man on Wire. I’m not surprised to see Hoop Dreams as the number one choice but it’s really overrated. I’m a huge documentary film buff and could never really enjoy Hoop Dreams. Maybe because I went to school with basketball players who were treated like gods even though they could barely read and made terrible grades and got away with breaking the law including gang rape. But, that’s just my personal experiences getting in the way.
    Many in the comments have mentioned great docs but what about Gates of Heaven? One of my favorites and I was surprised not too to see it included.

  • Angie

    What about the 7 UP series?

    • J. Davis

      I was going to say that too. I haven’t seen all those documentaries, but the Up series is the original reality show.

    • vliam

      The 7 up series is outside the scope of this list. The focus was on recent documentaries. The series began long before the cutoff for inclusion in the list.

  • winnie

    Any list like this without “Gates of Heaven” is a joke. And what about Apted’s “7-Up” series, the most enduring documentary project of all time? It’s like they think documentaries were invented in 1989.

    I’d second the votes above for “Dear Zachary,” the most heartwrenching thing I’ve ever seen on film.

Page: 1 2 3 5
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP