Jan 4 2008 06:24 PM ET

What's your excitement level for the return of 'American Idol'?

Filed under: American Idol and tagged: , ,

Idol_lAmerican Idol is to me what that demon in The Exorcist was to Linda Blair. Every January, the show takes possession of my mind, body, and soul, makes my head spin uncontrollably, and fills my ears with loud, cacophonous sounds. (Oh, audition episodes, how you make me cringe!) Except, to paraphrase "Love Hangover"-era Diana Ross, I don’t need no cure. And I never will, not as long as there are undiscovered Fantasia Barrinos and Kelly Clarksons and Elliott Yamins left in the world.

This isn’t to say, of course, that season 6 wasn’t the lamest in Idol history, but producer Nigel Lythgoe has since admitted that mistakes were made, and promised that the show will return its focus to the contestants, rather than an endless parade of CD-shilling guest mentors, for its season 7. (Also, I sort of bought the Blake Lewis CD a couple weeks back, and I’m rather enjoying it.) So yeah, I’ll admit it: I’m currently at a "9" (on a scale of 1-10) in my excitement for Idol’s return. How about you? (Oh, and while we’re on the subject of Idol, after the jump, check out the new PSA/promo for EW.com’s Idolatry series that I shot yesterday; I’m pretty certain it’ll help reduce the amount of Idol-related violence in the U.S. in 2008.)


Comments (107 total) Add your comment
Page: 1 2 3 8
  • YANKEEMAN

    JEEZ, can you be more gay about this. It’s just a stupid show asshat. When are you going to admit this show has BEEN jumped the shark!!!

  • Anonymous

    I am at a 0. I hate this show

  • Heather

    I’m jazzed, especially in light of the fact that we won’t have to endure a season spent focusing more on the guests than the contestants AND because they get to play instruments. Yay! I’ve been dying for the ones who can play to have a chance since Bo Bice.

  • snarky

    My excitment level – MEH. I would rate it at 0. Unless Sanjaya comes back – then count me in!

  • shawn

    eh. I’m at about a 5. Ever since the phenomenal Kelly won in season 1, the show has been going downhill, and last season was just god awful. I’ll tune in, cuz, well, it IS Idol, but I’ll probably care not in the least about the outcome. The world does NOT need another Jordin, Blake, or Sanjaya.

  • Broadway Baby

    With you all the way again. Yippee!
    God? Watch over my children for the next few months. Amen.

  • Don’t Care Anymore

    I’ve only watched the past three seasons and the show has gone downhill with each passing season. I was so disgusted by the end of last season that I refused to watch the finale and swore I would never watch the show again so my excitement level is a 0. The most entertaining part of last season was reading the after-show posts here on this website so thanks for the laughs.

  • Penelope

    Michael–I’m a 10 for Idolatry! I have to admit that I’m a little bit in love with you.

  • junior

    does anyone watch this show anymore & if so, why? it’s boring & predictable. even the first few episodes showing the horrible people is boring & predictable. randy will dawg everyone, paula will be the idiot we all know she is & simon will be honest to everyone & get booed. who needs it!? if you’re still watching this show you’re a moron who needs to get a life!

  • John

    Slezak – I’ve been secretly enjoying the Blake Lewis CD as well! I’m at a 5 for the return of Idol, a 10 for the return of Idolatry!

  • Fatima

    Hey Michael, I have a suggestion for you this year. Through Jan-May, you should actually try to talk about something other than Idol for once. I know it is big and deserves coverage, but 9/10 popwatch posts were Idol based last year and it got really lame. This website needs to calm down a tad over it.

  • Wes

    The past two seasons, I’ve skipped the last two episodes. In both cases, Third Place was the winner to me.

  • GeeMoney

    Idol sucks. I can’t believe people still watch this show! I lost my faith back in season 3, when they voted off LaToya London. ARRRGGGGH!

  • Maureen

    Do you know what I love even more than AI? Well, many things, actually, but EW’s Idolatry is right up there. You made the show even more fun to watch. I look forward to your new season.

  • peachmahoney

    Here’s the thing- I hate Idol, I love Idol, but mostly I love love love making fun of Idol. So I guess I’m about an 8 out of 10.

Page: 1 2 3 8
Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP