More American Idol

Mar 22 2010 02:29 PM ET

Miley Cyrus will guest-mentor on 'American Idol'

During a routine scrape, American Idol producers found Miley Cyrus at the bottom of a barrel next to some Hannah Montana doll hair and decided Read the full post.

Comments (342 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 11
  • SB

    EW.

    I’m so not watching that episode.

  • llevinso

    This makes me very glad that I decided to stop watching this season after Alex, Lilly and Katelyn were eliminated. I won’t have to be subjected to the awfullness that is Miley Cyrus. What were they thinking?

  • Madd

    There are too many rude comments about her I want to post. I can’t decide on just one.
    Oh, how about: “Don’t worry about what the judges say about your voice of look. I have no singing or acting ability at all, dress like a hooker and act like one too…yet I’m still successful!”

    • Madd

      “of” should be “or”

  • PFitz

    Could this season get worse?! She’s going to be a MENTOR?! I mean, it’s one thing for her to perform, but can you imagine being Crystal Bowersox having to pretend to take her advice?

    Did not think this season could get worse. Clearly, my imagination is not very rich.

    • Sally in Chicago

      the producers have lost it.

    • Dana

      American Idol is now a joke. Miley is a MENTOR??? Crystal and Casey probably have more performance experience than she does. Boy, you can really tell how desperate Idol is… pandering to the tweens. Miley, Joe Jonas and Demi Lovato all in the same week? I know there is an AI attraction at Disney, but this is ridiculous. I guess Selena Gomez must be next week’s musical guest! :(

  • Sally in Chicago

    Ugh!

  • ktwolf

    APRIL FOOL! what? no? REALLY?

    • Teclo Bolano

      Ms Ktwolf is not April so I find your query to be specious and odd. Please do not clutter up this otherwised intelligent and deepling felt discustion about the great Punky Brewster and her namesake, Mr Cyrus, with your snivelling inanities.

  • Teclo Bolano

    I dont understand so much acrimony- you are very fortunate in your big country to have such a brilliant performer as Mildy Cyrus- her work on Punky Brewster is phenomenolol good and hugley a good influence on the young girls. This is what is wrong with you big Americans- you don’t appreciate the greatness of your greatest citizens. God Bless you Mr CYrus and thank you for Punky B.

    • Ed

      Punky Brewster? What? You do know it’s 2010, right?

      • Jennifer

        I think Teclo is being funny. I hope so anyway.

      • Timmy

        Well, if it’s an attempt at humor, it is painfully not funny. Stupid.

  • Mandy

    desperate times call for desperate measures? bye, bye American Idol…it was nice while it lasted.

  • Sally in Chicago

    AI is losing youth audience, so they feel this little trollop will help them reel in the teen watchers. Won’t happen. The teens are playing video games, or on the computer doing homework.

  • Isn’t it Obvious

    I just can’t believe they kept Big Mike on this show… he is a terrible singer. His range is awful. The only reason he is on is because he has a good personality and his physical presence takes up the stage. But can he sing? NO!

    • Teclo Bolano

      Big Mike is brilliant. ANd damnably handsome, which is more than I cann say for your Post Isnt It Obvious. His physical prescence is Big and Husky-great, and he can sing too! That’s a plenty big range- bigger than you!

  • Scott

    How can the show be anything but a hilarious trainwreck with her on it? I really want to see the looks of scorn thrown her way.

  • Joe

    Having Miley Cyrus mentor the Idols is like having a stand-up comedian as a judge!……..Oh wait……

    • Shana

      lol zing!

  • Amy

    As annoying as I find Miley Cyrus, I believe that she has a unique voice and is not a poor vocalist. She has singing talent that is much greater than a number of her disney costars, and has undergone musical training. I think that she’ll have legitimate vocal advice to offer to the contestants of American Idol, and the fact that she appeals to a huge number of people (although a relatively narrow audience) is definitely something that the producers of Idol have taken into consideration. Not only can Miley provide advice on entertaining to the contestants, but her presence will attract viewers to a season that has been less than spectacular. She may be a bad role model or the next to follow in Lindsay Lohan’s footsteps; regardless, she has a ridiculous amount of fame, and getting advice on how to obtain that is relevant to every contestant.

  • Gabe Loves Idol

    NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!! Surely they could have found someone, anyone, better than Miley! And I think someone should have to be a decent singer to mentor them. Why don’t they bring in David Cook (he was there last week!), Carrie, Kelly, Chris, Kris or someone from the show? At least we know they can sing!

    • Dana

      What a great idea. Instead of Miley (who got her big break because of her father’s fame), why don’t they get Kelly Clarkson, Carie Underwood or Chris Daughtry as a mentor. At least those three had to go through the AI competition and have sold the most records out of all the Idol alums. And we know that all three of them can actually sing LIVE without sounding like a choking cat!

  • Perkle

    So sad. I think it’s time to find a new show on that time slot. I’ll just watch idolatry and read Slezak’s review. They need to end Idol after this season.

Page: 1 2 3 4 5 11
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP