More American Idol

Mar 1 2011 08:00 PM ET

'American Idol': Discuss the Top 12 guys

Update: Annie’s recap is live Brand new Idoldome! Steven’s got a new Popsicle! So many changes, you guys. Read the full post.

Comments (311 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 8 9 10
  • cha

    I love Paul Mc Donald too… he’s good.. reminds me of THRIVING IVORY..

  • PHYLLIS HOMA

    What about Scotty, I thought he was awesome.

  • Rg

    So Randy’s sitting in Simon’s seat, wearing black leather, and trashing everyone. Is he the new Terminator?

  • irwan

    sorry…but, i think this is one of the WEAKEST lineup for the guys on AI. out of the 12, only 3 who actually got my attention. the rest…?? i kept thinking what went thru the judges’ minds to putting em thru?? one case in particular…Jordan (is it?)…they picked the wrong “other” black guy. My pick was this other black dude (i’m just really bad with the names, this season), who was shorter and was on the group Jordan left, during the Hollywood “group” day. Jordan’s just too obnoxious and lackin in talent or instinct in pickin songs (as proven).
    Another REALLY painfully bad one was that prissy boy with the big red hair..that flickin of his hair act is just soooooo…i kept hoping he slips and falls on his bony behind. (yup, i’m that upset with his freakishly laughable performance).
    For me, this year, it ought to be 3 guys vs. 7 girls. Oh, by the way, the 3 guys for me are: Lusk, Casey (his look might give him a hard time, i hope not) and the rock guy with the tourette and high voice. (again..i’m bad with names, this year).
    oh, p.s., i miss SIMON too…

  • Janice D.

    Jordan was awful. He needs to go. Bye bye Jordan. Sorry.

  • Janice D.

    Clint was super-dynamite. Stefano, I loved your singing. It’s so sweet.

  • Longshanks

    I now dub thee William Hung, Sir Loin of Beef.

Page: 1 8 9 10
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP