Dec 14 2009 01:00 PM ET

Guilty Pleasures Semifinals: 'My Super Sweet 16' vs. 'Dog the Bounty Hunter'

We’re in the Semifinals of our Guilty Pleasures Reality TV Showdown (see full bracket here).

Semifinals, “Real” Lives: My Super Sweet 16 vs. Dog the Bounty Hunter

My Super Sweet 16 Dog the Bounty Hunter

Here’s what some fans had to say during the first round of voting:

“et” on My Super Sweet 16: “I don’t think I’m exaggerating when I say My Super Sweet Sixteen is proof of the end of Western civilization. (That’s not to say I haven’t seen the entirety of most of the early seasons.)”

Cowboy Roy on Dog the Bounty Hunter: “It should be a crime to be able to kick so much ass. And the Dogisms … don’t even get me started!”

Relive some classic moments on video — and vote — after the jump.

My Super Sweet 16


Dog the Bounty Hunter


Tell us in the comments below why you love the show you voted for.

Vote in more EW Guilty Reality-TV Pleasures semifinal matchups:
Real Housewives of New Jersey
vs. Say Yes to the Dress
Cheaters
vs. Rock of Love
Flavor of Love
vs. Temptation Island

Comments (69 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 5
  • ANN KLIPPLE

    IF I COULD I WOULD WATCH DOG THE BOUNTY HUNTER EVERY NIGHT

    • Marion Wright

      I agree I could watch Dog every night. I do watch viedo on a&e. They have Wednesday dog. Cool

      • sherrill benson

        I also would watch Dog every night.The best show on tv.

    • spokane sparky

      ARE YOU KIDDING ME??WHY ARE WE EVEN HAVING THIS PINK TWITT HERE ANYWAY…CAST MY VOTE FOR BETH &
      HER BIG DADDY DOG THE BOUNTY HUNTER. LAW & ORDER SUV WOULD HAVE BEEN A BETTER RACE THEN SPOILED KIDS TO FOLLOW…NO WONDER YOUNG ONE’S HAVE NO GOOD MENTORS TO FOLLOW…FOLLOW BETH…FOR HONOR, GRACE & DIGNITY…PEACE 2 ALL…

  • darclyte

    There is no way on God’s green earth that I could show ANY support for that “Sweet 16″ showcase of obnoxiously entitled spoiled behavior. I’ve only seen the one clip of the show of the girl who got a new car and it was the “wrong color” and that was one scene too many. Epic fail.

    • Putrid 16

      I’d most like a hybrid of the two where Dog goes gunning for the pieces of trash from Sweet 16. Get those wastes of life off of the streets!

  • Dog Fan

    I love the Dog show. Not only is the Hawaiian and Colorado scenery awesome, but the theme behind the whole show is to get the bad guys and to turn them away from their bad ways if possible. What’s not to like?

    • Candie

      Dog the bounty hunter best show EVER..theres suspense,family love & loyalty,justice & laughter..LOVE THE SHOW

    • kayla

      i love dog so much..he helps so many people out..i just love dog and the family so much ..i watch it every wedensday..i was even him for halloween.next year is leland

  • Beverley

    Sweet 16 (and pretty much everything else on MTV these days) shows the absolute worst in America’s youth of today. They behave terribly, have bad attitides, expect everything to be given to them for nothing and have little to no parenting. Parents who let their 16 year old kids stay overnight in a hotel with their boyfriend should be investigated by the police. And to think that these kids will be the future of America sometime is tragic. Not one of them is prepared to be let loose on the world. Their parents must be so proud.

  • Dee

    The plastic surgery has worked out well for Beth.

  • Kelly Jack

    Dog and his family are a rare thing. They are bounty hunters, yes, but they also genuinely CARE about the people they capture. They know what its like because they have been there and they ALWAYS try to find the BEST in even the baddest! If I was a criminal (which i’m not) I would want to be captured by Beth and Dog and the rest of the Chapmans. Keep up the good work and I’m voting for Beth too for Mrs. December twitter!

  • Crissy

    Champans and Family all the way.. The do an awesome job and deserves the best… Keep up the great work getting the bad guys off the street…hugs and loves

  • Lynn

    Hands down best show on TV.

  • Crissy

    They do an awesome job.. sorry for the typo

  • isis

    I love Dog the bounty hunter n his family he is not only the best at wat he does but they r amazing role models n they r a tight nit fams they r absolutely amazin they r not judgemental n they try 2 help those that want 2 b help n that is indeed rare n not 2 mention they r all gorgeous ppl too I love the Chapmans I am their biggest fan holla

  • Susan C

    Hands down, Dog the bounty Hunter. I couldn’t watch a bunch of brats tuning 16. Dog & his crew are real hard working people. Plus the boys are easy on the eyes:-)

  • Joe

    Shows about spoiled teenagers make me sick. Sombody needs to slap the crap out of those brats. I vote Dog all the way.

  • Stacey

    Dog & Crew all the way…genuine people doing their part to make this country a better & safer place! Though I could honestly do without the superficial bs of Beth..I don’t see as much sincerity with her attitude as I do with Dog’s blood family. She would fit in better with the “Sweet 16″ cast members. Hard to believe someone as REAL as the DOG is in love with someone so FAKE..but then again, maybe he had no prenup so he has to put up with it…regardless, his kids are awesome!

  • Linda

    I have a teenage daughter, I don’t need to watch a show about teenage girls. It’s Dog the Bounty Hunter all the way!!!!

  • suzanne tyler

    DOG THE BOUNTY HUNTER ROCK’S IT SHOWS A GREAT FAMILY THAT IS DOING THERE HARDEST TO STAMP OUT DRUG’S AND VIOLENCE,THEY ARE TRY TO KEEP THERE LITTLE PEICE OF HEAVEN CLEAN! WE COULD DO WITH PEOPLE LIKE THIS IN THE UK TO SHOW OUR KIDS THAT DRUG’S AND VIOLENCE ONLY LEAD TO ONE THING,PRISON!

Page: 1 2 3 5
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP