More American Idol

Mar 10 2010 10:11 PM ET

'American Idol' semifinals (Top 8 guys): Who rocked? Who tanked?

It’s all over but Didi Benami’s crying*. Read the full post.

Comments (560 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 13 14 15
  • Philly

    I think Todrick and Andrew should go home and that’s a shame because Andrew was one of my favorites!

    • ed

      Same here, I was very dissapointed that he has not improved or even stay consistent to really be in the game. I am now convinced that he does not have it in him to do more. If there is one guy that may have a chance to the final five is
      Alex, if he learns to settle down and get on with having some fun.

  • Katja

    I have to comment purely on the awesomeness of clicking on your “crackin’” link and finding a picture of a KRAKEN. I actually snorted when I laughed…thanks for that!

  • Chicho

    Im Sorry But Big Mikes Performance Was Not All That.. It Was’nt Bad It Was Alright But To Cry, C’mon Kara What The Hell Has Gotten Into You I See Behaving Like Paula More & More As The Weeks Go By…Keep It Real!!!!

  • Final Word

    Todrick and Tim need to go home. Period. End of discussion.

  • LLona

    After Adam Lambert – everyone sounds bad. Adam’s talent ruined it for everyone else. They all sound bad this year except the girl Bowersox.

  • nointrospec

    Every time I think Kara is getting better as a judge, she does something like produce tears for a mediocre performance. The judges aren’t doing Mike any favors telling how madly wonderful he is when he’s just okay/good. What’s up with the judges? I know this is a pretty poor season for guys, but trying to pretend the talent is better than it really is, does not take them off the hook for selecting these guys.

  • naynay

    Oh no, they didn’t. Aaron and Tim get to stay and Alex is gone. Paige gets to stay and Katelyn is gone? What is going on? It is going to be just like the year Melinda Dolittle didn’t win, if Chrystal Bowersox gets elminated I will never watch again. And I know nobody cares if I watch or not. But I am pissed!@

    • Tim

      Yeah, “Worst Season Ever”. Has to be said.

      I like Crystal but she’s about the only one left to care about. Everyone else is too raw. No “Star power” yet.

      Lee D is nice but just isn’t Daughtry or Cook. Aaron is no Archie.

      I liked Alex a lot, not yet even a Kris Allen but he had potential.

      • naynay

        Yeah, lots of potential. I just wanted to give Alex a hug, he looked so upset.

  • t

    OMG…Big Mikes performance was perfect and he deserves his spot in the top 12. Have any of you haters ever listened to “This Woman’s Work” probably one of the hardest songs to sing…all I see on these posts are a bunch of ignorant people trying to comment and disrespect people who are giving their soul to this competition when none of us carry the talent to do what they do!

  • Janice

    Thank you for bringing back Andrew, to remain in the finalists, because I was so worried that he would be gone last night, and that save the night. I just hope that Idol continues to make him through the finalists. He’s still, in my heart, the winner.

  • Wicked Glitter

    Well at least this year I don’t feel sick to my stomach worrying that Adam Lambert could get voted off. I will stop watching if Casey goes though.

  • sofiane

    Bring Alex Lambert Back on Idol! We might influence Fox!
    Sign the petition and spread it around through facebook and twitter! Join the movement!
    http://www.change.org/actions/view/bring_alex_lambert_back_on_american_idol

  • Melvin Bazer

    I can see why Simon is leaving, writing is on the wall. Idol is dead, Let”s go to America got Talent.

Page: 1 13 14 15
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP