More American Idol

May 8 2008 02:30 PM ET

On the Scene: 'Idol' Top 4 results night

Given that Wednesday night’s results were pretty much a foregone conclusion, I wandered into the Idoldome with a renewed desire to drink in as much Read the full post.

Comments (191 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 11 12 13
  • Dee

    And another thing I hated about Wednesday’s show: Bo Bice openly criticizing (oh so obviously) Jason for ‘hiding behind his guitar’ both on the results show & on the Idol Tonight TV Guide show. What a disgusting dig! So he’s done oh so well with his # 2 finish?? NOT. I liked Bo ok on the show, but the guy is not nearly as talented as Jason. So the judges, producers, much of the media, a pompous guest mentor, & egotistic AI has-been all decide to join forces & use Jason as a punching bag…so NOT cool.

  • to idolfan and previous archie bashers

    You all have so much class to be using autism as an insult (or at least what are coming off as insults) to Archie or to Slezak. Maybe I’m too easily offended because I’m actually an Aspie myself (yes, and I was diagnosed with it), but, honestly, you sound like idiots.
    …although I do think Little David may or may not have A.S., using his shyness against him, as well as every little thing he does “wrong”, is petty and very immature. In any case, he’ll be making more money doing what he loves than all of you haters will at a job you most likely want to quit. I wish him all the best. Although I’m not a huge fan of either Syesha or Rocker David (but I do like them…really!), I know that others here are, and they would do much better to show their support for them rather than bash the other contestants.

  • Shari

    This article was a riot. I laughed out loud at least six times. I have always wanted to be in the studio audience, but have never gotten tickets. Your play by play made me feel like I was actually there. The very best line in the entire article was David Cook with “bullet proof talent”. Truer words were never spoken. This guy is so great I am really hoping that the High School Musical set do not have enough phone/text power to take away the win from him because he is the real deal. I can’t wait for the David Cook CDs and concert tour. I am such a fan. He is the one I tune in for each week to see what new treat he has in store. After the homecoming activities, I am convinced that there never has been a nicer guy or one more deserving of the title of American Idol.

  • Princess Anne

    I just love David Archuleta’s voice and singing style. Millions of fans all over the world would love to see him win the much coveted title “American Idol”. Good luck David A.

  • TicklePig

    Whitney bashers, back off. She does her job well and writes an entertaining column. Jason lovers, I’m right there with you, sad to see him go but his heart wasn’t in it. Little David can’t possibly win this. Even Nigel and co. have to realize that his personality is 0, and would make a horrible entertainer. He is not entertaining, he just has a great voice for a 17 year old robotic boy.

  • sillyme

    I will miss Jason. I can’t wait until Jason gets a CD out. Sorry if people don’t get him. I do. The show will go back to the same old boring stuff.

  • Danita

    David Cook has this competition in the bag. He is the next AMERICAN IDOL

  • Danita

    You go with your bad sexy self David Cook!!!!!!

  • Herculeon

    David Cook to me always looks obnoxious when listening to the judges comments and thats saying a lot since Simon Cowell normally holds that crown…
    Lizzie calling people twits only shows your ignorance….Whitney spent more than a quarter of her recap talking about herself and her dietry requirements….BORING!!!
    David Cook finishes his songs by SCREAMING and making MONKEY FACES…..can you honestly sit through a concert listening and more IMPORTANTLY WATCHING him in concert for 2 hours? I THINK NOT!

  • ammy

    ok, all you people who think david cook sucks…. you clearly dont know talent when its right in your face… he is going to win this year,, FOR SURE.. he is THE ONE to beat!

  • Rabab Ririta

    Selecting a hidden photographic camera is a big offer and there are lots of choices. Strategies : the most used to aid guide you. Keep reading for more information.

Page: 1 11 12 13
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP