Elton John as Sue's love interest on 'Glee'? Don't let the sun go down on this...

elton-john-and-sueImage Credit: Sylvain Gaboury/PR Photos; Patrick Ecclesine/Fox Record 20905008Elton John, the future Mr. Sue Sylvester? Oh please, TV gods, make this dream come true: Matthew Morrison is pushing for Sir Elton to guest-star on Glee, and he told People that “he should maybe play [Sue’s] boyfriend or some kind of love interest for her.” Preach on, Mr. Schue!

It will be tough for any guest star in the near future to compete with Gwyneth Paltrow’s turn on the show, but if anyone can out-dazzle someone else, it’s Elton John, no? More importantly, I actually want to see Sue in some kind of decent (even if it’s strange) romantic relationship. So far we’ve seen her get her heart broken, break a heart or two herself, and possibly rape Figgins — a track(suit) record that would make even Carrie Bradshaw weep.

Do you want to see Elton John on Glee, PopWatchers? And what song would you want to hear him sing?

Read more:
‘Glee’ ‘Thriller” preview pics
Gay teens on TV: A timeline
Elton John and David Furnish welcome baby boy

Comments (25 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2
  • Mr. Holloway

    But first, she’d have to get a divorce from herself. (Not that this show really concerns itself with continuity, but still…)

  • Rolo Tomasi

    Wouldn’t he be the girlfriend?

  • Anissa

    How about he’s her old music teacher who she had a major crush on, and this gives her the chance to see what could have been as he sings “Your Song” to her.

    • Jackie

      That would be perfect! It could explain why Sue has it in for the glee club so much. She had a crush on her music teacher and got hurt because he could not reciprocate (flashback to Susie Pepper), and she has hated music and music teachers ever since.

    • Luca

      I love it. that would be so perfect.

      then perhaps we find out that in truth she actually still has a crush on him and we might get a little duet in secret. only to have her totally revert back to typical Sue when he leaves (Ryan would probably have him pointedly tell Sue that he’s gay which is why he didn’t reciprocate)

  • fromMarkHall

    Song–“jamaica jerk off” as part of a student field trip to the island getaway. Of course, it’ll be tough besting The Brady Bunch outing to Hawaii, but with Elton along for the ride as perhaps a Princess Cruise line entertainment coordinator/dictator, who knows???

  • MiaS

    Elton and Sue? Sign me up!

  • Nate

    Can we please stop acting like Gwyneth Paltrow was the best thing to ever happen to this show?

    • Soldier


    • Scott

      This, please. Definitely.

    • Luca

      Oh I don’t know. I think perhaps she was. Which just shows how lame and gimmicky the show has become (if that was the best thing)

  • Done

    Great. Another guest star that won’t add anything to the story line. Thats sounds as lame as the story line with Arnie joining the football team. Just another reason to switch the channel.

  • Max

    Elton John, sure, or maybe someone who can act

  • Josh

    Yep, another gimmick. The show would gain a little credibility with me if they didn’t bring big names in for a few minutes, then drop it like nothing happened.

  • Gimme a Break

    When will the people that produce this show realize that the story lines are being hijacked at the expense of having a guest star on the show.

    • Kristy

      You are so right. I am so tired of the music driving the storyline instead of the storyline driving the music! And please, no more “themed” episodes (Madonna/Britney). Madonna episode was great but that should have been a one time thing.

    • Mr. Holloway


      Just because “Glee” CAN lure all these big names since the show has blown up, doesn’t mean they SHOULD.

  • Geri

    The only character I’d like to see Elton play on Glee is one of Rachel’s fathers!

  • BlackIrish4094

    Please no. And also, Gwyneth was no big shakes either. This show is going downhill rapidly.

  • xxx

    I’m over the guest stars on the show. They need to lay off.

  • kim

    If they must have him on, it can only be as one of Rachel’s dads. They should have had them on ages ago.
    Not Sue they wasted a great guest with Carol Burnett with that stupid plat. Let’s get physical with ONJ was horrid. The show is about the glee kids have him be one of their family members, um like RACHEL’S DAD.

  • AmandaLH

    Elton John would be fun, as long as the story isn’t around him.
    Also, I don’t get why everyone thinks Gwenyth Paltrow was so great. That episode was one of the worst for me.

Page: 1 2
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP