'American Idol': Kara attacks Simon...'s chest, on the scene at the Top 12 performance night

Seacrest-Simon-IdolAh, the Idoldome. It’s my fourth year recapping the behind-the-scenery at American Idol, and my third inside the double-decker, steel-and-mylar-and-HD-jumboscreens behemoth that is known as the Idoldome. Best I can tell, the set itself hasn’t changed much at all since The Season of Kradison — the only major difference to the studio I caught was the addition of three rows or so to the rear of the audience.

Still, the place never fails to impress with its über-blue ridiculousness. It really does usher in a sense of grand occasion and drama to the Idol experience, and after visiting the intimate and easygoing Idolcupola last week, I understand that even better. In just five scant days, these 12 kids went (if I may venture into a didn’t-research-this-at-all-on-Wikipedia sports metaphor) from a triple-A stadium in Pawtucket to Fenway Park in Boston, and I gotta say, I was expecting it would cause several of them to fly fast and far off the rails, Sanjaya-style. So I’d count the fact that my ears were only inflicted with some bland pitchiness and awkward reggae stylings last night as a victory for Idol Season 9’s first foray into the big leagues.

I arrived inside the Idoldome as crew members were still putting some final touches to the Idoldome’s ThunderScreen, taking my seat underneath the giant neon Idol logo that hangs over the stage right side of the audience for the occasional sweeping wide shot. (I count it a personal victory that, upon noticing said giant logo, I only freaked out about the earthquake that had jolted many in Los Angeles awake that morning for maybe 30 seconds.) The CBS Television City pages dutifully filed people into their seats, while Idol producers taught the Sway Pit how to clap. Band leader Rickey Minor worked the crowd in a page boy cap and sweater vest. I noticed that the neon “meri” on the stage left American Idol spinning globe was flickering. And with 22 minutes to go until airtime, Jay the Substitute Warm Up Comic took to the stage. That’s right, dear readers; no Paula, no Cory the Warm Up Comic, and Kara is still making sense. What is the world coming to? (I understand that Cory will be returning next week, though, so no need to panic.)

Like most other Idol warm up subs, Jay thought it would be hilarious to bring audience members on stage to sing, although he did have standards: “No breathy Whitney Houston; no ‘Amazing Grace.'” After Kiki from Orange County gave up singing Brandi Carlile’s “The Story” after a single line, Jay eventually pulled up a guy who turned out to be Katie Stevens’ brother Ryan, i.e. the kid who brought his college roommates to the Idoldome as Katie’s personal cheering section. Wearing baggy jeans and a tight red polo, Ryan pulled out a solid take on Michael Bublé’s “Everything” that was pretty much better than anything his little sis has pulled off on the show.

With about 10 minutes to go, Jay was all set to start a battle of the sexes dance off when Debbie the Stage Manager stopped him so the production could get a generic shot of the audience, explaining “I think this is in case we have a wardrobe malfunction.” Idol audience perennial Camryn Manheim took her seat literally right in front of me with her unlikely guest, Sugar Ray frontman and onetime Extra host Mark McGrath. (In fact, should you be so inclined, you can see all three of us on camera for a hot second at the start of the show. That’s me clapping pensively behind McGrath.) Debbie then asked everyone to hold up their signs, and other than those adorable Katie heads, I really only caught ones for Crystal and Siobhan. Well, and the signs behind me that read “Forget Ferris, Save Simon Now!” and “Simon Should Stay — Just An Opinion!”

With four minutes to go, Debbie nixed Jay’s attempt to get a mom and dad on stage for another dance off. The Top 12 were brought out, and took their marks for the cold open. Didi and Crystal goofed around waving their arms in the air. Jay asked the crowd “to make some noise” with 30 seconds to go, and then Debbie immediately quieted everyone down. Cue Ryan, cue the moody red lighting, cue the opening credits, cue the Idols’ exit, cue the ThunderScreen, cue the judges’ entrance, cue ThunderStairs, cue Ryan again.

First up: Big Mike Lynche with “Miss You.” As I’ve noticed season after season, the sound mix within the Idoldome makes for a sometimes radically different listening experience than the one you have at home, especially for a big, up-tempo song, when the band is working at top volume. So Big Mike’s on stage dancing shenanigans, while still cheesy, at least matched the band’s intensity in the room. Also intense: Ryan’s sudden decision to get up in Simon’s face about giving Big Mike some constructive criticism. After Simon quipped that the two would “sort this out in my trailer,” one of the drummers did a rimshot. And in case the confrontation wasn’t plainly artificial on camera, the moment we went to an ad break, Simon and Ryan quickly laughed about it and moved on.

As they would for most of the night, the judges left the studio as quickly as possible for the ad breaks, with Ellen often leading the way, her wife Portia de Rossi always close behind, if not directly in hand. During the first ad break, the audience broke out into wild cheers as Ellen passed by, regular cheers as Simon passed by, a few random woo-hoos as Kara passed by, and no discernible change in volume as Randy passed by. Meanwhile, Jay began taking a demographic profile of the audience, asking for applause by kids, teenagers, twentysomethings, and so on, finally handing out dinner for two at a local DoubleTree hotel restaurant to an 81-year-old man sitting in front of me, and an 82-year-old woman across the aisle.

We came back from the break, Didi Benami tore through “Play With Fire,” and as the crew set up for Casey James’ set, the two shared a quick-but-friendly finger point. The band exploded as Casey began “It’s All Over Now,” overpowering the wannabe blues man to the point where his vaunted guitar work was often barely audible. After Ellen (figuratively) winked at the fact that Casey’s long blonde locks don’t do so much for her, Simon (literally) winked back at her with an impish grin while Ryan was giving out Casey’s call-in numbers. And once more, at the ad break Ellen walked off stage with Portia, this time clasping hands as if clinging on for dear life. As Simon and Randy chatted with two unidentified women in row nearest their table, Jay continued his 2010 census of the audience, this time polling the location of the audience’s home towns and everyone’s marital status.

Lacey Brown glided through “Ruby Tuesday,” and Ryan tried once again to make something, anything interesting happen on stage by randomly escorting Lacey around it. The judges vacated once more at the ad break after Simon gave Ellen a friendly shoulder squeeze. Jay moved on to actual birthdays in an attempt to give the youngest kid in the audience an iPod, and Camryn Manheim became vocally outraged when she thought the girl in her row was younger than the one Jay picked — until the snubbed girl’s mom says Jay got it right. Mike McGrath then said to Manheim, “I like your commitment to the contest, though.”

During almost his entire video package, Andrew Garcia held the mic stand as if “Gimme Shelter” could’ve started at any moment and/or it was soothing his nerves about leaving behind his acoustic guitar. After Kara was teased by Simon and Ryan about being too literal and too angry about the lyrics, she stalked off with a wee stank face, while trading some quick words with Simon. Ryan stayed behind to quickly chat with Ellen and give a kiss hello to Portia, and then was stopped so one of the wardrobe peeps could fix his pocket square. If it hadn’t already, Jay’s audience census entered the absurd when he asked “anyone wearing orange to make some noise!” Jay then requested that people who wanted to show off a special skill for an AT&T-related prize first show him their AT&T phones, forgetting that security checked everyone’s mobile at the door. Camryn Manheim decided to remind him: “No phones!” Mark McGrath volunteered that he’d juggle as his special skill; Manheim replied that she’d do sign language.

Katie Stevens eked out a tepid “Wild Horses,” and her brother’s college buddies roared in approval. The judges plodded off stage at the ad break, and Jay gave his mic to Leezette* (*spelling approximate), the (professed) AT&T customer who volunteered to sing the national anthem for her AT&T product-related prize (the identity of which I apparently never wrote down). She began a cappella, and sounded rather good; almost immediately Rickey Minor began bringing in the band section by section, and Leezette finished in grand style with just 30 seconds to go before we went to air. Ryan even jokingly gave out Leezette’s numbers as the judges began filing into their seats. But with all the commotion, Debbie didn’t count the show back from the ad break. With literally just seconds to go, Jay asked the audience for their approval of Leezette’s performance, just barely making it off stage as the Idol back-from-the-break theme ditty began. Whoops!

After Tim Urban’s video package, Simon sat way back in his seat, and during his performance, the Brit looked back at the audience, as if to investigate whether anyone could actually be grooving to the kid’s reggae take on “Under My Thumb.” (The squeals radiating from the Sway Pit would seem to indicate some people were feeling it; that, or that Tim’s form-fitting henley was one savvy sartorial decision.) Kara then asked Simon a question, to which Simon nodded yes, beginning a series of rather inexplicable interactions between the two of them. At the ad break, Kara immediately turned to Simon, thrust both index fingers repeatedly into his chest, and then leaned down to say something into his ear. With her back to me, I couldn’t tell whether Kara was kidding or not, but when she stood back up, Simon looked genuinely chagrined, and Kara quickly left the stage wearing the same stank expression as before. Randy waylaid the slightly dazed Simon to chat, pointing out the “Simon Should Stay — Just An Opinion!” sign while jokingly miming to its owner that she should rip it up.

When Kara entered again, she was talking with Ryan and exchanged just a few quick words with Simon before sitting down. During Siobhan’s Glambertian “Paint It Black,” though, Kara whispered something to Simon that caused him to break into a genuine smile — and that was well before the quirky Massachusetts native’s string of killer power notes. So I guess all was well again? Maybe?

Anyhoots, we went to an ad break. Ryan gave Siobhan’s glasses a quick cute pinch, walked over to Lee, and appeared to go over his penetrating questions about paint color with the nervous rocker. Simon was out of his seat after Lee’s “Beast of Burden” before the ad break outro music had even finished, but Randy took his time to fist bump a kid sitting with the Bowersox contingent before leaving with the other judges. They all quickly returned, Simon and Ellen arm in arm. Paige Miles managed make an actual impression with “Honky Tonk Women,” and Aaron Kelly sounded strong with “Angie” while looking like an 11-year-old kid with no idea about what to do with his arms.

As per usual, Ellen and Portia zipped out at the ad break, but Simon, Kara, and Randy stuck around for a bit to chat up some random bald dude who I think was one of the strategically placed body guards. Camryn Manheim and Mark McGrath took off for reasons passing understanding, leaving just as all four judges re-entered the Idoldome for Crystal Bowersox’s pimp slot performance of “You Can’t Always Get What You Want.” (I should take this moment to note that, unlike every previous season I’ve covered the show, the judges barely spoke to one another during pretty much every single performance, including Crystal’s.) After Mama Sox finished, Simon looked back at a roaring audience with a kind of detached bemusement.

The recap clips played as Debbie lined up the Idols, and out of all of them, Mama Sox seemed by far the most happy-go-lucky of the group, dancing with Paige and joking with Lee about maintaining a wide power stance. The 19 Entertainment logo chirped and the Idols headed off. Debbie kept the audience seated for Ryan to film a quick promo sans jacket, but we couldn’t hear Ryan’s audio, so all I know is that Debbie and another crew member deliberately walked into the shot. Like the pro he is, Ryan nailed it in one take.

And that, dear readers, was what you did not see on TV during my two-and-a-half hours inside the Idoldome. Phew! Tomorrow, I’ll download all the best details on tonight’s results show, but in the meantime, what did you make of the newest Idol Top 12’s first time performing on the big stage? Why do you think Kara was poking at Simon’s chest? And what would you write on your sign if you had a chance to sit inside CBS Television City’s Stage 36?

Comments (144 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 5
  • madduxfan

    It just will not be Idol without Simon. And, who knew, I miss Paula.

    • chrissy

      true, but Ryan’s attempts to make some sort of “drama” on tv with Simon is PAINFUL

      • m-1

        What a jerk Ryan has become. He and Kara are two of a kind – wish they both would leave. I’ll miss Simon.

      • Jennifer

        Ryan has become so damn annoying this year. He is unwatchable.

    • Tarc

      Yeah, it will be the new, vastly improved Idol…

      • lalalalalala

        Ryan is insufferable. Who thought we’d ever miss Dunkleman??

    • Katie G

      I don’t miss Paula, at all …

      • Cari

        I don’t miss Paula, either. And guess what? I doubt I will miss Simon…

      • Avalon

        Me either. I used to get so frustrated with her rambling that I’d fast forward through Paula’s comments. I’ve been enjoying Ellen. Haven’t had to fast forward through her once.

    • michelle/kc

      The show is just not the same without Paula, Kara is just annoying. I wish she would stop compairing the contestants to the actual artists. I mean we all know they are no Mick Jaggar. It’s really not fair and very confusing

      • Lizabeth

        That’s right…and it’s not like they CHOSE to do the Rolling Stones. They had to.

    • Teresa

      Hate Ellen on Idol. She should stick to her own show. Actually she should have stuck to her first TV show.
      Not fond of Kara, but at least she’s better than Ellen.
      Randy – what’s up with him? He seems to have dissolved into the background as soon as Paula left.
      Love Simon, even when he’s being a twit he’s straightforward and honest at least.
      Paula – geez, back in the day when she was spaceyness personified, I never thought I’d miss Paula judging. But I do. She had something that her 2 new substitutes don’t.

      • Sam

        Love Ellen, so refreshing and entertaining. I agree with her most of the time. For someone who doesn’t have music background she’s excellent. Where does your hatred for Ellen coming from Teresa? Bit rude to give advice to someone who has more than 4mln followers on Tweeter and the same number watching her show daily. Are you bitter, jelous or homophob?

    • Devon

      I don’t miss Paula at all. Towards the end, judging time became more about what blather would come out of her mouth or in what way she would have her hands on Simon than it was about helping the contestants. Even Simon this year, while still brutally honest, has become more helpful and positive in his comments without her around. As far as I’m concerned, good riddance.

    • Terri

      I don’t miss Paula. At all.

  • Shelby

    I think that Siobhan and Crystal are really the only stand outs. There are some guys that are good, but none of them are GREAT by any means. I think that Kara is the new Paula. She is sickening the way she hangs all over Simon. Simon has truly been much nicer the last few weeks.

    • tracy

      Ditto !

  • Jennifer

    Wow, the performances obviously sound very different in the theater, ’cause I had no trouble hearing Casey’s guitar work on my tv. That does explain some of the judges’ comments last night.

  • Renee-FL

    Hate the swaybots!!!!!

    • Casey

      They drive me crazy – swaying for no particular reason, clapping out of rhythm – aauugghhh!

    • AnitaT

      Can we blow them up?

    • Mary Beth

      I hate the swaying and the clapping that is so obviously
      forced. It is an insult and distraction to the viewers.

    • Brian

      I find the clapping really annoying and I think it throws some contestants off their rhythm.
      They should be told to hold back until a contestant indicates it is OK.

  • tb

    LOVE your day after idol write ups. Glad I came across them!

  • April C

    Didi was GREAT last night!! She really proved herself to me.
    And I will take Siobhan’s “screeching” any day over Katie, Paige, Lacey or Andrew doing anything.

    • craig

      and please don’t compare Siobhan to Adam…for her sake!!

      • jerri

        Yeah, because Adam did so poorly..NOT

  • tb

    If Crystal Bowersox get’s booted before the final two I will have lost all faith in idol. This season so far on a scale 1-10 been a 2.5 at best. The only good thing about it has been Ellen.

    • Kara-mba

      Word. The moment Bowersox checks out so would I. Not worth the torture, it was bad enough they made her go last last night I was fighting my sleep deprived body to stay awake, at least Shevon(sp?)was entertaining, but man Bowersox is really owning everyone! Rad!

  • UGH


    • UGH

      ..and Kara while you’re at it.

      • jen

        and Randy too please.

      • model44

        ….and Ryan

      • Dominic

        And those red cups. Hate those things.

      • Sam

        Can we get rid if you?

  • laurener

    Still missing Alex. Watch him on Ellen today. AMAZING VOICE. He is performing the Mario song he wanted to do instead of Trouble. Producers talked him out of it. Would have made it into the Top 12 with it. Darn it!!!

    • Meliss

      He’s a good kid, but the “producers talked me out of it” is a copout. It was his decision to listen to the producers opinion that the other song had more voter appeal, he could have trusted his own instincts but he didn’t.

      I like him, but some of the post-boot comments he’s made in interviews have taken a little bit of the shine off of him. And MAN was he ever awkward in his interview on Ellen’s show. Adorable, yes, but painfully awk.

      • wino

        he’s a shy teenage, of course he going to be awkward during his first major tv appearance. i find it refreshing that he’s such a scared puppy. and sorry, i dont think him listening to producers is a copout, more like telling the truth of what goes on behind the scenes. and how much manipulation TPTB really do have.

      • Maria

        I think he is endearingly awkward. I find it refreshing.

      • jlb

        When you’re as green as Alex, of course he will trust the opinion of the producers who’ve been doing this a while. I don’t think it’s a cop-out at all.

  • Kathy

    Love – Siobhan, Crystal and Casey
    Love – Ellen’s humorous jokes
    Love – the rolling stones

    Hate the swaybots
    Hate listening to Kara
    Hate that Simon seems to have already left the show.

    • Gata

      I concur with everything you said…

      will add – that I love Lee’s voice, which he could pull his self together and do some big things with a song or two…

      Nobody else was really memorable for me.

    • Sam

      Spot on Kathy, can’t put it better myself

  • BruceMpls

    My sign would say “Would someone please remind me why I am here”

  • BruceMpls

    Crystal needs to get a headset type mic so she can move around on stage. She’s getting a bit monotonous standing there each song. Not that the other guitar players aren’t getting boring too but I don’t care about them. As Simon would say: “That being said, she did great and is still the one to beat”.

    • Sublime1

      David Cook didn’t need to wander all over the stage. He used his guitar, his voice and his talent. Crystal needs to be exactly who she is and definitely NOT start pandering to the shifting vagaries of Idol judges and fans.

      • Mandy

        Well, she can maybe get rid of those dreadlocks. Her hairs looks dirty, dirty and totally ugly. Hopefully the stylists will get to her soon.

      • Yo

        Well Mandy obv no stylist can fix how ugly and superficial you are. Too bad huh? And NO don’t say you’re pretty, girl we both know you’re not! Snap snap

      • Louise

        Despite popular belief, dreads are not dirty. I think it looks beautiful and totally her.

      • Nshi

        Bowersox DOES look dirty and dingy. But man, can she sing!

      • @Louise

        I disagree, I’ve known many people who’ve worn dreads and they always had lint, fuzz and who knows what else stuck in them. They can’t be washed properly so of course they’re dirty. Common sense tells me that.

    • Sally in Chicago

      Ditto. I’ve been saying that for a while. It’s going to get old and the audience will send her home, early.

      • Kathryn

        I think Crystal is really pretty, actually.

  • mike martin

    The Stones formula calls for a gritty blues oriented rock and roll. 10 of the final 12 contestants butchered their songs worst than a blind meatcutter with St. Vitus Dance. Are the Clapbots returned to the asylum after the show? Season 9 of Idol shows that the wheels are falling off and it’s time to move on. The proof of the show’s demise will be when Simon starts to compliment contestants and Randy gives ebonics a rest and starts using English during their critiques.

    • gerritv

      @mike martin

      10 of the final 12 contestants butchered their songs worst than a blind meatcutter with St. Vitus Dance.

      You’re being too kind. That statement would indicate that 10 out of 12 contestants should some kind of personality on stage. They did not.

      Nice metaphor though.

    • Charlie

      Agree totally. Nothing wrong with different arrangements but please, for goodness sakes, don’t sing the song in a way that you can’t tell what the heck it is!!!

  • darclyte

    Sign: Mama Say Mama Sa Mama Bowersox

    • tvaholic

      I Love That!

  • chrissy

    ugh! someone stop ryan with his PAINFUL posturing. he’s supposed to host! not judge, not instigate even fake fights!

Page: 1 2 3 5
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP