More American Idol

Sep 24 2007 03:20 PM ET

Snap judgment: Kellie Pickler's '... A Man's Mind'

She may have finished behind Taylor Hicks, KatharineMcPhee, and Paris Bennett during her sixth-place run on American Idol‘ssuper-competitive fifth season, but Kellie Pickler looks more Read the full post.

Comments (74 total) Add your comment
  • Me

    Not a fan of this music but I think she’s cute. Whether she’ll be around 5 years from now is another story. I just wish she hadn’t ‘enhanced’ herself. It was totally unnecessary. She was fine just as she was.

  • Dr. Evil

    Kellie enhanced herself??? What did she enhance? It obviously wasn’t her chest because all her recent photos show her chest to be the same size as it was during Season 5 on Idol. I think your tripping dude.
    As for the person who commented that she is no Carrie Underwood, thank god for that because it’s bad enough country music has one boresfest like that around, not to mention Kellie’s album proved she is a better singer/songwriter than Carrie could even dream of being. Seeing how few concert gigs Carrie was able to get this year I wouldn’t be surprised if her 15 minutes are almost up. All that hype and overpromotion might have been able to sell a few Cds for her but once the music fans actually heard the album I don’t think they were impressed anymore than I was.
    As for Kellie’s new single, I’m sure Shania Twain and Sugarland would have loved to release this song like some of you have mentioned, but when there is a better singer like Kellie around she gets first dibs.

  • Yo: Dr. Evil

    It’s obvious you know nothing about the music industry and your hearing needs to be checked. Carrie Underwood’s voice soars over the mediocrity of Picklers. It’s as obvious as the ‘enhancement’ in her chest.

  • JAmy

    Woah! Cant believe some of the comments. But hey, no worries, Kellie’s definitely going to be around for a long long time. Watch out guys, when someone’s got talent, looks, personality and stage presence – the total package, u know she’s gonna rock! ;)

  • Anonymous

    Carrie’s voice soars?, shrills is more like it, and judging by how much they machined her vocals on her new single I don’t even know why they bothered with a second album seeing how there are more talented woman in country music today. I’m glad Kellie doesn’t have to have her vocals machined when she records but then as beautiful as she sounds live she doesn’t need to. Then I’m sure that explains why Kellie’s concert schedule has been booked all year, because music fans like what they hear, unlike Carrie who only could get a handful of offers this year for her mediocre talents. But seeing how clueless you are to Kellie’s chest I shouldn’t be surprised your as clueless in the rest of your opinions.

  • Funny Boy
  • Funny Boy
  • BB

    Whoa, people! This blog is about Pickler not Underwood. But since yer on the subject, it has to be clarified that Underwood has won every major award there is in the music industry, whereas Kellie has not. Fact is fact.
    As for this particular song, nothing to get excited about.

  • red

    Enough about Carrie. This is about Kellie’s new song. She does a great job with this song. Fun and upbeat. But then again she does great with everything she sings. She is a great upcoming singer who will be here for a long time. Love it.

  • Selachimorpha

    Why is it that every blog about Kellie draws a few jealous Carrie fans bashing Kellie? Since Carrie is so great, why even bother? What are you worried about?

  • TOTO

    One word about the song – yawn.

  • JAmy

    Haha! Every time Kellie is mentioned, you would be sure Carrie will be mentioned to put Kellie down. This is getting old. Carrie has so many awards, now why would her fans even take a few mins of their precious time to flaunt it in Kellie’s face. Give it up. Now that’s not making Carrie look good at all. ;)

  • Dorothy to TOTO

    Wake up, you’re not in Kansas anymore!
    What are all you bashers missing, a heart or a brain? Maybe it’s time to take a trip to see the wizard!

  • TOTO

    So I’m not allowed an opinion?? Sorry but this song does nothing for me. If it’s good for you, then great. Frankly I liked the high heels song a lot more. And you all need to lighten up when someone dares criticize Ms. Pickler’s talents. She’s ok, but she’s no Martina, Reba, Faith or as of late Carrie. Those gals all have pipes and the awards to prove it.

  • Toto is an idiot

    It’s funny how country music fans don’t seem to care about Carrie, her music, or her “pipes”. Carrie hasn’t been in the Top 10 searched artist’s over at gactv.com in months even though she has a new song and video out along with a new album coming out, that’s because nobody cares what she is doing.
    The same over at CMT.com, Carrie’s videos have lost 17 out of the last 18 Power Picks she was included in, that’s because country music fans would rather watch someone elses video than hers.
    The same with Carrie’s myspace, she hardly has anyone leaving comments on her myspace, that’s because nobody really cares for her or her music.
    Sony/BMG might have been able to hype and overpromote this no talent hack to sell a few Cds but after everyone heard the Cd they obviously weren’t impressed. The only thing I see Carrie fans try to brag about are those few things a few suits control, sales, awards, charts, but when it comes to fans Carrie is nothing but a loser. See how long that last.

Add your comment
The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject - or we may delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk (*) indicates a required field.

When you click on the "Post Comment" button above to submit your comments, you are indicating your acceptance of and are agreeing to the Terms of Service. You can also read our Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

TV Recaps

Powered by WordPress.com VIP