According to Variety, Jack Nicholson is in talks to join James L. Brooks' upcoming untitled romantic comedy starring Reese Witherspoon, Paul Rudd, and Owen Wilson. Nicholson would play Rudd's father, a role that Bill Murray was initially considering but has apparently abandoned.
If you ask me, Nicholson and Murray are both ridiculously cool choices to be anyone's dad. But which of the two more resembles Rudd? Take a look at these photos and judge for yourself.








Bill Murrary. Sucks that he’s not doing it.
Definitely Bill Murray! The resemblance is there and plus he (to me anyway) is much funnier than Nicholson.
Bill Murrary. Sucks that he’s not doing it.
Jack. Rudd is sarcastic. It just makes more sense.
Bill Murray, for sure!
I love Jack, but Bill Murray is by far the better choice. It just suits the character better.
Steve Martin!
Jack, of course. Murray looks like he could be Rudd’s grandfather or great-grandfather. As far as comedy, Nicholson can do anything and do it well!
Please visit the best site ever! Celeb-king,com All your favorite celebs exposed!
Scandals & Sex Tapes, Paparazzi / Oops, Nude Movie Caps, Top Celebs Reviews!
Current Content Count: +150.000 Pics, +15.000 Movs, Total +20.000 Celebrities on site, Updates Every Single Day..
Join for 1$ only using this link!!!
http://www.celeb-king.com/main.php?id=6466&site=13&tr=13
Please visit the best site ever! Celeb-king,com All your favorite celebs exposed!
Scandals & Sex Tapes, Paparazzi / Oops, Nude Movie Caps, Top Celebs Reviews!
Current Content Count: +150.000 Pics, +15.000 Movs, Total +20.000 Celebrities on site, Updates Every Single Day..
Join for 1$ only using this link!!!
http://www.celeb-king.com/main.php?id=6466&site=13&tr=13
Please visit the best site ever! Celeb-king,com All your favorite celebs exposed!
Scandals & Sex Tapes, Paparazzi / Oops, Nude Movie Caps, Top Celebs Reviews!
Current Content Count: +150.000 Pics, +15.000 Movs, Total +20.000 Celebrities on site, Updates Every Single Day..
Join for 1$ only using this link!!!
http://www.celeb-king.com/main.php?id=6466&site=13&tr=13
I like them both, but Murray is the better choice IMO
I vote for Murray. I do not like Nicholson, and I can’t stomach watching him in a movie. Hollywood, don’t make me miss a Paul Rudd movie by casting Jack Nicholson in it. popculturecurmudgeon.wordpress.com
Looks wise, there’s not much similarity between any of them. But comic wise and personality and acting wise, I’d definitely go with Bill Murray!
Bill Murray for sure. Not that it matters who plays his dad: as you’ve pointed out before, who DOESN’T love Paul Rudd??