More American Idol

Feb 24 2011 08:00 PM ET

'American Idol': On the Green Mile (I hope they dance)

Update: Annie’s recap is live Tonight the remaining hopefuls will be walking the terrifyingly long plank for two whole hours, so yeah, I hope they Read the full post.

Comments (97 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3
  • Sweety

    @ Mel: I completely agree with you and was wishing for there to be a way to vote against Clint. I would vote all night to get him out. Yuck. How can a bully like him make it and not Jacee? Broke my heart completely. I did love Scotty’s humility though and appreciated everything he said about Jacee

    • Marcus

      Easy – Nobody wants to watch a little fat kid sing on TV. If Jacee loses 20 pounds and comes back next year, he’ll get in.

      • etm

        What?! I want to watch a fat little kid sing on TV. He was so friggin cute.

  • Kathy

    It doesn’t matter which guys made the top, because in the end, it will be Casey Abrams for the win. That guy ROCKS!

    • Kasey

      I can’t believe someone as talented as CAsey was right up the mountain from me and I didn’t know it.

  • sternum

    jacob lusk = amazing

  • KatieT

    Colton……ahhhhhhh cwap!

  • tae

    A much as they were telling the minors to come back they weren’t ready how in the world did Lauren alaina make it especially in that dress not trying to be mean and also tatiana made it I though she was done in Hollywood week

  • Derek

    The decision over the last three guys was a little annoying, and predictable. The way Steven put it: “You’re so young” (to JC), “You’re story really touched me (to Brett), “and you’re just crazy good” (to Colton). Hmmmm, by that logic, should have been Colton.

    Alas…

  • memo

    I would have prefered John Wayne over the deep voiced cowboy. Deep voice will always sound the same. John Wayne had a beautiful counrty voice.

    • etm

      Me too.

  • James

    Rachel Zevita!? Where have they been hiding this little siren. Love her Alanis vibe. I hope America embraces her over some of these questionable picks (Dorsey?? Seriously). Also, Durbin (poor man’s Lambert) and Lusk (hurts my ears) are just plain terrible.

  • Amanda

    Any one of these top 24 contestants would have won last year which just goes to show how crappy the top 12 were last year.

    • teri

      I would go farther and say anyone of the top 40 (at least the ones we heard)would have won over last years sorry lot!…Simon who?

  • DreamyK

    So sad to see Jacee go, what a beautiful pure voice he has. Hopefully he will come back next year. Durbin makes my ears hurt. I seriously had to mute him. I am thinking my Top 5 will be Brett, Julie, Thia, Stefano and Pia. I will NOT be voting for Divas Lauren, Durbin, Junebug or Jordan. I am really enjoying Steven, JLo was NOT crying last night and Randy is starting to toughen up. Turning out to be an interesting show after all.

  • Zack

    Hold on… ok, break it to me softly if you must… Are you guys really not doing Idolatry this year? Thats so sad. I probably wont even watch this season now because I dont have my Idolatry comrades to bitch with.

  • teri

    Colton was robbed! they should have went with on less girl to make room for him his voice was superior to most of them, Tatiynisa Wilson was flat out terrible!

  • JML

    I need to stop watching this show until the final 12 is set. Too many bad choices and disappointments. Can’t stand Jacob’s over the top antics! Didn’t like Rachel and the judges put Bret through over Colton?? Ridiculous! The real heartbreak was losing John Wayne Schulz. I love that guy!! *Sigh* I may need to boycott this season, too.

  • Lana

    The only girl I like is Ashton Jones. I think Clint is a little arrogant but he is a great singer people need to stop hating on him. James is so annoying!! I LOVED Adam Lambert but this guy doesnt sing, he screams!! I love Jacob also

Page: 1 2 3
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP