Apr 23 2010 03:01 PM ET

'Project Runway': Should Jay be allowed to design for women if he hates them?

Last night, my DVR said “Models of the Runway,” but thank god it was a 30-minute combo platter Project Runway/Models reunion special, because if I had sat through one more full episode of Models of the Runway, I do believe my head might’ve just rolled right off! Missy alluded to it in her finale recap, but can we talk about Jay’s ridiculous comment to model Cerri? In a clip series, Cerri was shown saying she didn’t like Jay’s design, and then Jay fired back at her during the live show, “That’s why we don’t hire models with bad teeth and thick legs.”

Oh, honeybitch. It’s understandable to take criticism of your work as a personal affront, but you need to let that stuff process at least 30 seconds before proceeding in any way. Grownups do it all the time. I do it with bitchy PopWatch comments nearly every day!

1. Did Jay just sabotage his career?
2. Do you think Brittany has recovered yet?
3. How pretty is Cerri?!?

Annie on Twitter: @EWAnnieBarrett

Comments (88 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 4
  • Karen B

    My mouth dropped as far as Brittany’s when I heard that. Complete lack of class by Jay.

    • Karen B

      (and Cerri is beautiful and articulate. Jay even agreed that he designs for an L.A. aesthetic, which she is not, so his retort was even more egregious and hostile in the end.)

    • Jean

      Yes! They previewed that clip before one of the commercial breaks but my jaw still dropped when he said it. And look at his face after he says it! “Look everyone, I just made a really witty comeback!”

    • Scooter

      Cerri is ugly on the inside! All season long she spouted off nasty comments towards others (not just Jay). Though she didn’t deserve the horrific insult from Jay, she certainly needed to be taken down a notch. Pride is one of the deadly sins, after all.

      • Yes

        she is not a nice person.
        commenting on her looks is commenting on her modeling work – although not warranted at that moment.

      • Alex

        Jay is beyond rude. So don’t like him anymore. What was crazy was when he started crying!! after he made the comment as if he was the victim! No Jay you are not!

      • GirlfriendinaComa

        Amen. While Jay surely lost points with me, that Cerri was slagging people off all season. She has the personality of a turd.

      • Sarah

        My thing is the comments that were being said were about work nothing personal. jay made it personal so to me thats immature. Yeah she can be a bitch but what she said about Jay wasn’t even an insult. It was her honest opinon about his work. What he said was really childish and if anything it took down his carrer a lot and help make her’s.

    • Bobby’s Robot

      So glad he finished out of the Top 3.

    • Lisa

      Cerri is the classless one. All those people who say Jay needs a thicker skin should also realize that you need a thick skin to be a model as well. Stop taking Cerri’s side just because you feel like your own legs are thick

      • synapse

        Lisa, better thick legs than a thick head.

      • you said it

        oh snap, synapse!

    • Nia

      Cerri was an opinionated bad teeth big leg witch! I am so over the drama of the models of the runway. The older models are used, mean and bitter. It’s one thing to diss your comp (models) but leave the designers out of it. There is a heirarchy in the industry and models work for desingers. So ballsy itches like Cerri an Mayonaise can go to hell.

  • emily

    it was a horrible moment. nobody should speak to someone like that. it was very petty.

  • Lizzy

    I’m not sure he sabotaged it, but he sure didn’t do it any favors. He clearly isn’t ready to be a commercial designer if he can’t stand someone giving their opinion of his work that he doesn’t agree with. That’s what was incredible… she wasn’t saying it was bad, just not her style.

    He needs to grow up just a wee bit.

    • Lisa

      Actually, Cerri WAS saying that it was bad, and she didnt even have good reasons (clearly she just wanted her designer to win so that she could continue). Watching her make stank comments about nearly everyone made me hate this show forever. She got what she deserves.

      • sure…

        the thing is Cerrie said no offense, and she did repeat it. Just because Jay couldn’t take her honest opinion he had to go personal. Beside Cerrie may be rough on the inside, but so what?
        Everybody has their one way of being and nobody is bad. She just expressed her opinion and Jay insulted her personally. He could have said something like well i respect your opinion but i definitely do not agree with it. I mean if you are so desperate to get back then go ahead, make yourself seem immature, stupid and like a jerk on national television.

  • Lizzy

    PS – I think Cerri is GORGEOUS and I could listen to her talk for HOURS

    • jennrae

      Agreed! Love when she says, “simple as,” and so on. She’s gorgeous and SMART!

    • Lisa

      PS – Cerri is an idiot and a downer (WHO would consider her smart?!?!)

    • Erik

      I agree with Lizzy.

  • Meghan

    WOW. I was so sad to see Jay lash out like that, because he was one of my favorite designers all season, for just the opposite reason: he was usually so fun and upbeat! We all say things we regret sometimes, especially when we’re feeling attacked, and I’m sure he learned his lesson: save your bitchy comments for that special space inside your head, not the camera. This just shows he has some growing up to do, which is pretty much the point Cerri made about his professional work as well. And if Cerri has thick legs, the rest of us might as well chop off the Redwoods we call ours.

    • igee101

      Yeah same I loved Jay’s stuff for most of the season especially in the beginning like I still remember that trash bag look he did and I thought it was awesome don’t know why Maya tried to criticize it at the reunion show. I mean Jay was in the wrong for slagging the girl off but I understood where he was coming from. Why should someone who doesn’t get your aesthetic diss it just because they don’t like it, Emilio knows if Cerri had said the same thing about his work he’d probably have said something worse.

    • Sarah

      I agree with everything you said. It made him look childish and he did nothing but prove Cerri point.

  • Sara

    “I do it with bitchy PopWatch comments nearly every day!” Hahaha! that must take admirable restraint, Annie! And I’m serious!

    Jay is/was bitchy–I thought he was super bitchy with Tim last week, too–and I never quite understood why he was so crabby with Mila. It was nice to see him get taken down a peg or two by losing.

    His stuff was creative, but too much! He’s not as awesome as he thinks he is.

  • @dennang

    Between this comment, him saying that Mila got the third spot because she was equipped with ladyparts, AND his noted fear of boobs, Jay’s got some serious ladyhate to the point of serious concern for his mental health.

  • Kristina

    He’s a thin-skinned bitch who will never be able to design for “real” women.
    Here’s a picture of lovely Cerri — wish I had those legs.
    http://gawker.com/comment/22138672/

  • Sara

    Also–agreed the Cerri was so pretty and I loved how she clearly had no patience for the Britt’s and Leona’s of the group, but yet wasn’t QUITE as irritable as Brandeis.

  • cameobrooch

    Methinks Ms. Barrett should have processed the headline of her article for 30 seconds before submitting it. Yes, Jay’s comment was a nasty personal attack, but I think it’s very presumptuous on Ms. Barrett’s part to declare him a woman hater because of it.

    • Marri

      He also said that he was scared of boobs. That may not make him a women hater, but if he thinks all women should be boobless with thin legs then he isn’t a women lover.

      • Sarah

        “but if he thinks all women should be boobless with thin legs”

        umm if he thinks that then he should just desgin for men. Cause he would never be able to make anything for a REAL woman.

  • LizP

    I was horrified by his comment! Cerri was my favorite model – intelligent and gorgeous (love her even more as a brunette). She made watching Models of the Runway (mostly) palatable.

    He has no clue how to design for women – I lost count of the number of designs of his that had something right at the hips/ass to make them look enormous. DUH. He’s a classless & talentless jerk.

  • Mary

    It was wrong BUT how soon everyone forgets how Cerri trash talked Brittany the entire season. Now granted it wasn’t personal attacks on her looks….but Cerri isn’t a perfect angel either.

    • Scooter

      It’s good to see that at least one other person was paying attention to Cerri’s non-model behavior this season! Jay was wrong to say what he said, but Cerri deserved to be called-out on her piss-poor attitude.

      • Cerri is awful person

        The whole show long she said terrible things about everyone, prefaced with “no offense” like that made it ok. YUCK. A pretty person? no.

  • JP atx

    HAHA! b*tchy PopWatch comments! People should be nicer, right?! Anyway, I noticed that Jay had a bit of a stanky attitude in his exit interview last week on EW. What a jerk!

  • Nella

    Cerri was being a total b****. All y’all that keep saying she was just expressing a measured opinion about his design aesthetic are missing some serious social-perceptiveness genes. She was totally going after him and it was totally personal and b**chy. His response was equally so. Big b***fest. I was more troubled by his fear of boobs. Then why do you want to spend your life adorning them?

    • jennrae

      Nothing she said hit below the belt as what he said. Sure, she might’ve been bitchy, but it wasn’t a PERSONAL attack like making fun of someone’s teeth is.

      • ugly teeth

        ugly teeth make a bad model – in his opinion. he has just as much right to his opinion of her “work” as she does to her opinion of his work.

      • Lisa

        BOTH Cerri and Jay attacked each other’s work: Cerri went first by attacking his work (which was totally wrong) and then Jay attacked her looks, which in essence is her work

    • Mary

      This ignores the fact that JAY himself was constantly talking crap about his competitors, especially Mila, during his one-on-one interviews. He, of all people, has no right to cry and complain when the tables are turned. One of the reasons I’m glad Seth Aaron won is that he was generally very sportsmanlike about his competitors during his solo interviews.

  • Cathy

    Cerri is a beautiful model.
    I would love her skin.
    What a dopey diva Jay is … I’m glad he didn’t get to show at Bryant Park.

    • erin

      He did get to show at Bryant Park; along with 9 other PR designers.

      • sure…

        haha good one :P

Page: 1 2 3 4
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP