More American Idol

Apr 14 2010 04:36 PM ET

Casey James explains his obscure song choice, decision to perform in the 'American Idol' Swaybot pit

Hot on the heels of last week’s sensational “Jealous Guy” cover, Casey James seemingly took a step backward in momentum on last night’s Elvis Presley-themed Read the full post.

Comments (42 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2
  • ricardo b. prospero

    I may agree he is good but his rendition is a total distortion of the original version just to sound different. This is a clear disrespect for the song composer and the subject singer (Elvis)

  • Luciana

    I’m old enough to remember Lawdy Miss Clawdy, and I couldn’t even recognize it in Casey’s version.

  • paisley

    Although he sang it okay (not great),the song itself was terrible, he did NOT look cool, and I hope he gets his act together — SOON! C’mon, Casey!

  • MNCyn

    Check out YouTube for both Elvis’ and Paul McCartney’s “Lawdy Miss Clawdy!” …. Warning … the song may get stuck in your head! I like it, and I hope if Casey does an album, he includes it!

  • keeley

    He needs to get up there and do some Bob Seger– think it would be amazing

  • Peggy Sue

    I adore Casey- he sounded amazing and although he doesn’t have his show face “down” yet – if you listen to his voice, it’s a sound you could listen to all day long. He’s rock/blues all the way and this song suited him perfectly.

    • naynay

      I love him too and it is frustrating that the judges and Slezak are not showing him any love at all.

  • Rush

    I think it was a good strategy for this theme, just that Casey didn’t pull it off well. He went back to that cover band vibe, and yes stage placement didn’t help at all. On the other hand, Mike Lynche also picked a lesser known Elvis tune, made it his own, and had a minor Idol moment.

    • naynay

      Lesser known? Never wathced South Park, did you? That is all I can hear when I hear that song. Much better than Mike’s performance!

      • naynay

        Uh, that was “watched”

    • MaryS-NJ

      One of Taylor Hicks’ best performances on Idol was “In the Ghetto”. Mike’s was very nice but Taylor blew him out of the water. That’s the risk picking a song that’s been performed before on Idol.

  • MaryS-NJ

    Thanks for interviewing Casey, Michael. I think he’s very talented, has a great recording voice and has a lot of potential. Not to compare musical styles and preferences, but I feel like Casey’s being thrown under the bus just like a certain Pocket Idol of your acquaintance. I don’t know if he has the showmanship to win it, but I think Casey’s definitely got the talent to have a nice career doing what he loves.

  • yambo

    EW complains that Casey’s song choice isn’t a mega-hit and praises Sourbox for choosing one more obscure. I can’t wait till she sings in the pit with the bots so you can praise THAT. LOL

  • flw

    I love casey and even though he changed the song,it still sounded great to me,more entertaining than most other performances that night. Even without Idols,its obvious the guy is going places cos he is very good and also he looks good. Best of luck to you Casey!!!

  • Minerva

    I think Casey is the best choice for winning

Page: 1 2
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP