More American Idol

Mar 9 2010 09:06 PM ET

'American Idol' semifinals (Top 8 women): Who's going home on Thursday?

Eight women enter, six women leave! Not to go all Mad Max on you so soon after listening to the mellifluous sounds of American Idol‘s Read the full post.

Comments (384 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 12
  • Sheila

    So far this season of AI is sucking and blowing at the same time. Finding it dull and boring. zzzzzzzzz!

  • corkykep

    Katie stevens i think deserves a spot in the top 12, everyone is forgetting the game changes as they are forced to sing stylized themed music, so this could pose a problem for people like lily, and people like lacey, but benefit people like katelyn, katie. Katie however has been misguided by the judges over and over, she is by far one of the strongest singers

    • psychoanalyzer

      true, true…

    • Doreen

      I agree with you. What bothers me is that all the other contestants can sing songs from the 50′s and 60′s and she was torn apart for singing Michael Buble which I thought was a great performance.Patsy Cline is from the 40′s and 50′s. The problem with Katie is she is listening to the judges. She should just sing what she likes.

  • DivA

    Crystal and Siobhan FTW – both ladies have AWESOME voices, show great stage presence and rock the house!!

  • John

    Who cares?

    • DivaSoulSista

      If you didn’t care, why would you read the article and then comment?

  • gerritv

    I think Lacey & Paige will be going home.

    I didn’t get how they can tear down Siobhan & Katelyn & build up Lacie. Do they really want atrocious singers in the top 12?

    Randy sure has a lot of ‘favorite songs of all time’.

  • James Allen

    Paige was horrible, but Didi completely butchered the Fleetwood Mac song. She took a haunting melody and rhythm and completely changed it up and ruined it for no good reason. I thought her performance was going to be great, because that’s how it started off, but then she started taking liberties with the melody and phrasing, and she just left me cold.

    Katie has a great, powerful, strong, competent, sultry adult-sounding voice, but she just doesn’t have “it.” She unfortunately doesn’t make me feel anything. It’s not her age cuz Archuleta was the same age and he sometimes sent chills up my spine when he sang.

  • Travis

    Paige and Katie should GTFO – but I agree, it’ll probably be Paige and either Lacey or Katelyn.

    • Joe

      Katelyn better not be booted, dammit! If anything, foddery Paige should go and meh Lacey should follow suit.

  • dru

    Crystal was tops. Siobhan is alright.

    From there it gets worse with some unskilled and some just a mess. There was too much overlap in “artistic” style for the girls this year. It’s boring.

  • Gen of Montreal

    Please remove Ellen from the panel. Each week she proves that she does not belong there. The fact that you love music and are a fan of the show does not give you the credentials to be there; if it does, then why not pick a random person in the audience for each show. This week she said to Katie that she chose the right song but then ripped her apart for not connecting to the lyrics. Pick a side lady and stay there.

  • Ben

    Didi was really, really good. “Rhiannon” is NOT an easy song to sing and she was able to take away the harmonies from the song without stripping away the melody. Great!

  • ObiHave

    Don’t care who goes home as long as it’s not Crystal. She’s so incredible it hurts.

  • chuck

    I can;t believe you people think their are any real singers on this show outside of Crystal , her soulful Janis Joplin like vocal,s are mine blowing, as for the rest, take away the back up singers and they all sound like shit, If you people would like to see real singing contest , tune in to Mr. Kirk Franklin Gospel show on BET, the worst singer on that show would make any girl or boy, with exception of Crystal, sound like a dog with a bone stuck in their throat.

  • Mark in FL

    Hopefully the Top 6 girls will be Crystal, Siobhan, Lilly, Katelyn, Didi and Katie. Lacey and Paige will go home.

  • Suenee

    Going to Semi Finals
    1)Crystal
    2)Siobhan
    3)Lilly
    4)Katelyn
    5)Didi
    6)Paige/Katie

    Going Home
    Lacey and Katie/Paige

  • Wren

    I’m concerned about MamaSox. She sounded AMAZING, as usual, but kinda looked as though she might collapse. take care of yourself girl!!!

    • Anna

      I adore her, and want her to stay healthy (most importantly) so she can continue to sing!

Page: 1 2 3 4 5 12
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP