Which ad do you hate more: Charmin or Cottonelle?

Those Charmin bears have been the bane of my existence for ages, wiping their backsides with abandon in plain view of the cameras, shaking their tailfeathers against trees like exotic dancers working the pole of a low-rent strip club. To make matters worse, Charmin has taken to using a deeply disturbing visual — the "sullied hand" graphic — to show their bathroom tissue is stronger and more absorbent than its leading competitors. "Best for bear bottoms?" Heinous!

Not to be outdone, competitor Cottonelle is running a new ad where a puppy roams the streets commenting on the dubious conditions of various human hind ends, while a voiceover declares "the world can be tough on bottoms." (Seriously?) The clip ends with said canine finding sweet relief on a beanbag, while a Cottonelle package appears on the right of the screen, showing the pooch’s pooper swathed in Cottonelle’s comforting T.P.

I know none of you are going to try to tell me you love these ads, so the better question is, which do you loathe more? Vote now!

Comments (186 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 13
  • marilinda

    i stopped buying charmin because of those damn bears.
    and my boyfriend and i were just talking last night about how that puppy (voiced by zach braff) has a serious butt obsession.

  • pede

    Omg, I am SO glad to see I’m not alone in hating both of these commercial’s creatures. Its a toss-up for me, luckily, with my dvr I almost never have to deal with commercials anymore anyways. But I think the puppy is more annoying. You know its bad when an animal lover like me wants to toss an innocent puppy under a bus because of a commercial.

  • MrKitty

    I too quit buying Charmin because of the bears…the puppy is a cutie – it was better when it was just rolling rolls down the hall..but I guess they needed to keep up with Charmin. The bears running on the beach is the WORST.

  • EP Sato

    I hate the puppy ads, but not anywhere near as much as those bears. They always remind me of the old joke about the bear and the rabbit doing a #2 in the woods next to each other. The Bear complains about getting dookie on his fur, so he asks the rabbit about the issue.
    The rabbit replies “you know, the dookie’s never bothered me”, so the bear wipes his “bottom” with the rabbit.
    So it’s either out of that joke or the old “Does a bear crap in the woods” saying that inspired these ads. Either way, I always think of bears taking a #2 when the ads come on. I guess TP is a difficult product to advertise for, but why a bear or a puppy?
    For a cool TP ad, use J.lo as the spokesmodel. At least then the ads could be ironic or funny something to the tune of “When I shake my booty, I want to be sure it’s clean”

  • MCM

    Those Charmin ads have been appalling me for years. They are almost everything that is wrong with advertising. The Cottonelle ad at least benefits from the cutey-pie puppy, and you have to be paying attention just a tiny bit harder to realize exactly what they are saying. They both make me go “ew” but Charmin makes me go “eeeewwwwwww…”

  • Emma

    I think I agree with most of the posters so far. That puppy is pretty bad, but I change the channel when the Chramin bears come on. I think those commercials are some of the worst on tv.

  • Emma

    Oops, “Charmin,” not “Chramin.” That’s what I get for trying to type while holding a baby who does not want to sit at the computer…

  • MattS

    That Cottonelle ad makes me want to punch Zach Braff in the mouth even more than I already do. I’m not sure if that’s good or bad.

  • Louise

    Both those commercials make me feel dirty.

  • gnome

    Cottonelle

  • megan

    They’re both bad, but the puppy one is horrible. I feel like it’s only in the past few years that the TP ads have gotten so graphic. We all know what it’s for, we don’t need to be shown actual backsides to get it. I would be much more on board with a 30 second shot of the puppy just sitting there next to the logo, looking cute.

  • Stephanie T.

    The Puppy is cute but the Cottenelle commercial is lame,not to mention that it’s a total rip off the PBS children’s show “Wishbone”. I don’t care for the Charmin commercial either, so I’d say that I don’t care for both.

  • kats

    Charmin. I get the reference but that doesn’t mean I want to see it played out literally on my television screen. The bears and the old commercial (for jeans? a diet product?) with the singing belly buttons are my most hated commercials of all time. I’ve actually had long discussions with my little brother and one of my best friends regarding how heinous and disturbing they both are.

  • tia77

    Gee thanks, Even though it’s not on the commercial, I have the Charmin Ultra “Less is more” song stuck in my head. I can’t stand the Charmin bears…

  • Ben

    Seriously? This is what you get paid for?
    I’d go with the Charmin.

Page: 1 2 3 13
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Latest Videos

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP