Still flummoxed over the early ouster of Natalie Reid on So You Think You Can Dance? So are we. On the latest episode of Must List Live!, Annie Barrett and I discuss the dancers we were sorry to see not make the top 20. Also on tap: We mourn the death of dignity for I’m a Celebrity…Get Me Out ofHere! participant Lou Diamond Phillips, fear for 10 more years of bad John Travolta movies, and hang out with the force of nature that is Neil Patrick Harris (straight off his triumphant Tony Awards hosting gig), Not only that, but we’re giving away a FREE Comic-Con prize giveaway, including passes to theconvention, a hotel room, and entrance to our exclusive Entertainment Weekly Comic-Con party for a lucky winner and their even luckier friend. (The always sexy contest rules can be found right here.) So if you are a lover of So You Think You Can Dance, sad-sack celebrities on second-rate reality shows, Neil Patrick Harris, or scoring awesome freebies, then click on the video below for a heaping helping of all of the above. And say it with me: Natalie Reid was robbed!!!
Jun 8
2009
04:05 AM ET
Must List Live!: Who was robbed on 'SYTYCD'? Plus, Tonys host Neil Patrick Harris stops by!
- Comments 23
- Add comment
Latest News
Most Commented
Top 5 Most Read
- Blue Ivy Carter makes her photo debut. Commence your freak-out now.
- ‘Star Wars: The Clone Wars’: Darth Maul is an angry, angry Sith in new pre-’Phantom Menace’ teaser —…
- This Week’s Cover: ‘The Vampire Diaries’ stars talk about the red-hot Damon-Elena-Stefan triangle
- ‘NCIS,’ ‘Once Upon a Time,’ ‘Fringe,’ ‘Vampire…
- Star Wars Galaxy
Natalie did fall apart during her performance, but her practice session with Brandon looked great. I would have liked to see if she had not done great before then. She was nowhere near as cute as Katee, so casting might have let her go for that reason, too.
Last year I was disappointed that Evan was not through and Brandon, too. I’m not really disappointed this year.
Natalie was sooo robbed, but I think they are just setting up something for next season. Ryan should have had Tony’s spot.
Natalie was so robbed, but I think they were just setting up something for next season. Ryan should have had Tony’s sopt.
sorry i think the dancers they picked were great, and deserved to be there, now lets see if there all as good as last years
What I don’t understand is why was she just cut and not given a chance to “dance for her life” as some of the other contestants that did not perform up to par? She may not have been as strong as she was in the practice session, but she should have been given the same second chance as some of the others. She would have made it. AND WHAT IS MIA’S problem with Brandon, the man killed it in everything!
1) Natalie’s cut seemed oddly abrupt — and yes, she was robbed. She didn’t even have a chance to “dance for her life?” Or was it just a case of REALLY BAD EDITING??
2) So how would you rate the Tony Awards hosting job done by Neil Patrick Harris? Take the poll here:
http://movies-tv-entertainment.blogspot.com/
What is wrong with the site? I’ve been waiting for the video to load and it’s not coming up? I wanna win that ComicCon prize pak!
Video won’t load for me, anyone else?
Yoli – Mia was the same way with Danny. I think if they don’t visibly bow to the “genius” of Mia, she thinks they have an attitude problem.
If you can’t get it to load with Internet Explorer, try Firefox. That fixed the problem for me!
Lythgoe should fire Mia Michaels and set an example. There is a huge difference between tough love and a nasty, bitter hater. Her Emmy went to her head. Her head in turn shoved itself in her a$$.
She was robbed! She seemed to be cut very rashly when other dancers got 2nd and 3rd chances…..i still don’t understand it. Her example with Brandon was so good, it was weird that the actual choreography performance was weak. BUT i still think she should have gotten through. she’s awesome!
Natalie Reid Season 6!
Natalie Reid robbed, I don’t think so. I never cared for her dancing. Looks like she is a having a seizure – and I love contemporary dancing. The one I feel for is the Asian ballet dancer. His dancing was beautiful. And why is Mia and Lil’ C being so hard on Brandon? I hope Mia is busting Brandon chops because she has a brilliant routine on the horizon for him.
I am totally lovin’ a gal from Aurora, CO, blonde Kaylee? I think is her name. She is very amazing! I hope she goes far. I too am not impressed with Mia’s critiques. She pretty much just says I don’t like your dancing, and gives no helpful critism at all.
WE were all robbed since we had to listen to Mia’s bitter, jealous comments instead of a supportive honest judge.