Image Credit: Michael Courtney/ABCIt’s really not that hard to enjoy V. Every episode, you’re guaranteed one awesome scene, two awesome sci-fi concepts, a cameo appearance by the Magic Flying Ball of Doom, a cameo appearance by an actor from another great sci-fi series, a cameo appearance by Scott Wolf, and lots of scenes featuring attractive people wearing expensive leather jackets. By that metric, last night’s episode, titled “John May,” went according to plan. Let’s run down the list:
Awesome Scene: Le Resistance was hanging out in Father Jack’s study, talking to Doctor Joshua and Georgie via the Magic Glowing Ball of Communication. Georgie had suffered all manner of V torture. He asked Father Jack for his Last Rites and bade farewell to his comrades. The soundtrack, which usually sounds like paranoid elevator music, suddenly discovered an eerie guitar track. Doctor Joshua injected Georgie with Death Juice.
(Thank you, V writers, for granting my humble wish from last week and sending Georgie to Hobo Heaven. But my blood lust has not been sated! Father Jack: you’re next.)
Awesome Sci-Fi Concept #1: Anna called in the Human Pain expert from the Tokyo Ship to torture Georgie. Apparently, Beardie McHobo had enough mental strength to withstand incredibly advanced truth serums. Okay, sure. I’ll accept ridiculous plot turns, if the payoff is something as weird as the Scour, an insect-like creature who pokes around inside of your body and “usually exits through the reproductive organs.” Speaking of reproduction…
Awesome Sci-Fi Concept #2: This was another big week for pregnancy plotlines. Anna was suffering from some brutal morning sickness. Pregnant Girlfriend (or whatever her name is) felt her two-week-old fetus kick, then caught a gander at a disturbing sonogram. (Any sonogram with more than zero visible lizard tails counts as disturbing.) We learned that Tyler’s dad isn’t really his dad. Or maybe he is. It’s Mamma Mia! Starring Meryl Streep! Tyler confronted his dad about this. Daddy Krycek said, “It’s complicated.” Starring Meryl Streep!
Oh, and a random V-loving interviewee made a big point about mentioning how infertile she was compared to her siblings, who all have “big families! Not one under eight kids!” (Was this some kind of veiled Dancing With the Stars reference?) I poked fun at the preponderance of pregnancy plots last week, but I’m starting to think that it’s all intentional — that pregnancy is a kind of overarching motif-thesis for V, kind of like how everyone on Lost has an emotionally distant father.
Certainly, we can agree that any show that features Morena Baccarin laying a million eggs in a giant tub of water has something on its mind.
Magic Flying Ball of Doom Cameo: The ol’ MFBoD falls somewhere far below the Smoke Monster and the evil Prisoner balloon on the scale of “Inexplicably Murderous Flying Things.” Last night, a mere human pistol caused it to explode. That’s no way to get ahead in life, Ball!
Sci-Fi Actor Cameo: Michael Trucco of Battlestar Galactica totally crushed it as John May last night. The big twist – that John May has actually been dead all along – was one of the niftier parts of the episode, and yet more evidence that V can be pretty smart.
Unfortunately, May’s death continues a troubling V trend of killing off some of the most promising characters. First Alan Tudyk’s Dale, then the fearsome bald V enforcer… heck, I dunno about you, but I even found the sleeper-agent V girlfriend more compelling than any members of Le Resistance. (Aside: We didn’t actually see May’s death, which makes me a bit skeptical.)
Sci-Fi Actor Cameo Bonus: The director of this episode was Jonathan “William Riker” Frakes. Nifty.
Scott Wolf Cameo: This week, on “Two Minutes with Chad Decker”: Chad got suspicious, figured out that the Visitors were targeting people who could be great but aren’t, and somehow used this knowledge to show Anna he’s not to be trifled with. Hooray for journalism! With very little actual plot to work with, Wolf is totally making me love Decker’s morally ambiguous, fame-yearning character. I’d be happy with more of him and less of…
Attractive People Wearing Expensive Leather Jackets: The best-dressed resistance movement on earth trucked up to Reedsville in search of the Magic Glowing Ball of Communication. Clever Erica tricked the surprisingly unprepared sleeper agent with the old “mix up the college mascots” gag. (Like anyone knows what a Bruin is.) Also, I might be wrong, but I think Hobbes’ tight black T-shirt shrunk since last week. As the team toasted to their fallen comrade, I could swear that his pecs looked mournful.
I didn’t even get to Tyler, who stole Justin Bieber’s hair and spent the episode pouting. Besides him, I actually think that just about everything about V is working… except for the Fifth Column plotline, which is unfortunately about 90 percent of the show.
What’s your prescription for curing V, viewers? Should we shed a few more main characters? Do we need less pregnancy, or more pregnancy? And am I wrong, or did Anna’s birth-tub look like a flooded version of the Dollhouse set?








Did the Lost Chick say “I need to get my son off that ship!!”. That is really her only dialogue in the show. Along with Father Jack looking confused and Scott Wolf looking suspicious, and Anna looking cross eyed. And, yet I still watch.
This was one of my least favorite episodes…the teen angst is killing me…I want to see more of Jonathan (the ship doctor) and less of Erica!!
The doctor’s name on the ship is Joshua, not Jonathan.
Agreed. I wish Anna’s daugther would eat Tyler and put us all out of his misery.
I’m so glad I’m not the only one annoyed by Tyler. At elast if he’s gone, it’ll give Elizabeth Mitchell something to do/say besides, “I need to get Tyler of that ship!”
I was thinking the very same thing lol.
Lol, very true. Most annoying teenager since Dawn on BTVS.
I absolutely agree. Every single scene with Tyler makes me cringe. Last night when he was crying about his father, I swear I could tell he just received his diploma from the Keanu Reeves school of acting. How could the show’s producers NOT realize that he is the weakest part of the show? Whenever he’s on screen it’s like an automatic bathroom break or trip to the kitchen for me. The only, and I mean only, saving grace is the fact that he’s usually accompanied by Anna’s daughter who sometimes looks a little too perfect (definite plastic surgery) to be beautiful but still has a really nice body and is almost as hot as her mother.
Daughter is way hotter than buzzcut mom and her Million soldier babies.
lol, i got the image of a underwater dollhouse sleeping chambers as well.
Rats I fell asleep and missed that part.
I liked much of this episode, but I agree the 5th column stuff is still moving really slowly…
Enough with Lisa and Tyler – either make them interesting and let them help the Resistance from the inside or let them be a D plot and only seen once every 5-6 episodes!
More Dr. Joshua, Ryan with a clue, and more action please. Especially if we are not going to get a season two!
Chad finally grew a pair and talked back to Anna (who totally creeps me out). I keep thinking she is going to bare her fangs and eat him too as a snack. We are of peace my %$^.
I totally hate Tylisa! They are boring, terrible actors and the fact that something “special” whatever is built around such Ken and Barbie is a major albatros around this show`s neck. hello, can`t we have a show where a special character(s) are actually interesting and make their own destiny instead of being wooden whiny b****es who are told they are special but nobody sees it except if that meant specially idiotic.
This show could have potential but there are some things that could have been done differently.
The show has too many commercials. You get into a story and boom a commercial.
V should have had a two-hour premiere to introduce the characters. Instead we have to find out about the characters as the story goes.
Forget the commercials, the show has TOO MUCH TYLER.
You talk about a “Sci-Fi Actor Cameo” without mentioning Nicholas Lea from The X-Files? I’m disappointed.
I`m super disappointed that the whole John May set up ended up with him being dead for 10 years. Wow, that was profound. Now, please, don`t make Tyler be his son or clone or somesuch crap!
You know this is coming…
He did…in last week’s recap.
I’m actually starting to like the series. I was a big fan of the original as cheesy as it was, and I want to give this version a chance. Hope ABC feels the same way, but I’m doubtful that we will see more than a handful of new episodes before it’s cancelled.
Darren, YOU ARE HILARIOUS!!!! Loved your recap – better than the show!!!
I think the whole tyler story needs to be cut…he gets on my nerves and I’m ready to see Anna unhinge her jaws and swallow him whole.
I absolutely concur. Worst actor ever.
I think he’s too pretty that it makes his character unreal. He plays a very naive teenager. That naiveness is extremely frustrating to watch.
If you want a really great sci-fi icon on the show, get Joel Gretsch’s father-in-law!
William Shatner? Yeah, he could play himself and have Anna on an episode of “Raw Nerve.”
great episode last night!!!
The show is just okay, but who am I to say anything neg. about it, heck I’m home in my confy chair with a snuggly blanket and a fresh bowl of buttery popcorn…just enjoy the show baby!
i meant “comfy”
IMO… the worst thing about this show is the dialog. Some of it last night had me and the boyfriend groaning out loud. Second? The faux emotionality around Georgie. They barely knew the guy! I’m glad they got Joshua to kill him off. And the 5th column is like, what? 4 people? They need more resistance characters, stat. And as much as I like Elizabeth Mitchell, I DISlike Erica. All the stuff on the ship is good to awesome, all the stuff on Earth is kinda “meh”. And yet, great hook at the end… gotta tune in next time for the birth of Anna’s Army. DC: she beyond creeps me out. The scour thing was so gross. Made sleeping tough last night!
I don`t like Mitchell`s acting in this either. She comes off as if she dislikes the show and doesn`t really try.
The show’s working but it needs to kick it up a notch!
That`s easy. Start with killing off characters that stop the show cold. Aka Tylisa. They are on the show just to provide hotness for teenage viewers but I don`t know anyone who likes these awful Ken and Barbie.
So true. The writers are trying to cater to the young female demographic with Tyler/Lisa but barely anyone can stand them. Neither together nor apart.
A lot went on during the episode, but not much happened. Hope people get their fill of V this spring, because it’s not coming back. Too bad, because it had a lot of promise. It’s suffered from terrible pacing and a refusal to reveal hardly anything to the audience of consequence.
Some terrible acting too. If they thought people will flock to the show just because it has a Justin Bieber lookalike, oversexed blonde mannequin and stunt casting from other popular genre shows, then they made a huge miscalculation.
And the writers have yet to clue in that if you write it smart, smart people will flock to it… Lost anyone?