Fingers crossed that American Idol‘s decision to go back — way back — in musical time for an evening of songs popularized by the Rat Read the full post.
Apr 28
2009
04:22 PM ET
'American Idol': What should the Top 5 sing for 'Rat Pack' Night?
- Comments 176
- Add comment








ooh…duet week! would love to see Adam and Alison doing a little Fleetwood Mac or maybe Kris and Matt doing a little Sinatra/Bing Crosby…Kris doing the smooth and Matt doing his little runs and changes…okay enough, never gonna happen…especially with Kara (A.K.A. death of a live show on time)
kris allen allen allen allen…….
ADAM LAMBERT WILL WIN….
ADAM ADAM ADAM ADAM…..
WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOoo….
GO ADAM LAMBERT! He’ll win for sure.
Adam…. WILL WIN.
Though, I hear train wrecks, I hope I’m wrong. For the group numbers I think they should do something from “On The Town” or “Guys and Doll(s).
Ok I just watched the first performer which was Kris, and I totally agree with Simon. Kris didn’t step up his game at all. It was a typical mediocre to good performance, nothing special at all. I was shocked that other judges went completely overboard with praise that was totally undeserved. It’s almost like they care more about getting the audience applause than giving criticism. Judging by the audience reaction they didn’t think much of the performance, only Kris’ friends and family were standing and applauding. That performance was a B- at best. He looked nice in his suit though.
Is this a joke?
If you can sing, sing.
If you cant, the judges will say you can. Sorry America……..
Yes Las Vegas will take you……
Adam and Allison………
I’d love to know who started the “2 songs each” rumor! I thought it was too soon for that…and it was.
Actually, it said that on the Idol website! (That they would be singing two songs each.) When you click on the little boxes that are just previews for the back drops that change, if you leave your cursor there, a message pops up and that’s what it was. I was very dissapointed…I thought it would have been a good week and time for them to do two songs each to see who really was in 5th place.