May 31 2010 10:02 PM ET

'Bachelorette' instant reaction: The guys get catty, hooray!

Some true front-runners emerged, Ty played the guitar some more, Craig R. made yet another “Rated ____” pun, and much, much male flesh was shown thanks to a “sexy guy calendar” swimsuit shoot. (We also spent a lot of time admiring Ali’s abs.) But mostly, this week was about Craig M. and his hair vs. Jonathan the Weatherman and his insecurities. Which was just fine with us — at least for now.

The full recap will be up soon, but if you’ve already watched and want to weigh in on the fallout of The Bachelorette‘s first guy-on-guy smackdown of the season, read on after the jump for more. [SPOILER ALERT: Read on only if you've already watched Monday's Bachelorette premiere. Seriously.]

Frank, our favorite screenwriter who lives with his parents, killed it on the first one-on-one date of the season. His dubious employment played as free-spirited. His hyperactive humor came in handy as their car broke down mid-date. They kissed atop the Hollywood Hills. “I met a guy today who made me believe that everything I’m looking for is possible,” Ali voice-overed. And there was more making out and a rose for Frank.

The group date yielded a lot of dude insecurity about swimwear, a song from Ty (and thus a rose for Ty), and a revelation from Jonathan to Ali that Craig M. was “dangerous” after the latter’s relentless taunting in the house. “The amount I want a rose is equal to how much of a dick Craig M. is,” Jonathan told us. So, a lot.

Jesse — who is distinguished by his woodworking and his hotness and his tattoos and the interplay among those three factors — got to go to Vegas, which was good because it enabled us to see him in a variety of hot settings and hot outfits. (Ferrari, pool, swim trunks, suit.) Ali seemed like she really wanted to like him, presumably because he is so hot. He got a rose and some making out for his trouble.

The big choice of the night — Jonathan vs. Craig M. — came down in Jonathan’s, and, miraculously, our, favor. Craig M. was out after just two weeks of villainy, and we also lost the unmemorable Tyler V. and Chris H. in the process. My full recap will be up in a few hours, but let us know right now what you think now. Did all three of the date roses ring true for you? Did she make any mistakes this time? How psyched are you to be rid of Craig M. so soon?

Image Credit: Chris Chavira/ABC

Comments (99 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 4
  • Jo

    Did anyone else notice that they showed the rose on Weatherman’s lapel before Ali actually gave it to him?

    • melissa

      Oh yeah, I saw that too! I thought I imagined it or something, so it’s good to know I’m not the only one.

      • April

        Not only that, but when the car broke down at the beginning, they were next to a wall on a freeway. And then all of a sudden, they were broken down next to a hill and trees. Bad editing. Do the producers think we are all stupid or blind??!!

    • Jill

      I did notice that too.

    • Robin

      I know! My husband and I were like What was that????

      • Kqt

        I did not seem to notice, but my husband who happened to watch the show with me did notice the rose. When I looked a few seconds after that it was a red hankerchief. I am now under the impression after reading everyone else’s comments, that my husband was not see things! I thought I liked the Weatherman at the beginning, not too sure of him.

    • Charlie

      I saw that too! I had to rewind to make sure I wasn’t imagining things.

    • etm

      yeah I noticed that too!

    • Mrs M

      Yes, I backed it up and pointed it out to my husband. Horrible editing! Although I’m not a huge Jonathan fan I think that Craig M was a jerk. Couldn’t even be bothered to learn Jonathan’s name.

    • Beth

      I totally noticed it. I wonder if Chris Harrison will mention it in his blog tomorrow. I’ll be checking it out!

    • Red1947

      Yes, I did notice the rose on the Weatherman’s lapel before she gave out the final rose to him. Makes you wonder how much of this show is rehearsed/staged or was it just poor editing. I replayed the DVR few times just to be sure I saw it correctly.

    • Tim’s Toots

      Man got rid of the “villian” so soon? The man looks older than his age, for real. I am trying myself to like the “weatherman” but his tattle-telling reminds me so much of gradeschool. I would have gotten rid of him just for that. Maybe the reason Allie didn’t is because she did the same to Vienna to Jake. The only difference was Jake had his own mind and he didn’t get rid of Vienna because of what Allie said. And we all know who won that one. I guess Allie doesn’t have a mind of her own and so she got rid of the so called bully. Hey Allie, you WERE the REAL bully in your episode so you should know how Craig felt. Losers!

      • Sars

        You’re right that Ali was a real bully in the Bachelor… but Craig did act like a big jerkoff bully to the guys. And then, when he was with Ali, he didn’t even act interested in her at all! Is it just me, or did that guy look like he was on coke the whole time?

    • Miss M

      OMG I saw it too but thought I must’ve been seeing a different guy. Or maybe because they showed the Weatherman sooooo much in this episode that I was just seeing him over and over again! I wish he would’ve gone too. My boyfriend thought Weatherman was too effeminite to be on the show. LOL!

  • Elly

    I LOVE Roberto!!! He is hot, funny and genuine. :D

    • Emily

      HECK YEAH, my husband and i both saw that!!!! it makes me think it’s all preplanned now, but i can’t help but get involved in it anyway. GOD i wish she’d get rid of both though!! get rid of the drama before it starts!

    • Mrs M

      I heart Roberto too – especially after he said he got drafted by the Twins and Rockies – my two favorite baseball teams! (Twins girl at heart but moved to CO and have learned to cheer on the Rockies too) That just capped it for me, he was one of my faves already but what can I say? Huge baseball fan.

  • TONY

    I thought the only reason she let Craig stay around after the first night was because the producers told her they needed some drama. Surprised they killed him off so soon.

    • Juneau

      They let him go because there is, no doubt, other drama coming (from previews at least one guy is there with a girlfriend). But glad to see good win out over evil for once on this show. How immature/big a bully can one guy be. He made a total a$$ out of himself talking to Ali. And his face looks like a saddle.

  • Valerie

    Weatherman is sweet, sensative, and I think he did the right thing by alerting Ali to Craig M’s maliciousness. Do I think he’ll stick around? — no. But I think he went out on a limb, and he has my admiration for that. And by the way, Roberto is HOT!

    • Allison M

      On one hand, I hate when guys waste their alone time by venting about others. On the other hand, Allie did this herself last season and probably appreciates it…

      • Tim’s Toots

        Yeah she did this and look where it got her?! No Jake and Vienna stayed! It usually never pays to tattle but I guess in this instance it did. Whatever, Allie has no mind of her so I don’t really care who she chooses. I am watching for the HOT men!

  • kelly

    ahhh why did chris h leave why why why grrrrr

  • Kate

    So bummed about Chris H — He was definitely hottest and just didn’t get the opportunity to show who he was… they didn’t really air him at all!!!

    • Kelsy

      So was I! I really thought the last rose would go to him and couldn’t believe it when she gave it to Jonathan who came across like a major whiner. Chris H. was REALLY cute.

  • chrissy870@gmail.com

    I am so glad Craig M. is gone! I was surprised Ali didn’t get rid of him sooner! I am not a fan of Ali because of her caddy ways from the last batchelor!

    • Sasrah

      AS a Torontonian, I’m completely MORTIFIED that Craig M. is roaming our streets right now. I guess all hope rests in Justin “Rated-R”…Oh goodness! :(

  • pamela

    thank goodness you sent Craig R home. He was like the mean GIRL on the playground. He chose Johnathan and tried to ge all the other guys to jump on the nasty bandwagon with him. He needed to go and I hope hes lonely now.

    • wakeforce

      Craig M. is what you get when you troll the bars looking for reality show contestants. I agree that Jonathan should have gone home. He seems totally insecure. Craig seemed to pick up on that. The weatherman seemed heavily “therapized” and was prolly picked on as a child.

      • JA

        “prolly?” What is that?

      • Tim’s Toots

        Come on JA, it is slang and if YOU don’t know what for then you shouldn’t be on here anyways! LOL

      • nuffsaid

        To JA: “prolly” is short for “probably”.

  • Jim

    Chris might have been cute but he was laughing the loudest at Craig M.’s childishness and that was about all the personality he showed.

    • Heidi

      I saw that too Jim and was unimpressed. That Chris was pretty good looking but anyone who sides with a bully and joins in, is a loser and he deserved to be cut.

  • Heather

    I’m glad that she sent Craig packing because he is such a jerk and didn’t seem interested at all, but I also think she should have sent weatherman home because he is so insecure and focused on talking about Craig that he didn’t ask Ali any questions either. I guess we’ll see how he does now that he doesn’t have Craig to obsess over

  • Madd

    I feel like I shouldn’t like Frank, but I do.
    Yes, Jesse is hot.
    Yes, Craig M should go home. He’s not even attractive once you look past the hair.

    • Madd

      *should’ve

    • Heidi

      Craig M. reminds me so much of Dean McDermott, Tori Spelling’s husband.

      • etm

        So true!

  • Joan

    Justin has a girlfriend and Frank is gonna ditch ali for a girl back home anyway. Go Roberto and Chris L.

    • a

      Did anyone ask you? Thanks for spoiling it, b!tch.

    • Amber

      Joan, how do you know that? Why do you have to said it and spoiling it?!

      • Chelsy

        Read realitysteve.com for everything about the season

      • spoilerhater

        Hey Joan and Chelsy…
        Give it a break! Reading, Reading and then the two of you come along and ruin the experience. I don’t appreciate it and I’m sure others don’t either!!!! Thanks for the buzz kill! I knew I shouldn’t read these posts and you and others need to stay away from these boards if you think what you say and write is acceptable – IT’S NOT!!

    • Kristen

      Really?!? Did you really just do that? Granted, I already knew that because I read Reality Steve, but you just ruined the season for everyone else! “a” is right, that was a bitch move.

    • Tim’s Toots

      I wish now I didn’t go to that site you mentioned. It ruined everything for me. It does say who the last two who are standing but not who won. Damn the temptation was too much and I had to go and see, now why bother to watch the show??!! Thanks for ruining it and well I won’t ruin it for others…….

  • etm

    Why does Ali always talk like she’s drunk? Always slurring and garbling her words. Also, are we supposed to believe that some of these guys are in their twenties? They look 35+ for sure. Also, wtf is up with Kasey’s voice???? The biggest WTF goes to Ali’s hair extensions. What possessed her to do that, and who is telling her they look good?

  • wakeforce

    Friends think he may be hearing-impaired.

    • etm

      Oh no! If that’s the case, I would never have brought it up. Though I guess it’s not a nice thing to say anyway :)

    • Heidi

      That was my guess as well though they’ve never spoken about it.
      He is a big sweetheart. I like him, Chris L., Kirk, and Roberto the best so far. Jesse is a little young but there are others I’d let go first, that’s for sure.

  • rmr

    etm, with all the libations flowing at al times, she may indeed be drunk! i dunno, i thought she kind of jumped into this whole thing before she gave herself a chance to get over jake. quitting her job and everything–seems kinds dysfunctional. her manner is definitely false a lot of the time, and she’s gained quite a bit of weight since the bachelor. she’s acting like she’s depressed but trying to hide it and hoping no one will notice. sorry, girl. you’re too good for all this nonsense, i thought.

    • etm

      In the premier I thought Ali looked really out of shape, but she looked good tonight in the bikini top and cargo pants. It’s weird – it’s like she looks heavier with her clothes on!!

    • Susan

      I didn’t want to sound catty, but she does look like she has gained weight. She seemed totally into Frank, which surprised me. I think she kept Jesse because he was hot – not too much connection going on there!

    • ben

      i hear she got with a bunch of guys in sf cause shes always wasted… dont people realize that they put slutty girls on a pedastol on this show??

Page: 1 2 3 4
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP