More 'Survivor' Central

Dec 17 2009 12:05 AM ET

'Survivor': Ranking all the seasons (including 'Samoa') from best to worst

Whether you love or loathe Evil Russell, most people agree that this season of Survivor: Samoa has been a good one. Read the full post.

Comments (215 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 6 7 8
  • Adrian

    1 – Palau
    2 – Cook Islands
    3 – The Amazon
    4 – Tocantins
    5 – Micronesia
    6 – Guatemala
    7 – Samoa
    8 – Marquesas
    9 – Borneo
    10 – The Australian Outback
    11 – Gabon
    12 – Fiji
    13 – China
    14 – Pearl Islands
    15 – Africa
    16 – Panama: Exile Island
    17 – Vanuatu
    18 – All Stars
    19 – Thailand

  • Sachi

    My favorite seasons were Pearl Islands- Sandra was a great underrated winner with excellent villains, blindsides, twists, and characters

    Cook Islands- also a beautiful location, the Aitu 4 dominance made for great TV as well as other funny moments like Billy’s declaration of love- Yul and Ozzy were the best final two ever

    Tocantins- Taj,and Stephen rank very high up as my favorite survivors and the location was breathtaking, I loved Sierra and Coach was hilarious

    The others, China was great because of James’s epic fail, Todd’s scheming and Jaime’s stupidity- the location was miserable though

    dont like Russell so Samoa was a snooze, great characters and winner on Africa.(Guatemala, Panama, Palau, Vanuatu all kind of blur together for me)

  • John

    Almost all of my synopsis’ are going to end in, except for the winner, I find the sole survivors to be a little undeserving most of the time. In my eyes, there are 2 series of Survivor, Borneo-Fiji and China-Nicaragua. Game play in the first half was about Outplay and in the second it is about Outwit, that is why I like the sarcastic, witty humor of the second half to be more entertaining.

    Micronesia: The best cast, the fans vs. favorites concept was amazing, amazing blindsides, and the best final 2. Also, Parvati = best survivor ever.

    Heroes Vs. Villains: What should be considered the only All-Stars season on account that they played like All-Stars. Parvati’s double hidden immunity idol play is easily the best move in Survivor history.

    China: Probably the best cast, aside from seasons with past survivors, great challenges, great
    blindsides. Courtney. That’s all I have to say.

    Palau: The only season pre-China with a great cast, great challenges, good ending. The only downside was Ian being ridiculous about his love for Tom in the Final 3 challenge.

    Gabon: Such a great cast, Sugar in Gabon was the best storyline the show has had, just a bad ending. Also, best landscape in my opinion. I really love the landlocked seasons because the water challenges aren’t just swimming and retrieving.

    Samoa: The Natalie edit triumphing over her ally Russell made this season amazing to watch.

    Tocantins: Aside from the Final 3 challenge and the winner, an underrated season. Also, I loved the addition of wearing your tribe color.

    Exile Island: A decent twist that they kept around for the right amount of time, Cirie’s move to get rid of Courntey sits at a brilliant second place for the best move, in my book.

    Now for the not so good…

    Nicaragua: Started off great, some of the best pre-merge episodes. Once they hit the merge, terrible. Brenda, Alina, Jane, and Marty were the only ones that should have proceeded, and only Jane did. Also, the medallion of power was dumb and boring. I hate that they brought in a celebrity for ratings.

    Outback: Such a boring season, and Colby ruined this season by taking Tina, she didn’t earn it, he did, but she did deserve it once he brought her. Amber and Elizabeth were the only ones who did it for me.

    All-Stars: Boring to watch, all this was was a Rupert showcase where he did nothing. I did love that such an underrated person won though, go Amber.

    Thailand: Not a single good character in the lot, boring boring boring, also, I do not understand the obsession with Shii Ann. The only season I didn’t watch religiously.

    Fiji: The most boring season, worst final 3, oh yeah, this is the season that started that stupid tradition.

  • Kathy

    I agree with some of the ranking. I would definetely put All-Stars in the top 5. I thought it was AWESOME! Robfather, Lex being bitter, everything was great and I loved the commentaries on the DVD’s. I would also put Gabon, Tochantins, and China higher.

  • Deni

    Heroes Vs Villains. Russell and Parv were great! Lol

Page: 1 6 7 8
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP