Which 'Idol' lady brings the momentum into tonight's semifinal finale?

Dawnie Walton and I discuss this all-important question, and engage in a heated debate over Kady Malloy (feel free to break our tie in the comments section), plus PopWatch message-board maven Nine Daves (hip, hip… hurrah!) shares his Idol pet peeve, on today’s episode of Idolatry.

Comments (20 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2
  • Corran

    The only sour face Kady will make is when she comes into your office Slezak. How friggin rude? Ok, it’s one thing to have opinions, but you took it WAAAAYYY too far for judging Kady Malloy. You don’t know what she is going through, so don’t assume how she thinks or feels. This is a singing competition, judge the vocals. Well, I guess you don’t since you like the craptastic (or should I say cracktastic) Asia’h Epperson. GO ALINDA WHEAT!!!

  • Tonic

    I’m sorry, but these cheap videos of office discussion are horrible. I can discuss my opinion of tv shows in my own office with my own co-worker…why would I want to watch this?

  • AL

    Gotta agree with Tonic. Ok so you guys get PAID to comment, it’s your job, but I must say, if I were Simon, I would skewer the job you do on it.

  • Melanie

    I totally agree with Slezak about Kady Malloy’s stank attitude.

  • mscisluv

    Whoah, I didn’t realize Kady Malloy’s BFF (Corran, first poster) was on this board. In fact, AI is really NOT a competition based on whether or not you can sing. Personality, attitude, and look all play into it. And Kady’s facial expressions during judging definitely make her look bored, irritated, and stank. It’s completely valid for people to have a reaction to that and comment on it.

  • Top Sheff

    The phone interview with “Nine Daves” was spot on. It was nice to hear someone else comment on the idol performers. Dave had the background of knowledge from other seasons and made some damn good points. If someone has “owned” an idol song, don’t be a dumbass and try to one up them!

  • Jenna Von Oy

    Way to go NineDaves! Another PopWatcher is now an official Idol Expert! Woot!

  • b0bbyr0we

    I’m going to agree with both Dawnie and Slezak…Kady has been terrible, but I do not want her to leave. I’m going to add another pretty to that list…pretty voice. I’d actually go so far as to say gorgeous voice.
    So much of idol has become about range and runs, that the actual tone of people’s voices is too often overlooked. She’s absolutely struggling to figure out who she is…and thats part of the fun. The critiques about knowing who she is from the judges must be confusing, so she may never find it, but I still hold out hope that with the right song she’ll go down as not another one of the girls with the pretty voices, but the girl with the gorgeous voice.
    Also…I miss Kelly.

  • Aaron

    The sad fact is that Kady has not yet lived up to her fantastic first audition because she hasn’t picked the right song. And when she’s picked the wrong song, she’s tried so hard to make it her own that she destroys it a little bit. She do a straightforward take on a mid-tempo song that she shine on. I’m thinking “Don’t Get Me Wrong” by The Pretenders…

  • b0bbyr0we

    Also, Carly’s my girl….I just think Kady would be interesting to keep around. I fear that Carly may face a similar problem as Melinda, everyone knows she’s a flawless vocalist (I actually prefer Carly’s style) but becuase of that, she needs to practically blow people’s minds every week to keep them excited. Simon’s absolutely right, she needs her “Summertime,” “Stuff Like That There,” etc.

  • Anonymous

    Tonic – Then don’t watch it. You have to actually click on the play button and make a conscious effort to watch. If you hate this so much, why do you do it? Maybe your time would be better spent in anger management than on an Idol blog.

  • ORKMommy

    Tonic – Then don’t watch it. You have to actually click on the play button and make a conscious effort to watch. If you hate this so much, why do you do it? Maybe your time would be better spent in anger management than on an Idol blog.

  • Anthony

    Great point Dave – I expect more from the ladies too! But I think we both need to forget about that this time around, as the men seem to be dominating like there’s no tomorrow.

  • JLH

    NineDaves you are a wise wise man. Your knowledge of American Idol, both past and present, blows my mind! I bet you are a wonderful and attractive person.

  • McGinn

    Dave is my hero!

Page: 1 2
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos


From Our Partners

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP