Actually, to be technically accurate, the above headline should read "trying to make sense of American Idol‘s top 36. Read the full post.
Feb 16
2009
03:42 PM ET
'Idolatry': Making sense of American Idol's top 36
- Comments 52
- Add comment
Latest News
- 'Revenge': Gabriel Mann live chat tonight!
- 'Great Gatsby' trailer's 'Zeigfeld' folly
- 'Men in Black 3': EW movie review
- 'G.I. Joe: Retaliation' pushed to 2013
- 'On the Road': EW movie review at Cannes
- 'Moonrise Kingdom': EW movie review
- 'Snow White': 'The Huntsman' has his say
- Phillip Phillips: Post-'Idol' surgery?
Tatiana was the best female vocalist.
I am sorry to see that she did not make the cut. However, I think that she will be in the final three that will make it afer all. I hope so. In addition to her beautiful voice she has STAR quality. Another Elizabeth Taylor. Don’t let it get you down girl you keep on going to the top!!!
Not only was Tatianna the most irritating and obnoxious contestant I’ve seen but I thought she was going to explode and slap someone when the learned she was ‘out’. While Danny sang the show off, she was the ONLY one not clapping or smiling or swaying or making any kind of attempt at being a graceful loser. For a minute, I thought she was going to go stomping off the stage! don’t let the doorknob get stuck in there Tatty.
Am I the only person that believes that DANNY GOKEY has a MASSIVE EGO. He is so full of himself. Nothing like the humble David Cook that won our hearts in season 8. I would much rather see the humble and sweet ALexis Grace win then Danny with his massive ego. He is talented but FULL OF HIMSLEF.
Idol is a joke what does Paula or Randy know about singing or talent? Jamar should be on instead of Casey. This show is a joke!
It sucks that we have to wait until Monday for part 2 – Idolatry always makes me wish I worked at EW – it would be a blast to be there on Weds and Thurs and here all the talk about AI. As for this season – yikes, I just don’t think it’s going to be good. I liked Alexis and I hope she continues to improve, but Gokey is just plain gross – and I hope to god someone takes him aside and tells him to ditch all the wife references. I am almost waiting for TMZ to report that she’s actually alive and that it was all a scam – stranger things have happened…
Titiana Del Toro was the most annoying contestant ever(running a close 2nd is the quy with the alter ego)maybe hes the craziest! Whatever, but titiana changed once she made the cut in Hollywood. The uncontrollable laughing turned into a big head she didn’t show good sportsman ship at all. She thought she was one of the best, she can sing, I’ll give her that but she just is not that likable. I know opinions r like buttholes, everybodys got one. Now on the alter ego dude with 2 names and personalities, he should not have made the cut he totally sucks, he took the place of someone that had talent , thats just CRAPPY, come on AI
why stoop to that level. Just 4 ratings, I’m surprised the judges, especially Simon was ok with that. U should never b that Greedy, nothing good can come from it.
I want Kris Allen 2 win also. I would also like 2 know why some contestants get alot of air time and others not so much. I guess once again its the ratings thing, if the person is just a talented singer with one personality and they don’t have a crazy weird clothes or hair or they don’t laugh and scream uncontrollably then the person with the camara dosen’t notice them. So next year every singer that auditions be sure and act crazy dye ur hair orange, add a couple of hard time stories to your resume. Just make sure u r just t.v. wortht enough to make the cut. worry about the talent later..