They grow up so fast, don’t they?
As quick as they came, before we even learned all of their names (thanks, CBS!), the pioneers of Kid Nation were gone. But not, blessed be the Lord, before giving us one of the most emotional and controversial episodes yet — beginning with the total destruction of society as we came to know it.
It all started with Mike’s daybreak ramble, when he (totally unsuspiciously alone at such an hour) noticed that the job board was all sparkly and aflame. The cry went out, the Nation builders came, and they watched in awe like the little budding pyromaniacs they all have the potential to be, if they work hard enough. But this was no act of God, this burning of the Arbiter of Social Order. It was arson. Can’t say I was sorry that the producer-imposed caste system (and that infernal journal) got torched. But did the kids’ minds have to go too?
Quick — what’s the template for the chain of events when society collapses?
1. There’s a run on the banks. Or, in kid currency, the candy store.
2. Looting breaks out. It might’ve been a trick of the mind, but I’m almost certain I saw somebody carting off TVs. (Wow, they are making them lighter and flatter!)
3. Moral institutions (read: DK and Zach) call for order.
4. Regret sets in, and society elects to re-establish itself, only better and more equitable than (i.e., exactly the same as) before.
So it was with Bonanza City. But before anybody had time to really reflect on how far they’d regressed, there was money to be given away. (Lesson: Anarchy pays?) At least this was for a good cause, because our budding statesman Zach finally got his first campaign contribution. Whee! Karma kinda works! Kinda. Because while we were still savoring that warm fuzzy, wrongness happened.
Sometimes we forget that the most feral species in the animalkingdom is the adolescent girl — and they roam in packs. Last night’sprey was Emily, who’d foolishly strayed too close to theyellow-district Heathers, wanting to (silly Rabbit!) hang out withthem. It was Kelsey who pounced: "You know you’re awesome, right Em?Because you are totally awesome. And so pretty! I wanna, like,grow up to be a stylist, just so I can give every woman in America yourhair color. No, f’real. It’s like spun effing gold. And did I tell youhow spesh you are? I lovelovelove you to bits and bits. You’re likewalking, talking cotton candy. But just for right now — and theforeseeable future — I don’t wanna be within three feet of you." Atleast that’s the way I remember it. Then there was the back-and-forthof Emily giving as good as she got, then stripping herself of dignityby still wanting to befriend them. It was all so very ugly and shove-y,until Migle stopped it by sorta letting the Heathers win. Yes, Emily,that’s high school. Every day. For four years. Enjoy.
Again, before we had time to, say, reflect on anything incidental like feelings, there was a party to throw. Picnic tables were assembled, garbage was dumped, and "food" was prepared. Then came the parents.
We’ve been together awhile now, PopWatchers. You know I’m a cynicaltermagant with a soul, but no heart. Even I got misty when I saw thosemiddle-aged breeders risk coronaries trying to run to their babies.Then Zach’s dad told him the greatest thing in the history ofFatherdom: "I said this was going to be a test of your self-relianceand independence. I was wrong. It was a test of ourself-reliance and independence." Awwwwww. If you didn’t weep at that,you’re inhuman (or you have some sort of tear-duct disorder, and Itotally apologize).
We snorted as the ‘rents discovered the third-world conditionsthey’d sent their children to live in. We giggled, realizing how shortthe distance was from the apples to the trees. We searched desperatelyfor Pageant Princess Taylor’s parents (and maybe caught a glimpse ofher mom? No? Damn.). We were ready to leave Bonanza City content.
Then they had to give more stupid money away. Look, we both knowthose last three gold stars — the fifty thou cash payouts — were a badidea. Yes, it was cool that the all-male Council rewarded three femalePioneers for their contributions. Yes, it’s nice that such a pile couldpay for a whole semester of private education. But the truthis, the last-minute rewards forced the Council to pick too hastily, andif we’re honest with ourselves, not every star was fully merited.
Plus, we viewers didn’t need it. Once again, Kid Nation tookthe sad position that the kids weren’t interesting enough bythemselves, without burning job boards, party-planning challenges, andcash prizes. For me, and I suspect for most of you, the joy waswatching Laurel and Sophia lead, Greg and Blaine mature, and Taylor do…whatever the hell she does. Just knowing that in this world, there’s aZach, an Anjay, an Alex, a Morgan, and a Michael — that’s enough togive me hope. Because like it or not, in the very near future, thequestion of whether these kids can build a better society will be more than theoretical. And there will be no cameras.
Thanks for hanging with me PopWatchers. See you next year!








thanks for doing this popwatch!! Good show, amidst all the repeats and shows stricken by the writers’ strike. Hope, hope there’s a KN2!
I wish they had given Mike a gold star. He deserved it for putting up with one of the worst humiliations I can imagine (having no one vote for him), and deciding to stick it out and stay positive. He didn’t look so bad after others gave the council a shot.
I hope CBS gives this show the same second chance it gave The Amazing Race after its debut season didn’t go so well. It’s much better than its critics (most of whom never watched it) give it credit for.
Amen about Mike. What a cool kid he was!
Never watched it. Wouldn’t watch it with your eyes. Why would people prostitute their children like this? No No No.
I feel kinda bad for the peeps who never gave this show a chance. They missed out on meeting some pretty cool kids. M’girl, Sophia…what’s not to love. She could make her nation listen to reason when needed and have them bend to her will for her own amusement at times. LOVE HER! And if anyone should have been awarded a gold star for being the caregiver, mother figure…it should have been Laurel. Sorry, Migle. Then we have our brilliant (sure to be misunderstood by their junior high and high school classsmates) boys, Jared and Tooth. What we have done without’em? Just knowing they exist warms my heart. Anjay. Michael. Hunter. Zach. Morgan. Siiiiiigh. I’ll miss ‘em all. Just wish we could have met ‘em all. And thanks, Alynda, for sticking with us even when we lost our official TVWatch. You brought a smile to my face every Thursday!
Hi Alynda: Great blog and thanks so much continuing blogging under Pop Watch. I enjoyed the show and also cried a few tears last night. I was hoping that Mike would finally get some recognition, but I guess it wasn’t to be. It will be interesting to see how this show will impact the kids involved and hopefully, we will receive updates on how our darlings are doing. Chow.
I was truly moved by the arrival of the parents. The looks on everyone’s faces seemed to be as genuine a thing as you could find on primetime tv these days. The kids were crying, the adults were crying,(someone hugged Taylor, so I’m assuming that was the mother responsible!) It was quite a nice finale.
Especially the town riots! This is why I love kids! “Emily, you’re cool, but you’re not THAT cool.” So say the “heathers” (nice one, Alynda). Without the journal or a showdown, some of that drama did well to keep the ep interesting.
More money…Good. More kids deserve it. What’s that? Two of them went right back to people who already were rewarded? That just doesn’t seem fair..(I guess Kid Nation is more like real society than I thought.)
Glad Zach got his due. Too bad, Mike couldn’t get his. I love that kid. And Sophia. She deserved the second 50k, and truly embodied the best aspects of Bonanza.
I also hope some of the kids are able to keep in touch…We all know how much it sucks to never see someone you’ve grown attached to again…
Alynda, thank you so much for the TV/Pop watches. Even if someone hadn’t seen the show, it was your well written articles that they were really missing out on…
I was thrilled to see Sophia get a big star, but had also hoped to see Laurel rewarded for her awesome leadership of the green district. Her district dominated the gold star race. Also, I was sad to see whiny Zach get a star. For what???
I’m with Lady Bug, it would be nice to have a check-up on these kidlets in a few years. And I too will chime in with my thanks to Alynda–thanks for sticking up for us and keeping the Popwatch alive. Hopefully you and Rob Grizzly have a lovely wedding. Now, one question: what was that “dough” they were stuffing into the pasta machines? Looked more like mashed potatoes to me.
It occurs to me, the next season, will not have the “surprise” element, and that may detract. Lesson to learn – DONT be on the coucil at the end. You’ll miss out on the big rewards. This was a good show, but I’m not sure about parents who would send their kids into that kind of environment for 40 days. Does seem to border on abuse, if not neglect. Kids should be in a summer camp with a lake and horseback riding, not concerning themselves with how best to win a gold star.
BTW, notice the complete lack of response on this board? Guess the eight of us who watched liked it, but the rest of the world was off doing their Xmas shopping!
Say it isn’t so. You watch this child abuse. And jes, as far as I can tell you didn’t MEET anyone.
You said it all. 8 fans!!!!!!!!!!!
Wow, AmyWinehouse, I cant believe there are still people out there that dont see the value of this show… I would put child on that show in a second. I cried as soon as the parents came over the hill, it was a real moment… I too questioned certain people getting 2 gold stars when some got nothing (poor Divad! her potatoes wouldnt get her a gold star). I wish they had a reunion special so the parents could defend their decision and we could see what happenend behind the scenes; how did they take showers? did they have toilet paper? My fav part of this episode was the emily situation, it totally brought me back to middle school… yea now their pumping my gas, so hang in there emily! Cant wait for season 2!