More American Idol

Apr 17 2008 01:00 PM ET

On the Scene: Idol Results Show

The palindrome is dead; all hail the palindrome. Read the full post.

Comments (293 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 4 20
  • Ryan

    I need to read more closely. I thought for some reason you picked “Tell Me on a Sunday” for Brooke. Anyway I think she’d be better suited for that song, and Carly can do an up tempo song like “Buenos Aires.”

  • Lyn

    Idol and Christian music should not be combined. I love passionate songs about healthy and happy love. However, prayer is not mainstream music unless you have a gospel choir and Ms. Franklin. As a Jew, I mute the songs because it’s just too much. If I was a non-religious contestant, I would have felt very awkward during “Shout to the Lord”

  • ZF

    Funny that you mention the fan. While I was watching her, I was thinking it was like that Paul Reiser stand-up special where he keeps seeing a beautiful woman who seems to have a breeziness about her. It turns out that she has a small fan strapped to her ankle.

  • whereimgoing

    Okay…I’m glad it’s not me that feels like I’m being preached at here. Although the song IS mainly a secular song, the show’s intent is clear. Look at the closing shot on the song, where all of the contestants are holding their mics out like they’re praying, with the “heavenly” light blasting, and then tell me they weren’t going for a spiritual impact.

  • RTA

    Your Christian-phobia is a little too cynical, dude. Methinks thou dost protesteth too much, ya know what I’m sayin’? Well-writtne songs about God or his Son are vastly preferable to those about cheating, lusting and revenge. But maybe that’s just me…

  • Matt

    I’m not a fan of all the Christian music either.

  • kay

    I really don”t want to see BRILLO HEAD one more week. Can”t someone please give her some hair products. They were even able to help Kim Locke”s unruly locks..

  • mscisluv

    Aww I love “Close Every Door,” even if it is dreary. And thanks so much for pointing us towards that Huffington Post article. It made the perfect point: That there’s nothing wrong with the contestants singing Christian songs if it is their individual choice, but there is a problem when it a statement from the show in the form of a group number and puts any participant who would rather not perform it in a very awkward position. Elliot Yamin is Jewish, and I wonder how he would handled something “Shout to the Lord” if he was asked to sing it in a group number – because, as the HP article point out, no one wants to be the contestant that refused to sing and evangelical Christian song.

  • Sally in Chicago

    Thanks for the wrap-up, as always just wonderfully written. I too started getting a soft spot for KLC and just knew she would be the last woman standing…but now it’s looking like Syesha just might pull off the last woman standing…because Brooke just cannot possibly continue to make it to the safe seat. She is just too wimpy. And that piano playing she does? It’s not piano playing, it’s plucking chords while she sings. Poor thing needs to take lessons.

  • Cordelia Willis

    I love christian music, there is not a thing wrong with it. I am a christian and there are a lot of us
    christians out there, that also love
    that type of music. So, live up it ot turn it off.

  • NoRs

    What about “I don’t know how to love him” from Jesus Christ Superstar for Brooke? With the guitar it could be pretty awesome.

  • Cordelia Willis

    I love christian music, there is not a thing wrong with it. I am a christian and there are a lot of us
    christians out there, that also love
    that type of music. So,you can take it or turn it off.

  • Martha

    Wow, I don’t even watch this show and read your entire blog entry! Whittlz, my girl crush on you continues… As for the “Jesus” controversy, I’m with Michael Giltz from HuffPo on this one. If you’re going to sing a gospel song, sing it as is. But don’t make everyone sing it as a group song. (Full disclosure: I’m a church-going Christian.)

  • Stef

    I love the show Bones, it was great to see a mention of it here.

  • Stef

    Sorry, why should I be offended that they mentioned Jesus a few times again? I never want to miss out on a chance to be offended!

Page: 1 2 3 4 20
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP