Our time has come, procedural watchers. This is Beat Cop, and it’s our TV watch. Well, it’s a mini-watch…in PopWatch…and we’ll cover lots of shows instead of getting all precious about just Lost or Fringe, but we’re doing God’s work here, ladies and gents.
No really! The hallmark of the procedural fan is that we have an overdeveloped sense of justice. We seek resolution, answers. We like our bad guys nabbed, diseases diagnosed, cases closed. It’s not that we mind continuing storylines—we like our cops, docs, investigators, and fake psychics to have personalities (even Columbo had a missus to whom he frequently referred, even if her spin-off wasn’t quite worthy of the man, himself). But there’s something about wrapping up misery and mystery in a neat little bow at the end of an hour that just feels satisfying.
So here’s what we’ll do: We’ll meet here twice a week (let’s start with Mondays and Fridays and see how that goes) and discuss our favorite procedurals. It’ll be a mix of review and preview, in that if I’ve seen an episode, I’ll tell you about it in as spoiler-free a manner as possible. Otherwise, we’ll just chat about what happened on CSI, Lie to Me, NCIS, and myriad other shows. Understand, though, this is an advocacy blog, which means I’m not even aiming for fair. I’ll talk about Castle more than I should because I adore that show (seriously, the chemistry between Nathan Fillion and Molly C. Quinn makes them cutest damned father/daughter pair on television). I’ll coo over Criminal Minds Kirsten Vangsness’s flirty banter with Shemar Moore, and make snippy comments that Richard Belzer and Ice-T don’t get nearly enough face time on Law and Order: SVU. I’ll ask you to explain–since somebody needs to tell me–why I just can’t seem to get into Cold Case even though I watch literally every other network procedural out there. We’ll talk.
So let me tell you what I know so far:
House (Fox, tonight at 8pm)
This two-hour episode is an unequivocal must watch, especially for those of us who caught those stellar last 15 minutes of the season ender. Okay, I’m gonna have to break the rules and drop a spoiler about that finale: House is the krazy! His hallucinations bled so far over into real life, he’d imagined that he kicked Vicodin and slept with Cuddy. Now he’s in a mental hospital doing what he does best—no, not medicine, instigating. He’s supposedly there voluntarily, but the nurse won’t let him check out without the doctor’s okay, and guess who the doctor is? Andre Braugher (squeal implied). There are few actors out there who can go toe to toe with Hugh Laurie and not look like the lesser being. Braugher is in that very tiny group. And you gotta love the way House voices his displeasure at being detained by Dr. Andre: “Wow, and he’s black! I thought you’d be a little more sensitive on the slavery issue.”
NCIS: Los Angeles (CBS, Tuesday at 9pm)
Okay, no, they don’t have the fun, light feel of the original…yet. But what they’ve got is a very cool new set, one of those super fancy computer thingies like out of Minority Report (which they let me play with when I was on-set, so now I love them), and Oscar winner Linda Hunt. Let me repeat that: Oscar winner Linda Hunt. Her line delivery alone is worth giving the show a chance, and the season premiere has a few nice surprises. Hey, we’re friends, right? So I can tell you things. Like that time this summer when I was alone with L.L. Cool J in his trailer, and it was all I could do not to rub my hands all over his sexy, glorious, shiny…bald head. He’s a seriously positive dude, but I still don’t think he’d have taken kindly to being molested for EW’s Fall TV Preview. Oh, but I wanted to.
The Mentalist (CBS, Thursday at 10pm)
It’s a fairly standard ep, so I won’t waste much breath on it other than to say the first five minutes have a nice sense of style. I always wonder how much of what Jane (Simon Baker) does could possibly be replicated. I watched that British series, Derren Brown: Mind Control, and that guy got total strangers to hand over their wallets within, like, 30 seconds. It was insane. Check out this little bit with him and one my many imaginary boyfriends, Simon Pegg.
As for what I haven’t seen, we need to make sure we check in with three CBS shootings: Delko (Adam Rodriguez) on CSI: Miami (tonight at 10 pm), Hotchner (Thomas Gibson) on Criminal Minds (Wednesday at 9 pm), and the bullets at the bar on CSI: NY, right after Criminal Minds. And of course, please, please sit in for Castle (ABC, tonight at 10pm). Castle (Fillion) is diggin’ in Beckett’s (Stana Katic) mama’s murder, and at least in the short term I don’t see that going well.
So that’s it for our first edition. We’ll have a lot to talk about Friday, so let’s regroup then, Coppers. And hey—let’s be careful out there.
Photo Credit: Larry Watson/Fox








Hah! You are manna from Internet heaven. I’ve spent the last 12 hours (not consecutively, mind you) defending my beloved Criminal Minds from various Haters. Nice to have a little sanctuary/an advocate. I’ll definitely be back. (If I remain conscious through the *squee* that must necessarily ensue at 9 PM Weds.)
How is this possible that there are CM haters? Who are these people who do not appreciate abhorrent violence and twisted mental defects? Who ARE they?
Those of us who A) found the few episodes they watched to be misogynistic and/or B) completely filled with silly plot twists that didn’t make sense.
Granted, I only watched about half the first season before giving up, so maybe it got better, but it is one of the few procedurals I do not watch.
Meredith nailed the two big reasons I loathed Criminal Minds for a while. I have to admit it has a sharp ensemble, even without Mandy Patinkin. CM’s not so bad in small doses nowadays, but I’d rather watch Dexter and reruns of L&O: SVU (and maybe a bit of CSI) for my criminal pathology fix.
Oh, man. Thank you so much! Can’t wait to get gleeful over all the procedurals I watch (last count: five, with NCIS: Los Angeles on my must see list).
Oh, how I’ve missed your ‘What to Watch,’ so I’m glad to have you back on a regular basis. I’ll be tuning into ‘House,’ and I’m dying to see Laurie and Braugher go toe-to-toe.
Thanks, Via! And ohhhhh, Braugher is so good. I have not been an entirely whole person since Homicide went off the air.
i am loving this!
Yes. Someone who isn’t going to be all snobbish about procedurals. And, also for knowing that the characters on procedurals can have personalities.
Yes…another procedurals fan! I’m a fan of almost every procedural that CBS has (except for NCIS – though may check out NCIS: Los Angeles)and of House and Bones so I’m glad that I’ll have a place to read about all of them. Looking forward to all the premieres this week!
House is awesome, he rocks. I love NCIS and i’m really looking forward to NCIS: L.A. The Mentalist is great, Simon Baker is hilarious.
Alynda Wheat I’m also a Criminal Minds fan! I appreciate that you are taking the time to actually advocate it. Who hates the show? Someone from TVGUIDE with the name M. R. He’s a TOTAL jerk face. CM may not get EMMYs, but believe it or not it has gotten praise from those in the FBI AND has won awards for actual depiction at FBI ceremonies. It’s not treated FAIRLY, and CBS treats the show like crap, as it is the INVISIBLE step-child.
CBS ignores Criminal Minds? Really? You could’ve fooled me. Although I’m not a fan of the show, it’s better written and earns stronger ratings than the humorless and emotionally sterile CSI: NY. Also, when CBS should’ve been advertising Jericho’s second season more during the writer’s strike, CM got all the attention (and yes, I’m still bitter). That’s one of the last things I expected to hear.
Oops, I meant ACCURATE depiction.
oh you have made me so so happy with the criminal minds love.
Criminal Minds? Is that on opposite of SVU now? Hmm, sorry, I can’t go with the CM love…unless, of course, you’re talking Chris Meloni. Gotta go with your first true love, people, and SVU is it for me! So yeah, Belz doesn’t get enough screen time, true, but really, Marish and Chris are just too darn good to keep off screen for too long. Season 11 kicks off in two days…I’m pumped!
I don’t have my DVR anymore so I am gonna have to miss “HOUSE” due to the fact that I am a 58yr old hooked on “ONE TREE HILL”
I don’t have my DVR anymore so I am gonna have to miss “HOUSE” due to the fact that I am a 58yr old hooked on “ONE TREE HILL” and “GOSSIP GIRL” and I’m African-American too! Maybe the gay aspect of my person might help explain it.I also have to miss my favorite comedy “TWO AND A HALF MEN”. I feel like screaming. Shout out to JON CRYER for finally snaging that Emmy.
Yay! As someone who is an avid procedural watcher (I currently watch about a dozen or so of them and favorite fandom at the moment is probably NCIS), I love this idea and look forward to the discussions.
I’m so looking forward to House and Castle tonight!
I’m there! I’m a total CSI/L&O geek. I also love House and NCIS (LA is the only new show I’ll be adding this season).