Missy Schwartz and I try to create a six-song set list that won’t turn the Idol stage into a hot honeyed mess. Read the full post.
Apr 22
2008
12:41 PM ET
What should the Idols sing for Andrew Lloyd Webber night?
- Comments 78
- Add comment
Latest News
- 'DWTS': Season 14 winning team is...
- 'American Idol': Notes from inside the Nokia
- 'American Idol' poll: Jessica or Phillip?
- 'True Blood': New showrunner is...
- 'Deadliest Catch' clip: Rescue at sea!
- Michael McKean hit by car in NYC
- 'Great Gatsby': Gonzo new trailer
- Nick Offerman: Blond to 'have more fun'?
Most Commented
Top 5 Most Read
- ‘Dancing With the Stars’: Season 14 winner is….
- ‘Glee’ season finale: Who made it to New York?
- ‘American Idol’: Did Phillip or Jessica win the night?
- On the scene at ‘American Idol’ finale: The audience at Nokia Theatre clearly liked Phillip Phillips better than…
- ‘Deadliest Catch’: Greenhorn medical emergency on the Wizard — EXCLUSIVE VIDEO
David Cook gets better every week. I can’t believe he can do understated and soft that well. It was gorgeous. I was thunderstruck. Archuleta bored me to tears as usual. I love Brooke and am sad for her now. Carly’s screaming is the WORST. Hope she goes home. Syesha really belongs on broadway. I enjoyed Jason’s perfomance because it seemed genuine, but of course his voice isn’t the best.
I agree with Rosie. Carly’s voice has its limits as evidenced by her off key screaming when she tries to hit high notes.
Hey, that’s me on WildBluff Media!!! I know this is too little, too late but… I liked what Syesha sang last night but I picked “As If We Never Said Goodbye” or “With One Look” from Sunset Blvd for her. I LOVE Jason but, ugh!, Memory?? I wanted him to sing “Any Dream Will Do” from Joseph. Brooke should have sung, “I Don’t Know How To Love Him”. NO ONE SHOULD HAVE SUNG A PHANTOM SONG! THAT IS SACRILEGIOUS and POMPOUS! Archie should have sung “Memory”. It would have been better suited for his voice. Loved Carly’s “Superstar” but I picked “Don’t Cry For Me Argentina” for her. And I wanted David Cook to rock out with “Gethsemane” from JCS. It’s slow, soulful and excellent for his upper range. Bottom Three: Brooke, Jason, and David A or Carly.