More American Idol

Jan 20 2011 09:13 AM ET

'American Idol' poll: Did you like the new 'Idol'?

We knew the faces were going to be different and the show would have a different vibe, but there was no way of knowing whether Read the full post.

Comments (123 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 4 5 6
  • armitha

    I tried to watch several minutes but I yawn, and yawn and fell asleep.

  • Kenneth

    In the begining i thought these guys wouldn’t fit but they fit so well its unbelievable. I love how they compliment each other. J bring the hurman side to the show which was totally needed and the guys just make the show fun to watch. My wife and I both will enjoy this season I am sure. I almost gave up on this show. Thanks!! for saving the show. These People know music and they are honest as well. Again – great show. Love them all.
    Kennth Slade

  • mare

    Couldn’t wait to see our 2 new judges in action. Was not disappointed! Especially love Steven Tyler’s wit. All 3 judges work well together. Hopefully this will continue – Much better than Kara who? and although I love Ellen, it was not the right fit. Keep it up guys!

  • Ellen

    Idol shouldn’t be about the judges. It’s all about the contestants! That said, I loved the new panel.

  • Francine

    The show has become boring! Jennifer & Steven are passing through people who cannot sing, and feeling sorry for them, because Jennifer can’t say NO!! Seriously I can’t stand to watch Idol anymore. Bring back Simon.

  • Carol

    I was reluctant, because Idol is my favorite show. But, the Idol producers nailed it when they Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez as the new judges! I’ve always enjoyed Randy Jackson, and having him come back, along with the two new judges makes the show even better. Way to go!

  • Shaman Jerome

    As I said before, now that the Boston Tea Party is over and we have gotten rid of the Simon Factor, the show does seem to have new energy and flash. It looks like so far it could be a young person walking away with the prize, but, it’s a long ways yet, and we have seen some, not all that made it through. The judges are making people feel more relaxed and comfortable. This is prolly going to go down as the best season since the beginning. I like it, and I’ll be watching when the winner is annouced.

  • Chantel

    I like the new american idol even though i miss simon…steven tyler is so funny, i laughed so hard when i heard him say “build a fire, save the matches, f*** a duck, and see what hatches” that was great, even though he got in trouble for saying it hahaha…jennifer needs to be a little meaner, but i guess she’s fine taking paula’s role…i thought would comment on last season too: ellen should not have been there!!!!!

  • Julie

    Love love love it!!!

Page: 1 4 5 6
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP