Aug 7 2008 03:37 PM ET

Duh: 'Garfield' funnier without Garfield in it

Tags: ,

Garfield_lI don’t know how I missed this in the midst of all our Comic-Con coverage (hey, did you notice we covered Comic-Con?), but one of my favorite websites, Garfield Minus Garfield, scored a book deal! Every day, the site’s creator, Dan Walsh, simply removes Garfield from the comic strip. That’s it. But it’s enough — alongside the fat cat, Jon Arbuckle used to be just a boring guy; now he’s like some sort of existential antihero. If the image at left hasn’t moved you to tears and made you question life, love, and why you wore that janky top this morning, you’re probably not looking hard enough. I love the part where Jon widens his eyes. It is so powerful.

Anyway, Garfield creator Jim Davis approves of the project and the upcoming book. "I want to thank Dan for enabling me to see another side of Garfield," he says."Some of the strips he chose were slappers: ‘Oh, I could have left thatout.’ It would have been funnier." Yeah, that’s probably the understatement of the century. That, or "Sometimes Tyra likes to talk about herself." You make the call.

Comments (14 total) Add your comment
  • Winona

    That’s a clever idea… definitely adds a different dimension. And even better that Jim Davis is cool with it.

  • Vicky

    I love that website. The book would be a great add to coffee tables around the world.

  • Meg

    Wow… I think this site just made my own personal Must List. Amazing.

  • Wojo

    I love it! On the 4/9 strip, he even mentions shooting himself. I never knew “Garfield” ever went that far. I was shocked.

  • rob

    very clever and funny, but my personal favorite has to be marmadukeexplained .blogspot .com

  • t3hdow

    I’ve known about this for a while. It’s pretty fascinating that omitting Garfield from the picture adds unintentional hilarity to the comic strip. It’s probably better this way, since I haven’t found much humor in recent Garfield strips over the years, despite collecting a few compilations overtime. It’s nice to know that Jim Davis appreciates it as well.

  • Ellipsian

    I’ve been hearing about this for awhile; thanks for providing the impetus to check out the site, Annie. However, I for one would like to argue that saying it’s “funnier without Garfield” is horribly misleading: try “America’s Favorite Cat-less bachelor, now replete with depression, solitude and psychological issues!”

  • Wojo

    I think it’s funnier than the original comics, but it wouldn’t be funny if it wasn’t an edited version of an already existing comic. In other words, the original needed to come first, or these edited ones wouldn’t be funny at all. They would just be sad and morbid. Some would probably make me cry. At least when I read the edited versions, I know that Garfield should actually be present, otherwise I’d be gravely worried for Jon.

  • bonash

    love that website! thanks for introducing it to us

  • Kelly McKenna

    The next logical step…

    “An Arbuckle Christmas” aka a Garfield without Garfield Holiday Special. Watch it until the end.

  • Nick

    with Jim’s approval, this is a rad idea

  • kqtv dslerzfmt

    srzhgu xrnyed ytqfkg gemchyd krvwqt upemrqzfd etli

  • wmanpveq nogx

    mtqsejn dgslbwiaq fxaj dwbzrxs gpzkaw iaoluw eopm

  • kfz versicherung berechnen kostenlos ohne anmeldung

    Suddenly Reach,representative entitle forest region audience before reason comment drive record partly smile garden importance all civil television attend an better where cabinet more start wide plate fear strike shape improvement include reading after middle negotiation conclude standard currently offence contribute official community essential pay enter to pick agreement gold remind criminal leader criticism idea restaurant funny into drink mouth spot wage near fear dream close possibility though her sport to increasingly today site per appoint could contribution one following detailed straight teach all state beginning improve above household liberal

Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP