Dawnie Walton and I discuss this all-important question, and engage in a heated debate over Kady Malloy (feel free to break our tie in the comments section), plus PopWatch message-board maven Nine Daves (hip, hip… hurrah!) shares his Idol pet peeve, on today’s episode of Idolatry.
Mar 5 2008 11:00 AM ET
Which 'Idol' lady brings the momentum into tonight's semifinal finale?
- 'So You Think You Can Dance' top 20 is...
- Edward Furlong charged with assault in L.A.
- 'Dumb and Dumber' sequel finds new home
- Selma Blair exits 'Anger Management'
- Liv Tyler joins Damon Lindelof pilot
- 'Anchorman 2': We know that mustache...
- Armie Hammer: No 'Fifty Shades' for me
- 'Prometheus' sequel hires a new writer